More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Chris Michael

Chris Michael

Posted: April 26, 2010 02:47 PM

Arizona Immigration Bill Makes History by Ignoring It

What's Your Reaction:

PHOENIX--Arizona passed the toughest immigration bill in the United States on Friday that many critics say is a slap in the face to over a century of civil rights efforts across the globe, fanned by lingering Birther sentiments against President Obama.

"Whoa, whoa. Hold up. Let's get one thing straight," said Arizona Governor Jan Brewer, who signed the bill into action last week. "This is not some snarky reaction to a black president in the White House right now. That's ridiculous--everyone knows there are no black people in Arizona. This is a reaction to Washington's inability to act."

During Obama's first year in office, the Department of Homeland Security, lead by Governor Brewer's predecessor Janet Napolitano, deported on average over a thousand people a day--more than twice the average under George W. Bush--and a detail many suspect never trickled down to Arizona lawmakers because it wasn't fair and balanced enough.

Governor Brewer defended the new bill, saying it was a crackdown on illegal immigration in the state that would require police to stop anyone suspected of being illegal and demand proof of U.S. documentation.

"Um... Am I the only one who remembers the first twenty minutes of Schindler's List?" asked Cardinal Archbishop Roger Mahony of Los Angeles.

Arizona lawmakers say the new bill is about legality, not ethnicity. Owners of cars with purple-tinted windows and last names spelled in gold Gothic lettering can expect to be pulled over and questioned, regardless of ethnic background.

Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio says law enforcement officials plan on implementing a tagging system to prohibit the blatant racial profiling that many fear could result from the new law.

"Any detained brown people," said Mr. Arpaio, "found to be American brown people will be given a star to wear on their clothing, like mine--see? Now, this way my officers know if they've already handcuffed and interrogated someone. And like I tell my brown people: Wear it with pride! It's a star that says they're winners. They're special. Like USDA beef."

"Going forward, it's important to look back and learn from history," said the governor, herself a product of Arizona's education system. "And if there's one thing that history has taught us again and again, it's that conservative white people in political power in regions where they're the ethnic minority--waving flags to fan the flames of their racial, economic, and nationalistic fears--always ends well."

Earlier that week, Ms. Brewer also signed into law a bill allowing Arizona citizens to carry concealed weapons without a permit and lifting the ban on firearms in bars.

"Always," said the governor. "Always, always, always."

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 14
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
02:30 AM on 04/27/2010
The fundamental reasoning behind not enforcing basic immigration law is: There are already so many illegals here who will object to being arrested / deported that it's just not worth even trying anymore.

This is the same as saying, "There are too many law-breakers who would object to the law being enforced once in a while, so let's just forget the whole thing."
05:33 PM on 04/26/2010
You gotta love these 18th century Republicans. They are clueless. Good luck getting the Hispanic vote guys !.............LOL
04:51 PM on 04/26/2010
Well, well, well, Sheriff Joe's certainly a "star", isn't he - what a clever way to minimize abusive, repetitive racial profiling. You (Chris) have put a humorous twist to a despicable situation - the right-wing nuts who have taken over the AZ legislature and turned AZ in 2010 into Alabama of 1963 - Arpaio and Brewer are the "modern" day Bull Connor and George Wallace. You've deftly used humor to call out these clowns. I'm glad that I don't live in AZ - next time I go there I'll bring my passport, and show them the numbers tattooed on my forearm. Well done, Chris !
05:02 PM on 04/26/2010
I am never going to Arizona......I am so glad I do not live in such a hateful state.
04:08 PM on 04/26/2010
Hey! Why don't--ALL--the illegal aliens, squatting in Arizona pack up their truck with all their family members and head for California. Los Angeles Mayor will give you food stamps, low income housing. There is a few emergency hospitals not closed down yet, where you can get treatment for free. The schools can build more outbuildings, so the already clogged classrooms can take all the children that don't comprehend English. They can get money expenses from the state and the old, the handicapped people in your family circle can collect SSI. Come to think of it, why don't we just put a welcome mat on both borders and one at airport terminal and let millions of pregnant females get instant citizenship for their new baby, collect the supplements to low income above. Then remember even though you haven't paid any taxes you can still cheat the IRS and collect thousands of dollars for your kid's under the Mothers name, then collect the same amount again for the same kid's under the Fathers name. Oh! Yes! Don't forget you can collect even more government checks for existing or non-existing kid in the country you left behind. Our IRS agents don't check. We have our share of common criminals amongst our citizens without importing more. No wonder this country is slipping into bankruptcy, because this government does not care for the people--they have sworn to protect. NumbersUSA will spill the truth, not lies.
05:00 PM on 04/26/2010
so, I'd love to hear what your thoughts are about how much this country is spending on our war.....You seem al concerned about our finances, yet totally overlook all the money we spend on this lie of a war....it's okay to worry about your taxes as long as you sound as seething hateful beings...but, when it comes to really looking at our true expenses...no one seems to see the huge elephant in the room.....our military......
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Rick Scheuer
Techincal writer, architectural specifier
02:13 PM on 04/27/2010
Not good enough for Arizona, but good enough for the US Army. http://www.truthout.org/article/illegal-immigrants-uncle-sam-wants-you
04:07 PM on 04/26/2010
Any state, county city, town or public servant that boycotts the exceptional state of Arizona, should be black-listed. Hopefully--Americans will donate (however small) money to Arizona if the Governor Jan brewer gets sued. Perhaps a good patriotic American will arrange a website for everybody to give money in the immediate future? If and when it happens my check will be waiting...? If that happens Americans will boycott companies that hire illegal immigrants and that I will add--ONE--company hiring foreign labor to my blogs.
photo
BlackJAC
It's better to be a black king than a white knight
09:32 AM on 04/27/2010
Arizona's the second most useless state in the US. Its most recent contribution to Civilization was Emma Stone. It hasn't done jack since.
05:32 PM on 04/27/2010
YEH, well you won't ever catch me in AZ, I'd drive miles around it if I have to, they ain't gonna get my tax dollars for anything. its a dirty state. why should anyone hold conventions in AZ, so their members who are foreign looking, will have to show papers when stopped, RIGHT. jane
03:37 PM on 04/26/2010
The comparison to the Nazis is a favorite mischaracterization of this law. I am sorry a fellow Catholic in a high office chose that irresponsible comparison, from a movie, no less. And he is educated?

What happened to protecting our borders? My grandparents came into this country legally, doing everything to be responsible as contributing...LEGAL...members of this country. They actually learned the language. Now the vast and legal majority have to press as friggin' button on the phone and read everything in taxpayer-paid signs in several different languages.

What the hell happened to the laws? They were there for a reason. They keep our country united, functional, and safe.

Most other countries jail you, or worse, for crossing their borders. Here we give them everything, at the expense of the legals.
04:57 PM on 04/26/2010
This law is moving towards a fascist ideal. Now tell me what is an undocumented woman to do if she were to get robbed, raped or beaten? You sound hateful as all these people do......hate disguised as a concerned citized......yawn!
05:31 PM on 04/26/2010
How detached from history and absurd! Hitler would have gassed all the illegal aliens if they weren’t blue eyed and blond. The government has to protect its citizens not hordes of invaders. So much for the hollow phrase “we are a nation of laws”. Instead of enforcing the immigration laws our federal government on purpose skirts enforcement and now bellyaches that somebody actually is trying to do the job. The investigation by the justice department needs to start by investigating the gross negligence of the federal government bloodying their hands for being responsible for the killings committed by the invaders. Who cares about the invaders national origin, get those criminal parasites out.