BMO Harris Bank has released the results of a survey indicating that 59 percent of homeowners expect their home value to rise over the next year.
Results of this survey could be telling us that there is pent-up demand for homes. Other survey points and some possible conclusions:
59 percent say their home values have risen over the last year.
This is good news if it holds up. Over the last year inventories have dropped, and continuing buying by investors is reported to be the major influencer of prices in the under $300k range. Most studies show nationwide that investors have purchased 30 percent or more of homes. In higher price ranges there has also been price appreciation with competition for shrinking inventory. As rising values bring more homeowners out of underwater territory, will there be an increase in listing inventory, and will demand keep pace? If not, we could be in for a period of seesaw price movement.
29 percent indicated they had to delay or end their home buying plans due to market activity.
The reasons for ending their plans isn't stated, but it's logical to conclude that they have been priced out of the market by recent price movement, low inventory, and competitive buying pressure. This group may be back if the economy and their financial positions strengthen, but if prices continue to rise, they may not gain enough ground to re-enter the market.
29 percent say they have sped up their timeline for buying due to current market activity.
This goes along with another survey response: 59 percent expect interest rates to go up, with 42 percent expecting a small increase and the other 17 percent expecting a large increase. Most of these are people able to afford a home and qualify for a mortgage. However, you can't buy something not for sale. Inventories need to approach more normal levels, or this group may become frustrated non-buyers, or they may add to the bidding competition for available homes.
41 percent aren't being influenced by current market activity.
This group says that current market activity hasn't affected their home buying timeline. I see this group made up largely of "wait and see" buyers. They would like to buy a home, but the housing and mortgage crash makes them cautious, and with interest rates still low, they feel that there is time to be cautious. They're also waiting to see if the economy improves and if they may see increased income to afford a better home.
Last year 21 percent experienced a loss in home value, but only 9 percent believe this will be repeated in the next year.
Optimism seems to be surfacing that the housing market has turned the corner, as the majority of homeowners who moved further into underwater territory last year do not expect that trend to continue in the coming year. For some balance though, 7 percent of those surveyed have given up on buying a home anytime soon due to current market activity. The good news is that 7 percent is very much a minority group.
So, what's coming in the near term future?
Overall these survey responses seem to indicate a growing optimism about the housing market and home prices. From the BMO release: "Housing affordability remains historically very attractive, despite rising home prices and borrowing costs coming off their lows. As a result, there continues to be decent demand for homes, assisted from firming household formation."
That last phrase is really important. Is household formation improving significantly? Even if it is, are these new households near term buyers, or will they add to the increasing demand for rental homes and higher rents? We investors are watching the market closely. Rental investors win either way. If rental demand stays strong, rental return on investment will as well. If the tide turns and buyers flood the market, it could be time to take profits and sell rental homes. Using the 1031 Exchange to defer capital gains and roll into higher priced rental properties could work well.
Survey results cited in this report are from a Pollara survey commissioned by BMO Harris Bank using interviews with an online sample of 2,500 Americans conducted between April 1st and 7th, 2014. The margin of error for a probability sample of 2,500 is ± 1.96%, and 250 is ± 6.2% 19 times out of 20.
Avg. listing price: $1,230,880 Median household income: $110,929 Pct. households $200,000+ income: 30.3% As of 2010, the median income of households in San Carlos was more than double the U.S. median of $51,914. Over 30% of households in San Carlos earned more than $200,000 per year, more than five times the national rate of 5.4%. San Carlos is one of the most expensive housing markets in the San Francisco metropolitan area. Over a twelve month period, ending in October, it had the nation’s highest median home price per square foot at $473 among all homes listed, according to Trulia. In San Francisco, the median age of home inventory was just 45 days as of the third quarter of 2012, according to Realtor.com, lower than in all but seven markets. Read more at 24/7 Wall St.
Avg. listing price: $1,232,167 Median household income: $74,489 Pct. households $200,000+ income: 18.7% Carmel-by-the-Sea, a small coastal city in California, is well-known for its former mayor, actor Clint Eastwood. Currently, the average four-bedroom, two-bathroom home in the city lists for more than four times the nationwide average listing price of $292,152. With nearly 19% of households earning more than $200,000 in 2010, many families and individuals in the small town can afford expensive properties. One house, despite being not much larger than 2,000 square feet, is currently listed for nearly $4.5 million. Read more at 24/7 Wall St.
Avg. listing price: $1,238,208 Median household income: $91,082 Pct. households $200,000+ income: 14.7% Kailua is one of just two cities on this list not located in California. The O’ahu Island city is 12 miles northeast of Honolulu, which had a vacancy rate of 2.7% — better than most areas but considerably worse than the other areas on the list. As of October, the median price per square foot for a home in the Honolulu area was $398, more than in any other metro except for San Francisco. According to Trulia, a 0.75 acres plot of land, which includes 128 feet of beachfront, is currently for sale for $16 million in Kailua. Read more at 24/7 Wall St.
Avg. listing price: $1,312,250 Median household income: $146,069 Pct. households $200,000+ income: 53.0% The average listing price for a four-bedroom home in Rye is more than $1,300,000, or more-than $1 million above the U.S. average. Employees in the often high-paying finance and insurance industries accounted for a 27.8% of employed population in Rye in 2010, well above the 7% average rate nationwide. As of 2010, 53% of households earned more than $200,000 annually, more than any other expensive city, and nearly 10 times the national rate of 5.4%. Additionally, just 1.3% of households lived below the poverty line versus 13.8% nationwide. Among the properties available for sale are a five-bedroom, 7,446 square feet waterfront home for $12.9 million and a 34.2 acre plot of land for $19 million. Read more at 24/7 Wall St.
Avg. listing price: $1,444,214 Median household income: $120,971 Pct. households $200,000+ income: 37.5% Los Gatos is one of several cities near San Jose on this list. Like these cities, Los Gatos likely benefits from the overall boom in the San Jose real estate market, which currently has the lowest vacancy rate of all metro areas surveyed by Trulia at just 1%. Currently, a number of unique properties are available in the city, including an 11,000 square feet property with an eight stall horse barn and a garage that fits 12 cars listed at slightly under $13 million. Also for sale is the former home of Apple Inc.’s co-founder Steve Wozniack. It is currently listed for $4.5 million. Read more at 24/7 Wall St.
Avg. listing price: $1,495,364 Median household income: $120,670 Pct. households $200,000+ income: 39.3% In Palo Alto, 48.7% of adults have a graduate or professional degree — well more than four times the national rate of 10.3%. The city’s proximity to Stanford University, one of the top universities in the nation, may be partly the reason behind the city’s highly educated population. Among the companies headquartered in the city are Hewlett-Packard and Tesla Motors. The city is a large employer of highly skilled employees, as 25.3% of its workers are employed in professional, scientific and management occupations, well above the 10.4% of workers nationwide. Perhaps the most famous resident of Palo Alto is Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg, who Read more at 24/7 Wall St.
Avg. listing price: $1,506,909 Median household income: $107,860 Pct. households $200,000+ income: 34.9% Menlo Park is one of just four cities where the average listing price for a four-bedroom home exceeds $1.5 million. As of 2010, the median income in the city was slightly below $108,000. However, the recent Facebook IPO has been a windfall to the area. In June, real estate listing service Zillow reported that the “proportion of million-dollar listings” in Menlo Park — where Facebook is headquartered — rose by 87% between the company’s IPO filing and its first day as a public company. Among the houses available in Menlo Park are a five-bedroom home with a gym, theater area and wine cellar, which is listed for $4.6 million, and a six-bedroom 5,200 square feet home that’s listed for slightly under $5 million. Read more at 24/7 Wall St.
Avg. listing price: $1,582,434 Median household income: $145,023 Pct. households $200,000+ income: 43.1% Though home prices in the nearby San Jose metro area fell by 25.1% peak-to-trough, Saratoga is yet another example of how the Silicon Valley housing market has recovered. Currently, the median price per square foot for homes in San Jose is $337, according to Trulia, more than all housing markets except San Francisco and Honolulu. Prices for many homes in the area have skyrocketed, according to listings on Zillow. A home currently listed for nearly $10 million last sold for just over $2.1 million in 2000, while a home listed for $14.9 million last sold in 1994 for just over $1 million. As of 2010, 43.1% of Saratoga households earned more than $200,000 per year, while 40.9% of adult residents had a graduate degree, versus 10.3% nationwide. Read more at 24/7 Wall St.
Avg. listing price: $1,658,000 Median household income: $107,007 Pct. households $200,000+ income: 37.6% Outside of Northern California, Newport Beach is the most expensive city to buy a home. Home prices are so high in the city that in 2009 legendary bond investor Bill Gross bought a nine-bedroom, 11,000 square feet home for $23 million — and then tore it down. In 2011, Gross listed the empty plot of land for $26.5 million. Orange County as a whole has a vacancy rate of just 1.5%, among the ten lowest in the nation. Despite a 32.7% drop in home prices from peak to trough during the recession, Orange County’s median price per square foot is $265. This trails only the Honolulu, New York, San Francisco and San Jose metro areas. Read more at 24/7 Wall St.
Avg. listing price: $1,706,688 Median household income: $149,964 Pct. households $200,000+ income: 43.6% In Los Altos, the average four-bedroom, two-bathroom home lists for nearly $50,000 more than any other city in the nation. According to Coldwell Banker, for that price a buyer could purchase 28 similar homes in Redford, Mich., the nation’s cheapest housing market. In Redford, the average home lists for just $60,490. Currently, asking prices in the San Jose metro area have risen 12.7% year-over-year, according to Trulia. This is more than nearly every other metro area in the country. Read more at 24/7 Wall St.
Follow Dean Graziosi on Twitter: www.twitter.com/deangraziosi