iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Cheryl Forberg, RD

GET UPDATES FROM Cheryl Forberg, RD
 

Open Letter From a Chef/Dietitian to Paula Deen

Posted: 01/19/12 07:47 PM ET

Dear Paula,

First off, let me say that me say that I am sorry to hear your announcement that you have been diagnosed with Type 2 Diabetes (DM2). I want to make you an offer: Let me help you. Let me work with you and to control your diabetes through proper diet so you don't have to take any medications.

I've done this before, many times in fact, and I am confident I can help you. But most important, I don't want the millions of Americans suffering from diabetes to think the only way to control the disease is through a prescription.

I understand you've modified your diet (and are sharing your new recipes with others), and I applaud your efforts. But I'm here to tell you that you can do so much more with diet and lifestyle changes.

As the former nutritionist for NBC's "The Biggest Loser" and the co-author of the show's eating plan, I personally counseled and worked with every one of the 250-plus contestants for 12 seasons from 2004 to 2011. One in four of them began with the same type of diabetes you have: They all left without it (and without taking prescription medication). In fact, U.S. News and World Report recently ranked the diet I co-authored the No. 1 Diet for Controlling Diabetes.

Of course, there are cases of diabetes that need medication, but Paula, why don't we work together to show people that there are other ways to control it? You may not present yourself as a role model, but I am urging you to lead by example on this important issue.

Like you, I am also a chef. I attended the Culinary Academy in San Francisco before apprenticing in France. This was 20 or so years ago, so the foundation of my cooking was French classical -- lots of butter, cream and the like. This was before nutrition was a part of any culinary school curriculum.

I worked in restaurants in San Francisco for a year before I realized restaurant life wasn't for me and I chose another path -- working as a private chef for families who could afford to have their own chef. At the time, the interest of most of my private clients was healthy cooking -- low fat, low salt, low sugar, low cal or some combination thereof. Since there were few chefs at the time that knew much about nutrition (and few nutritionists at that time who knew about cooking) I taught myself how to adapt my recipes to suit the needs of my health-conscious clientele. My burgeoning culinary awareness coupled with the healthy approach led to high demand. To explore the bounds of how far I could go designing nutritious meals that also tasted great -- and to understand the physiology of why my clients were eating a certain way -- I returned to school at UC Berkeley to earn a degree in Nutrition and Clinical Dietetics along with my Registered Dietitian credential.

Since then, my career's taken a few detours and I've followed an incredibly interesting path. Seven years ago I joined the medical expert team of what was then a pilot for a soon-to-be smash hit television series "The Biggest Loser," which I mentioned to you already.

I don't claim to know a lot about your cooking style. I haven't watched your show, though I've read much about it and I've seen your recipes. As long as we are talking about recipes, here's the perfect one for a diet that can lead to DM2: large portion sizes, eating foods high in fat and full of too many simple carbs, processed foods and baked goods; add meal skipping, drinking too many calories (such as sugary soft drinks and sweet tea), and little or no exercise and you have a recipe for disaster.

I know you've teamed up with a drug company to get your blood sugar under control in hopes of reversing your DM2. Because you are a public figure, I'd again implore you to use this opportunity to help educate the millions of Americans who have developed weight- and diet-related DM2. And to educate the millions more who are in danger.

Though medications are indeed the optimal route for some people with DM2, the fact is that old fashioned exercise and dietary changes are cheaper, better and more accessible for most people.

I'd love to help you and in turn help many others.

For more by Cheryl Forberg, RD, click here.

For more on diabetes, click here.

Cheryl Forberg, RD is a James Beard award-winning chef, former nutritionist for NBC's "The Biggest Loser" and NYT bestselling author. Her latest book is "Flavor First" (Rodale). She lives on a farm in Napa, California. For plenty of scrumptious recipes, check out her website or follow her on Twitter or Facebook.

 
 
 

Follow Cheryl Forberg, RD on Twitter: www.twitter.com/CherylForbergRD

 
 
  • Comments
  • 8
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
01:11 AM on 01/29/2012
I feel compelled to post a comment because (as an RD and CDE), I cringe when I hear promises that if people just try harder, or just change their diet, they won't need diabetes medications. Sure, avoiding the need for diabetes medications can be an outcome of improving diet, losing weight and exercising. I also see people achieve this. Early in the diagnosis of type 2 diabetes, or in prediabetes, people can make incredible progress with lifestyle management. But we (health professionals) shouldn't be making promises that we can prevent the need for medications. Nutrition and exercise are essential in the management of diabetes--whether a person is on medications or not. In fact, the role of diabetes educators and dietitians is equally essential once a person is using diabetes medications or insulin. The ultimate therapeutic goal of diabetes management is not to get everyone off medication or prevent the need for medication, but to manage blood glucose, cholesterol and blood pressure levels, maintain health, and prevent complications. We need to celebrate good blood glucose control without holding persons with diabetes to an often unreachable standard of accomplishing this via diet and exercise alone. The mere fact that at diagnosis, a person with type 2 diabetes has already lost 50% of insulin producing capacity makes the need for medication necessary in a majority of people with diabetes.
08:10 PM on 01/22/2012
Sorry but I respectfully disagree with this post. Ms Deen isn't a contestant on Biggest Loser who are/were all carefully chosen by a team consisting of not only TV producers but also medical staff, exercise coaches and a dietitian. I know this because I've interviewed Cheryl. Though I've met Ms. Deen, interviewed her and spent time with her and her family I don't know her height, weight, medical history, HgbA1C or fasting glucose...nor does Cheryl because that's private information. Having worked with diabetics for over 15 years and growing up with a type 2 diabetic and being married to a type 1 diabetic I would say yes, there are diabetics who may be able to delay being on medication or may be able to decrease or even eliminate medication by following the appropriate diet, exercise and achieving weight loss (if necessary). But then I'm a dietitian - not a doctor - and I don't prescribe drugs - nor does Cheryl Forberg or any dietitian-so I don't get to make that decision. If diabetes - and clearly we are talking about type 2 here - was a disease that could be managed solely by going to dietitians then we would rule the world...but alas, it isn't and so we don't and that's because even within type 2 diabetics there are those for whom diet and exercise are not the complete answer.
07:19 PM on 01/23/2012
I respectfully disagree with you. Many doctors are the drug pushers of Big Pharma and the financial interest is with the drug not the diet. And "if type 2 diabetis was a disease that could be managed solely by going to dietitians" NO, dietitians would not rule the world, Big Pharma still would. That's because changing diets and exercising is a lot harder than popping pills everyday and hoping for the best.
01:10 AM on 01/25/2012
Good points. The way 100% of "Reality" shows are Scripted & Staged - I would venture to guess they carefully screen those contestants so that, for example, ONLY the ones who have the kind of Diabetes that can definitely be reversed via diet/exercise alone are the ones selected for the show -- so they can say precisely that -- that it was the show's approach via diet/exercise that "cured" the contestant of their diabetes.

NO ONE but Paula, her team of doctors and her family know what she has been doing for the last three years to get her diabetes under control.
Had she been successful with diet and exercise -- she would undoubtedly -- be promoting that.
As it happens, she requires medication and therefore, that is the route she is taking -- for now.
Perhaps one day her condition will be such that she may be able to come off the meds and maintain her health with just diet and exercise.
Everyone is different and she is quite wealthy enough that she does NOT need the extra money AND likely has the BEST team of doctors money can buy.

It seems alot must be genetic with her because let's presume her sons ate the same as she for 18 years and they appear pretty fit.
In addition, if you actually watch her show - the does not use ANY processed foods (that I can recall - or very little).
At least she's encouraging home cooking.
07:45 PM on 01/20/2012
I should point out that there is nothing in the way of scientific evidence that Ms. Forberg's diet is effective in the treatment or prevention of diabetes. The U.S. News & World Report rankings are based on the opinions of "experts".

That Biggest Loser contestants achieve greater glycemic control through weight-loss is not surprising, but diabetes is a life-long condition, and those same contestants, almost without exception, return to both their original weights and their original problems with blood sugar in fairly short order.
01:11 AM on 01/25/2012
haha...i thought the same thing. it's not exactly a ringing endorsement coming from a 'news' magazine.
it's not like it's the New England Journal of Medicine or the American Diabetes Assoc or something with some street cred.
10:16 AM on 01/20/2012
YES.
12:28 AM on 01/20/2012
If you are looking for freebies like myself the best place online to get is "Get Official Samples" You can qualify easily with out credit card.