iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Christian Piatt

GET UPDATES FROM Christian Piatt
 

When Preachers Become False Prophets

Posted: 12/ 2/2011 9:06 am

My first job in a church was as a music minister. I loved the senior pastor I served with, as did the congregation we faced every Sunday morning. He taught me a lot about worship, preaching and how to connect with people.

One time we were at lunch, reflecting on the previous week's service, when he made a statement that seemed benign at the time. "I love my job," he said. "every week, I get to stand up in front of a congregation and say beautiful things to people."

Doesn't sound so horrible, right? I mean, who doesn't like to hear beautiful words? It was only over time that the issues I had with this perspective on preaching came to light.

A couple of years later, the church fell into disarray when the pastor had charges of sexual harassment levied against him. Though not the first time such charges had surfaced involving him, the congregation rallied around the pastor they loved. Amy and I, however, left the church, disheartened by the scandal. Within another couple of years, he was accused yet again and the church fell apart. He left the ministry for a secular vocation.

The matters of sexual impropriety are obvious indicators of a sickness, one that reflects a larger disenchantment with organized religion throughout our contemporary culture. From child-abusing priests to televangelist con artists, such violations of both the office of ministry and of the trust of those we serve is easy to name. Plenty of people will name such illicit wrongdoing as the reason they have walked away from organized religion all together, though there is a problem that I would suggest is far more insidious and pervasive that is at the heart of the Church's popular decline.

Preaching is a curious discipline. Summoning equal parts poet, philosopher, scholar, counselor and theologian, there truly is no other vocation like it. There is an opiate-like attraction of preaching. We hold not only people's attention in our hands, but often their faith as well. It's a position of power and influence, and the response we get from those who receive the message can be addictive, particularly if our paychecks hinge upon the receptiveness of such an audience.

We all love to witness beauty, and to hear words that convey that beauty. We love being told that, despite our circumstances, things will always get better, that everything ultimately will be all right. It's tempting for preachers to offer such messages of superficial optimism too, as such messages evoke the kind of ego affirmation that helps us feel good about the job we're doing.

We feel good about what we say, the congregation feels good about what they hear, and everyone leaves smiling. We return the following week to receive our next bump of feel-good assurance to help us through the next week.

The problem is that none of us believes it, including the preacher.

Yes, life is beautiful, but it is also difficult, tragic, complicated and sometimes inexplicable. Yet we come to church and hear that, despite the hard times, everything's actually tinted with a rose hue; we just have to look a little harder. Have faith; it all will work out for the best.

Except when it doesn't.

It's nice to leave church smiling and feeling optimistic, but there's a growing sense of disconnect between what is conveyed within the church walls and what happens the other 167 hours of the week. We're told God is always there for us, yet we feel a profound sense of loss. We see rows of smiles and pleasantness on Sunday while there's suffering just outside the door. We get the implicit -- and even sometimes explicit -- message that having faith is synonymous with self-assuredness, certainty and perpetual happiness, and then we struggle through the week with our doubts, our fear and tragedies.

Pastors should indeed celebrate the beauty, joy and miraculous mystery of life, but to focus on this while not tempering this with an acknowledgment of struggle, doubt and, yes, suffering, is to offer false prophecy. It is proclaiming the world as it isn't, assuring those who seek wisdom from us that they should feel, think and act one way, while so much in the rest of the world seems to contradict this reality. Yet we continue to seek and affirm the message that offers a short-term bandage for our gaping spiritual wounds, all the while knowing at a deep level that what we're hearing is, at best, not the whole truth, and at worst, a brazen lie.

We think we want to hear that everything will be all right, but the truth is that life is difficult.

We seek words from the pulpit that will ameliorate our doubts and fears, unwilling to acknowledge those same doubts and fears in the very one offering the words of assurance.

We seek a fear-proof faith, but reality reaffirms daily that faith and doubt are not mutually exclusive. In fact, they are inextricably, necessarily married to one another.

We think we want answers, but what we really long for is peace. Such peace cannot be found in pithy, lovely messages or lyrically gilded praise songs that do not reflect a genuine experience of life.

We ask to hear a handful of beautiful words, but what we truly crave is for others to bear witness to our lives. Our whole lives. Not just the pleasant, cheerful parts.

The prophets of the Old Testament will, in one breath, celebrate the fullness of God's presence, and in the next, mourn an equally profound absence. There are psalms of praise and dirges of despair. They hope, dream, doubt and suffer, all the while seeking to better understand what it means to be a divinely-created, divinely-inspired creature. It's beautiful, ugly, healing, terrifying, soul-stretching, gut-wrenching work.

Just like life.

 
 
 

Follow Christian Piatt on Twitter: www.twitter.com/christianpiatt

 
 
  • Comments
  • 108
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Neil20
10:07 AM on 12/05/2011
What the preachers preach are just surface coating akin to jam on bread on a person's spiritual life. American Christians are awash with materialism. They go to church very week or every once in a while to appease their conscience. Their decadent consumerist lifestyles do not offer a chance to enhance their spirituality. Pastors preach what the congregation wants to hear.Unlike other Eastern religions such as Hinduism and Buddhism, Christianity does not believe in re-incarnation. Hindus tolerate the pains of poverty because they believe that they will return in the next life as a different person (or even an animal) and in more fortunate situation. They observe penance, bathe in the sacred rivers of the Ganges and believe that if they're having hard times now, they will surely be blessed with a better next life. This faith bolsters them to face hardships, poverty and grim battles of daily living. Hindus, Buddhists and Jains respect the environment. If they harm the smallest of God's creatures there chances of returning with a better life becomes dim. The real truth as you yourself have admitted is that the Christian preachers themselves don't believe in the messages and the sermons they preach. They themselves are not convicted of the message of Christianity. How can they convict others? Hence, for the lack of conviction Christian preachers become false prophets. Your deeds in this life will determine your position in the next life. This philosophy is absent in Christian teachings and hence the problem.
06:00 AM on 12/05/2011
The gospel message is to comfort the afflicted and afflict those who are comfortable. It seeks to bring comfort in the midst of trials, while challenging those of us sitting on our duffs to engage in making better the lives of our sisters/brothers around us and to care for all of creation. This is part of the reason why I left my last pastorate. I spoke truth to power and was told by members of my congregation that they came to church "to feel better" and "not to hear about suffering." While the pastor must take responsibility for what is said, the question remains, "What responsibility will the people assume in living the gospel messag?"
07:03 PM on 12/04/2011
To wca16
EPO (erythropoietin), a synthetic hormone that stimulates bone marrow to produce red blood cells at an accelerated rate can be used Of course, the body still needs the basic building blocks in order to produce healthy red blood cells. These building blocks are folic acid, vitamin B, and especially iron. Iron dextran (Imferon) administered intravenously is the fastest way to supply needed iron.
Jws do not advise people what to do, consultation with a doctor is still advisable to discuss treatments.
Jws refuse transfusions of whole blood but alternatives can be used which carry no rist.

Fluids: Ringer’s lactate solution, dextran, hydroxyethyl starch, and others are used to maintain blood volume, preventing hypovolemic shock. Some fluids now being tested can transport oxygen.
Drugs: Genetically engineered proteins can stimulate the production of red blood cells (erythropoietin), blood platelets (interleukin-11), and various white blood cells (GM-CSF, G-CSF). Other medications greatly reduce blood loss during surgery (aprotinin, antifibrinolytics) or help to reduce acute bleeding (desmopressin).
Biological hemostats: Collagen and cellulose woven pads are used to stop bleeding by direct application. Fibrin glues and sealants can plug puncture wounds or cover large areas of bleeding tissue.
Blood salvage: Salvaging machines recover blood that is lost during surgery or trauma. The blood is cleansed and can be returned to the patient in a closed circuit. In extreme cases, liters of blood can be recovered using such a system.
Surgical tools: Some devices cut and seal blood vessels simultaneously.
ThinkCreeps
Seriously, it's time.
06:32 AM on 12/04/2011
I'm still not sure when the magic happens to make a prophet false. Is it a single event when they're born, or is it repeated when the alarm goes off every morning?
07:57 AM on 12/04/2011
You just repeated yourself. We all heard you the first time.
ThinkCreeps
Seriously, it's time.
08:06 AM on 12/04/2011
Superstitious deleters are at large - you've got to be careful
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Joel Mendez
actual atheist reverend
08:26 AM on 12/04/2011
no, it's when they 'think'. oh, also when they open their mouths.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ninetailedfox
banning people.....so childish
06:03 AM on 12/04/2011
I was christian. Went to many churches. Tried to find spirituality.
It wasnt until my trip to W Texas that I realized Christianity, because of all its sects and denominations (even non denomination IS a denomination) can break up families.

I finally deconverted, and I havent looked back. People that are christian think I stir up trouble. I just hope they realize that some people just cant be christian, because it goes against their experiences.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Joel Mendez
actual atheist reverend
08:28 AM on 12/04/2011
they can, it just takes a lot. all religions, like bureaucracies, are designed to be self sustaining.
photo
bermudababy
Left lane for passing only!!
06:22 PM on 12/04/2011
Your right. You should not fake feelings that don't exist. That's what hypocrites do.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
gal416
is a Bible verse † † †
11:51 PM on 12/03/2011
"We seek words from the pulpit that will ameliorate our doubts and fears, unwilling to acknowledge those same doubts and fears in the very one offering the words of assurance."

But the ship was now in the midst of the sea, tossed with waves: for the wind was contrary.
And in the fourth watch of the night Jesus went unto them, walking on the sea.
And when the disciples saw him walking on the sea, they were troubled, saying, It is a spirit; and they cried out for fear.
But straightway Jesus spake unto them, saying, Be of good cheer; it is I; be not afraid.
And Peter answered him and said, Lord, if it be thou, bid me come unto thee on the water.
And he said, Come. And when Peter was come down out of the ship, he walked on the water, to go to Jesus.
But when he saw the wind boisterous, he was afraid; and beginning to sink, he cried, saying, Lord, save me.
And immediately Jesus stretched forth his hand, and caught him, and said unto him, O thou of little faith, wherefore didst thou doubt? (Matthew 14:24-31)

As long as Peter kept his focus on Jesus, the storm wasn't a problem, "But when he saw the wind boisterous, he was afraid; and beginning to sink, he cried, saying, Lord, save me".
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Joel Mendez
actual atheist reverend
08:29 AM on 12/04/2011
so what you're saying is, the more you ignore things, the better they become. amazing. is there an empty platitude list somewhere you all are reading from?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bbriani3842
400+ yrs of science & STILL no evidence for a god
08:36 AM on 12/04/2011
Faith is believing what you know ain't so.

-- Mark Twain
09:42 AM on 12/04/2011
Unfortunately Mark Twain was wrong. At Hebrews 11v1 we read "Faith is the assured expectation of things hoped for, the evident demonstration of realities though not beheld.

In other words faith is based on knowledge not blind credulity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Claude Hosch
A single bracelet does not jingle
09:24 PM on 12/03/2011
"When preachers become false prophets"

I'll start with the great deception mentioned in Matt.24:4-5,11. To be deceived you must 1) trust the deciever, 2) not know for yourself, making it possible and easy to be deceived, 3) you accept whats given without question of followup.

For preachers to become successful false prophets they need inaction from their congregation.

If congregations studied more on their own, cultivating a personal relationship with God they would not be easily deceived, and not deceived for long.
09:26 AM on 12/04/2011
Yes you are correct people fail to check what they are taught. At Acts 17v11 we read "Now the latter were more noble-minded than those in Thessaloni′ca, for they received the word with the greatest eagerness of mind, carefully examining the Scriptures daily as to whether these things were so.

Yes they carefully checked the scriptures, something that the churches dont encourage. See 2Tim3v16-17 John 17v17 Matthew 7v15-23
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Claude Hosch
A single bracelet does not jingle
09:47 AM on 12/04/2011
Thanks for sharing that.
ThinkCreeps
Seriously, it's time.
06:37 PM on 12/03/2011
When do they become false prophets?

Either every day between the time the alarm rings and the time they wake up, or from the time
they first take up flock-fleecing.
photo
credfernjr
Writer, minister in conflict transformation
06:32 PM on 12/03/2011
Good one, Christian. It seems we've lost the prophetic aspect of preaching, which calls us to "speak the truth in love:" we humbly attempt to pursue the truth and follow it wherever it leads. If it leads to comfort, wonderful. If it leads us to discomfort, so be it. The problem is that preaching can be seductive to preachers themselves: We love the accolades; we love the laughter that a warm sermon gives. We feel warm ourselves and we can wind up striving for that warmth. We need to check ourselves and ask: "What is my goal? Is it to proclaim the truth to the best of our discernment, or is it to pursue warm fuzzies?" If it is the latter, we may get tentative compliments -- but our people will feel like they're only being fed candy and will ultimately walk away. Trust me. I know.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SmileAndActNice
Utilitarianism, the -ism that works.
06:18 PM on 12/03/2011
It happens the moment you put out a collection plate.
photo
bermudababy
Left lane for passing only!!
03:05 PM on 12/03/2011
I must say when I attended main stream Christian churches I was always left wirh an emptiness. At a younge age I was keenly aware of my spiritual needs, a desire to really know God. I received no encouragement from my family. Eventually I left off looking. The disapointment was too much to bear, so I tried to go through my life still undernurished spiritually.

I knew I needed hard answers, not just my ears to be tickled. I needed to Believe first of all, but in order to do that I'd need to comprehend the Bible. Next to explain the faith in me. To trust those teaching me, so that I, myself, could share in teaching others.I always believed it to be foregone conclusion for true christians to express their faith, to anyone who'd listen. Jesus and His disciples did just that.

Eventually through prayer and spiritual guidance, I was presented with a 'possible' answer. I tread VERY carefully. It wasn't what I was lead to believe. I fought hard to refute the logic presented from the Bible, even though that's the very thing I wanted most. In time it became wholly undeniable. I had found The Truth. I have never regretted my decision to become one of Jehovah's Witnesses.

It very well saved my life. One has to be humble to see it. No fear of man will do, it has to be whole souled.
09:38 PM on 12/03/2011
"I have never regretted my decision to become one of Jehovah's Witnesses" Sister, my only regret is that I didn't do it sooner.
photo
bermudababy
Left lane for passing only!!
10:05 PM on 12/03/2011
Hello My Sweet Sister!!
I knew from your posts on another thread you were my sister. It is undeniable, the ring of truth in our ears. Jehovah's pure language comes through loud and clear. I would love to meet you some day, if not this system, surely in the Paradise. Stay close to Jehovah always!
09:07 AM on 12/04/2011
Well said sis, Bro from England
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Joel Mendez
actual atheist reverend
08:33 AM on 12/04/2011
oh. i see. there are JW's in my family. you people are beyond scary. i mean, children of the corn scary. and sad. you'll wear glasses, drive cars and use computers, but blood transfusions? no. who needs science, right?
09:11 AM on 12/04/2011
According to the textbook Modern Blood Banking and Transfusion Practices by Dr. Denise M. Harmening, “delayed hemolytic transfusion reaction” can occur “in a patient who has previously been sensitized by transfusion, pregnancy, or transplant.” In such cases, the antibodies that cause a patient to react adversely to a transfusion are “not detectable by standard pretransfusion methods.” According to Dailey’s Notes on Blood, hemolysis “can be triggered even when only a small amount of incompatible . . . blood is administered. When renal shutdown does occur the patient is slowly poisoned because the kidneys cannot remove impurities from the blood.”
The Journal of Clinical Oncology, reported: “Patients receiving perioperative blood transfusions have a significantly worse prognosis than patients undergoing cancer surgery without a perioperative transfusion.”

We are glad that science found this out.
photo
bermudababy
Left lane for passing only!!
05:42 PM on 12/04/2011
@joel
Why don't you ask your family members about explaining the stand on blood the Witnesses take? I'm sure they'd tell you.
Joel....I've never met you, but yet you feel the need to insult me. Why? OH, yeh...
I'm 'children of the corn' scary. That's just not right. You do know that, right Joel?
Contrary to what you think, I'm extremely Happy! How could I not be? I have a huge worldwide Christian Family and no fears of the sort this thread discusses.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:24 PM on 12/03/2011
They are ALL false prophets, promoting delusions....
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Robert Frano
‘Plausible Deniability’: NOT A FAMILY_VALUE!!
01:20 PM on 12/03/2011
Re: "...From child-abusing priests to televangelist con-artists, such violations of both the office of ministry and of the trust of those we serve is easy to name."

There are individuals & groups all over the religious.world who, to borrow from my (former) Christianity, I'm literally NOT worthy to wipe the bottoms of...

That said, when one sees a 'Harold Camping', and/or a 'Zyman Alzawaheri', 'J. Ratzinger', 'Meir Kahane', 'Tim McVeigh', etc., another nail is jack-hammered into the whole (ravaged) Abrahamic-Belief idea.
I've NEVER considered proselytizing, (...let alone, violence!), against someone else due to 'religious' differences from either my (past) Catholicism, nor my (current) Neopaganism.

Even if I were a 'prolifer’ I WOUDN’T be caught dead, (or in any other state-of-matter), outside an abortion-provider's site!
It’s just NOT my place!
That makes me a 'bad believer' in some ‘faith’ circles! ...Guilty-as-charged, I'll admit!
01:05 AM on 12/04/2011
I really don't understand what you're talking about...

So Abrahamic religions are violent? And whats wrong with Pope Benedict?

What....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Joel Mendez
actual atheist reverend
08:44 AM on 12/04/2011
uh..yes, and lot's of things.
PATOISJAM
reason: strategize: succeed
06:10 AM on 12/03/2011
Christian, if God's Holy Spirit does not reside with a church, it will not stand. It cannot prosper and it will not flourish. It may for a time and that time be seem to be permanent but it will be destroyed. You are absolutely right about what you say, for although we see around us all the signs of the time of the end being fulfilied in front of our eyes, these preachers have yet to say to people how they are going to escape the Great Tribulation that is coming upon them. That makes them bloodguilty.

Additionally, because these churches do not have God's Holy Spirit they do not have the Godly love that is necessary to be united and strong as a congregation. As they fail and fall you get to see that their foundation is not one built of the "rock" of teachings as set forth by Jesus and his disciple but on a house of cards.

All I can tell you is to get ready to witness the fall of religions for God is not sitting idly by. He is going to destroy them so that not even the ashes from her complete destruction will ever be found.

Revelation chapter 18 describes the demise of false preachers.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Joel Mendez
actual atheist reverend
08:46 AM on 12/04/2011
stop being creepy. the world isn't going to end, you're not going to be raptured, and i don't think the Jets are going to win this season--but then, i don't know anything about football....wait, you don't know anything about the future, either! i guess you can say what you want about the future, so long as i can say i don't think the Jets are going to win this season.
PATOISJAM
reason: strategize: succeed
04:31 PM on 12/04/2011
Creepy no. On point, yes.

People like to have their ears tickled. Truth is a hard thing to swallow because no one wants their way of life disturbed.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bones Rhodes
12:27 AM on 12/03/2011
"The problem is that none of us believes it, including the preacher"

Refreshing when a professing Christian admits the truth.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Joel Mendez
actual atheist reverend
08:47 AM on 12/04/2011
i've already taken a screenshot of this. it might never happen again.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jeff Rosenbury
I love all people -- in the abstract
09:11 AM on 12/04/2011
Do you believe life is without struggle? I've never met anyone who did. Why should this be news?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bones Rhodes
11:11 AM on 12/04/2011
I am not sure of exactly what your question and first statement are in relation to: but, no, I certainly don't think that , for the majority, life isn't a struggle. I, however, have known a few with extreme wealth who wouldn't agree with you.

It is always news when someone who professes to be a Christian admits the truth about their beliefs, even if they didn't really mean to. This a rarity that should get a headline in the Inquirer alongside the "Chicken Gives Birth To 6 Kittens" one.