iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Dean Obeidallah

GET UPDATES FROM Dean Obeidallah
 

What Are the Names of the People Massacred in Afghanistan?

Posted: 03/20/2012 6:52 pm

We all know the name of Sergeant Robert Bales -- the US soldier accused of killing sixteen civilians in Afghanistan. We know he's 38 years old and married with two children. We've heard him described as "happy-go-lucky," and as a former high school football player who volunteered his time with special needs children.

We know he enlisted shortly after 9/11 and was injured twice in his earlier tours of duty in Iraq, with one injury resulting in the loss of part of his foot. Oddly, we don't know his religion but we can safely assume that he isn't Muslim because if he were, that would be the headline.

We have even heard testimonials about Bales from numerous fellow soldiers and childhood friends, like Marc Edwards, a former NFL player who once played on the New England Patriots, that this attack is out character for the Bales they know.

The media has painted us a detailed portrait of Robert Bales. But do any of us know the name of even one of the sixteen people he has been accused of killing?

You may have heard that nine of the sixteen victims were children and three were women. You may have read descriptions of them as "villagers" and "civilians." But again, do you know the name of even one victim in this horrific massacre?

Probably not. Not that you should because our media has ignored that part of the story.

The US media has treated the sixteen victims as statistics-not human beings. If they were human, we would at least know their names and ages. We might even have heard from their classmates or family members about the kind of people they were- maybe they, too, were "happy-go-lucky"" like Sergeant Bales.

But our media has not told us anything about them. Is it because the victims are Afghans? Maybe it's because they are Muslim? Or is it simply because they aren't American?

In the ten plus years of the war in Afghanistan we essentially only see the Afghans in our media when they are protesting, denouncing the US after some of their people have been accidentally killed or when our politicians are debating their fate. When is the last time you watched a story about the human side of the Afghan people?

Some will undoubtedly ask: Why should we care about them? They will make blanket statements that the Afghans, and Muslims in general, don't care about our culture or lives. They will then cite a few isolated incidents from over the past ten years to support their conclusion.

I don't subscribe to the view that isolated incidents sum up an entire people, but even if it did, shouldn't we be better? Shouldn't we set a positive example for others to emulate?

We need to hear about the people killed in this massacre such as the Wazir family who lost eleven relatives and the Jan family who lost four. We need to hear about the hopes and dreams that the parents held for the eleven murdered children. We need to know if the children played soccer or were good students in school.

Maybe even hear from their neighbors who might tell us that those killed were "good people" who were simply trying to survive in a challenging time. Lets hear something - anything - about these people who committed no sin other than being in the wrong place at the wrong time when their lives were so violently taken.

Our media needs to tell us about these sixteen people - these human beings - who were killed because they deserve the same respect and sympathy that we would have for our fellow Americans.

 

Follow Dean Obeidallah on Twitter: www.twitter.com/Deanofcomedy

 
 
  • Comments
  • 200
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (6 total)
04:18 AM on 03/24/2012
When is the last time you watched a story about the human side of the Afghan people?

It was this afternoon actually. Watch.

http://mediastorm.com/publication/a-darkness-visible-afghanistan
05:53 PM on 03/23/2012
This law:Stand your Ground, needs to be investigated and see if other police and police stations have ignored the civil rights denied to the dead, as well as the law targeted to specific persons it is designed to jail. The Police have so much to answer to when they do such deadly, sloppy police work and cause the lives of so many people in their care, protected by taxpayers dollars and sent on paid vacations on those same dollars, when they are being investigated.
06:37 AM on 03/23/2012
The dead:

Mohamed Dawood son of Abdullah
Khudaydad son of Mohamed Juma
Nazar Mohamed
Payendo
Robeena
Shatarina daughter of Sultan Mohamed
Zahra daughter of Abdul Hamid
Nazia daughter of Dost Mohamed
Masooma daughter of Mohamed Wazir
Farida daughter of Mohamed Wazir
Palwasha daughter of Mohamed Wazir
Nabia daughter of Mohamed Wazir
Esmatullah daughter of Mohamed Wazir
Faizullah son of Mohamed Wazir
Essa Mohamed son of Mohamed Hussain
Akhtar Mohamed son of Murrad Ali

The wounded:

Haji Mohamed Naim son of Haji Sakhawat
Mohamed Sediq son of Mohamed Naim
Parween
Rafiullah
Zardana
Zulheja

http://blogs.aljazeera.com/asia/2012/03/19/no-one-asked-their-names
03:02 AM on 03/22/2012
Although NPR may have covered this angle, I think the point being made is about mainstream media's lack of reporting.....therefore not reaching the masses. Only a selective population reaches out for additional reporting from NPR.
I wonder if we delved into the psychology of each aggressor (even if from "the other side") in a similar fashion, what we could learn from that. Could we come to understand what led them to such a point of destructiveness and finally move forward? Right now we're on a vicious cycle to nowhere on what we call "War on Terror".
12:01 AM on 03/22/2012
i thought you were going to tell me the names of the victims. but no; just another story
06:30 AM on 03/22/2012
Julia, even the author, who is yearning to find out the names, couldn't get to know the names because of biased media, because of media's flood of empathy for each and every American and a pile of apathy for the poor creatures from the animal kingdom called Afghanistan. Right?
10:10 PM on 03/21/2012
This is truth. Thank you for reporting on this.
05:10 PM on 03/23/2012
Thank you, Mr. Obeidallah, but you're only halfway there.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
The Knocker
a mind is a terrible thing to waste
09:22 PM on 03/21/2012
Of course announcing the names of the victims who were massacred by a trained terrorist by the U.S army, especially the children, would have immediately humanize them and perhaps delegitimize the occupation of Afghanistan.
Moreover, it would have been a distraction for some in the media to bring to the forefront Robert Bales past background of a hardworking and a patriotic American, who has serve his country with honor and was him selves a victim of a war mismanaged by politician.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TheDarklady
04:02 AM on 03/22/2012
... you mean other than the joining the military to dodge a conviction for having conned a million bucks out of an elderly couple, of course...
photo
hot lava
soft rocks
08:58 PM on 03/21/2012
A farmer or rancher will tell his kids they can't give names to the stock animals. They know that if you give them names, they become an identifiable and real and you can't slaughter them
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
seerickson
06:39 PM on 03/21/2012
Thanks enormously for this post. This has bugged me also. I see that NPR did a piece on it and I will look it up.
05:19 PM on 03/23/2012
This a one of many stories on this subject but most of them come up short, when it comes to bringing the names of the innocent victims to the attention of the American public.
05:40 PM on 03/21/2012
while a murder spree such as this may not occur every day, the naming of innocent victims in american wars and "military" or "cia" actions which happen daily in afghanistan, pakistan, sudan, yemen, and no doubt other countries would require time from every nightly news report and space in every daily newspaper. the million iraqi dead from the wrongful invasion of a country that had nothing to do with 9/11. perhaps the sleeping american public would realize the crimes and evil done in our name by an out of control pentagon and cia. responsibility would have to be taken, hearings held at the congressional level.

we americans might understand the way most of the world views american foreign policy. we might come to understand why american troops are targeted where-ever they are stationed over-seas.

"they hate us for our freedoms" what a crock. as congress passes laws with remarkable cross party cooperation that take our freedoms away, the islamic world hates us for the indiscriminate manner we take the lives of both complete innocents and all nearby "collateral" damage from "militant" targets of drones, american trained security forces, american special forces, american army, and marines. maybe if we and the world knew the true tally of death it could be stopped just as we stopped viet-nam after a decade of lies.
09:17 PM on 03/21/2012
Thank you for an eloquent and insightful comment. We know whom our media serve. It is not humanity. It is not even the American people. It is the narrow interests that promote and profit from the evils of war.
05:24 PM on 03/23/2012
So maybe it's time we started to run separate pages with the names of all these innocent children and adults, harmed, maimed, murdered and left to be ignored by the U.S. Military and the Allies, who are as responsible as the American Troops and their leaders, the U.S. Congress, U. S. Presidents, that share blame with the rest of the American public that goes about their lives and can't get themselves to demand an end to invasions, until we fit our messy, domestic laws that are costing our U.S. Citizens, their lives each day in the entire USA and their territories.
photo
hot lava
soft rocks
04:26 PM on 03/21/2012
Farmers and ranchers will always tell their family members to not give the stock animals names. Once you've given a calf or a lamb a name, it becomes extremely difficult to kill it.
photo
Ice9
If money is speech, then speech is never free
04:19 PM on 03/21/2012
American broadcast networks and cable news don't cover it unless it happens in America or to Americans. BBC World Service does a great job of covering the globe, but we don't even try, you have to seek out international news through other means.

It's like living in a bubble or should I say on the Raft of the Medusa. (Google it. It didn't involve Americans, so possibly it didn't happen.)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
skiddie76
Living long enough to be a burden to my children.
02:57 PM on 03/21/2012
You're listening to the wrong news then. NPR did a long piece on the victims of the shooting. They talked to family members and neighbors and gave personal information about each of the victims.
05:34 PM on 03/23/2012
You got to love NRP!! And to think the GOP wants to shut it down or take away funding, so it doesn't reach the seniors and people in rural places.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
F Sz
Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidenc
02:52 PM on 03/21/2012
It has been pointed out over and over again in the past, how US media handles any news regarding the war and Middle East, compared to non-American media. And the research weren't done by commenters on facebook, but by journalists and anaylists. But I bet, even that document was censored and not shown to Americans, perhaps if someone finds it on youtube or some back alley internet site.
Let me say this much: If you don't know this or you think it's ridiculous to think there is no bias in American news, that doesn't mean you aren't lead by your nose.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
dancingstu
Christian, liberal lawyer
02:34 PM on 03/21/2012
"Our media needs to tell us about these sixteen people - these human beings - who were killed because they deserve the same respect and sympathy that we would have for our fellow Americans." While I agree with your point, I would also wish that the media would tell us about every single one of the people killed in the "War on Terror", both civilians and soldiers. But putting a human face on the statistics would have brought on calls for an end to this stupid war before the politicians wanted it to end.