More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Cheryl Forberg, RD

GET UPDATES FROM Cheryl Forberg, RD

Why We Eat When We're Not Hungry

Posted: 07/27/11 09:24 AM ET

After a rough meeting at the office, your day ends with an empty carton of ice cream and then a stomach ache.

At a party where you don't know anyone, you stand by the buffet table and graze.

The kids have been a handful all day, so you have a second helping of pasta and a big glass of wine (or two) once they're in bed.

Forget physical hunger -- sometimes we reach for food to soothe our emotional cravings. When we're anxious, angry, fatigued, overwhelmed or otherwise under stress, a seemingly hard-wired desire to overeat can take over.

Emotional eating -- if you eat when you're not hungry, for a variety of reasons -- is a very real, and under-recognized problem. It affects many more of us to varying degrees than you might have guessed. The solutions often must go far beyond merely identifying the problem, because many emotional eaters do realize what they are doing and they do it anyway. Beyond identifying the problem and its causes, we must learn to replace the mindless eating with healthier habits. Easier said than done, but when recognizing this behavior, try to replace it with exercise, calling a friend, reading, meditating, drinking some water or making a mindful decision to nurture yourself in another healthy way.

Why do our emotions trigger certain eating habits? Understanding this connection is key to developing a healthy lifestyle -- every bit as important as nutritional knowledge or even physical fitness. After all, it's only by understanding the psychology of overeating that you'll be able to counteract it and maintain healthy habits permanently, even through periods of stress and adversity.

Do you eat when you're lonely? Depressed? Afraid? Keeping a food journal helps identify problem emotions and their related food patterns by tracking not only what is eaten, but the emotions and feelings that often initiate this eating. Many experts believe that overeating and emotional eating share a similar pathway in the brain with recreational drugs. Emotional eating may actually lead to chemical changes in the brain that an individual experiences as pleasure, beyond the normal satisfaction one gets from eating when hungry. This kind of overeating provides a short-lived escape from stress, sadness and other negative emotions, but as with other addictions, the high is followed by a low and then the cycle starts all over again.

What are the triggers that cause overeating? Major life changes that are stressful, fearful or anxiety-provoking, such as divorce, losing a job or a sudden financial crisis, as well as everyday stress, such as work, family, traffic and even the weather, can trigger emotional eating. Sometimes our emotions are so tightly connected with eating, that as soon as we feel a strong emotion, we reach for a particular food -- it's like our brains become conditioned to reach for the food as soon as the emotion hits.

Here are a few questions to ask yourself if you're wondering whether you have a healthy relationship towards food:

• Do I eat when I'm hungry or are my emotions talking to me more often than not?

• Do I overindulge on occasion or do I have a regular routine of binge eating?

• Am I a mindless eater or do I savor my food most of the time?

• Am I obsessed with food? Am I constantly monitoring what I eat? (And do I feel a sense of failure when I "blow it"?)


To develop healthier coping strategies that will work for you, it's important to learn more about the connections between your brain and your food choices.

• Pay attention to your body's hunger cues and don't skip meals.

• Be mindful when eating. Don't eat in front of the television, in the car or standing up. Pay attention to your meal. Sit down in a comfortable place and enjoy it.

• Drink plenty of water.

• Give yourself encouragement. Think positively.

• Don't beat yourself up when you slip.

• Try not to ignore your problems and negative feelings. Facing them may be hard, but it's healthy.

• Use your support system; call a friend to talk through any problems you may be having.

• Write it all down! Keep not just a food log, but a journal describing emotions that trigger overindulgence.

• Get out of the house, exercise, read a book, take a bath -- be good to yourself!


If you haven't been able to help yourself, you may benefit from seeing a therapist or psychologist who specializes in emotional eating. Remember that seeking help is a sign of strength not weakness. When it comes to weight management and issues like emotional eating, psychology can explain the "why" of overeating.

Cognitive behavioral therapy is a style that focuses on helping people change their way of thinking which in turn leads to a change in their behavior. Just like a weight loss program, resolving emotional eating is a journey. The first step is awareness and the second is being ready to change. Changing negative, self-defeating thoughts into more positive constructive thoughts is key.


Cheryl Forberg RD is a James Beard award-winning chef, Nutritionist for NBC's The Biggest Loser and NYT bestselling author. Her latest book is Flavor First (Rodale). She lives on a farm in Napa, California. For more nutrition and cooking tips, visit Cheryl's website

 
 
 

Follow Cheryl Forberg, RD on Twitter: www.twitter.com/CherylForbergRD

After a rough meeting at the office, your day ends with an empty carton of ice cream and then a stomach ache. At a party where you don't know anyone, you stand by the buffet table and graze. T...
After a rough meeting at the office, your day ends with an empty carton of ice cream and then a stomach ache. At a party where you don't know anyone, you stand by the buffet table and graze. T...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 89
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
sabelmouse
my micro bio is emty
08:18 AM on 07/31/2011
if you're a woman read '' fat is a feminist issue '' . possibly if you're a man too.
03:13 AM on 07/31/2011
Everyone of us have one craving or the other hungry or not hungry but the big point here is, how you control that crave which puts you into trouble of being overweight. If you know you can't help but scoop a spoonful of that creamy ice cream each time u open yr fridge, keep big cups of ice cream out of yr fridge. Some of my lady clients will tell me--ooh its for the kids! well if you keep it there for the kids..learn how to close yr eyes and control yr urge. Eating when not hungry is a big culprit in being overweight.
10:57 PM on 07/30/2011
The subject of conquering emotional eating is well covered by Roger Gould in Shrink Yourself. I'm not on the payroll but his book and online program have helped me greatly.
07:08 AM on 07/30/2011
Perhaps it's not all about the content of what we're eating, but rather the context. People in many cultures do not eat alone, but rather communally. My parents, of Mediterranean heritage, will wait for over an hour to sit down and eat if one or the other is not home in time. When you eat alone, physical hunger cues may be addressed, but not the need for eye contact, company, conversation...love. But the way our lives are set up, many of us have no choice but to grab and go, or eat whatever we find when we get home after a day's work, and maybe we use extra helpings to compensate for what's missing: the relational part of eating. Also, in many parts of the world, people take their main meal at mid-day, not at the end of the day. This way, they have adequate time to digest and process what they've eaten. Our eating schedules are crazy here in the US, and not just for adults, but for kids in school as well. They come home from school, scarf something down and then go to sports practice, and then come home ravenously hungry and eat some more, or keep eating until they hit the sack. What a mess! Why not just give them a shorter school day, but longer school year (can you tell I'm ready for summer vacation to end already?), so that they can live a lifestyle that is implicitly healthful?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
johnsmith9875
Cranky old man
03:53 PM on 07/29/2011
I eat when I'm not hungry because let's face it, some food is delicious even when you aren't hungry.

Pizza for example. I have a hard time not thinking about it if there are a few slices in the fridge. I don't connect guilt with food, I just like the taste.

Ever have a hankering for raw celery? Yeah I figured as much.
03:07 AM on 07/31/2011
You are just honest but if you refuse to control yrbody and urge to open the fridge and pick a slice of pizza...you could wake up one day not fitting into yr fav pants/skirt.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:48 AM on 07/31/2011
With pizza inside my fridge is talking to me 24/7
05:53 PM on 07/28/2011
I think it's also important to understand the difference between diet foods that can create these hunger cravings and healthy eating for fat-loss and a healthy lifestyle as stated by Exercise Physiology Expert Ben Greenfield: http://naturalvitalitysports.com/2011/03/healthy-eating-fitness-do-diet-foodhttp://www.huffingtonpost.com/cheryl-forberg-rd/emotional-eating_b_909080.html#s-lower-your-fitness/
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bryneen Gary
No cash no post
02:27 PM on 07/28/2011
When a Woman sees a Good Lookin' Man, she Looks
When you se some Good Looking Food
You may want to taste it
Mochilero
Have backpack, will travel
02:50 AM on 07/28/2011
There is a simple reason that most people overeat. Our mega-corporations push over processed, chemical non-foods full of empty calories. Many people are both overstuffed and malnourished. Their bodies are crying out for nutrition, which is why they feel hungry even when full.
11:06 PM on 07/27/2011
The "emotional eating" hypothesis is one of those things that catches on in spite of a complete lack of empirical evidence that such a thing actually exists, because we can all think of times when we experience a negative emotion or some other stressor, then ate something. (This is the "confirmation bias". We forget the times when we had the same emotion or stressor and didn't eat a damn thing.)

In fact there will likely never be any evidence for "emotional eating", for this reason: Just because something happens after something else, doesn't mean that the second thing was caused by the first thing. (This is the "post hoc, ergo propter hoc" logical fallacy.)

Cheryl will probably keep her job, though.
12:06 AM on 07/28/2011
I agree. It's kind of like the somewhat common theory that back pain can be in your head.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
skeptique
Graphic designer in LA
12:29 AM on 07/28/2011
I would imagine, to varying degrees, many clinical disorders are fallaciously diagnosed.
10:56 PM on 07/27/2011
I eat when I'm not hungry because, these days, I'm not sure there'll be food around tomorrow.
03:20 AM on 07/31/2011
if you keep going like this, then you will go out of shape..how do you even enjoy what you eat when not hungry? Eating should be fun and enjoyable and this happens when u really hungry and want to eat something u love. Talking about not having what to eat next day. Rather than having this negative idea or feeling, snap out of it and do things that will keep you positive. When you plan your life and resolve to LIVE life to the fullest, you just can't be afraid of what to eat next day...do your own bit...trust in GOD and tommorr will take care of itself. Doesn't sound good to you? That is the bare fact.the truth!
09:55 PM on 07/27/2011
People had stress, 50 years ago, a hundred years ago, a thousand..­. Why didn't they have our weight problems? Admittedly they got more exercise, and the food they ate was probably higher in nutrients, but there is a third problem we face that they didn't.

Our food choices require extreme selectivity to avoid chemicals added by big-food. These chemicals, of the MSG family, are documented to increase appetites by 40%. Big-food adds them because they will do almost anything to increase profits, and hungrier customers equals more sales and bigger profits.

If you are like me, you want tomatoes and peppers when you buy salsa, you want oil, vinegar and herbs when you buy italian dressing, you want eggs, oil, vinegar and herbs when you buy mayo. In other words, it is not now, nor has it ever been your intention to buy chemicals that increase your appetite when you buy salsa, italian dressing, or mayo. But guess what, that's what you are getting from big-food. Welcome to modern life.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dsws
No owning ideas. Limit only commercial use.
08:31 PM on 07/27/2011
"Do you eat when you're lonely? Depressed? Afraid?"

No, I eat when I'm not hungry BECAUSE THERE'S FOOD SITTING IN FRONT OF ME. About nine times out of ten I see the food and have the presence of mind not eat it. But the tenth time, it's still there. I could raise that to ninety-nine out of a hundred, and unless I have a way to actually escape from its presence before the hundredth time, the food would still get eaten.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
dsws
No owning ideas. Limit only commercial use.
08:24 PM on 07/27/2011
"After a rough meeting at the office, your day ends with an empty carton of ice cream and then a stomach ache."

Where did this nonsense about stomach aches come from? Parents tell the Iie to their kids, who grow up and tell it to theirs, but no one has ever actually gotten a stomach ache from too much sugar. It makes you feel crabby and tired. It makes you fat. It shortens your life expectancy. Isn't that enough? Why do we need to add a fictional stomach ache to the pile?
photo
Absolute
Teacher and Old-School Liberal
10:29 PM on 07/27/2011
Ice cream is not just sugar. It is not uncommon for some people to get a stomach ache after eating a carton of ice cream.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sarah Trickey
love, luck and lollipops. Narf!
12:21 AM on 07/28/2011
I have gotten a stomache ache (and nasty migraines) from eating too much sugar, but I have hyper-insulinism.
mikiao
Empty my micro-bio is.
04:44 PM on 07/27/2011
"Keeping a food journal helps identify problem emotions and their related food patterns by tracking not only what is eaten, but the emotions and feelings that often initiate this eating."

And then after reading this journal you become depressed about how much you eat. And because you eat when you're depressed...you eat some more. But you remember to write it down in your journal, which you read later and get depressed about how much you eat...

I know some people that just eat when they're bored. Preparing, cooking, eating, and cleaning up afterwards gives them something to do. On the plus side...they usually send me leftovers.
04:03 PM on 07/27/2011
Actually just the opposite happens with me. When I'm tense or upset, I can't eat.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Gudrun
My micro-bio is empty
05:20 PM on 07/27/2011
Same here. I can eat too much when I am bored, but I am pretty good at noticing when that happens and stopping the behavior.
06:36 PM on 07/27/2011
Depends on the type of tension. True anxiety definitely kills my appetite. But loneliness and boredom definitely makes me scramble to the fridge.
photo
liberalarmyfamily
let them eat blue velvet cake!
05:05 AM on 07/28/2011
this is me too. When I'm EXTREMELY upset or tense I can't eat. But just being bored or perhaps annoyed with the circumstances around me and I'll rush to the chocolate or nuts.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
peachfuzz
my favorite color is pinko
09:49 AM on 07/29/2011
I think this is why most people eat too much. I think there are many lonely people in the world. And it is not necessarily not being married or not having family or friends. It's the quality, not quantity of relationships. Eating is a source of comfort. We can't fix peoples' relationships but if we can get people to move more and love themselves more without external sources of love or approval, they can start to change themselves and their lives.