THE BLOG

The Death and Possible Rebirth of Racial Profiling

09/12/2009 05:12 am ET | Updated May 25, 2011

Now that the Beer Summit has resolved any lingering issues over the arrest of Henry Louis Gates, we can get back to our perfectly harmonious post-racial society.

I for one am relieved. Like most Latino males, I've had some uncomfortable interactions with cops (go ahead, ask your minority friends; most of us have a story or two). However, none of these scraps have risen above slight inconvenience or principled annoyance.

So I didn't like hearing that racial profiling was making a comeback. You can imagine my joy, therefore, when conservatives informed me that profiling is a myth. And if cops aren't doing it, I presume that non-authority figures -- like storeowners, next-door neighbors, fellow riders on the subway, and the like -- are also beyond jumping to conclusions based on the color of a person's skin.

I was thinking of this last week when I stopped in a new wine shop that recently opened in my neighborhood. I thought it would be a good idea to support the local merchant (plus, I really like wine).

The only other person in the shop was the white, middle-aged woman behind the counter. I browsed under her suspicious glare for a moment before spotting the open bottle of red before her.

As you may know, many wine shops have free tastings to encourage people to buy. It was the standard set-up, complete with little plastic cups, so I asked, "Are you having a tasting?"

"No," the woman said.

Then she grabbed the bottle and put it under the counter.

Now, this was odd. In fact, I could think of only three reasons why she would hide the wine from me.

1. The bottle was hers, and she gotten sloppy in concealing her day drinking. Naturally, stealing from the inventory and getting blitzed on the job is something you want to keep from the customers.

2. The bottle materialized from another dimension in some kind of time-space anomaly. The woman, an amateur scientist, recognized the cosmological implications, and instead of calling Stephen Hawking at once, she hid the bottle rather than acknowledge the frightening paradox that its existence posed.

3. The bottle was for a tasting. But she just didn't like me.

I couldn't decide which of these scenarios was true. So I just nodded and left. And of course, I didn't buy anything.

Now, the shop is a brand new establishment, locally owned and without the benefits of major corporate sponsorship. It is no doubt heavily in debt from start-up costs, and it has opened in the midst of a devastating recession. And it was not exactly crawling with customers. So why would an employee take even the slightest chance of offending one of the few people who walked through the doors (a person who was, until the moment of refusal, ready to buy something)?

Well, if it wasn't scenario one or two, above, I can only figure that the woman thought, "We may be on the verge of financial ruin, but damn it, if we let in browsing Hispanics, it will just be a matter of time before all kinds of riff-raff are shoplifting Chardonnays."

No, you can't be too careful.

So was this racial profiling? Or is that something that only cops can do?

Regardless, is there another explanation for the woman's behavior that I'm missing? If not, should I have caused a scene? And most important, where else in my neighborhood can I find an inexpensive bottle of Cline Zinfandel?

Feel free to offer me advice should I encounter another situation like this, or let me know about your own suspicious interactions.

But don't call it profiling. I've heard from trusted sources that such a thing doesn't exist.