More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Darya Pino, Ph.D

GET UPDATES FROM Darya Pino, Ph.D
 

How to Tell if Your Diet Plan Is BS

Posted: 12/09/10 11:28 AM ET

It doesn't take a genius to figure out that most diet plans out there are full of it. If they worked, a third of us wouldn't be classified as obese. But if you're trying to get healthy and lose weight, how can you tell the healthy diets from the lousy ones?

Bad diets that are designed to slim your wallet rather than your waistline actually have a lot in common. In my opinion, if you see any of these five hallmarks of a BS diet plan, hold on to your credit card and run the other direction.

Five Hallmarks Of A BS Diet Plan:

Single Case Studies And Lots Of Testimonials
People who don't have evidence to back up their claims often rely on personal testimonials instead. Testimonials are accounts by people who have supposedly used the product and had incredible success. But in many cases, these stories are better described as uncredible rather than incredible.

The reality is that it's fairly easy to get people to say/do/look exactly the way you want. Sometimes the testimonials are made by paid actors who are lying for profit, other times the quotes are simply taken out of context and exaggerated. It is even possible that some of the testimonials are true, but that the person giving them doesn't understand the true ramifications of the results they are seeing (or will only see those results for a short time).

The point is, individual case studies rarely reflect the true effectiveness of a product, and are hand-selected to make the product look good. Because you can be sure that if the seller had real statistical data on his product's effectiveness, he would be using that instead.

Black And White Rules
One of the easiest things to do to lose weight is follow a set of very strict rules for a set amount of time. Limiting calories in and increasing calories out will make just about anyone lose weight for a little while, so even ridiculous plans like the Twinkie diet can seem effective for a short period.

But very few individuals can maintain a strict diet permanently, and I would argue that this should not even be your goal. A healthy eating plan must have flexibility, since everyone has different personal and dietary needs. If a diet has too many rules, it isn't going to be your salvation.

Angry Proponents
Rational people don't get upset when someone disagrees with them. When you see health advocates defending their diet as if it were a religion you can bet there's a bigger, more personal reason for all the commotion.

While it is great to be passionate about the way you eat, if supporters resort to name calling and hate blogging there's likely more dogma than truth in whatever they're selling.

Truthiness
Is that data you just told me, or just a bunch of science-y words that explain your opinion? Don't be fooled by a scientific theory about why a diet works. If you can't find numbers to back up that information, then the diet is still a hypothesis and not a proven therapy. People love to tout our need for dietary "enzymes" or what we've "evolved" to eat, but I've never seen any evidence suggesting these things are true.

Fantastical Results
Does that diet sound too good to be true? It probably is. There are many ways to induce rapid, dramatic weight loss, but unless the plan is sustainable the weight will come back. Don't be lured by the promise of quick, amazing results. Look for plans that encourage improving habits and are designed to keep weight off permanently.


You can find more healthy eating tips by Darya Pino at Summer Tomato.

 

Follow Darya Pino, Ph.D on Twitter: www.twitter.com/summertomato

 
 
  • Comments
  • 12
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
dana c
Tempus fugit, memento mori!
01:34 PM on 01/07/2011
Diet, any diet, doesn't work. Period. Change of lifestyle works if you can do it. But that's hard. And should be permanent, if it's not permanent than it's a diet and diet doesn't work.
12:06 PM on 12/21/2010
... when you know you won't be able to resist, put on an ingenious oral restrictive device and behavior modification tool--made from floss -- costs less than four dollars. No, it's not a joke. The inconspicuous (no one will know if you wear it) device enables an individual to regulate food intake in ways that sheer willpower cannot. It reduces bite size capability, and helps to control the impulses associated with mindless snacking, emotional eating and binging. It may just be the “Susan Boyle†of the diet world. Unlike anything you've ever done or read; it is shockingly inspiring! The Floss Diet should make a big buzz in 2011...
Happy Holidays
10:57 PM on 12/14/2010
A couple of more clues a diet is BS:
• It comes with a diet pill. Especially if available only by prescription. It has been proved over and over that you can’t fool the body.
• It calls for restricting calories by willpower. Willpower doesn’t work when you body is starving for vitamins, minerals, and other basic nutrients. Feed your body what it needs and you will eat less.
• It calls for restricting fats: this has been totally debunked in the medical literature. Eat plenty of natural fats.
01:19 PM on 12/12/2010
Here's my 2 cents: find some kind of exercise that you actually enjoy, that you'll want to do, and then make time for it, even if you "don't have time". Anything is better than nothing -- walking is great -- but something that really gets your pulse going is the best. Unless you have a will of iron, an exercise program will fail unless it's something you like to do, so it becomes a habit.

Regular exercise tends to relieve stress and tends to reduce pointless overeating. If I were overweight -- thankfully I'm not -- I'd start with the exercise, and then see about changing my diet if I didn't like the results after 6 months.
ThinkCreeps
Seriously, it's time.
12:01 PM on 12/10/2010
After a week, are you eating less every day? If not, then it's BS.
10:42 AM on 12/10/2010
Your diet is BS if you're on a diet!

marketing and advertising has steered us away from the simple truth. Eat only foods that Mother Nature placed on Earth, with no processing. Nothing added. No sugar, no preservatives, no pastuerization, no super heating, no filtering, nothing.

Do this and watch you health soar and your weight normalize. The elegant truth is not profitable, so you seldom hear it.
photo
HerrMonk
Son of Apollo
03:16 AM on 12/10/2010
You diet plan is BS if it allows you to eat unhealthy foods in any quantity: quantity control doesn't work. If it did, our population wouldn't be getting fatter and fatter.

There are bad "foods" (generally more "food product than food", and they need to be cut. Simple as that.
03:07 AM on 12/10/2010
If you know how the fat metabolism (the mechanism of losing and gaining body fat) is working, you can control your own adipose tissue. This is knowledge most of the physicians, medical specialists and dietitians are lacking. If you understand the mechanism, you don’t need a diet. Here http://www.cutthecarb.com/how-to-control-your-body-fat-part-1/ you can read how to control your body fat.
05:41 PM on 12/09/2010
Truthfully, there is no one single universal diet for everyone. If somebody plays middle linebacker for the Bears at 275 pounds, and someone is an 80 year old grandma,a diabetic,a sedentary 19 year playing video games or someone who plays tennis and swims daily we see a great variety in not only diets, but metabolism. The "M" word, metabolism is hardly ever recognized or utilized by clinicians or commercial weight loss experts today. This is the key decider on diet and even levels of exercise. Metabolism is the system that balances your total intake of calories with what you have "burned" in activity or via restriction(diet). This science is based on your Basal metabolic rate(BMR) and Resting Metabolic Rate(RMR) these are the number of calories your body consumes at activity and rest combined. The average is about 2000 calories a day, but even this number is changing. The BMR can be measured electronicaly by an electro-resistance computer. There are 3 basic metabolic rates that require different quantities and qualities of food. Fast metabolism requires more dense calories so they do not go into energy debt(proteins),slow metabolism causes people to accumulate calories so they need to concentrate on complex carbohydrates more. The majority of us are fitting into a mixed-variable type due to stress, all-nighters, insomnia, fast food, foods with toxins, skipped meals, lack of nutrients, water, too much salt , trans fat,and salt.Here the body needs to be re-suppiled with vitamins, antioxidants, enzymes and water
04:22 PM on 12/09/2010
I like to stick to proven results I've seen with my own eyes.
photo
ScritchfieldRD
Helping people detox from deprivation diets and ge
12:40 PM on 12/09/2010
Great article! I swear I should have a PhD in dieting! (been there, tried that) As a nutrition expert who now counsels in weight management, I have to say that anything that even uses the word diet is probably no good. We have bars that are supposed to help us "fight" hunger (full bars, think thin) and we're taught that if we get hungry and eat we won't lose weight. After spending years up and down with my weight and countless "resolutions" I never kept I'm all about self-care and meeting my needs.

Sharing info about the "me" movement blog and twitter chats. People can sign a self care pledge to help them on a non-dieting journey and say bye-bye to resolutions.

www.theMEmovement.com
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]