More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
David Groshoff

GET UPDATES FROM David Groshoff
 

Child, Please: How Much Worse Does It Have To Get Before 'It Gets Better'?

Posted: 01/13/12 12:41 PM ET

While at least 12 queer teens succumbed to hostile schoolground violence (HSV)-induced bullycide (bullying that leads to suicide) in the final four months of 2010, the anti-queer HSV-motivated bullycides rolled right into 2011.

A year ago this week, in mid-January 2011, after suffering HSV that included (but wasn't limited to) a broken jaw and cyber-attacks on a Facebook page created specifically to ridicule him in part based on his perceived sexual orientation, 14-year-old Kameron Jacobsen succumbed to bullycide.

I couldn't imagine what it would be like for a parent to live through the death of a child for any reason. I also couldn't imagine how a parent or sibling could live through the bullycide of their family member and then see other kids celebrating or mocking the death of the parent's or sibling's family member, at school, with the school refusing to meaningfully intervene to stop it.

Dan Savage wants us to think that somehow, someway, "it gets better." While I value Savage's intentions, laud his efforts, and adore his irreverence, I'm calling B.S. on the "It Gets Better" propaganda. Jamey Rodemeyer was proof enough of that to me, as last year, after he made an "It Gets Better" video, he ultimately succumbed to the torment of HSV by killing himself. It didn't get better. And as we unfortunately just learned, this week it didn't get better for EricJames Borges, who took his own life only a month after filming his video for the "It Gets Better" campaign.

While it sometimes does get better for queer adults, many queer or queer-perceived youth simply can never envision making it to adulthood, no matter who stars in the video.

And now, beyond more deaths of queer teens, we're sadly also seeing how it doesn't get better for the surviving families of these kids' bullycides.

Resiliently attempting to honor Kameron Jacobsen's memory following his bullycide last January by trying to help make "it get better" for bullycidal kids, Kameron's dad, Kevin Jacobsen, devoted the past year to fight against the HSV that can lead to bullycide. In the last year alone, Kevin helped create the Kindness Above Malice Foundation (KAM), an organization with a simple and noble goal: "Teach kids to be kind."

Even assuming kids are inherently kind and instead are socialized into their discriminatory and ignorant conduct, what a great and understandable message, right? How could you not praise Kevin Jacobsen for his efforts to create KAM following the heartbreaking bullycide of his son?

But whether because of the daily battle he faced to ease bullying and HSV for other kids or the arrival of the one-year anniversary of his son's bullycide or any other conceivable reason or combination of reasons that we don't know about that may have existed, earlier this week Kameron's dad, Kevin Jacobsen -- an advocate for kids to just be kind to each other -- took his own life.

So let me say this:

First, whether you're a queer or straight teen, if you're violently tormented for not living up to the gender-conforming behavior that peers, teachers, parents, or others want, please understand that so many people care about your well-being.

Second, if you're a K-12 student being treated unfairly for your real or perceived sexual orientation or gender identity, contact the ACLU, and email every teacher, administrator, principal, school board member, and superintendent (even anonymously) so that a permanent written record exists of your having put the school on notice of the violence occurring at their school. If you feel suicidal, please get in touch with the amazing people at the Trevor Project. If your parents kick you out of the house, then seek out a welcoming shelter that will help; do your best to not involve yourself with alcohol, drug use, or the sex trade, as so many homeless queer teens have regrettably done in their attempts to survive parental and peer rejection. You may not believe it now, but your life and health are precious. There are numerous people whom you probably don't even realize view your existence as a blessing, and many of us are fighting every day to make this world a better place for you.

Third, if you're the parent of a child of whatever real or perceived sexual orientation or gender identity, please embrace your child's development, and support who that child is as an individual. Please recognize that enforcing a socialized, collectivist mindset of what teens "should" or "should not" be, if they're not harming anyone else, can lead to scarring psychological damage.

Fourth, if you're the parent of a kid who has succumbed to suicide, and particularly bullycide, please find resources for counseling and companionship from understanding and empathic people and organizations.

Fifth, if you're like 20-year-old Kiersten Jacobsen, someone who has lost a brother to bullycide and, subsequently, a parent to suicide, please know that despite the unimaginable pain and numbness you are feeling, you have peoples' thoughts and prayers for peace and comfort. Stay strong; we're rooting for your success in life.

I'll digress slightly before concluding with a message for the bullies.

Several months ago, I was honored that the University of Maryland's School of Law flew me cross country to speak at the school's Symposium regarding anti-GLBT youth bullying, organized by talented third-year law student Brooke Irving. The panelists and attendees articulated numerous stakeholder perspectives to engage a common nexus to help ease this problem and those affected by it. I had the opportunity there to publicly discuss and debate strategies with ACLU attorney James Gilliam, who represented Seth Walsh's mom following Seth's publicized bullycide. As I generally stated in a prior column, what I've seen in laws, court decisions, and analyses of how schools evade laws demonstrates that anti-bullying laws don't work. And don't think that the bullies don't know that.

But not so fast.

If you're a teen physically and psychologically tormenting your peers because they're somehow perceived as different, please understand that projecting your emotional problems onto others has unimaginable consequences rippling across this nation. And know that you're the target of my work, and recognize that I and many others are pushing every boundary to strategically create legal frameworks that will exploit unthinkable penalties for you so as to deter your antisocial behavior and make life a little better and more peaceful for all bullycidal teens -- regardless of sexual orientation or gender identity -- their families, and our society.

 

Follow David Groshoff on Twitter: www.twitter.com/davidgroshoff

While at least 12 queer teens succumbed to hostile schoolground violence (HSV)-induced bullycide (bullying that leads to suicide) in the final four months of 2010, the anti-queer HSV-motivated bullyci...
While at least 12 queer teens succumbed to hostile schoolground violence (HSV)-induced bullycide (bullying that leads to suicide) in the final four months of 2010, the anti-queer HSV-motivated bullyci...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 119
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
02:26 AM on 02/14/2012
It will only "get better" if we make it better. The message needs to change from being directed at victims of bullying, to being directed at parents, other adults, and the bullies themselves. And the message needs to be direct and uncompromising. Until then I fear words of solidarity and hope for a less devastating future ring hollow.
11:23 AM on 01/20/2012
I am glad to see an article address what I have been saying since these video's started - you have brought up excellent points. As a parent of a bullycide child - no one can understand except another parent of a bullycide child. Our children broke under horrific circumstances, and people tend to be so apathetic to what drove our children to break in the first place! James is an excellent source, but in so many cases the ACLU tends to not support strong peer abuse legislation with strong consequence as was the case of the bill that we put up in California SB453. I also commend you are your resouces for grieving parents - The Compassionate Friends is a life saver for those of us that live this journey.
Peace,
Lisa Ford Berry ~forever Michael's mom~
BRAVE
05:21 PM on 01/19/2012
Well, I suppose it depends on what one feels the IT GETS BETTER campaign is all about. Of course, it is to decrease bullying. And to protect victims. And to ostracize bullies. But more important - it is also about emboldening the rest of us in the community to take action against bullying. For those of us who are neigher bully or victim, it is a call to action to speak up. Bullies thrive when the community response is silent. Bullies are less likely to engage in bad behavior when the room is filled with others who will step forward and say NO or BACK OFF! There will always be bullies (note: Cain v. Abel). And history is replete with stories about good people who said nothing when evil was present. Only when enough of us respond verbally, openly and with action will the bully back down and cower......
12:02 AM on 01/18/2012
A Sad Story. There is still not enough being done to help these young kids make it through those tough high school years. Not only young kids but their family members. Life is long! Life can be tough! I know! My High school years were hell! Find what you are passionate about. Find something to live for! And help others struggling to find a way to make it through or offer them advice on where to seek help!!
10:55 PM on 01/17/2012
I do think there is some practical value of the steps laid out toward the end of this piece. In order for social justice to start happening, a person must know the importance of keeping a record of injustice as evidence of their cruel and unrelenting torment (which is a shame that such burden is placed on them). A central repository for these complaints will be the first step to presenting the damning truth that this type of behavior is pervasive has a continual ripple throughout the entire lives of many many others
10:51 PM on 01/17/2012
While I appreciate the issue of childhood bullying in our youth communities and schools remaining in the forefront of our consciousness, I strongly feel The Headline to this Article seems just a bit Disingenuous (at best) if not outright Counter Productive to a greater Purpose!
I see NO benefit whatsoever in insulting the efficacy of another organizations attempts to address and fight what is CLEARLY an ongoing issue for our youth across the country and MOST importantly the prevailing ignorance of the educational institutions which haven't responded adequately enough and actually systematically perpetuate the issue with evasive policies rather than addressing it directly! :(
I applaud ANY and ALL organizations that strive to project a positive message for our youth ALONG with providing necessary resources to seek help and provide education in the interest of prevention of these acts of violence and ignorance! YES, part of this process DOES and SHOULD include ADULTS and other youth who provide visual representations to our youth of individuals who have survived and experienced success in life!
AGAIN, We must NEVER lose sight of the REAL issue and that is HOW to best prevent these acts of violence among our youth to begin with NOT making disparaging remarks against other organizations and causing pointless distractions seemingly solely in the interest of making another "headline". Remember , to Inform/ Educate , Address and Resolve are ALL part of a collective process! Stay Alive, Stay Well !
11:52 PM on 01/17/2012
ps- With all due respect Mr. David Groshoff, Can you Imagine what the end result of The Civil Rights Movement would have been like if the "collective thinking" would have been to simply "Call B.S." on Dr. Martin Luther Kings Non-Violent approach of Civil Rights for ALL Americans? Again, It's worth noting, Any and All stances against this horrific and asinine mentality of bullying in our society (specifically our youth) is part of the Collective Process by which I stand firmly!
NEWS FLASH! Social Change is Never accomplished by only 1 or 2 acts of defiance, but rather a COLLECTIVE group of individuals who remain constant and UNITED in it's purpose to Extinguish Hate, bigotry, discrimination and injustices everywhere!
10:44 PM on 01/17/2012
Appalling and heartbreaking. Thank you shining the light on this continuing tragedy and for a call to action for us all to stand up to bullying where it exists in today's world. So many talented folks lose their own battle - not because they are troubled nor confused nor struggling with their sexuality. They struggle with a lack of acceptance from others and that the rest of us allow it to continue. We are all to blame for allowing bullying from preventing these individuals to live.
.
11:56 PM on 01/17/2012
Agree with AvidAC...bottom line.... we shouldn't lose sight of the main point - to best prevent these acts of violence on our youth, to stop bullying in our schools & our neighborhoods and to foster acceptance in families, social circles and communities.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
nzchicago
03:37 AM on 01/17/2012
It seems to me the bullies are a very small proportion of the student population. Couldn't a cultural shift be encouraged in the schools, so that the other kids banded together and stuck up for each other? And what about instilling in the jocks and kids who are at the top of the food chain that they should be looking after the students who are less able to defend themselves? If the whole school culture could be changed so that the bullies have their power taken away from them, I think the situation could be greatly improved. I really think this could be done if we wanted to do it, and I don't even think it would be that difficult - a few school assemblies, and some reinforcement in the classroom, and getting the parents involved.
08:15 PM on 01/16/2012
I know some of these points were already made, but I feel the need to make them anyway. I don't think the point of the "It Gets Better" videos is to play down the horrors of the bullying of LGBT youth. The point is to offer hope to them during what seems like an impossible and endless time. For most of us it did indeed get better. We grew up to be well adjusted, successful, happy people for the most part. The idea is that showing kids our lives now will hopefully make some of them think twice before taking their own lives. Should these videos be the only solution to the problem? Of course not. Policy to change the bullying itself is the solution. I don't think that means the videos can't help as a short-term bandaid until one day the issue itself can be addressed fully. When I was a younger I would have been over the moon to see a public figure, especially a straight one, make a video about how its cool to be gay. Do these baseball players really know what they're talking about? No. Were they pushed into it by other people? Probably. Does that change the positive effect it may have on someone watching it? Not at all. Can you imagine a campaign like this occurring twenty years ago? Its the little triumphs over time that eventually sway public opinion and lead to larger reform.
pavementends42
Micro-bio is a study, not a blurb.
02:25 PM on 01/16/2012
The kind of despair it takes to end one's own life is often too deep and dark to be rectified by a speech by a famous person. The depressed always have a little voice in the backs of their minds that tells them they are alone, no one understands, it will never get better--because that's just how it feels. Many will have to seek professional help to overcome this burden and awareness of that fact is paramount to this campaign to let others know this hardship is shared--and triumphed over--by many!
photo
Arithrianos
reality has already (w)on(e), surrender!
07:46 AM on 01/17/2012
from personal experince that voice has all the leverage, and strength has nothing on leverage after all. it takes a lot to even be able to hear others at all, the voice has already undermined them.
pavementends42
Micro-bio is a study, not a blurb.
11:44 AM on 01/17/2012
It takes considerable WILL POWER to listen to anyone other than those feelings--it's like a malicious entity, almost--and come back to reason.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ninetailedfox
banning people.....so childish
04:17 PM on 01/15/2012
the people encouraging school violence are christians. This is why I will never understand gay christians. They work against their own cause, and they seem to hate themselves by being in a religion that from my experience, hates them. There are other religions more accepting than Christianity.
02:37 AM on 01/16/2012
Because that's the religion they believe in. It's not like someone decides to be religious and then chooses a religion. At least not typically. That's just what they believe in. There's nothing in the bible that states homosexuality is a sin. A religion is not it's followers, and just because a loud obnoxious portion of those followers are hateful and discriminatory, doesn't mean that anyone should stop having faith in what they believe. Related video: Why Gays CAN be christians http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LvKBFwWj-gI&list=FLC9PidCnB8XeH7lmjot8Jbw&index=2&feature=plpp_video
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
David Moore
Teacher, German, Math, Pennsylvania
09:11 AM on 01/15/2012
Too many kids suffer needlessly at the hands of bullies. Whether you find support in the "It Gets Better" campaign, or through the outreach of teachers like me, take comfort in knowing that support does exist. As MemphisHopJack stated, his family turned their back on him. Now he has built his own family, but through the support and love of therapists, medication, and others. I applaud MHJ for seeking the help he needed. My question to the author is simply this, if not the "It Gets Better" project that demonstrates with enough love and support from others, then what system would you put in place that shows a message to bullies, to the victims, and to the families of victims? How can we reach kids before they take their own lives?
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
David Groshoff
12:21 AM on 01/16/2012
David,

First, thx for being a teacher, one of the most honored professions, IMHO.

Second, we can reach them by giving them information, advice, etc., which is what I tried to do in this column. Trying to let them know that, no, it may not get better - they may need to go to a shelter or whatever, but stay the heck alive, and then re-assess. "Survive and advance" to borrow a sports cliche.

Third, the fear behind this column is that once kids start seeing that "It Gets Better" kids are succumbing to this horrible problem, then they're going to realize that the campaign was a farce. Great for the Sec. of State or the President or the World Series champs (all either straight or closeted) from making these videos. But when two kids who claim "It Gets Better" die, that's a frightening trend, and I want it to stop.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DanielSC
09:02 AM on 01/15/2012
I do not disagree on many things that you say. But you seem to be alluding that "It Get's Better" was designed as an end-all solution. It is not, it was not. It is simply a part in a very large, complex mechanism. "It Get's Better" is relevant, and not B.S. if it saves just one life. Just because it did not work for everyone in every circumstance gives it no less importance. You in fact, cheapen it by calling it B.S. and using words that really do not fit the situation. Had I access to "It Get's Better" in high school or growing up, I assure you my life would have been much better! I understand you are frustrated and angry, WE ALL ARE! But lashing out (intentionally or not) at something that has virtue in our community is self-destructive and counter intuitive. And please, do not feel that I took nothing of quality away from your article I did… you listed concrete steps of action, something we all need to know! But, I feel you took some of that weight away by shifting blame towards the wrong target.
-Daniel Campbell
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
David Groshoff
12:23 AM on 01/16/2012
Thanks, Daniel, As I mentioned in another post, my fear is that when two kids who claim "It Gets Better" die, that's a frightenin­g trend and a *terrible* message for other kids on the verge or contemplating taking their lives, and I want it to stop.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Robert Cat
Low probability events occur
10:55 PM on 01/16/2012
You're right. It couldn't send a worse message to other kids feeling desperate.

This bullying has absolutely got to be stopped. I don't understand why it's still going on. The kids and teachers all know who is doing the bullying and who is bullied.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
nzchicago
03:24 AM on 01/17/2012
Perhaps others have already said this, but terrible as it is that two kids have died, isn't it possible that many, many others who would have died have been saved through these videos? I don't see it as an either/or situation. It's obviously not the only solution, and no one ever said it was. But it's a worthwhile contribution and has raised a lot of awareness.

I watched Eric James Borges video, and sad to say, he seemed so damaged from what he went through, I'm not surprised that he didn't make it. I sincerely hope his death won't lead other kids to take on board the *message* that they might as well also give up. I see the "It Gets Better" campaign as doing a lot of good, and certainly much more good than harm.
07:54 AM on 01/15/2012
As the parent of a bullied child and a school that blames the child for the bullying, rather than the bullies, I thank you for your work.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
David Groshoff
12:24 AM on 01/16/2012
I will not rest until those schools begin blaming themselves or alternatively become defendants in lawsuits that bankrupt already near-bankrupt municipalities.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Robert Cat
Low probability events occur
10:48 PM on 01/16/2012
Agreed,

These schools need to do more than say they don't tolerate bullying. It is their responsibility to stop it.
photo
MemphisHopJack
Loving life--one dog at a time
11:55 AM on 01/14/2012
I guess that since you do not care for the "It gets Better Campaign," you would have preferred the support system I received as a young gay person coming out. My father disowned me and turned his back on me completely and my mother said she hoped I'd die of AIDS.
So while you surmise most parents would not want to suffer the death of their child, my parents would have welcomed it as to not suffer the humiliation of a "queer" offspring.
While no support system is perfect and it seemed to have failed one young person, I might have wished I could have had something like this.
I too often dealt with suicide, no one to talk to, no internet support. Even to know there are others out there like me would have been helpful. My church told me to rot in hell.
I am alive today, not because of skeptics or "B.S. Callers," but because of medications, therapists and the eventual support of people it took years to find.
01:25 PM on 01/14/2012
I'm sorry :( i know how you feel
photo
MemphisHopJack
Loving life--one dog at a time
03:17 PM on 01/14/2012
Thanks you. To further the story, I proved them all wrong. I am a very happy, adjusted, medical professional that moonlights as a musician in love with my partner of 8 years!
So it does get better and I am proof.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
David Groshoff
08:40 PM on 01/14/2012
I think that you may have misunderstood my column. Having said that, even though I don't know you, I am thankful that you are alive today, and I truly thank you for contributing your thoughts to the dialogue that I'll continue pushing and pressing. Too much is at stake not to do so.
photo
MemphisHopJack
Loving life--one dog at a time
11:10 AM on 01/16/2012
After your comment, I did go back and reread you column. You are correct, I did misunderstand it the first read. Sometimes emotions take you on a path that blinds you to what is right in front of you. I apologize. Keep up the good work and keep writing. Thank you.