NYR More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Darya Pino, Ph.D

GET UPDATES FROM Darya Pino, Ph.D
 

Book Review: Folks, This Ain't Normal

Posted: 12/23/11 09:47 AM ET

Joel Salatin is one of the most interesting people I have ever met. Self-described as a "Christian-libertarian-environmentalist-capitalist-lunatic-farmer," you're probably more familiar with him as the "beyond organic" owner of Polyface Farm featured in Michael Pollan's landmark book The Omnivore's Dilemma and the documentary Food, Inc. (note: if you haven't read/watched those do so immediately).

I sat down with Joel recently to talk about his latest book, Folks, This Ain't Normal. On the outside, Joel does not appear abnormal in the least. He was well dressed, well spoken, extremely polite and fiercely intelligent -- a gentleman in every way. But once you get him talking you quickly see that his ideas make him an anomaly in modern society, not because they are far-fetched, but because they come from so many different sides of the political and societal spectrum. People are rarely this thoughtful and well-rounded, and after finishing the book this is the point I keep coming back to.

You are almost certain to disagree with some of Joel's ideas. Folks, This Ain't Normal runs the gamut in controversial topics. He touches on politics, religion, the environment (including global warming), sustainable agriculture, big business, peak oil, taxes, protectionism, meat eating, government regulation, women's role in farming (he told me to my face he's "sexist") and likely a few more subjects that will get your blood boiling. But this is not your usual liberal-conservative political banter.

Joel is a thinker, and just a few pages into the book it is clear that he has a more intimate understanding of these topics than most experts and advocates could even dream of. Folks, This Ain't Normal is by far the best ecology lesson I've ever had, and I try to be a responsible person and keep up on sustainable food issues. While most people discuss this subject academically Joel actually knows how an ecosystem works, because he works with one every day back at Polyface Farm. For example, despite the cries of some environmentalists to do away with cows and replace them with tofu (aka soy beans), Joel explains in detail why a tillage-based crop like soy depletes soil, while a grass-based system of herbivore feeding builds and protects soil, and is necessary for environmental sustainability.

Food politics is another topic where Joel's position runs flatly against conventional wisdom. Most of us in the food movement agree that Monsanto is the devil, and Joel is no different. But while most foodists lean liberal and think more regulation is the answer, Joel explains why those very regulations are what protect the big companies and put small farms like his out of business (exactly what Monsanto wants). So contrary to what you might guess, his position on this topic is strictly laissez faire.

As mentioned above, there's almost certainly something that Joel writes that will offend you. (Yes, he takes more than a few shots at urban farmers market goers with award- winning poodles -- Joel, in my defense, I at least use my fancy kitchen and make my own sauerkraut). But I'll argue that this is precisely why you should read the book. When crafted by a thoughtful, intelligent person, opposing viewpoints are among the most valuable thing in a thinking person's arsenal. Even if he doesn't convince you to change your opinion, at least it forces you to question your beliefs, think a little harder and refine your position. There are no worthwhile topics that don't have valuable insights from both sides of the fence. Thinking is good for you, and it is something that is sadly lacking in our current political environment.

In this spirit, the types of people who would certainly benefit from reading Folks, This Ain't Normal include: vegetarians, carnivores, environmentalists, McDonald's patrons, farmers market shoppers, Chipotle patrons, Tea Partiers, liberals, Christians, scientists, atheists, politicians, big farmers, small farmers, city folks, country folks, the 99% and the 1%. In short, everyone who eats.

What Joel wants us to understand is that it isn't him who is historically abnormal. What's not normal is having no idea where food and water come from, nor how to keep them healthy and safe. In other words, it is the rest of us who have lost the basic life skills necessary for survival. This, he argues, is what isn't normal.

Originally published at Summer Tomato, where you can find more healthy eating tips. Summer Tomato is one of Time's 50 Best Websites of 2011.

 

Follow Darya Pino, Ph.D on Twitter: www.twitter.com/summertomato

 
 
  • Comments
  • 9
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
12:06 AM on 12/28/2011
He writes about work and innovation, using his farming methods as a framework of factual anecdotes. He's refreshing and gets you thinking about your own perceptions of economic and political ideology. I'd compare him to Thoreau in some ways.
01:06 PM on 12/27/2011
I think Joel is "right on"! Back to the land movement revisited. I have been canning/preserving and growing my food for 40 years and he is my guru! What an education to read his books. We need to heal the planet and quit excepting the food the USDA is forcing down our throats! They will kill us! If you can't grow/raise your own I think it is great to find a local farmer. The are around - you just have to "look". I wish he could be put in charge of our food system in the country! He could "change the world"!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
KarlaElisa
The atmosphere is Toxic
12:28 PM on 12/27/2011
Salatin has great stories and some great solutions. He does what works best for him and I have enormous respect for his operation. His politics/religion aside, his books are a real treat.

The only book I've read to date by him is 'Everything I want to do is Illegal' and he and a few others he mentions in the book find some truly clever ways to turn the very regulations that stifle a small farmer back on the alphabet agencies messing with them that actually give them legal ways to avoid paying income tax on what they are selling.

But if you're looking for true permaculture, Salatin wouldn't be your guy. Try permies.com with Paul Wheaton and Sepp Holzer as your guru's.
photo
artleads
Let's have a national retreat.
08:23 PM on 12/25/2011
He sounds scarily superior. Where are his flaws?
05:01 AM on 12/24/2011
I read this article yesterday, the twenty third. Figured I would come back today and read the comments on this important issue of food production.

Seems like no readers are interested.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bnL3JAjXT0g
photo
FaunaAndFlora
Daughter of Pan
11:43 PM on 12/24/2011
Same here.
thebigbike
ran away to be a cowboy
11:56 PM on 12/24/2011
given that there are virtually no mentions of the actual positions taken in the book, not too surprising. Though I will say I concur totally with Mr Salatin's support for herbivore/grazing based food production. Wes Jackson can provide some interesting practical work in the field. I am guessing he does recognize that there is a need - given the vastly overblown and ultimately unsupportable world population for grain production, being the cheapest source of calories per unit of outside energy invested. Even given that, as conducted even with "best practices" it is ultimately destructive.But pigeons, cockroaches, jellyfish and rats are seemingly protean in their adaptability.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
KarlaElisa
The atmosphere is Toxic
11:45 AM on 12/27/2011
the guys politics/religion annoys me as he's against regulation but thinks abortion shouldn't be legal stating in his 'everything i want to do is illegal' book that we'd HAVE enough workers to do the work of the illegal immigrants if we'd just stop 'murdering' our babies.

HOWEVER, he runs a freakin' fantastic farm using the circle of life to sustainably promote health of land and livestock.

example: he rotates cows into different fenced pastures so they graze aggressively in an area eating ALL the grasses evenly as opposed to them picking out favorites and leaving the rest. before they scar the land they're moved into a new spot, allowing the grass to recover. in the barn, he throws corn into the cow manure. later, he moves his pigs in to forage and toss the manure looking for the corn. he then uses this well tossed and now aged compost in the garden.

chickens are free ranged and lay and live with a giant mobile chicken tractor. it provides shade, they never remain in one spot long enough to turn it into a moonscape. his animals are always on the move. his outdoor chicken slaughtering set up has far less contamination than an indoor processing center. has been tested and proven several times. his food production is quality.

and he's witty and tells great stories about using the govts red tape to thwart them.