NYR More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Dave Astor

GET UPDATES FROM Dave Astor
 

If All Books Were as Violent as Cormac McCarthy Books

Posted: 08/17/11 12:50 PM ET

Jane Eyre packing heat at Lowood. Vigilante justice in Goodnight Moon. Redemptive violence in Green Eggs and Ham. Drug-war shootouts in Little Women. A trigger-happy Jim Burden snarling: "My Antonia? Bye, Antonia!" Waiting to Exhale? It's a long wait when your brains have been blown out. Beloved? Make that beheaded.

Yup, it would be quite a literary world if all books contained as much mayhem as Cormac McCarthy novels.

I think McCarthy, who turned 78 last month, is one of the best authors of the past half-century. His books contain neo-Biblical narration, stunningly lyrical descriptions of landscapes, iconic/laconic characters, and terse dialogue ("What have you done for him?"/"Aint done nothin"/"What do you want me to do for him?"/"Aint asked you to do nothin"/"That's good, because there aint nothin to be done"). But, man, all that violence!

For instance, McCarthy's Blood Meridian -- the source of the above dialogue -- is one of the bloodiest "serious" novels ever written. Heads are split, innocent bystanders are blown apart with powerful bullets, people and dogs are agonizingly burned to death, hapless mules are pushed off cliffs, etc. After reading McCarthy's take on the unspeakably evil acts perpetrated by a group of depraved 19th-century American marauders from the Old West, I queasily figured it was better to write this post than try to eat breakfast.

Of McCarthy's nine other books, I've read these seven: The Road, No Country for Old Men, Outer Dark, The Orchard Keeper, and the "Border Trilogy" of All the Pretty Horses, The Crossing, and Cities of the Plain. These titles don't feature quite as many sickos as Blood Meridian, but their pages still include plenty of death, brutality, and brutal death.

The renowned McCarthy is not a sadist; rather, he's depicting mankind's real-life violent nature (in the past and, by extension, the present) as well as humankind's often short, sorrowful lives. And he's such a stupendous writer that I keep coming back for more despite the gore, cruelty, degradation, suffering, blatant shortage of prominent women characters, and depressing depictions of casual and not-so-casual racism (including liberal use of the vile "N"-word). But ... I'm still not ready for breakfast.

Got any ideas for "McCarthy-ized" books? Here are a few more of mine: Lad: a Psycho. Crazed Canadian cannibals in Anne of Green Gables. Gut-spilling genocide in Tender Is the Night. The Message in a Bottle message: "Eat lead." A Clint-channeling Colette character growling, "Make my Break of Day!" The Life of Pi tiger gassed after being "glassed" (a Cormac-ian word for looking through binoculars). A Time to Love and a Time to Die? More like A Time to Die REPEATEDLY.

 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 28
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Jerry Zezima
10:33 PM on 08/25/2011
Funny piece, Dave. It belongs in both books and comedy. How about this mob-family memoir: "Please Don't Push Up the Daisies."
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Dave Astor
06:03 AM on 08/26/2011
Ha ha! I like that one. Thanks, Jerry! If you were a stand-up comic, it would be time to tour (i.e., hit "The Road").
08:47 AM on 08/18/2011
I love McCarthy, although James Wood's review of "No Country" in either the New Yorker or NY Times (I forget which) made me see his prose in a different light. It does get a bit bombastic and overblown at times, but he's still a great author. And his imagination stuns me (as depraved as it is sometimes). Speaking of "No Country," here's a review defending it for anyone that is interested.

http://intrinsicgratification.blogspot.com/2011/08/in-defense-of-no-country-for-old-men-by.html
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Dave Astor
08:59 AM on 08/18/2011
Thanks, Zoo Station, for your interesting comment! And that was an excellent review you linked to. I agree with the reviewer that McCarthy, among other attributes, occasionally flashes a wry sense of humor in his books -- which is especially welcome amidst all the violence.
09:21 AM on 08/18/2011
I haven't read all Cormac's stuff yet--still have to tackle all of the Border Trilogy--and am anxiously anticipating "The Passenger" or whatever he's calling his next book. And I hear he's a Nobel front runner. Good for him. I love Philip Roth, too. Too bad these guys are so old. We'll miss their voices when they're gone, especially with how American history keeps rolling on. We need their commentary and ideas.

Glad you like the article, too. That guy reviews book, movies, religion. I like what he has to say.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
donnyraindog
Hi Mom!
09:45 PM on 08/17/2011
While it is easy to become mesmerized by cormacs strange prose and mind numbing violence his ridiculous attempts at female characters and pop philosophy spouted by the most unlikely actors does grow tiresome,still he is well worth reading as the brilliant parts can blow one away. I notice you didn't mention Sutree which for mr. mc carthy might be termed light as only 3 or 4 major players in the novel get killed. At one point the protaganist is described as " a reprobate scoin of an ancient saxon clan of a rainy day dream surmised" truly fun stuff!
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Dave Astor
10:10 PM on 08/17/2011
That was VERY well said, donnyraindog. When it comes to describing McCarthy's writing, you nailed it several times in one paragraph -- with humor thrown in! Your mention of "philosophy spouted by the most unlikely actors" reminded me that McCarthy's narration also sometimes makes it seem like a dumb thug of a character is on some epic journey or quest. But, yes, as you wrote, "the brilliant parts can blow one away." I didn't mention "Suttree" and "Child of God" because those are the only two McCarthy novels my local library doesn't have.
photo
BlackJAC
It's better to be a black king than a white knight
02:01 PM on 08/17/2011
Cormac McCarthy's books are violent? Never would've guessed, what with his pretentious refusal to put dialogue in quotations so I could actually follow the story.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Dave Astor
03:00 PM on 08/17/2011
Thanks, BlackJAC! That was hilarious! McCarthy's lack of quotation marks does take some getting used to, but after a while I don't notice. I read somewhere that he feels quotation marks sort of clutter up a page. And, yes, the word "pretentious" can come to mind when thinking of McCarthy, but he's so amazing with language that I feel he usually goes beyond pretentious into high art.
photo
BlackJAC
It's better to be a black king than a white knight
04:20 PM on 08/17/2011
After a lifetime of essay tests and the acquisition of both a creative writing degree and a technical writing certificate, I can say that anyone who's celebrated for "language" is trying to cover up a weak story by plastering on the wordy spackle with a fire hose.
01:39 PM on 08/17/2011
Howdy, Mr. Astor!

-- Got any ideas for "McCarthy-ized" books? --

"Bambi and the Blue-Plate Special"?

MugBuckAndDoeShotRuith1
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Dave Astor
02:13 PM on 08/17/2011
Despite the fact that I'm a vegetarian, I had to admire that one! Very funny. Thanks, MugRuith1!
photo
BlackJAC
It's better to be a black king than a white knight
03:14 PM on 08/17/2011
There was a book years ago called TREKS NOT TAKEN that did STAR TREK: THE NEXT GENERATION in the style of various famous authors. Cormac was one of them.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Dave Astor
03:29 PM on 08/17/2011
Wow -- didn't know about that book, BlackJAC. "Treks Not Taken" sounds great! I loved "The Next Generation" TV series even more than the original "Star Trek" series. A lot of it had to do with Patrick Stewart's amazing acting as Capt. Picard.