More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Dave Astor

Dave Astor

GET UPDATES FROM Dave Astor
 

The "Goats" in Pro Sports Deserve Better

Posted: 02/ 3/11 05:10 PM ET

It was twenty years ago that "wide right" entered the American lexicon. Nope, that phrase doesn't describe an overeating Republican. "Wide right" was the direction of a missed Scott Norwood field goal that would have given the Buffalo Bills a narrow Super Bowl victory over the Giants in early 1991.

Norwood became yet another pro athlete doomed to metaphorically wear "The Scarlet F" (for failure) until the day he dies. And I think that's wrong. Firstly, Norwood's three-point attempt was from a relatively long 47 yards, not from chip-shot territory. Secondly, he didn't miss the uprights by much; it wasn't like he shanked the football towards, say, the belly of abrasive Giants coach Bill Parcells (though that would have been rather fun). Thirdly, a Super Bowl, for those fans who might not realize it, is just a game.

Another athlete who has been unfairly maligned for years is Bill Buckner, whose muffing of a ground ball helped cost the Boston Red Sox the 1986 World Series. Buckner was actually an excellent Major Leaguer (.289 lifetime batting average) who played hurt that day. Cut the guy some slack! Besides, the Sox would've still been baseball's '86 champs if they had beat the New York Mets two days later. Given that disgraced Ponzi schemer Bernard Madoff was a close pal of a future Mets owner, time travelers from today would have rejoiced at a Sox seventh-game win. Then again, given that '86 Sox pitcher Roger Clemens was later accused of steroids use, time travelers from today may not have rejoiced.

Then there was Donnie Moore, a California Angels relief pitcher who gave up a crucial home run during the 1986 playoffs that helped the Sox get into that year's World Series. Moore was viciously booed by Angels fans after '86, and committed suicide in 1989 (after the depressed man vented his frustrations by shooting his innocent wife, who survived). If unforgiving fans had decided to "get a life," maybe Moore would still have his.

And way back in 1908, New York Giants player Fred Merkle cost his team the pennant when he made a base-running gaffe in a game against the Chicago Cubs. As the Giants scored a run that (seemingly) won the game, Merkle didn't touch second base. It wasn't always the custom back then to touch a base in that kind of situation. Plus, fans were all over the field and the poor guy was a rookie. Yet Merkle was blasted and ridiculed by newspapers for his human mistake. Of course, no newspaper has ever made a mistake.

There are villains in sports, but they're not the people who unintentionally cost their team an important game. The villains are people like 2011 Super Bowl quarterback Ben Roethlisberger, who (while allegedly mending his ways in recent months) has been accused of sexually assaulting women. In a more just world, "wide right" would be better than not doing the right thing.

 
It was twenty years ago that "wide right" entered the American lexicon. Nope, that phrase doesn't describe an overeating Republican. "Wide right" was the direction of a missed Scott Norwood field goal...
It was twenty years ago that "wide right" entered the American lexicon. Nope, that phrase doesn't describe an overeating Republican. "Wide right" was the direction of a missed Scott Norwood field goal...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 12
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
05:39 PM on 02/04/2011
I never thought Bill Parcells was as "abrasive" as Dave thinks. If he was,he had to be to get the Giants and Pats to the Super Bowl,and almost got the Jets there. I agree with the premise of the column. Scott Norwood could be Mother Theresa,and all he'll be remembered for will be the missed field goal at the Super Bowl. Bill Buckner shouldn't have been on the field,he was hobbling.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Dave Astor
07:46 PM on 02/04/2011
Thanks, liberalking37! Bill Parcells was a great coach, but not very warm and fuzzy. It's interesting how coaches can succeed by being hard-edged (Lombardi, Belichick, Parcells, etc.) and also succeed by being more of a "players' coach" (Tony Dungy, Rex Ryan, etc.).
"Scott Norwood could be Mother Theresa,an­d all he'll be remembered for will be the missed field goal at the Super Bowl" -- GREAT line!
Yes, Buckner shouldn't have been on the field. I read that his manager kept him on the field for the winning-the-World Series celebration. Of course, the Bosox wouldn't win a World Series for another 18 years!
09:59 AM on 02/04/2011
Howdy, Mr. Astor!

-- Of course, no newspaper has ever made a mistake. --

Shoot, if you must, the old Gray Lady and her more-youthful, more-colorful kin, but spare at least one celebrated newsperson-cum-poet, Grantland Rice, whose coach in "Alumnus Football" memorably contended, "[W]hen the One Great Scorer comes to mark against your name, He writes -- not that you won or lost -- but how you played the Game."

MugStillAwaitingTheYankees'CallRuith1
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Dave Astor
10:20 AM on 02/04/2011
I can only laud a person (Grantland Rice) who came up with a classic quote like that, and also laud a person (MugRuith1) who came up with a great Huffington Post comment like that. Thank you.
As for "Still Awaiting The Yankees' Call," can you pitch? With Andy Pettitte now retired, that team craves arms even more than a military dictator does.
03:37 PM on 02/04/2011
Howdy, Mr. Astor!

-- As for "Still Awaiting The Yankees' Call," can you pitch? --

Yup, according to me. Nope, according to Whitey Ford, who conducted my tryout at Ye Olde Yankee Stadium in the third quarter of the last century of the last millennium.

-- With Andy Pettitte now retired, that team craves arms even more than a military dictator does. --

They don't call them the Bombers for nothing . . .

MugSoldierOfFortuneRuith1
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Jerry Zezima
10:49 PM on 02/03/2011
A winner, Dave. As a former sportswriter who saw all kinds of boorish behavior (from fans, players, coaches, parents, even mascots), I'm glad you added some much-needed perspective to the subject. You hit a home run, scored a touchdown, netted a goal, ran to glory, brought home the gold ... HELP! I CAN'T STOP THE CLICHES! Anyway, nice job.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Dave Astor
06:17 AM on 02/04/2011
I appreciate the comment, Jerry! Sorry you had to deal with boorish behavior when you were a sportswriter, but I hope there were some nice moments to compensate. As for sports cliches: sounds like another column topic!
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Suzette Standring
08:20 PM on 02/03/2011
I applaud your column. Everyone needs a reminder that the person who missed a winning point already feels horrible. They were in the game because of their athletic excellence but nothing is guaranteed. It is a reminder that "fan" does derive from fanatic. Thanks for going to bat for common sense and compassion!
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Dave Astor
08:27 PM on 02/03/2011
Thanks, Suzette, for your comment -- and all the wisdom in it. Yes, the athlete already feels horrible without all the piling on.
06:38 PM on 02/03/2011
Jackie Smith, the Dallas Cowboys tight end who dropped a sure touchdown pass in Super Bowl XIII against the Pittsburgh Steelers, reportedly was haunted by it for many years thereafter. It's a shame, because Smith, who spent most of his career with the St. Louis Cardinals, was one of the greatest tight ends in NFL history, reflected by his membership in the Pro Football Hall of Fame.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Dave Astor
06:58 PM on 02/03/2011
Thanks, Scurvybro! "Haunted" is an excellent word to describe the way Jackie Smith and others felt after making a mistake. And, given how Smith became a Hall of Famer (as you noted), it can be a great player making the mistake. I wish more fans had more empathy for the mistake-makers.