iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Dan Dorfman

Dan Dorfman

Posted: October 8, 2010 01:02 PM

Funeral For a European Myth

What's Your Reaction:

Here we go again -- the death of another myth, namely the one that Europe's worrisome sovereign debt crisis has run its course. Far more likely, the evidence shows, we're in for a nasty rerun.

To put it in perspective, let's turn the clock back about six months when the U.S. stock market was repeatedly getting battered on a daily basis in response to news of swelling debt woes in Europe. Adding to the market's shellacking at the time were riots in Greece over proposed austerity measures.

Then came Superman to the rescue, the European Union, with a promise of a $1 trillion bailout package to stabilize Europe and drive away the bond vigilantes who were selling the debt of the weakest European countries, causing interest rates to rise. In response, the euro, aided by Chinese purchases, proceeded to strengthen, and fears of a debt crisis in Europe greatly diminished, so much so that many market pros have eliminated this risk from their radar screens.

Judging though from the recent downgrade of Ireland's credit by the Fitch rating agency, which came on the heels of earlier downgrades of Spain's and Portugal's debt, it's pretty clear that only Rip Van Winkle would dismiss the danger of a fresh outbreak of European debt problems, which has ominous implications for the world's financial markets.

That's also the thinking of currency tracker Bryan Rich, editor of the World Currency Alert newsletter in Jupiter, Fla., who says "a higher euro may have instilled some investor confidence, but nothing has changed. Not only does a debt problem exist," he says, "but it's getting progressively worse and a default by a European country is only a matter of time."

Addressing the trillion-dollar rescue package, Rich describes it as "nothing more than bold shock and awe, a promise that's a figment of someone's imagination." He notes that a number of the more financially muscular European countries, among them Germany, are already balking at the idea of anteing up funds to help bail out their weaker brethren.

London money manager Raymond Stahler of Stahler Dearborn, Ltd., concurs. He describes the $1 trillion promise of aid to the struggling European nations, such as Portugal, Ireland, Greece and Spain, as a farce. "Handouts are wonderful," he says, "but not if nobody is handing out."

Rich views the European financial situation as especially scary in Ireland, which he views as most vulnerable to a default. The European Union's guidelines prohibit its member nations from having their budget deficits, as a percentage of GDP, exceeding 3%.

That's a meaningless number, though, since no one is paying any heed to it. For example, the 2010 estimates call for Ireland to top the limit by more than 10-fold at 32%, followed by Spain at 9.3%, Portugal at 8.8%, Greece at 8.1%, and Italy at 5%.

The EU's limit on total debt, as a percentage of GDP, is 60%. Here again, Ireland strikes out badly. Its 2010 projection had called for 65%; it's now projected at 110%.

Against this background, a massive amount of debt in the European nations has to be rolled over. A dilemma here is that the governments and the banks will be competing for capital, which will drive interest rates higher. That, in turn, will make it difficult for the governments to raise money at rates they can afford, which, in turn, could cripple the ailing economies.

At the same time, Rich notes that the European Central Bank, which has been snapping up government debt of struggling countries to keep them solvent, has acquired a lot of crappy debt.

A related problem, as he sees it, is the threat of another major wave of risk aversion. That is when capital flees riskier investments and assets. The chief implications, as Rich sees them: Stocks will go lower, the same for commodities, except gold, and it all bodes well for the dollar.

What does all of this mean? Rich's view: "We're in a crisis period, a deleveraging phase for the world's economy, so look for more shocks, such as government defaults, bank failures, currency devaluations and rising protectionism."

He doesn't say it in so many words, but the word from Rich is clear: Watch out -- you could get poor!

What do you think? E-mail me at Dandordan@aol.com


 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 8
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
05:58 AM on 10/13/2010
Europe’s failings lies in a lack of focus, of goals. Furthermore, the “eurozone crisis” isn’t going away anytime soon. Read more at http://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/merritt12/English
12:07 AM on 10/09/2010
The Euro is rising for all the wrong reasons. Primarly because the US dollar is weakening and China running around to heavily indebted countries saying we'll buy your bonds, we believe in a stable Euro, we'll loan you money, we won't fix your fundamental employment problems, but please don't let your currency fall.

Last time I checked unemployment is still 20% in Spain and workers are still striking in Greece. Nothing fundamental has changed, some is going to get hurt big time in the not-too-distant future.
03:56 PM on 10/08/2010
"namely the one that Europe's worrisome sovereign debt crisis has run its course."

I wonder if anyone actually believes it has. Debt crises rarely terminate with an agreement to bail out the overindebted sovereign. Sooner or later the bill comes due, pay over time or default.
03:55 PM on 10/08/2010
t"he European Union, with a promise of a $1 trillion bailout package to stabilize Europe and drive away the bond vigilantes who were selling the debt of the weakest European countries, causing interest rates to rise. In response, the euro, aided by Chinese purchases, proceeded to strengthen, and fears of a debt crisis in Europe greatly diminished, so much so that many market pros have eliminated this risk from their radar screens."

Well, they have to keep the speculative attacks going to keep redirecting the money to the banksters instead of to the people. Pretty much sums it up.
07:01 PM on 10/08/2010
None of this would happen if the euro was a real currency. They can easily set up a system where default is impossible but the people running things don't want that, and why? It's all about "discipline"... forcing the little people to take losses and locking it permanently until a pre-war system is in place. The Red Menace is why the European social democracy was implemented and the end of the Red Menace is why European social democracy is being dismantled.
02:57 PM on 10/08/2010
This bodes well for the dollar? Right, like we're not in the same boat. Taxes and regulations add up to 5 times the cost of wages here. Gee, wonder why our jobs have been going overseas for the past 50 years? US debt is unsustainable. Unless they fix Social Security, Medicare, and military spending, then there is going to be a default here as well. It may not be outright, honest default. They just might give us a bout of hyper-inflation, which allows them to pay off the debt, or stabilize it using worthless dollars. Who gets hurt on that one besides US creditors? The public, that's who. You can only paper over bankrupt status for so long. Then the debt collectors arrive.
photo
BBackSoon
Hello, I must be going.
01:53 PM on 10/08/2010
'Watch out -- you could get poor!'

What if we are already there?

Also can you explain the effect of the so called 'Double Irish' on the Irish economy. As I understand it they allow a much lower tax rate for companies that would like to more or less launder profits thru them.

Does that not help their economy?
01:27 PM on 10/08/2010
The EU system has brought back many of the evils of the pre-Keynesian era as it's completely neoliberal. The euro is designed as a de-facto gold standard under which EU states are not issuers of currency and therefore can default and can be trapped in the needless situation where default risk increases interest rates despite a lack of inflation. The euro is completely under the control of private banks that are behind the European Central Bank that treats private banks far better than states - this is said to be required to "discipline" said states. The debt and deficit targets, again imposed in the name of "discipline", serve as a straitjacket, all of which serves deflationary neoliberal pro-plutocratic ends. The euro system cannot survive a depression much as during the Great Depression those countries that broke with gold started to recover whilst those that didn't continued in their torpor.