Well, most of the reporting on this case was based on reading a bad press release, rather than reading the judge's opinion.
Judge for yourself, it's linked to by the honest material here.
The judge says "craigslist leaves this field with something less than total victory." Not total victory, just a little less.
The judge kinda split the baby, but said we acted in good faith. We'll keep fighting the good fight in California.
Follow Craig Newmark on Twitter: www.twitter.com/craignewmark