More

Dave Zirin

Dave Zirin

Posted: October 14, 2009 04:18 PM

My Response to Rush Limbaugh's Rage

What's Your Reaction?

Yesterday I was referred to on air as "scum" by Rush Limbaugh. Limbaugh called me out by name on his radio show because, along with Bryan Burwell of the St. Louis Post-Dispatch and Drew Sharp of the Detroit Free Press, I challenged Limbaugh's efforts to own a NFL team, saying that his history of racial bombast should count against him.

Limbaugh said of us:

They are the ones with prejudice and bigotry coursing through their vanes [sic], through their hearts, and through their souls. They are consumed with jealousy and rage. They are all liberals--and make no mistake: That's what this is about. It is about ideology. It isn't about race. It's about their being jealous and attempting to discredit me, and they've now sunk to the low of repeating fabricated quotes that they cannot source.... These people are scum.

What we all did was carry a quote from Limbaugh that he absolutely insists he did not say. The quote is:

We didn't have slavery in this country for over 100 years because it was a bad thing. Quite the opposite: slavery built the South. I'm not saying we should bring it back; I'm just saying it had its merits. For one thing, the streets were safer after dark.

For all the dittoheads out there, here is how we came up with the quote: it was in the St. Louis Post-Dispatch, the Detroit Free Press, the Washington Post, and in the book 101 People Who Are Really Screwing America by Jack Huberman. In Huberman's book, it must be added, it is unsourced. It is also true that the quote has been out in the ether for years. Now that it is endangering his chances to become an NFL owner, Limbaugh is serving up a full heaping of indignation.

As Jason Whitlock, with whom I have had every manner of political disagreement over the years, writes:

Limbaugh claimed on his radio show Monday that his staff could not find any proof that he ever joked about slavery. I'm sorry. Limbaugh doesn't get the benefit of the doubt on racial matters.... You can argue the comments are presented out of context and were meant as jokes. Then I'd argue that Limbaugh needs to get on the comedy-club circuit and out of the business of attempting to influence presidential politics. Limbaugh wants to be taken seriously.

But let's take Limbaugh at his word that he didn't say it. We should also look at the myriad of quotes on record he makes no effort to dispute. We can only assume that he is proud to have said, "The NFL all too often looks like a game between the Bloods and the Crips without any weapons."

Or these other gems:

The NAACP should have riot rehearsal. They should get a liquor store and practice robberies.

Have you ever noticed how all composite pictures of wanted criminals resemble Jesse Jackson?

To an African-American caller:

Take that bone out of your nose and call me back.

Upon hearing that Spike Lee said that black schoolchildren should take off from school to see the movie Malcolm X:

Spike, if you're going to do that, let's complete the education experience. You should tell them that they should loot the theater and then blow it up on their way out.

Or calling Barack Obama "Halfrican-American" and saying:

In Obama's America, the white kids now get beat up with the black kids cheering, "Yay, right on, right on, right on, right on".... We need segregated buses--it was invading space and stuff. This is Obama's America.

The real reason Rush is doing a slow-burn on his show and setting loose his army of Internet flame throwers is that his dream of owning an NFL franchise is going up in smoke. After seven players and the union went public and stood up to Rush getting his mitts around the most powerful cultural and athletic brand in America, commissioner Roger Goodell finally spoke out. Goodell said on Tuesday that Limbaugh's "divisive comments" had no place in the NFL. "I have said many times before, we're all held to a higher standard here," Goodell said to reporters. "I would not want to see those kinds of comments coming from people who are in a responsible position in the NFL. No. Absolutely not."

Goodell's statement was complemented by Colts owner Jim Irsay, who told ESPN, "I, myself, couldn't even think of voting for him.... I'm very sensitive to know there are scars out there. I think as a nation we need to stop it. Our words do damage, and it's something that we don't need. We need to get to a higher level of humanity, and we have." Other owners issued decidedly lukewarm comments about the possibility of sharing space with Rush.

Some are surprised that ownership isn't welcoming Limbaugh with a passionate embrace because most owners are to the right of Attila the Hun. They are billionaires who have feasted at the public trough of corporate welfare while basking in tax breaks for the rich. In other words, they constitute Limbaugh's base. But his membership in this exclusive fraternity of billionaires would violate the first rule of ownership: protect the bottom line.

The inconvenient truth is that no matter how much he rants and raves, no matter how often he calls columnists like Burwell, Sharp and me "state-run-media scum," it's the commissioner and the owners who believe that his history of ugly vitriol would be just too harmful to the NFL brand. You reap what you sow, and Rush Limbaugh has reaped a whirlwind.

 
 

Follow Dave Zirin on Twitter: www.twitter.com/edgeofsports

 
 
  • Comments
  • 319
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (7 total)
12:35 PM on 10/18/2009
"We can only assume that he is proud to have said, "The NFL all too often looks like a game between the Bloods and the Crips without any weapons."

The NFL itself was concerned a few years back about it's players flashing gang signs in the end zone and other gang related behavior such as certain clothing styles. They actually hired gang experts to review the hand gestures of black players. Does Mr. Zirin consider this preoccupation of the NFL racist also?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
MyNameIsJames
What should a person say in their micro-bio
07:02 PM on 10/15/2009
Great Job Dave!
04:06 PM on 10/17/2009
I second that, great job Dave
05:21 PM on 10/15/2009
Bravo to the NFL!.

Sports is where a lot of racial barriers were broken. It amazes me how far the NFL has come. I use to watch football as a child in the early 70's, and I didn't see any black quarterbacks or coaches, now things have changed for the best. Not to say thing are 100% better, but at least they said NO to someone who has used the race card to make millions; however, those millions which was built off hateful words were not enough to gain him ownership, and for that I Respect the NFL.

Having Rush on board would have sent the wrong message, and would have set us back many years.
12:36 PM on 10/18/2009
Now you don't see any white tail backs. Isn't progress great!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:16 PM on 10/18/2009
Yes, and the world slipped off it axis...poor baby.

My childhood heroes were Gale Sayers and Brian Piccalo.
photo
lisaman
vote for your best interests or shut up
03:21 PM on 10/15/2009
I guess the old school yard saying works here as well, Rush can dish it out, but he can't take it!
SantaFeConservative
Hoping for Change in 2012
12:53 PM on 10/15/2009
I take it you will be as diligent going after all other owners/partners of national sports teams that have said insensitive/controversial things, correct?
01:32 PM on 10/15/2009
Which ones are they? Give us their names and we will tar and feather the scallywags.
01:58 PM on 10/15/2009
Uhhh...they're already owners. No one gets to vote them in or out. And di you even read the article? This is the free market in action. Rush would have been bad for profits.
12:40 PM on 10/15/2009
Let me provide a summary of this OPINION piece.

LOOK! All these bad things he said, well, the worse damning items I don't really have any proof, but it was printed here and there and here (again, these places don't have proof either, they just printed them), but nevermind that, these other things, which are not really that racist unless you line them up against the things that I don't have proof of then they look REAL BAD.

So he's a real BAD MAN. (trust me)

Opinion (yet again) passed off as fact.
01:16 PM on 10/15/2009
Statements that limbaugh made on his radio show are Zirin's opinion? That's some really strange logic. Don't you mean that statements limbaugh makes on his radio show are limbaugh's opinions?
03:09 PM on 10/15/2009
where am I saying that what Rush said is Zirin's opinion?? Having a hard time thinking for yourself?

Zirin claims Rush is a racist, except what he uses as "proof" is anything but proof, he concludes that Rush is a racist anyway, it's his OPINION that Rush is a racist yet this is presented as FACT.
photo
lisaman
vote for your best interests or shut up
03:13 PM on 10/15/2009
Hey, did I meet you in a Campbell Mo site about health care?

I completely agree with this post, whether or not you are the same YDD I befriended before!
12:26 PM on 10/15/2009
I think the federal government should take over the Rams.

Then have the feds give 50% ownership to the players union as a token of their support.

After all, what's most important about the sale of the franchise is not what the new owner can do to make it the best it can be. What's most important is that people with no financial interest in the organization speak their mind and have an influence over the change of ownership. Jesse Jackson, Al Sharpton, Shiela Jackson Lee, and anyone else that wants to protests it.

Rush doesn't need to buy the Rams, he just wanted to. It's not a big loss to him, but could be a big loss to St. Louis.
12:42 PM on 10/15/2009
Good post.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
silverball
01:03 PM on 10/15/2009
...i'm SURE the big "loss" you spoke of was a reference to rush.....and more specifically, his ego....and racist mouth.....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JakeHanson
Flying Spaghetti Monster Bless America!
12:21 PM on 10/15/2009
The best thing anyone can do is to not listen to Bah Humbugh. Like Beck, Hannity, Palin, and Bachman, Rush spews outlandish statements that are geared towards getting extreme reactions out of the left. The more we feed into it, the more he benefits, so I say turn off your radio and move on with your day. The world is becoming increasingly less-tolerant of these 5-year old temper-tantrum tactics to gain attention, and his followers are a dying breed.
photo
espressobeans
. . . just saying it like it is.
12:00 PM on 10/15/2009
Poor Rush. Learning the hard way that words have consequences. Keep hating, Limbo. See where it gets you in the end. Jacob Marley has nothing on you.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
Jaxy
Bah! My micro-bio didn't meet your guidelines
11:55 AM on 10/15/2009
Rush Limbaugh is a complete and total waste of air and space. He panders and makes appeal to the very ugliest genre of human behavior. He is an unmitigated rac.ist and a xenophobe.

Unfortunately, those who hang onto his every word are insufficiently evolved to know that he is using them. Do these hacks actually think Flush goves a flyin' frick how they live, whether they have food in the fridge, or clothes on their children's backs? Of course not ... that would actually require a soul.
11:35 AM on 10/15/2009
Lord, help us. The ditto-heads have arrived.. This thread is toast.
11:52 AM on 10/15/2009
Yes, people want to debate you! Quick! Run!!!
12:04 PM on 10/15/2009
Shame on you! Don't you know you are not suppose to question only agree/follow?
11:22 AM on 10/15/2009
The funny part about the links to the slavery comment is that it brings me to an opinion piece, not actual news. Anyone know when he said it? Or sound bite? No? Hmmmmm, wonder why.
11:59 AM on 10/15/2009
Actually... the left should hire 1000 interns, students, and paralegals to comb through all 24 years of Limbaughs shows transcribe them and index them. Electronic communications are poorly archived and with Limbaugh's more subtle racist arcs, I'm sure there is a metric ton of material that could paint a more complete picture. Whatever one says about Limbaugh's politics.. the blood tie that Limbaugh has with his listeners is founded on a deep strain of American racism. Where liberals get it wrong is that they look only for overt anti-black statements like the ones above which Limbaugh can easily defend as a parody of the black activists he dislikes taken to an extreme. What can't be explained away is the relationship of Limbaugh's father and brother to various southern conservative and neo-confederate movements... put together with a chronological analysis of what Limbaugh has been saying and when, a picture should emerge more clearly of how slavery and Jim Crow built not only the South but its posterity is the Southern Strategy and the rise of White Nationalist resistance to the post New Deal/post Great Society America by guys like Pat Buchanan, Sean Hannity, and Rush Limbaugh.
02:01 PM on 10/15/2009
These talking heads say horrible things about people for a living as easily as if they were breathing, and then act like there is some official document somewhere signed in blood that documents every true thing they've said and only that document (that nobody knows about) is a legitimate source. Don't make these kind of statements if you are too much of a w u s s to defend them. Here is what snopes has to say about limbaugh's racist quotes. Some don't have much evidence, but some do.

http://www.snopes.com/politics/quotes/limbaugh.asp
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:44 PM on 10/15/2009
the mcnabb comment itself says enough. didnt he get canned for that? why bring in McNabbs race to that comment? it was all about race and an appeal to the resentments over affirmative action that has been the bread and butter of the right since 1965. he may not be a racist but he exploits resentment over affirmative action.
11:22 AM on 10/15/2009
Rush & dittoheads are finding out there's no place in the modern world for their bigotry brigade.
12:08 PM on 10/15/2009
Rush Limbaugh has been "South Africanized" ... the limits of his wealth are beginning to come into a clearer focus for him. Ironically.. his imitation of Nelson Mandela and the hatred he has expressed for the man, should make him reflect that no such figure exists to liase between him and the black NFL players who stood against them. Let's not kid ourselves.. a majority of the employees in the NFL have attitudes that would probably make Rush Limbaugh look like Rosa Parks. And let's not lose sight of what ultimately happened in South Africa.. the rich whites sued for peace with the oppressed blacks... who got their "freedom" and the promise that the nukes wouldn't be dropped on them, while the whites kept their wealth, land and functional command of the society. This was a nice first volley against Limbaugh... but the work of making that $400,000,000 dollars a millstone around the neck of those who pay Limbaugh and those who do business with him dovetails with the continuation of the rise of black America economically and socially... two areas where there has been nothing but backsliding almost from the day the civil rights movement ended. Limbaugh can always laugh that his considerable holdings of money is still green and that while HE can't buy an NFL franchise.. neither can any serious black business person in this entire country with the exception of a few entertainment industry billionaires.
photo
getoffthecross
I take social satire seriously...
11:21 AM on 10/15/2009
I listen to Rush almost daily as a means to counter the parrotted arguments that I will receive from coworkers later in the day. It's not good for my disposition.

Rush spent a great deal of 2008 trying to convince people that there was no looming recession, and then attempted to label the economic crisis Obama's recession before the man even took office. He blames Obama for every single job lost in this country since his administration started. Before that, he tried to incite riots in Denver during the DNC, and before that he told people to switch their voter registrations in an effort to undermine the primary process. He constantly trashes Acorn for the very thing he gleefully attempted: skewing our elections.

On an almost daily basis, he calls our president "stupid" and "bitter" and claims that he WANTS people unemployed and WANTS our country to fail, and then bemoans the treatment Bush received by the left for eight years. The joke is on those who take him seriously. He doesn't love you, he just wants all your money.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Poiks
11:55 AM on 10/15/2009
Cherry-picking one comment: It's absolutely impossible for me to imagine how Barack Obama could be viewed as "bitter."

You want bitter? Check out Cheney, McCain, Palin, Boehner, Cantor, Birthers, Teabaggers.
photo
getoffthecross
I take social satire seriously...
01:08 PM on 10/15/2009
In most instances, you can substitute "right" for "left" or "conservative" for "liberal" and Rush would actually be speaking the truth.

Just today, he claims his dropped bid for the NFL franchise equates to "dark days for America." That's right, the country is going down the tubes because Rush wasn't allowed to flaunt his hatred in yet another public arena. As usual, I just consider his words to be the opposite of truth. Rush losing the bid is a "bright" day for America? Right on, right on, right on!
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
TexasMike
Liberals=Liberty/Republicans=Regression
11:18 AM on 10/15/2009
What must really stinging Rush's over-inflated self image is that he's spent his whole career defending the ultra rich from the "evil left" and yet, still, there is no way they want him in their "club" no matter how much he wants to buy in.

That must cut real deep, Rush......and those Dittoheads should take heed as well. The money crowd USED you to get tax breaks for themselves and that crowd could care less if you live or die. THINK. Who are you really supporting when you constantly vote against your better interests?
12:21 PM on 10/15/2009
Rush Limbaugh is too hot to handle in the broad entertainment biz sense... that's the extent of what was accomplished here. He is still a critical disinformation source and he is believed because of the bond of hatred he has with his listenership. The price of that bond is that he has been locked out of mainstream participation in broadcast sports. It was decided that he would do less for the business of having guys nationwide plop down on couches on Sundays in the fall. The uneasy alliance of white men and black men in football, into which the Limbaugh/NFL/ESPN incidents fall into a kind of no man's land, still contain questions which go right to the heart of black america's issues and pathologies in this country. Ultimately.... Rush Limbaugh still has access to the businessmen who run the place and can lay claim to the dominant culture of country music and football which still has a discomfort with black men dominating on the field and being cut in on some of the vast proceeds from the enterprise. There isn't a black business figure in the entire world.. with the exception of Oprah, Russell Simmons or Jay-Z who can even claim to have SOME of the money needed to buy into the NFL.. so really.. blacks are in the same boat as Limbaugh!