More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Clarence B. Jones

GET UPDATES FROM Clarence B. Jones
 

The 10th Anniversary of 9/11: A Unique Opportunity for Presidential Leadership

Posted: 09/06/11 01:55 PM ET

During the next 10 days, national attention will be focused on our current unemployment crisis, highlighted by labor organizations' commemoration of Labor Day, and by the 10th anniversary of the terrorist attack on the World Trade Center in New York City on Sept. 11, 2001. Special attention will be directed at the White House and how it responds to both events. And, of course, all of this will be occurring within the long shadow of the 2012 presidential election campaign, occurring less than 14 months from now.

There is disquiet across the land. Issues of climate change, illegal immigration, joblessness, Planned Parenthood clinics, health care, public education, raising or lowering of taxes, insurance coverage for abortions, rising costs of increased incarceration, same-sex marriage, reduction of our national debt, and housing foreclosures are likely to be the subject of spirited, if not acrimonious, public debate and discussion.

The gridlock during the last congressional session and the positions expressed by candidates competing in the Republican presidential primary suggest that we, as a nation, may be at a special place. Our "Ship of State" appears to have a damaged rudder and a malfunctioning compass, requiring the exercise of special, overarching presidential navigation and leadership. The recent "amateur hour" brouhaha between the White House and Speaker Boehner over the scheduling of the date and time of a planned speech by the president announcing new, job-creating initiatives only compounds the impression that our ship is adrift.

The coming 10th anniversary of 9/11 may be just the occasion for such course correction to be considered and implemented. The 9/11 anniversary provides us with another Gabrielle Giffords moment: the Arizona congresswoman's attempted assassination and the killing of several people shocked the conscience of the nation, causing us to stop and reflect for a few days and consider who we are as a nation, as a society and as a civilized people.

Are we reverting to the mindset of a red-state/blue-state nation instead of the mindset of the United States of America? If so, we may need to revisit Grant Park in Chicago on the night of Nov. 4, 2008.

Commemorating 9/11 provides a unique opportunity for the exercise of a healing kind of presidential leadership, the kind of leadership that Candidate Obama asserted in Philadelphia in 2008, for example, when he courageously and forthrightly focused our national attention on the divisive and controversial issue of race relations in America.

Lest we forget, on Sept. 11, 2001, more than 3,000 people, citizens of over 90 countries, were killed by terrorists who attacked our country. This 10th-anniversary remembrance requires us to ask ourselves: what kind of country are we? Is that great endeavor that occurred in Philadelphia in 1787 "to form a more perfect union" under a written Constitution now obsolete? Are those magnificent precepts embodied in our Declaration of Independence no longer relevant or operative in the lives of Americans? Is 21st-century America to be defined by assuring that the federal government is the least consequential factor in the lives of average Americans? Are the words of the Declaration of Independence to be set aside to enable our government to reduce our national debt and balance our budget on the backs of our military veterans, the disabled, the poor and the elderly?

President Obama recently spoke to the National Convention of the American Legion. During his speech he recounted the service of our men and women in uniform during the 20th century and the past 10 years. His speech reminded me of a visit I had made to a V.A. hospital in Palo Alto, Calif. last March. The hospital is affiliated with the neurology department at Stanford University. Many servicepersons from across the nation with head, neck, back and spinal injuries from their deployments in Iraq and Afghanistan are sent to the Palo Alto V.A. hospital for treatment.

The fight against al-Qaeda and others who seek to destroy us ceases to be abstract and impersonal when you see, speak and look into the eyes of 19- to 25-year-old men and women who have been seriously and often permanently disabled by their military service and sacrifice on our behalf.

Are we worthy, as a nation, of the magnitude of their sacrifice for us?

The 9/11 attacks were the apex of violence perpetrated against our country. This 10th anniversary provides us with a "teachable moment" to determine just what kind of nation we want to be: one dedicated to peace and non-violence, or one trapped in the pursuit of violence as a hallmark of our foreign policy? Domestically, is it unrealistic to expect that we could ever commit ourselves to personal conduct based on non-violent conflict resolution, instead of the promiscuous use of hand guns, to improve the quality of our lives?

Aside from TV and film clips and media coverage, most Americans have no real understanding or grasp of the reality of the horrors of 9/11. Each of us can probably remember where we were at 8:46 a.m. ET on Sept. 11, 2001, when terrorists crashed the first airplane into the World Trade Center. To better understand and get a better sense, up close and personal, of the reality of what occurred when the planes crashed into the buildings, I strongly recommend reading Edie Lutnick's "An Unbroken Bond," an e-book that describes the human consequences of that attack. Lutnick wrote the book in tribute and as a commemorative memorial to the employees of Cantor Fitzgerald, the Wall Street bond and currency trading firm whose offices occupied floors 101 through 105 of One World Trade Center, just two to six floors above where the terrorists' plane struck.

On Sept. 10, 2001, Cantor Fitzgerald had 960 New-York-based employees. At the end of the following day, Sept. 11, 658 of those employees had been killed, including Gary Lutnick, the younger brother of the author and of Howard Lutnick, CEO of Cantor Fitzgerald.

Just as I did not comprehend the nature and scope of the personal sacrifice of young men and women wounded in the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan until I personally visited them in the V.A. Hospital in Palo Alto, Calif., without reading "An Unbroken Bond," few can appreciate, up close and personal, the magnitude of the consequences of 9/11 on the families of the Cantor Fitzgerald employees murdered that day.

I was so moved after reading the manuscript of Edie Lutnick's book that I asked whether I could write a forward to it. Among my comments I wrote:

There are some events, past and present, that challenge our ability to comprehend the magnitude of the human pain and suffering and the destruction associated with them: Auschwitz and Treblinka in the Holocaust, slavery in the United States, Hiroshima, Nagasaki, genocide atrocities in Rwanda and Serbia, the 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami, earthquakes in Haiti and Japan, the bombing of the Oklahoma City federal building by Timothy McVeigh, the terrorists' killings in Mumbai and the recent floods and tornadoes in several Midwestern states.

In our minds we separate unforeseeable acts of nature from intentional acts of violence by one person or group of people against another. However, in either case, it is difficult for us to wrap our minds around the enormity of the pain and destruction associated with such events.

The terrorists' airplane attacks against the World Trade Center in downtown New York on Sept. 11, 2001 challenge our ability to grasp and comprehend the enormity of the pain and horror experienced by fellow Americans as a result of that attack. On that day, approximately 3,000 people were murdered.

If one reads nothing else about 9/11, Edie Lutnick's "An Unbroken Bond" is a must-read. Poignantly and painstakingly, she lets the reader sit, like a 24/7 video camera, on her shoulder, as she offers her chilling account of being awakened by a phone call on Sept. 11, 2001 and her last telephone conversation with her brother Gary before he became engulfed in the flames and crumbling building in his effort to escape from his Cantor Fitzgerald office.

"An Unbroken Bond," unconditionally and without qualification, tells us that the greatest blasphemy, the single greatest sacrilege we could perpetuate concerning the events of 9/11, is forgetfulness.

The White House's "bully pulpit" still remains a formidable instrument in shaping public opinion. It has the potential of morally challenging America's soul and summoning our better angels. President Obama is not just president and CEO of our government; he is also a distinguished recipient of the Nobel Peace Prize. He can remind us not to forget the greatness of our nation and the values enshrined in our Declaration of Independence.

Martin Luther King, Jr.'s receipt of his Nobel Peace Prize compelled him, as a Christian minister of the Gospel, to break his silence and speak publicly in opposition to the war in Vietnam. Commemorating 9/11 as a recipient of the Nobel Peace Prize confers upon President Obama a similar moral responsibility to "seize the time" and the moral high ground. To commemorate 9/11, he should consider a speech similar to his speech in Cairo, Egypt, similar to his speech on race relations in America in Philadelphia as candidate for president, similar to his address to the nation following the shooting of Congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords, and similar to his recent speech to the American Legion Convention.

The anniversary of 9/11 provides us with the opportunity to reaffirm yet again that we are not just "red" states and "blue" states but a country of people comprising the United States of America, with shared values that include caring about the least of these.

If not President Obama, who? If not now, when?

 
 
 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 18
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
10:43 PM on 09/11/2011
10 years later we still do not track visa overstays and illegals can get state issued drivers licenses.

Letting illegals roam free and giving them work permits is more important to Obama than the safety of Americans.

Aunt Zeunti and Uncle Omar benefit as well.
11:09 AM on 09/07/2011
The 10th Anniversary of the 9/11 attacks does indeed present an opportunity to, as you said, "seize the moment" and claim the moral high ground. In fact, I think its necessary to do so, because I feel this anniversary should not be about looking back for the sake of looking back. It should be about looking back to look forward and to fundamentally change course. I am trying to do this with the Be2021 Campaign (www.be2021.org). It's a campaign designed to empower young people to build a movement that will create not just a better country, but a better world in ten years, by the 20th anniversary of 9/11. I feel young people were especially affected by 9/11. I know I certainly was. And I feel its our responsibility to make the next decade better than the last one. We're asking students from across the country to join this campaign by declaring their vision for the world and themselves in 10 years. You can do so at our website: www.be2021.org
08:55 AM on 09/07/2011
The one area where President Obama has been decisive is on his committment to carrying on the foreign and security policies of George W. Bush. He has left no room for ambiguity on this subject as has his secretary of state and secretary of defense both of whom have been busy promoting permanant war.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:25 AM on 09/07/2011
Every day in office provides at least a dozen "unique opportunities for leadership."
I voted for Obama.
I'm still waiting for the leadership.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
The Lone Stranger
Yes, I am a lousy typist. OK!
02:16 AM on 09/07/2011
"The anniversary of 9/11 provides us with the opportunity to reaffirm yet again that we are not just "red" states and "blue" states but a country of people comprising the United States of America, with shared values that include caring about the least of these."

Clarence. let's stop with the wishfultinking. Obama is a failed leader and that's about all there is to say.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cheryl tobin
Alpha Dog with my pack!
09:35 PM on 09/06/2011
When Obama received his Nobel Peace Prize and dissed M.L. Kings reasoning that violence never brings permanent peace by saying that wars were necessary in the world today I knew Obama was not the leader I had hoped for in 2008 and the wars would continue indefinitely. Obama is not a man of peace like M.L. King. because Obama thinks wars really do solve problems
03:48 PM on 09/14/2011
Do you have a link to something that proves he said that? I'm not trying to be funny. It's a serious question. It sounds unlike him, but if he said it, I'd like to see it.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bjbold
Thank an Occupier
06:27 PM on 09/06/2011
There are hundreds of opportunities for presidential leadership. Wake me when he does something leaderlike.
06:10 PM on 09/06/2011
Today is a good day
04:56 PM on 09/06/2011
Due to 'lack of room', NYC Police Officers, Port Authority Police Officers and FDNY Firefighters are not 'invited' to the 10th anniversary of 9/11 at Ground Zero. Funny -they weren't invited on that day in 2001, either -they just 'showed up' and became our heroes.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lmktacwa
Progressive Dissident
08:41 PM on 09/10/2011
Where does it say that in the article...? which paragraph? I can't find it... .
photo
Left of Right
Want to default your country? Default your job!
02:08 PM on 09/06/2011
This is a nice video of what it looks like and how it all came about. It's 8 minutes, you might want to email it to yourself for later, but worth the look:

http://d.yimg.com/nl/ynews/newsmaker/player.html#shareUrl=http%3A%2F%2Fnews.yahoo.com%2Fvideo%23video%3D26271274&vid=26271274&browseCarouselUI=hide

OR, if you don't trust that link put in a search: Behind-the-scenes look at the 9/11 memorial + yahoo
02:08 PM on 09/06/2011
"The fight against al-Qaeda and others who seek to destroy us ceases to be abstract and impersonal when you see, speak and look into the eyes of 19- to 25-year-old men and women who have been seriously and often permanently disabled by their military service and sacrifice on our behalf."

I will not respond to you with the rage this sentence has induced in me. But I want to.

Instead, I will give to you the sentiment in a more measured and reasoned voice.

Let's start with some facts, shall we?

Al Qaeda is nothing more than a gang of individuals with a cause.

Something that the police can handle. Or our intelligence agencies.

The military should be reserved for fighting against countries.

No country attacked us on 911, not even the Taliban in Afghanistan.

Iraq didn't attack us.

Yemen didn't attack us, nor Pakistan, nor Somolia, not Libya.

The injuries of these soldiers were from misguided, illegal wars, something that the citizens of the U.S. will have to answer for, both internally and externally.

The deaths to innocents are not only in the U.S., say from 911, but also the deaths of innocents in Afghanistan, Pakistan, Somolia, Yemen, Iraq and Libya.

Over a milllion of them.

Are you implying that the deaths and injuries of our people mean more than the deaths and injuries of others?
02:19 PM on 09/06/2011
cont,,,

Not only that but Afghanistan, Pakistan, Iraq and Libya have been turned upside down.

We have destroyed Iraq, an ancient civilization thousands of years old.

And you are concerned only about 911 and wounded American soldiers?

Your priorities are misplaced, indeed.

How about that for measured?
04:15 PM on 09/06/2011
You left out a couple of facts: 1) Afghanistan allowed Al Qaeda to maintain its bases there, to plan 9/11 and train terrorists to attack the US. 2) Iraq attacked our ally Kuwait without provocation. After we repelled the Iraqis from Kuwait, Saddam Hussein repeatedly violated the terms agreed to at the end of the war (not to mention offerring bounties to the familites of terrorist suicide bombers and committing crimes against humanity (utilizing nerve gas, a WMD) against his own people.