More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Chris Ladd

GET UPDATES FROM Chris Ladd
 

Romney Is Right About the Very Poor

Posted: 02/ 2/2012 5:26 pm

A political gift can come in an awkward package. The left's efforts to frame Romney's remarks this week about "the very poor" are likely to have an unintended consequence for Democrats. They are hardening the impression that the left is hopelessly disconnected from middle class concerns. Call it a gaffe, call it an error, but if the Democrats succeed in their misguided effort to define Romney by that statement, Obama is more likely to lose this election.

Here's what Romney actually said:

"I'm not concerned about the very poor. We have a safety net there. If it needs repair, I'll fix it. I'm not concerned about the very rich, they're doing just fine. I'm concerned about the very heart of the America, the 90, 95 percent of Americans who right now are struggling and I'll continue to take that message across the nation."

Everything you need to know about the 2012 election is in that paragraph. Romney got it right.

The economic issue of our era is the damage done to middle and working class families by the financial disaster of the past decade. The housing crisis has destroyed the most potent method of capital accumulation available to ordinary people. The transition out of industrial era capitalism to a more dynamic information-based economy has stalled, leaving millions of workers in limbo. A culture of debt at all levels of our society is choking off opportunities for investment and fostering stagnation.

Meanwhile, in the midst of the worst crisis since the Great Depression, our safety net for the very poor is so strong that we have had to redefine hunger. We no longer count the number of people who starve to death, because that number is zero. We no longer count the number of people who suffer from malnutrition because that is so rare. The hunger statistic we follow now is called "food insecurity."

As Romney correctly pointed out, the very poor have state and federal assistance available to help with housing and food. They can receive direct financial payments. They get healthcare provided by the government through Medicaid (more than 50m people in 2010). Democrats deserve credit for building this safety net and Romney in his statement makes clear his commitment to keep it working. The outcome of this election will not affect the support system for the poorest Americans.

What Romney has accomplished with this "gaffe" is to expose the blinding effects of left's fascination with poverty. While Democrats kvetch over The Very Poor and far too many Republicans hyperventilate about abortion and gays, the rest of the world is building better schools, freer commerce, and new ways to compete. We need to shift our focus to stay ahead.

Romney gets that that a fresh program of government aid is not what struggling Americans are most concerned about. They want opportunities to earn their own way up the economic ladder through productive work.

The Democrats are welcome to make this election about the very poor if they want. There's no greater program of aid they could offer to America's needy Republicans.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 36
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bob Metcalfe
Caught at 1st. slip trying to cut
02:35 PM on 02/06/2012
It's only about the middle class because they're articulate and VOTE.
02:17 AM on 02/05/2012
We now interrupt this blog and switch to California

Dental benefits for adults who are over 21: Tooth extractions (And that's it)

But wait there's a small catch- You have to pay for your own X-rays and your own exam.

If your tooth can be saved have a great day pay the receptionist on the way out

A safety net you can depend on--- Please stop acting like Obama is passing out Medical Gold Cards for the disenfranchised...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Krystal Braswell
10:50 AM on 02/03/2012
Romney is not right about the poor. The same so called safety net for the poor, Romney is talking about is the same safety net that he wants to cut if he wins the presidential election. The safety net that the poor and middle class want is a job.
09:47 AM on 02/03/2012
Republicans are, simply stated, selfish, mean spirited, misguided, and self obsorbed. From health care to foodstamps, and every program in between, the GOP views them all as handouts. While it would be political suicide to campaign on the immediate removal of all of these programs, be warned, this is at the core of their inner beliefs. They view government as a hinderence to the continued march toward total social class seperation. It is simple folks; the growing seperation between the wealthy and the poor has never been greater in our society. If we revisit history it is one of the reasons that our founding fathers left Europe. Nobility (wealthy) and the poor (peasants). If the GOP was truely a party of the people, they never would have been the party that orchastrated the policies, and pushed for the deregulation, that have all but destroyed the middle class. Their business and political policies of greed over need are the reason we are faced with this crises we find ourselves in. President Obama didn't start unfunded wars while at the same time giving the biggest tax break in history to the wealthy. He did not create policies that allowed corporate america to flourish overseas, while Americans sufferd at home. I understand while the wealthy support Republicans, it procets their interests. When the poor support them all that comes to mind is insanity.
01:19 AM on 02/05/2012
Paranoid much?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:18 AM on 02/03/2012
Did I just tune in to another episode of "Pointless?" I feel like I've seen this show so many times!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
08:54 AM on 02/03/2012
What is a Republican Precinct Committeeman? ( I must confess, i really didn't know what one did, but I found the following on republicannewswatch).

"A Republican Precinct Committeeman represents the GOP voters of his or her precinct at the County Republican Party level.
But most importantly, a Republican Precinct Committeeman is the face of the GOP within the precinct. In many cases, a Republican Precinct Committeeman might be the only party official a voter ever meets in person.
This volunteer position is really what one makes of it. Some do more than others. But the Republican Precinct Committeeman’s job is in essence all about helping to grow the GOP and working to deliver the maximum number of Republican votes from his or her precinct on Election Day. Precinct Committeemen comprise the core of any grassroots effort and no political campaign can be successful without these front line GOP ambassadors.
The principle means of doing the job is just an extension of what most people already do – talking to the neighbors.
By becoming a Republican Precinct Committeeman you can take a leadership role in advancing the Republican Platform principles of lower taxes, smaller government, fiscal responsibility, individual freedom, strong national defense, and traditional family values. (family values myass)

O.K., so now I know. But I do have one other question:
Who is in charge of losing and shredding ballots?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
08:47 AM on 02/03/2012
Thanks Chris. Brilliant and insightful as only a republican zombie (must have long-term capital gains tax rates, must have long-term capital gains tax rates) can be. But seriously, I really do love the lock-step delusional qualities of republican puppies such as yourself. It's like you push a button or pull a string and you all utter the same nonsense! It's hilarious, and as you well know, your delightful republican bretheren and misguided sisterns (I made that one up to describe republican women) are busily trying to dismantle the shreds of any safety net still available to the very poor who have suffered inumerable indignities at the hands of your republican overlords. But I love a good laugh on a Friday morning so thanks!
photo
rbenjamin
Rule 5 rules
08:30 AM on 02/03/2012
You wish. The Democrats are going to make this election about Romney and how he made his fortune. The devil will be in his details. There are already plenty, and many more will surface when the forensic accounts have had a good look. Ah, the very special ethics of the rich.

Most people without rich, well connected genes won't find it very pretty. That will include many of the GOP rank and file who ultimately vote for him. Independents will not tend to be so charitable.

Mitt Romney, class warrior and gaffe machine. And he's the most electable candidate of the remaining four! Two of which seem likely to run as independents or third party.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:10 AM on 02/03/2012
If medicaid is doing such a great job, then why do very poor humans spend much time in the emergency rooms? If tuition assistance is doing such a great job, then why are we not seeing the very poor getting good paying jobs? If food assistance is doing such a great job, then why do very poor humans panhandle for a cup of coffee? If housing assistance is doing such a great job, then why are humans sleeping in abandoned cars and on the streets? If energy assistance is doing such a great job, why do very poor humans die during weather extremes? Are these not valid human concerns? Is it an insult to refer to these concerns as a human's "fascination with poverty"?
12:33 AM on 02/03/2012
Makes me sad to see such articles, that basically are part of the political agenda of the teapublicans because he is one and trying up most to put some positive spin and basically lie about the situation. This was a huge gaff of Romney's because I feel he truly believes this, that there is some safety net. There is no net you fools!!! You Mr Ladd and your ilk are so disconnected from the poor you have no idea of what is reality for the poor. Then just how close a middle class family is to being poor, last study posted this week put that figure at 47%, loss of job or major illness away from being poor. This attitude is callous. This attempt of spin is even more contemptible and an insult to the middle class and poor. He just wants to get his teapublican elected to further the assult by the rich against the rest of the citizens of the USA. Folks we are being used by the rich and Mr Ladd is one of their minions.
03:22 AM on 02/03/2012
all I see in this article is an attempt to excuse the utter tone deafness of the GOP's front running Republican candidate.

here's the thing about communication....nobody can suck words back into their mouth once they say them.

Sooner or later...all politicans do show you who they are...presidents, senators,,,in Canada prime
ministers and opposition leaders. They are in public too much and speak too often not to eventually...show who they are.

maybe Gov. Romney sounds like a guy disconnected from most Americans because that's what he is and all the opinion pieces trying to explain his comments can't change it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Lou on Vancouver Island
Allin, Lou: Mystery Author
11:39 PM on 02/03/2012
Medical problems alone should NEVER be the factor for tipping someone into poverty. That never happens north of the border. Thank Goddess and the NDP, New Democratic Party, the left wing which convinced the major parties to begin national health care in the Sixties.
10:54 PM on 02/02/2012
He says "If it needs fixing, I'll fix it." He doesn't know whether or not it needs fixing? He hasn't bothered to look at that, after all this time running for President?
10:52 PM on 02/02/2012
Romney says "If it needs fixing, I'll fix it." He means he has not looked into whether or not it needs fixing, after such a long time of running for President?
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Bruce Lesley
President of First Focus. Child advocate.
10:42 PM on 02/02/2012
Chris, you miss a very key fundamental point. Yes, Romney said, "I'm not concerned about the very poor. We have a safety net there. If it needs repair, I'll fix it." And, he cites how Medicaid is there for low-income seniors, people with disabilities, and children. So, what is his "fix" for Medicaid? He is proposing $700 billion...let me repeat...$700 billion in cuts to the program. That is no "fix." That is tearing the "safety net" apart at the seams.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
healthanalyst
Banned from commenting, so?
04:37 AM on 02/03/2012
Privatizing Medicare and turning it into a voucher program. Funny, Medicare was set up by LBJ because the elderly and retired could not afford or get health insurance. And its worse now if you go look for a personal policy (I know people in their mid 50s to early 60s who have their COBRA running out that can't find policies...)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Lou on Vancouver Island
Allin, Lou: Mystery Author
11:41 PM on 02/03/2012
LBJ. I hated him at the time for Vietnam, which wasn't entirely his fault. Blame Kennedy for starting it and the generals for lying to him.
My apologies, fellow Democrat. You were a gutsy guy when it came to bringing in civil rights. You knew the South would be lost to the Dems for fifty years, and you were right.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sd4david
10:06 PM on 02/02/2012
What planet is this guy on? Way to many homeless people in the US. No address means no food aid. Republican policies have devastated the price most people get for their labor. And they cut taxes on the wealthy to "starve the beast " so they can then cut funding on everything but the military industrial complex. Ie corporate welfare.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tpeserik
09:18 PM on 02/02/2012
What you fail to mention is that the Right wants to slash our social safety nets. Where will that leave these people?