iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
David Briggs

David Briggs

GET UPDATES FROM David Briggs

The Complicated Connection Between Religion and the Paranormal

Posted: 02/ 6/11 07:57 PM ET

Don't expect Hollywood to give up the ghosts.

The parade of paranormal entertainment filling American screens -- from the movie Paranormal Activity 2 to television shows such as Ghost Hunters, Psychic Investigators and Paranormal State -- is meeting an intense interest in otherworldly experiences, new research shows.

More than two-thirds of Americans have paranormal beliefs, sociologists Christopher Bader and F. Carson Mencken of Baylor University and Joseph Baker of East Tennessee State University report in their new book Paranormal America from New York University Press.

And the interest is only expected to increase, scholars say, with the growth of immigrant populations more open to paranormal beliefs.

Not everyone is interested. Those with no religious beliefs, Jewish people and the most committed Christians are among the least likely to believe in UFOs or psychics or Bigfoot.

But a generation of spiritual seekers are opening their minds and bank accounts to beliefs, practices and experiences that are not recognized by science and not associated with mainstream religion.

Whether it is a study showing nearly half of Americans believe extraterrestrials absolutely or probably exist, or ghost-hunting groups and documentary producers rushing to find the latest "haunted" house, interest in paranormal phenomena has entered the mainstream.

"What we can say with certainty is that we live in a paranormal America," write Bader, Mencken and Baker. "Put another way, the paranormal is normal."

Men hunt, women gather in New Age

In the 1980s, the actress Shirley MacLaine was ridiculed for discussing her interest in channeling, reincarnation and UFOs in her book Out on a Limb. But research indicates she may have been less a wacky outcast and more representative of the population than the image ingrained by late-night comics suggested.

The average American holds slightly more than two paranormal beliefs, report Bader, Mencken and Baker.

"Statistically, those who report a paranormal belief are not the oddballs," the researchers said.

But there are major differences in the types of people who gravitate toward different paranormal phenomena. Bigfoot conventions are almost all-male outings, while psychic affairs attract a largely female audience.

The 2005 Baylor Religion Survey found that women are twice as likely as men to believe in astrology, that people can communicate with the dead (a big reason Medium lasted for seven TV seasons) and that at least some psychics can foresee the future. Men, on the other hand, are more likely to believe in UFOs.

"Women tend to want to improve themselves, to become better people," said Bader, who is also a director of the Association for Religion Data Archives. "Men tend to want to go out and capture something, to prove it's real."

In reviewing the research, other findings reported by Bader, Mencken and Baker include:

• Belief in Bigfoot, ghosts, psychic abilities and other paranormal phenomena declines noticeably with increases in age and income.
• Unmarried and cohabiting individuals are far more likely to embrace the paranormal. Asked whether they have had any of five paranormal experiences from witnessing a UFO to contacting spirits, the typical unmarried respondent claimed close to two experience, while the average married respondent had no paranormal experiences.
• Republicans are "significantly less interested" in the paranormal than Democrats or independents.

Overall, the researchers said, conventional lifestyles and stakes in conformity are strong predictors of paranormal beliefs, with highly unconventional people the most likely to turn to otherworldly possibilities beyond the realm of traditional religion.

Spiritual and paranormal

There are conflicting theories about the relationship between religion and the paranormal. Among them are the idea those outside mainstream religion would be more likely to embrace the paranormal as a substitute set of beliefs. Another theory holds that religious individuals, already open to transcendent ideas, would also be more likely to hold paranormal beliefs.

What Bader, Mencken and Baker find in their research is that both individuals with no religious beliefs and the most committed individuals -- those who attend services weekly -- are among the least likely to hold paranormal beliefs. Those who believe the Bible is the literal word of God are also highly unlikely to hold paranormal beliefs.

It is in the middle, among people who have an interest in religion but who are not regular attenders, that there is greater belief in the paranormal. Belief in paranormal topics is at its highest level among people with more liberal views of the Bible, researchers said.

What does all this mean for the future?

The researchers say the aging of America's population and projected gains in income likely will reduce belief in some aspects of the paranormal, but the increase in immigration and the tailoring off of conservative religious growth is expected to lead to increased interest.

Going out on their own limb, the researchers predict that by 2050 nearly three-quarters of Americans will report at least one paranormal belief.

Be prepared, and forewarned: Paranormal Activity 3 is coming

David Briggs writes the Ahead of the Trend column for the Association of Religion Data Archives.

 

Follow David Briggs on Twitter: www.twitter.com/ReligionData

Don't expect Hollywood to give up the ghosts. The parade of paranormal entertainment filling American screens -- from the movie Paranormal Activity 2 to television shows such as Ghost Hunters, Psychi...
Don't expect Hollywood to give up the ghosts. The parade of paranormal entertainment filling American screens -- from the movie Paranormal Activity 2 to television shows such as Ghost Hunters, Psychi...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 376
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (7 total)
06:42 AM on 02/11/2011
Yes, belief in both religion and the paranormal necessitate that you suspend any requirement for evidence of and justification for your assertions.
photo
WoodsideCraig
Author of the blog "The Weiler Psi"
12:25 PM on 02/11/2011
I think that if you examined this closely, what you would find is that there is far more gray area than most people would like to admit. There is an awful lot that does not fit in accepted models of science and when people encounter these things they rightly trust their own senses over scientific theory.
08:43 AM on 02/12/2011
I'll agree with almost everything you say, except one word: "rightly". Our senses or rather our sensory organs and the brain that digests the information they transmit are both highly discriminatory. You are promoting truthiness.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
MoreDimensions
08:56 PM on 02/10/2011
The more a person makes their thoughts into their identity, the more this person becomes cut of from the spiritual dimensions within ones self. They equate truth with thought and subconsciously protect their identity through ego tending towards id, becoming completely unaware of the limitations of thought. It is only when we drop control of thought that we can just be, that we can just experience. It is only this life experience with out preconceived thought and judgment that allows one to delve into the deeper realms of our consciousness and interconnectedness with all of life. The quiet mind sees, feels and experiences what the busy mind can not perceive.
01:06 AM on 02/11/2011
whew.....could you boil all that down to a Chan type of statement so the last sentence is reflective in the rest of the comment.....just a thought.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
MoreDimensions
07:40 PM on 02/11/2011
The quiet mind is without preconceived thoughts, ego and the noise of busy thoughts about the day.  This allows us to sense what we otherwise could not.
photo
WoodsideCraig
Author of the blog "The Weiler Psi"
12:26 PM on 02/11/2011
Yup, no argument there. Fanned.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
MoreDimensions
07:39 PM on 02/11/2011
Hello new friend.
photo
DougSmith
I calls it like I sees it
08:54 PM on 02/10/2011
The paranormal and belief in possible life on other planets is two very different things.

If one believes in invisible spirits and and an unseen omnicient/omnipotent/omnipresent being that there is no proof for then it would be no surprise that they could also believe in the "paranormal" like ESP, Ghosts which they already believe in etc.

That's all magical thing where as believeing that there may be life on other planets is logical given the size of the universe. If you think they are waling among us, sucking people up into their spaceships or trying to take over the world, that's a mindset that doesn't fit into anything but the crazy category.
04:57 AM on 02/10/2011
The paranormal and religion share one commonality
 
They are both based on irrationality.
12:58 AM on 02/11/2011
At their "base" is not irrationality, it is people who put it there because they do not know or do not understand what they are doing. To quote Guirdjieff "the knowledge exist but people are too lazy to find it and learn it"
photo
WoodsideCraig
Author of the blog "The Weiler Psi"
12:28 PM on 02/11/2011
So if I consistently experience psychic phenomena and decide after awhile that it must be real, is this irrational?
05:29 PM on 02/11/2011
Yes it is irrational, because what you are experiencing is not psychic phenomena.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bob Wood
A.T.C.G...(sigh)
07:32 PM on 02/09/2011
Not too complicated...they're much the same...(sigh)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Hillbilly49
Don't tell me you are a Christian; let me guess.
04:12 PM on 02/09/2011
The paranormal and religion are very much alike; they both rely on a shared delusion with faith.
12:54 AM on 02/11/2011
The lazy mans version of both relies on faith, or if you only want to experience them then you may need some faith, though it may become a self fulling wish. At the root of both is knowledge and the exercise of knowledge.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Klarsonent
Semi-retired landlady, small business entrepreneur
03:33 PM on 02/09/2011
The statement, "Those who believe the Bible is the literal word of God are also highly unlikely to hold paranormal beliefs." is ludicrous, to say the least. Jesus, the person that they profess to believe in, was a mystic, psychic and medium and He taught his disciples the same techniques: Visit my website and click on "Bible Verses" at the top of the page: http://www.psychickaren.com I guess these "literal" Bible believers have forgotten a few verses taught by Jesus.
photo
ArtJunky
Belief is mandatory
08:57 AM on 02/10/2011
Business slow?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
bbriani3842
400+ yrs of science & STILL no evidence for a god
11:17 PM on 02/10/2011
Business ain't the only thing that's slow ...
02:41 PM on 02/10/2011
OK, so you plucked some scripture and used it to support your point of view. The bible is clear when addressing psychic activity.

Do searches of the Bible on words like:
Soothsayer & “SIMON” THE SORCERER.
check out "Divner"

Also check out Acts 19:19- read a few verses before and after. (To get a clear understanding as to what is going on)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Klarsonent
Semi-retired landlady, small business entrepreneur
12:05 PM on 02/11/2011
You are living in the dark ages. Have you ever heard of intuition? It's proven that we all have it. Animals also have it. It's not strange. It's not supernatural. It is part of your brain power.

Psychic ability is not "sorcery." It's not witchcraft. It's not voodoo. It's not affiliated with the occult either.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Klarsonent
Semi-retired landlady, small business entrepreneur
12:20 PM on 02/11/2011
Right back at you: Acts 2:17-18 . . . prophet Joel “In the last days, God said, ‘I will pour out my Holy Spirit upon all mankind, and your sons and daughters shall prophesy, and your young men shall see visions, and your old men dream dreams’ “Yes, the Holy Spirit shall come upon all my servants, men and women alike, and they shall prophesy.”
02:41 PM on 02/09/2011
The article says: "Those who believe the Bible is the literal word of God are also highly unlikely to hold paranormal beliefs." Shouldn't it be: "Those who believe the Bible is the literal word of God already hold paranormal beliefs."?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Dukedraven
11:03 AM on 02/09/2011
I think a lot of times people who've had paranormal experiences are less likely to believe in organized religion, which will often-times malign supernatural encounters. And people who possess no spiritual beliefs and are derisive of anything of a paranormal nature have, I believe, sensory blocks that keep their powers of perception low.
photo
WoodsideCraig
Author of the blog "The Weiler Psi"
09:54 PM on 02/10/2011
I've had a lot of discussions with skeptics and by and large, they share a strong desire NOT to know anything about it. They dismiss all facts which don't fit their narrative remarkably easily.

So I'd say yes, they have sensory blocks.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
KayAch7
A Delay Is Not A Denial...sometimes
11:18 PM on 02/10/2011
good answer!
06:21 AM on 02/09/2011
There seems to be a theme permeating this discussion thread, where a number of folks (author included) are bent on defending their pet belief as not worthy of inclusion in the "paranormal" category, in spite of meeting the dictionary definition (no scientific/naturalistic explanation). Same mental process by which people defend the "truth" of their particular religions while dismissing all the others as hogwash. When will we start teaching Skepticism as a high school subject? It's not a dirty word, it's a valuable life skill.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ddanimal
04:34 PM on 02/09/2011
And who determines whether there is a scientific/naturalistic explanation for something? Science is complex, obviously, and its frequently not clear whether an observation is in conflict with scientific models or not.

I have an interest in things that have evidence to support them, no matter what the politics are. The UFO phenomenon has a large body of evidence to support, unlike other garbage like astrology or spoon bending. Part of the problem is that skeptics group everything they dont understand into one giant category of woo, and dont take the time to look at the details.
07:36 AM on 02/10/2011
I'll add to my post above that everyone who thinks their pet belief is true is utterly convinced there's a mountain of evidence in support of it, and there's a conspiracy to shut that evidence out of legitimate investigation. For you, it's UFO's. For another guy it's "remote viewing". The other day it was homeopathy. Then of course there's "Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed".

No offense meant, but I think you've fallen into the same trap that you clearly see in others.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:41 PM on 02/11/2011
--The UFO phenomenon has a large body of evidence to support,

No, it doesn't. It has unverifiable stories, and *nothing* else.
researcher
researcher
12:31 AM on 02/09/2011
"Magic has been PROVEN not to exist unless you are talking about "slight of hand." Therefore, anything based on magic is false."

this is not only a false statement but an ignorant one. ignorance is simply unawareness so dont get upset with being called ignorant.

without our ignorance there is no us just isness. so count your blessings for ignorance, of course some are more ignorant than others. ie evolution of consciousness thing.

if one looks close and observes without cherished beliefs in neither; one can see this ignorance in religion and materialism. both sides actually think they understand reality the very best.
photo
ArtJunky
Belief is mandatory
05:36 PM on 02/11/2011
Yes, we know, if we would just stop thinking and bringing facts and asking for REAL facts, you wouldn't feel so inferior.

Sorry, magic HAS been proven not to exist.
photo
WoodsideCraig
Author of the blog "The Weiler Psi"
12:25 AM on 02/09/2011
It's always amazing to me what people believe. I have a friend who is an engineer who believes in string theory. 17 dimensions all wrapped up in a soda straw. No evidence for this anywhere and no ability to predict anything. It's nothing more than a mathematical construct, unrelated to reality, yet to him, it's more real than the existence of consciousness, for which there is a mountain of evidence that it is far more than a mere thing in our heads.

Yoo hoo, there is no objective reality! There is no "out there." Everything you have ever experienced has only occurred in your head. The chair you're sitting in is nothing more than a probability cloud when no conscious entity observes it. That's science.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ddanimal
04:30 PM on 02/09/2011
Exactly. String theory is garbage, and most of the high energy physics community buys into it. I guess they have nothing better to do.

There is vastly more evidence for UFOs than string theory. But for no good reason, string theory is a darling, and UFOs are ignored.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:36 PM on 02/10/2011
Huh? The mathematics for string theory "IS" evidence. True it can't be tested but scientists can't "see" the big bang either but it is accepted theory.

Please link to your ridiculous claim of vast evidence for UFO's. You will not find one scientist supporting UFO's yet find many top physicists working on string theory. Why do you suppose that is Igor?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
AdamWest1313
Hardcore Agnostic
06:57 PM on 02/10/2011
I love how you basically just said that you know more about the string theory than the entire "high energy physics community". You must be a complete and utter genious.
researcher
researcher
12:25 AM on 02/09/2011
"There is some scientific evidence for remote viewing, micropsych­okinesis and telepathy. See "margins of reality" by robert Jahn".

there is much more evidence that that but the materialist cannot and dare not even look at it.

even if it is presented they will reject without investigation. I have proved this time and time again. same applies to religion.

one unexplained paranormal event and their whole materialist paradigm comes crashing down and that is painful, very painful.

it would be like telling a christian jesus did not die for their sins so they could get a free pass to heaven. or even worst.

paradigms are that powerful; we dont even know they are creating our view of reality.

both the religious and the materialist cherry pick to support their system of beliefs. interesting to watch; like two sides of the same coin called unawareness.

above all seek awareness, but to seek one must give up their belief that they know.

the very essence of humility. ok meekness. :-)
07:29 AM on 02/09/2011
It's equally likely that if someone were to present to you the scientific community's critiques of Dr. Jahn's research (30 years of which ended up convincing nobody except the people who bought his books and DVD's), you would also reject it without investigation, because your convictions would be shattered and your feelings would be hurt.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ddanimal
04:28 PM on 02/09/2011
I have looked, but have never seen an investigative critique of Jahns research. So your statement is purely hypothetical.

The scientific community at large just ignores research into the "paranormal". Thats not scientific.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mommadona
I paint. I blog. Therefore, I am.
02:36 PM on 02/08/2011
I have a very nice ghost in my house. She wanders through, dragging a piece of yarn for my cats to play with.

I've gone to Virginia City,NV and encountered some really really nasty 'left overs' ~ if there's a portal to hell on earth, the mines under this city are at least the first 'gate'.

If you take the time and learn to live in reality ~ the 'other side' becomes more and more revealed.

All that ever was or will be is here now.

It's not rocket science. Just depends on where you want to spend your 'energies'.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
08:53 AM on 02/08/2011
Religion IS paranormal superstition. There is no divide.