Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Cherie Burns

GET UPDATES FROM Cherie Burns

Hype or Hurricane?

Posted: 08/26/11 01:58 PM ET

Seventy-three years ago the Great Hurricane of 1938 (GH38) ripped through New England killing 700 people in four hours. The East Coast is now bracing for a storm that may be of equal magnitude. Yet newscasters keep talking about how "unprecedented" the coming threat may be. This is total nonsense. GH38 was a category four hurricane with gusts up to 160 miles per hour. It would take more than that to make Irene an "unprecedented" event. The damage and and loss, both human and monetary, is unlikely to rival GH38 in any way for the simple reason that the 1938 hurricane came as a surprise.

There was no round-the-clock forecast of GH38, because no one knew it was coming. It crept up the East Coast well off-shore, unseen and unpredicted. Seventy-three years ago there weren't satellite pictures and up-to-the minute reports of where the storm was headed. The Weather Bureau relied on reports from ships at sea and the transmission of news to the weather service took hours, almost days, to reach the public. When the deadly storm made landfall, shoreline residents were at home or at the beach, totally unprepared. Some foolhardy souls even went out in boats or walked on the beach. Prevailing wisdom was that hurricanes didn't come to New England. There is no chance of a tragedy of that scale today.

For three days newscasters, some in shirtsleeves on the coastline, have been predicting the storm. It's easy to understand the attraction of so much hype. It's a relief to have something to focus on besides grim job reports and the unending hunt for Muammar Gaddafi. In the last five years since I wrote The Great Hurricane: 1938, hurricane season always puts me on alert. Yet not one of the storms that has mesmerized the media has come ashore as viciously as GH38. Maybe Irene will follow its predicted course into New York City and Connecticut, and a category three or four hurricane would no doubt cause injury, perhaps death, and costly damage. But its toll won't be an unprecedented tragedy. It won't be like 1938. This time every twitch and change in air current are instantaneously broadcast to the public. The population that lies in the storm's coming path is on alert and ready. Evacuations are underway.

I experienced a hurricane in 1991 and I well remember the excitement. I was in Nantucket when one of my neighbors, a friend from New Jersey, called to tell me that she was taking her daughter into their cellar when the storm hit. She wanted me to know where they had gone if -- well -- the worst happened. I asked a friend of mine from North Carolina who had experience with hurricanes what I should do to prepare. She told me in her southern drawl that her son Bubba had gone to the liquor store to lay in some gin and she had a ham in the oven. She'd inventoried her candles and was getting ready to party when the big storm hit. I decided right then and there that when the apocalypse comes, I want to be with the southerners.

Irene may hit the south first this time, and I don't want to make light of its real risks and threat of tragedy. A hurricane can be hellish and deadly, I learned listening to survivors' stories. Its devastation came to my attention again in my upcoming biography of the Standard oil heiress, Millicent Rogers. Her family's grand estate, modeled on an Italian palazzo, was washed out by GH38.

We all watched the deadly specter of Katrina, which was well forecast.

In 1938 the scope of the disaster that hit New England was overshadowed by world events. Hitler marched into Czechoslovakia and stole the headlines. With only sketchy media coverage, the rest of the country didn't know how deadly the storm had been. It wasn't like Katrina, which every American experienced vicariously on some level. There is no chance of that with Irene. If it hits New York, the world will know. We know already. If it goes out to sea, we'll know that too. There'll be plenty of time to refocus on job reports.

Cherie Burns is the author of The Great Hurricane: 1938. Her upcoming book, Searching for Beauty--the Life of Millicent Rogers will be published September 13.

 
 
 
Seventy-three years ago the Great Hurricane of 1938 (GH38) ripped through New England killing 700 people in four hours. The East Coast is now bracing for a storm that may be of equal magnitude. Yet...
Seventy-three years ago the Great Hurricane of 1938 (GH38) ripped through New England killing 700 people in four hours. The East Coast is now bracing for a storm that may be of equal magnitude. Yet...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 98
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
photo
Icecube
Fortuna's #1 Leykis 101 graduate
05:32 PM on 08/29/2011
We did not have to go bobbin for bodies ala Katrina. That's gotta mean something.
04:35 PM on 08/28/2011
Re Hype: In all the news reports all I heard was them reporting the highest possible number shown below from the Hurricane Hunter planes they could use ,without mentioning the winds at the surface were much much lower;
URNT12 KNHC 261724
VORTEX DATA MESSAGE AL092011
A. 26/17:06:0­0Z
B. 31 deg 02 min N
077 deg 29 min W
C. 700 mb 2660 m
this is max wind at surfaceD. 68 kt
E. 049 deg 43 nm
Max wind at flight level F. 137 deg 92 kt
G. 050 deg 84 nm
H. 951 mb
I. 14 C / 3046 m
J. 18 C / 3055 m
K. 8 C / NA
L. NA
M. NA
N. 12345 / 7
O. 0.02 / 3 nm
P. AF306 2709A IRENE OB 22
MAX FL WIND 105 KT SE QUAD 13:36:40Z
MAX FL TEMP 20 C 251 / 11 NM FROM FL CNTR
04:14 PM on 08/28/2011
Years ago I evacuated Wilmington for a 120 Killer Storm and got back to see only twigs down in my yard. When I looked deeper I saw the highest gust at the airport was only 68 MPH. I found the reports given are the winds atfligh level. I now watch it all from the NOAA website. This time I saw that the bouys as the storm approached were only reporting 50. This was confirmed by the Hurricane Hunter flights who reported only 65. Here is the report as it crossed SC into SC: 000
URNT12 KNHC 261724
VORTEX DATA MESSAGE AL092011
A. 26/17:06:00Z
B. 31 deg 02 min N
077 deg 29 min W
C. 700 mb 2660 m
this is max wind at surfaceD. 68 kt
E. 049 deg 43 nm
Max wind at flight level F. 137 deg 92 kt
G. 050 deg 84 nm
H. 951 mb
I. 14 C / 3046 m
J. 18 C / 3055 m
K. 8 C / NA
L. NA
M. NA
N. 12345 / 7
O. 0.02 / 3 nm
P. AF306 2709A IRENE OB 22
MAX FL WIND 105 KT SE QUAD 13:36:40Z
MAX FL TEMP 20 C 251 / 11 NM FROM FL CNTR
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sb1285n
01:12 PM on 08/28/2011
It was a lot of hype and nowhere near as bad as people were trying to make it out to be, but if the precautions taken saved even a few lives don't you think it was worth it?
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
messy
artist, writer, adventurer
11:43 AM on 08/28/2011
Nobody said it would be another Katrina, however....

Always remember what Mel Brooks said: "Tragedy is when I cut my finger, comedy is when you fall into a hole and break your leg," in other words, it's always more important when it effects YOU directly. The BosWASH area hasn't had a genuine hurricane in years and years.....
12:05 AM on 08/28/2011
I owned a business in NYC in 1985 when Gloria came through. All the dire warnings. We battened down the hatches. The banks closed. The post office closed. The merchants closed. Some wind blew but at the time we were told to prepare for the worst the sun was shinning. It was eerie walking through the business section of the community on what was a nice day and seeing everything closed and not a soul around.
photo
tnkeating
Dyslexic agnostic insomniac
08:58 PM on 08/27/2011
I'm also with the southerners, I've lived through many hurricanes and have never evacuated, but I'm smart enough to know when to get out. It is a great time to cook ham, and drink. The lightning is fantasticly beautiful, red, blue, and orange, and really hot. Have a few martini's and enjoy the sounds of electrical exposions and the freight trains, if things get bad get in the tub or a closet with a door that can be nailed shut and throw a mattress or two over yourselves, then pray. You'll be alright this is just a one out of five and there will be plenty of work (jobs) to do after the storm.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bar1ed
midnight toker!
06:39 PM on 08/27/2011
Photo-Ops and BS situations for all the Politicians!
05:52 PM on 08/27/2011
How about the Hurricane that wiped out Galveston in 1900, or Hurricane Audrey in 1957 in Southwest Louisiana (N i lived through that one). We have had bad storms before, and we will again, i don't believe its time for the apocalypse, yet, So what the rest of us need to do is watch what happens and help however we can once it is all over.
04:41 PM on 08/27/2011
Doesn't anybody remember Hurricane Donna of September, 1960? I certainly do! The eye of the hurricane came right through NYC with winds, I believe, of about 100 mph. You looked out the window and the treetops were virtually horizontal...
12:03 AM on 08/28/2011
Donna hit on the first day of the new school term. Of course the schools were closed. I remember sitting in the kitchen with my parents listening to the 9 volt transistor radio. Storm blew over a mulberry tree in our back yard in the Bronx.
FreeHat
Really?
04:37 PM on 08/27/2011
This is all about Katrina and somewhere down the road 9/11. The media are like vultures ready to prey almost willing something to happen.
04:37 PM on 08/27/2011
I can't ever remember a media circus like this BEFORE the hurricane actually hit. Maybe some government bean counter figured out that Uncle Sam would save a lot of money on lawsuits if they made it 100% crystal clear that it's dangerous. Now if you ignore the warnings and get hurt, you won't be able to sue.
photo
The INDYpendent
Equal Opportunity Offender
03:53 PM on 08/27/2011
3 people are dead already. Hype, or hurricane? Sheesh...
05:55 PM on 08/27/2011
And how did they die? Directly from the storm , or in accidents trying to flee from the storm?
OR, were they people who refused to leave?
11:11 PM on 08/27/2011
if you live on an island, and all 3 who died did, where you gonna go?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Infostream
03:47 PM on 08/27/2011
A few days ago a meteoroligist showed a map of ocean temperature, with an almost 20 degree drop between the Carolinas and DC. But somehow the ratings obsessed media decided that contrary to Hurricane 101, Irene was going to get more powerful as it approached NYC, even though the amount of ocean heat energy driving it will drop substantially.

How many times will people keep buying into the MSM hive-mind hype machine? When they all decided Iraq had WMD's and were wrong, we keep watching, and the same "experts" still have their pundit jobs. Ditto for the Housing Crisis. STOP watching!
03:39 PM on 08/27/2011
Hype or Hurricane? A bit of both. I think given this summer's record rainfall, the powers that be are concerned about flooding, broken pipes (old infrastructure) and failures in the sewer systems (major YUCK!). I also think that it's an opportunity to test disaster readiness, show strength to our enemies, and give a bit of a jolt to the economy beyond the "shovel ready" repair and cleanup jobs