iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Darrin Grinder

GET UPDATES FROM Darrin Grinder
 

The Presidency and the First American Religion

Posted: 04/09/2012 7:24 am

In the first half of the 19th century, and probably as early as 1820, upon this continent was born a new religion. Culturally grown from the great awakenings and the desire to experience the divine first hand, not merely as an intellectual exercise or a cultural legacy, Mormonism, founded by Joseph Smith, took root in America. The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints, as it was named in 1838, is, perhaps, the first truly American religion, making the Americas -- not just the old world or the Middle East -- the geographic setting of miracles, divine visitations and the promised land. Further, Mormonism values quintessential American traits of industry, community service, independence, thrift and virtue (to name a few).

Since Smith first began taking his followers to the West, American presidents have had to consider the political effects of this new religion, especially as they dealt with the ramifications of polygamy, militias, lynch mobs and Utah's statehood. Yet, only 14 years after Utah entered the Union, a prominent Mormon, J. Reuben Clark, was appointed as U.S. State Department Solicitor, later becoming Undersecretary of State and then Ambassador to Mexico. Since that time at least five members of the LDS church have served in cabinet positions, and Joseph Smith actually declared himself a candidate for President of the United States in 1844. While less than 3 percent of Congress is LDS, Mormons have been a quiet and persistent presence in American politics. In many ways Mitt Romney's presidential campaign may be a political coming of age for Mormons in America.

As of this writing, Romney can lay claim to about 568 delegates to the Republican Convention, while his nearest challenger, Rick Santorum, claims fewer than half that number. So while Romney has nowhere near the required delegates to claim a victory (he needs about 600 more, and there are only 1,200 still in play), it would be nearly impossible for Santorum to win the nomination before the convention. In other words, Romney will most likely be the first LDS presidential candidate with the support of a major political party behind him, this coming almost 200 years after the birth of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints. But for a member of a young, minority religion whose founder was murdered, whose way of life was outlawed, whose members destroyed printing presses and formed their own militias (all within the United States), for Romney to rise to a place where he could reasonably become the leader of the most powerful country in the world is literally unheard of either in recent history or perhaps even in the history of all world religions.

So what should we know about this religion, this new culture born on our own continent? A quick historical glance shows a troublesome relationship between the LDS church and government. First, the church leader Brigham Young led his followers to the Great Salt Lake in order to both protect them from persecution and to establish a literal theocracy. To this day, the temple square in Salt Lake City is the center of all things (the streets are numbered from the temple), and the church purchased a downtown block outside its doors less than two decades ago, closing it to traffic and cutting off a venue for free speech and personal expression (in 2009 a gay couple was arrested for trespassing after sharing a kiss on this Main Street block). Alcohol restrictions in Utah are some of the tightest in the country (beer sold in grocery stores, restaurants and many bars has to have an alcohol content of 3.2 percent or less), and not long ago Mormon state legislators threatened to revoke all high school extracurricular clubs, rather than let there exist one Gay-Straight Alliance on school grounds. Drive on Utah highways and you will see an image of a beehive, a symbol that comes directly from Brigham Young; the only other state with highway signs that connect to a religious past is the vaguely Native American New Mexico highway sign.

Despite what many LDS political leaders in Utah have done in the past to maintain the connections between the LDS church and government, the church's statements are very clear about the separation of church and state. The church explicitly refuses to allow its buildings to be used for partisan political events (thus we will not see Romney speaking as a politician from a church ward), unlike what we have seen in the last 30 years with evangelical Christian churches that invite presidential candidates to address their congregations. Interestingly, the LDS church also recognizes that its members who are political leaders will take positions that disagree with one another "or even with a publicly stated church position," but that it encourages those politicians to make choices that best serve their constituents. This is in stark contrast to the several American Catholic Bishops who stated during the 2004 presidential election that any Catholic politician who supported abortion should not be allowed to receive the Eucharist. Of course, these are the official statements of the LDS church, and it has to be recognized that many other churches make similar statements, but sometimes churches and their members act in ways other than official statements.

So what then can we say about religion and a Romney presidency? During his time as governor of Massachusetts, Romney proved that he was willing to follow policies that might infringe on religious freedom in order to serve the larger constituency. In 2005 for example, Romney overturned an exemption for Catholic hospitals that would have allowed them to refuse emergency contraception to its patients, saying "my personal view, in my heart of hearts, is that people who are subject to rape should have the option of having emergency contraception or emergency contraception information." During the same period Romney worked to prevent Massachusetts from legalizing same-sex marriage.

In a Romney presidency, America probably has little to fear as far as Romney's being a closet theocrat. Like most presidents before him, he would likely be a president for his political constituency first and foremost, regardless of the Mormon Church's stance on various issues. And he would likely have little to fear from his church if those policies sometimes were contrary to church beliefs. The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints is an American religion, and the church suffered when national government crossed the wall of separation, so it seems at least to appreciate the distinctly American line dance that straddles personal faith and public policy.

 
 
 
FOLLOW RELIGION
 
 
  • Comments
  • 112
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
raker
11:57 AM on 04/10/2012
With ancient myths and science fiction, Mormonism is the odious link between Christianity and Scientology. It's all bizarre, it's all toxic.
06:13 PM on 04/10/2012
Not any worse than fundamentalists believing that the earth was created in six literal days, or the extraterrestrials who visited some Old Testament patriarchs. Or people like Methuselah living upwards of 800 years, or Moses and tens of thousands of his followers walking through the Red Sea on dry ground, or Elijah being whisked up into space on a flying contraption. Not to mention Jesus magically resurrecting himself three days after being crucified, or the "close encounter of the 3rd kind" experienced by Paul on the road to Damascus. Don't forget Balaam and his talking donkey.
08:06 AM on 04/11/2012
Toxic? It produces families and communities of people who take care of each other, who work to educate themselves in all the varioys professions (except clergy--there are no paid clergy among Mormons), people who volunteer more of their time to community service and contribute more if their money to charitable organizations outside their church than other Americans, people who avoid alcohol and recreational drugs, people who regard people of all nations as their literal brothers and sisters under the fatherhood of God, people who are dedicated to religious freedom and equality for all, people who actually live for years in other countries and learn their languages and customs and establish life long friendships across boundaries of nationality and race--the world could use a lot more of that.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
raker
10:15 AM on 04/11/2012
Religion produces communities of people who gather to codify their hatred of everybody else. It strips away civility and reduces people to savagery. It moves people to violence and to cruelty. Mormons mobilizing to deny civil rights to gay people is cruel, and so typically religious. Yes, there are some lovely pancake breakfasts and church bazaars, but that doesn’t make up for the ruined lives, shattered families, all the vile consequences of religion.
09:10 AM on 04/10/2012
Mormons believe all people have the right to worship according to the dictates of their own conscience. Unlike some other Christian denominations, Mormons believe that good people of all religions can go to heaven, and they have been confirmed by scientific surveys to have the most positive view of people outside their church, even as other churches.have negative views of Mormonism. It is a fundamental belief that church and government should not mix, because it would threaten religious freedom for all. Mormons also recognize that people outside their church have not made covenants with God to live to the high standards taught in Mormonism, so they do not try to use government to make people live like Mormons. Even though Mormons do not drink alcohol, smoke, or drink coffee, Utah law allows all those activities. There have always been Mormons prominent in both the Democratic and Republucan parties, because the Church does not get involved in partisan politics. Mormon politicians do not try to make non-Mormons live like Mormons, because Mormonism is an essentially voluntary organization. Its local leaders are all unpaid volunteers. It emphasizes teaching children the wise use of free choice.
04:49 AM on 04/10/2012
Good read. Thanks!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mommadona
I paint. I blog. Therefore, I am.
12:18 AM on 04/10/2012
NOW ~ about that Proposition 8 in #California and the complete financial support of that POLITICAL item by the LDS Hierarchy.... inter-state influence, much?

Romney is not just a member ~ he is the equivalent of a priest in that same hierarchy.

The White Horse Prophecy is supported by Orrin Hatch. Pretty high-up-there politician.....

Now, tell me once more why the mormon don't want a theocracy?

I can't HEAR you......
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
netzach
Voiding warranties for 42 years
01:18 AM on 04/10/2012
White Horse Prophecy (so called) has been repudiated by the Church since 1918. In 2010, they again stated that it was "based on accounts that have not been substantiated by historical research and is not embraced as Church doctrine."
09:17 AM on 04/10/2012
Romney has no more rank in the Church than I and hundreds of thousands of other high priests hold. Mormon pastors areball part time, temporary unpaid volunteers, and every man who comes to church is ordained a priest. There are tens of thousands of former bishops like Romney, several in every congregation. What ot means is that every husband and father feels obligated to lead and teach his own family in living the commandments of Jesus Christ. There have been Mormons in Congress, as heads of Federal agencies like Treasury, Agriculture, HHS and HUD and EPA, for many decades, and thete has been no threat to the republuc. Mormons uphold the Constitution and democtstic elections, and the Bill of Rights. They tegularly vote for candidates outside their church, and five elections for governor in Utah chose non-Mormons, including Jewish businessman Simon Bamberger.
11:08 PM on 04/09/2012
Uh... the LDS doesn't become involved in politics?

Does the term "Proposition 8" mean anything to you?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
netzach
Voiding warranties for 42 years
01:12 AM on 04/10/2012
Correct. The LdS church does not endorse and political candidate or party- in accordance with IRS regulations. They will, from time to time, speak out on subjects involving morality.
photo
magic underwear
Obey The Profit
06:39 AM on 04/10/2012
I went to,and took pictures of a Mccain rally and fundraise held at the mormon church parking lot two blocks from my house in 2008.lds does not endorse political candidates my a*s
09:20 AM on 04/10/2012
Issues that are nonpartisan, like slavery 150 years ago, are a topic whete churches are entitled to participate in the public debate. In Califirnia, it was large majorities of Hispamic Catholics and black Protestants that voted in Proposition 8.
photo
Joe Hunt
NV adjunct Eng. professor.
11:01 PM on 04/09/2012
What a nice article. Not the usual thing, criticizing Prop 8 stuff or baptisms-for-the-dead.

Lest we forget: you can be a liberal Mormon, like Harry Reid ! -- God preserve him.

Maybe the article should've mentioned that, in section with "recognizes...opposing views."
04:36 PM on 04/10/2012
Yup, last I heard 1 in 10 Mormons self-identified as Liberal - about half the national average, but still there.
05:48 PM on 04/10/2012
Conservative or Republican "groupthink" among Mormons is no worse than the liberal Democratic groupthink which I previously encountered among Unitarians. To each his own.
10:47 PM on 04/09/2012
Thank you Darrin for some perspicuous comments.
10:17 PM on 04/09/2012
Mormonism is not a "new religion" created in America.

Mormonism is a sect of Christianity, officially The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints, established in America. It's Bible is the King James version of the Christian Bible, and it has a supplemental "Book of Mormon" to justify the sect's beliefs and offer "clarification" of what the Bible means. And one of the reasons Joseph Smith established Mormonism was to "restore" what he thought was true Christianity.

But, another reason Smith established Mormonism was to counter the Interfaith views of the Founding Fathers of the U.S.A., most of whom were Deists and many of whom were Freemasons who realized that government must be impartial and neutral regarding religions.

Read quotes from the Founding Fathers Regarding Religion, at http://messenger2.cjcmp.org/foundingfathers.html
01:18 AM on 04/10/2012
The LDS religion is not a Christian sect by dogma.
09:13 AM on 04/10/2012
WRONG, by the Articles of Faith it is Christian!
04:38 PM on 04/10/2012
So the Marcionites, Arianites, Pelagians, Coptics, Gnostics, etc., weren't Christian?
10:03 PM on 04/09/2012
You mentioned Brigham Young and the LDS church. Were you using his association with the Salt Lake church or the second mormon church that he left Utah to form in Missouri after his banishment from Salt Lake?
05:56 AM on 04/10/2012
bronceye what are you talking about??? Brigham Young lead the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter day Saints to the valley of the Great Salt Lake, where he guided the building of a great city.... There is no second Mormnon church that left Utah to form in Missouri.... and Brigham Young was never banished from Salt Lake City - He lived there until hi died and is buried there... The so called Mormons (Now named something else) was established by a son of Joseph Smith who though that the Church should be a family thing and hand down from son to son.... Not what God inteded...... Have a nice day.....
09:27 AM on 04/10/2012
You must be from an alternate universe. Governor Boggs of Missouri ordered all Mormons driven from the state or exterminated in 1838. After several years in Illinpis, building the city of Nauvoo, persecution rosebagain and in 1846 the Mormons, under Young's leadership, headed west, where Young died in 1877.
photo
demisfine
Often correct, NEVER right.
09:33 PM on 04/09/2012
Nice to know, but we'll never need to worry about any of it.
Since Mitt will never be president.
05:57 AM on 04/10/2012
As I tell all others "Hide and Watch" and be sure to watch his swearing in....
08:59 PM on 04/09/2012
Darrin....you're not a member of "the Church" are you?...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
08:19 PM on 04/09/2012
His "onstituency" i GOP; that leaves over half the country w/o a president?
05:58 PM on 04/09/2012
"Latter-day Saints believe that the founding fathers were raised up by God to establish the constituti-on of the United States, and that the Constitution is an inspired document."

"Mormons believe that Christ will come again to rule and reign over the earth for one thousand years of peace. He will rule from two capitals: one in Jerusalem, the holy city; and one in Zion, which will be founded in America and which will also be a holy city. Zion’s center will be at Independence, Missouri."

"The greatest event recorded in the Book of Mormon was the visit of Jesus Christ to America shortly after his resurrection. The Book of Mormon thus becomes a second witness to the divinity of the Son of God..."

“We believe that the Constituti¬on was brought about by God to insure a nation where liberty could abound, where his gospel could flourish. Joseph Smith said, “The Constitution of the United States is a glorious standard; it is founded in the wisdom of God. It is a heavenly banner.” (Teachings of the Prophet Joseph Smith, p. 147.) Again from Brigham Young, “[The Constitution] was dictated by the invisible operations of the Almighty...”
http://www.mormonbeliefs.org/mormon_beliefs/though...

http://lds.org/ldsorg/v/index.jsp?vgnextoid=024644f8f206c010VgnVCM1000004d82620aRCRD&local-e=0&sourceId=1e705930f289b010VgnVCM1000004d82620a____&hideNav=1
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dr Idris
polymathy is not understanding
12:11 AM on 04/11/2012
I"ve seen ideas like this. The best cure is the 1$ bill reverse. "annuit coeptis" from a prayer to Jupiter in Virgil. I have even seen some talk of an esoteric Hebrew Republic as model for US. Never existed. The real model is the Roman Republic-as in 18th century Enlightenment secular Neo-Classicism
03:50 PM on 04/09/2012
Grinder: "In a Romney presidency, America probably has little to fear as far as Romney's being a closet theocrat."

True. Although Latter-day Saints are kind of excited about the prospect of putting a Mormon in the White House, many of us are to the right of Romney politically. Many of us are somewhat concerned that his actions as governor have been somewhat incongruent with some of the tenants of our faith.

Can he still make those political decisions and still retain good standing in the Church? Yes.

Half of my Latter-day Saint family is Republican, half of us are democrat, sprinkled by a few independents, who have been known to vote in either party. All have retained status in good standing on the records of the Church.

Because Latter-day Saints hold the constitution sacred, and because we hold our own faith sacred, the separation of church and state, if not a sacred ruling by itself, is considered a very critical way to preserve both church and state.

That is not to say that when there are moral issues, we are silent. We are encouraged to be politically involved citizens and to vote our conscience.

Which is why you will find Latter-day Saints who hold political office in both Democratic and Republican parties.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jsgaetano
Legum servi sumus ut liberi esse possimus
03:40 PM on 04/09/2012
The LDS founder wanted to overthrow the US Government. No wonder they're such solid conservatives.
09:31 AM on 04/10/2012
Joseph Smith ran for president in 1844 as a Democrat in order to draw national attention to the religious persecution of Mor,ons. His platform including abolition of slavery by the Fedetal government sellung lands in thenwest and using the proceeds to buy the freedom of all slaves. He was politically far ahead of his contemporary in Illinois, Abraham Lincoln.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
jsgaetano
Legum servi sumus ut liberi esse possimus
02:18 PM on 04/10/2012
And he lost, and he tried to overthrow the US Government (as well as two state governments). Which is actually what lead to the deaths of him and his brother.