More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Desmond Tutu

GET UPDATES FROM Desmond Tutu
 

It's Time for Iran to Live Up to Its Commitment to Justice and Compassion

Posted: 05/ 8/11 06:21 PM ET

Shane Bauer and Josh Fattal have endured more than 21 months of uncertainty and isolation for no just reason and I urge the Iranian authorities to allow them finally to return home.

There is no evidence to support the charges against them. The world will be watching the actions of the court on May 11 and judge the proceedings on whether Iran lives up to its commitment to justice and compassion. I trust that Shane and Josh will be judged on the facts alone, which can only result in their immediate release.

Shane and Josh are global citizens, with a record of humanitarian engagement, respect for all cultures and nations, and a dedication to a peaceful and sustainable world. It serves no purpose, and is morally unacceptable, to continue to detain them and subject their families to needless suffering and anxiety -- solely on the basis of their nationality.

 
 
 
 
 
  • Comments
  • 106
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4  Next ›  Last »  (4 total)
11:35 AM on 05/18/2011
They might not be spies, but these 3 people exercised poor judgement and put one another in extreme risks by hiking in a war zone... Talk of being in the wrong place at the wrong time... I'm sure they've learned a valuable lesson and will use this experience planning their next hiking trip...
05:22 AM on 05/17/2011
"Shane Bauer and Josh Fattal have endured more than 21 months of uncertainty and isolation for no just reason.."

Really... "no just reason"? How would you know? The first sentence of this article just flat out says "PAID IN FULL" Come on Mr. Tutu, not you too! How much are the M0sSaD or C1A paying you?

"I trust that Shane and Josh will be judged on the facts alone, which can only result in their immediate release."

I really doubt they will be released if they get convicted on even something as small as trespassing because Iran wants to make an example of potential external elements that could have started the protests. Who knows how many "humanitarians" like the Bauer and Fattal DID get through the border and caused civil unrest.

.... and then the nail in the coffin.... a sentence that completely discredits his opinions from now on....

"to continue to detain them and subject their families to needless suffering and anxiety -- solely on the basis of their nationality"

solely on the basis of their NATIONALITY?? Neoconservatives have said less offensive things.

In conclusion, Desmond Tutu please turn in your Nobel Peace Prize for a copy of the latest National Enquirer.
09:55 AM on 05/16/2011
Yeah, because the United States always supplies evidence to support charges against individuals...
08:42 PM on 05/15/2011
I am glad that this message is coming from Bishop Tutu. It may actually mean something to someone in Iran. Probably not, but maybe. Nothing the USA says or, for that matter, nothing any USA citizen says, will have any credibility or persuasive force with the Iranian government.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
naschkatze
A free man creates himself.
05:49 PM on 05/15/2011
How good you are to make such an appeal, Bishop Tutu. May your influence succeed where threats of violence do not.
04:35 PM on 05/15/2011
Iran has a commitment to justice and compassion?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
naschkatze
A free man creates himself.
05:51 PM on 05/15/2011
It's religion, Islam, has a commitment to justice and compassion. I'm sure that is what Bishop Tutu is referring to.
08:40 PM on 05/15/2011
Many countries espouse a commitment to justice and compassion without actually living up their ideals and, indeed, failing their ideals by a wide margin. There is a lot of evidence that Iran is one of those countries, even discounting for the information obtained through the lens of Western media. Likewise, there is also a lot of evidence that the USA is also one of those countries that doesn't walk its own talk. As just one example: the remaining prisoners at Guantanamo.
thankgodimanatheist8
Think for your self
10:16 PM on 05/15/2011
F&F

We are number one in per capita incarceration and many independent people believe that we incarcerate African Americans way more than Americans of European decent for similar crimes.
photo
BurtonDesque
Fear a Blank Planet
04:34 PM on 05/15/2011
When has the current government of Iran ever been committed to justice and compassion?
06:21 PM on 05/15/2011
Iran is waiting for the US to take the first step.
07:33 PM on 05/15/2011
Ha. No steps at all 21 months? Surely Pres. Obama has sent several letters on the affair, like he did earlier to Khamenei which Khamenei laughed at publicly..as reported here at HuffPost no less.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Chris Herz
01:50 PM on 05/15/2011
The USA has held several Iranian diplomats prisoner in Afghanistan for years. Quite lawlessly, if that means anything to you. Iran has decided to retaliate, equally lawlessly, until some exchange can be arranged. That is called diplomatic reciprocity.
01:05 PM on 05/15/2011
True, but how about the US releasing at least ten innocent Iranians in her custody? Many of them were kidnapped overseas by the US allies.  
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
hu.man
transformation through communication
12:42 PM on 05/15/2011
The powers of the be in Tehran will not let go of the only card in their hand that amounts to anything. For Iranians, these two are nothing but bargaining chips. The rest (trial, charges, etc) is just a charade. The government wants something substantial in return for letting these guys go. If Obama admin is serious about bringing these folks home, they have to offer the clergy in Iran some concession of value to them.

It really doesn't have to be this way, but when there is no dialog and both sides have entrenched positions then simple matters like hikers wondering where they shouldn't becomes an international incident.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mccord82
f/2.8, 1/400 sec, ISO 100, 35mm, RAW
11:57 AM on 05/15/2011
Maybe they can escape when World War III starts.
I'm not saying that to be funny, I honestly think its going to happen. Until then I wish them inner peace and justice.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
EdRea
11:03 AM on 05/15/2011
And yet, the young mens' ordeal is still prolonged --

Iran Delays Trial Of US Men Accused Of Spying
May 11, 2011 7:30 PM

MINNEAPOLIS (AP) — Two Americans who have been held in Iran for nearly two years on espionage charges were denied their day in court Wednesday when Iranian authorities delayed their trial without explanation, prolonging the agonizing uncertainty for families who have been lobbying for their release.

Masoud Shafiei, the Iranian attorney for 28-year-olds Shane Bauer and Josh Fattal, told The Associated Press that the two were not brought into court Wednesday for the resumption of their trial, as had been planned. He said Iranian officials gave no immediate explanation. Read more at CBSMinnesota.COM

http://minnesota.cbslocal.com/2011/05/11/detained-hiker-trial-postponed-in-iran/

Archbishop Tutu makes a great point:
They are there to serve all of humanity.
They are peace workers.

If Iran is trying to make a parallel between these two -- whom they abducted from outside their own border -- and the CIA's clumsy detention of possible terrorist suspects, it fails. CIA, the Taliban and al Quaeda all live and die by the sword. Shane Bauer and Josh Fattal are blacksmiths, turning swords into tools for humanity. Shane and Josh, hammer me out a giant dove, would you please? Your plight will not be for naught.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:42 AM on 05/15/2011
Shane Bauer and Josh Fattal have endured more than 21 months of uncertainty and isolation for no just reason and I urge the Iranian authorities to allow them finally to return home.-- Bishop Tutu
==============================
It appears that the change from Bishop Tutu to Desmond Tutu is a simple but profound indicator.

While the whole of Africa is still suffering from occupation, thief, and conflict, the new “Desmond Tutu” publicly supported the violent, bloody, and bias western aggression against Africa's Libya.

Now, with all the issues facing poor and starving Africans, Desmond Tutu has taken up the cause for two of those that suspiciously entered into known, dangerous territory. Will Amanda Knox be next?

The new Desmond Tutu has taken a sharp, bias, and unholy conservative turn, I wonder if he is receiving funding from the old American conservative machine?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:32 PM on 05/15/2011
Look, it is you who have turned on Tutu, not Tutu that turned on you. You decided what is important and what position he should take without considering that, as a person, he may have a variety of ideas on justice. Clearly its you who misunderstood him and his beliefs when you took them as proof of your own ideology. Regardless, no one is going to agree with you 100% and you can't act like they are the unholy devil when they don't.
10:44 PM on 05/15/2011
Not sure I could have said it better, maxben, thanks for saving me a couple of minutes.
05:38 AM on 05/17/2011
Tutu clearly has taken a stand.... His major point has been their innocence.... his mistake for jumping to conclusions
photo
checkmoot
We have met the enemy and he is us.
09:31 AM on 05/15/2011
At least they have been charged with a crime and have been allowed access to family and lawyers. I'll bet some of the people we have snatched off the street, all over the world, put in Guantanamo or secret prisons and tortured, some of whom we have held for years brfore admitting they had done nothing wrong and releasing them, would be happy to change places with these folks.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:00 AM on 05/15/2011
Yeah...I have a hard time finding " Compassion and Justice" in Islamic fundementalism...this is about dogma and clerics..its not about rationalism.