iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Dr. Boyce Watkins

GET UPDATES FROM Dr. Boyce Watkins
 

Yes Barack, You ARE The President of Black America

Posted: 08/08/2012 6:42 pm

During a recent interview with Black Enterprise, President Barack Obama was asked about some of the criticism he's received for allegedly not doing enough to support black businesses.Ā  In response to the question, the president had this to say:

"My general view has been consistent throughout, which is that I want all businesses to succeed. I want all Americans to have opportunity. I'm not the president of black America. I'm the president of the United States of America, but the programs that we have put in place have been directed at those folks who are least able to get financing through conventional means, who have been in the past locked out of opportunities that were available to everybody. So, I'll put my track record up against anybody in terms of us putting in place broad-based programs that ultimately had a huge benefit for African American businesses."

The president's remarks reflect a consistent perception that there are members of the African American community who expect too much of the Obama Administration.Ā The portrayal is that they are demanding that Obama re-paint the White House black and put a picture of Malcolm X on the front door.Ā The president is absolutely correct that he has to be sure to serve all of his constituents, not just the black ones.Ā That point has been duly noted and consistently reiterated by both the Obama Administration and all of its surrogates in the African American community.

The concern about the president's remarks is that he has actually forgotten one undeniable truth:Ā  Mr. Obama, you are the president of black America, in addition to being the president of white America, Jewish America, Gay/Lesbian America and all the other groups that came together to form the melting pot that broke their backs to put you into office.Ā The "I am not just here for black folks" defense certainly excludes you from having to spend a disproportionate amount of time looking out for black interests, but it does not exclude you from the responsibility to treat the black community with the same degree of legitimacy as every other group that is being consistently patronized by the White House.

If I own a restaurant and my own family comes through the door, I can't simply say "I'm not just here to serve you" and then leave them without any food.Ā This is especially true if my relatives loaned me 20% of the money I needed to buy the restaurant in the first place.Ā Instead, I should make sure they are taken care of like the other patrons, and then tend to the rest of my job.Ā By refusing to meet with the Congressional Black Caucus for years at a time, and speaking specifically to almost none of the issues plaguing black America (i.e. mass incarceration, urban violence and unemployment inequality), it's easy to argue that the Obama Administration has gone too far in taking the black vote for granted.

We've all seen this before: A teacher has her child in class and treats her worse than the other children, or the football coach who mistreats and humiliates his son in front of the other athletes.Ā  All of us are tempted to substitute preferential treatment for abusive treatment.Ā And when one considers the fact that black quality of life has worsened over the last four years, while simultaneously improving for whites, it's hard not to argue that the Obama administration has pandered to conservative (and racist) white Americans by showing how far it can go in ignoring African American interests.

So yes, Mr. President, you are the president of black America.Ā The same inconvenience being hoisted onto your administration when we ask for targeted (not coincidental) action is no less than the inconvenience being thrust onto the black community when people are asked to take off work to show up to the polls. One favor deserves another, and it is disappointing to see a presidency predicated on the idea that black Americans are their employees.

Anyone who compares transcripts of Obama speeches to black Americans vs. speeches to other constituencies notices that the tone tends to become a bit condescending, non-committal and even disrespectful when black people are being addressed (as we were once told to "stop complaining, take off our bedroom slippers and put on our marching boots" - something that would never be said to gay people or women's groups). Ā If anyone can prove me wrong on that point, please do so.

The modified rhetoric is not by accident, since the white guys working with Obama in the White House know that black people can be swayed more easily by style over substance.Ā  Also, it's easy to interpret standard black political advocacy as stereotypical whining and complaining of welfare recipients (we are the only group with a collection of media people telling all Obama critics to be quiet).Ā  Even Mitt Romney leaned on stereotypes when he said that NAACP members booed him because they wanted "free stuff."Ā  Ā But when white folks show up at the White House door and demand action for the issues that matter most to them, they are simply utilizing their democratic voice.Ā That, my friends, is White Supremacy 101, and you don't have to be a racist to use it to your advantage.

If the respect shown to black Americans does not match that which is shown to the gay community, Hispanic community and other demographics, then the Obama Administration has fallen woefully short in its duty to America. The president has stood strong for marriage equality for gay Americans, so I'm sure he'll understand those of us who stand up for political equality for African Americans.Ā If the action and rhetoric is not equally respectful across the board, then it is entirely unacceptable.Ā There are no two ways about it.

The saddest thing about the experience of the black political orphans in America is that when you ask them why they support the Obama administration, a large majority of them can only say "they're better than the Republicans." That's like a wife saying "I'll never divorce my husband because he's better than the man who used to beat me." Perhaps a more meaningful endorsement from his wife could be "I won't ever leave my husband because I am absolutely sure he loves me." Ā Even the most ardent Obama supporter can't make such a claim.

The very same broken, two party political system that the Obama Administration complains about is the one that's keeping them in power. The black vote is held hostage with fear of a Republican presidency, not hope for a better future. Rather than being able to point to any evidence that black quality of life has improved over the last four years,Ā they simply win the black vote by default.Ā There is not much to celebrate about that and more should be expected from any politician who asks us for so much.

Dr. Boyce Watkins is a professor at Syracuse University and founder of the Your Black World Coalition. To have Dr. Boyce commentary delivered to your email, please click here.

 

 

Follow Dr. Boyce Watkins on Twitter: www.twitter.com/DrBoyceWatkins1

FOLLOW BLACK VOICES
During a recent interview with Black Enterprise, President Barack Obama was asked about some of the criticism he's received for allegedly not doing enough to support black businesses.Ā  In response to...
During a recent interview with Black Enterprise, President Barack Obama was asked about some of the criticism he's received for allegedly not doing enough to support black businesses.Ā  In response to...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 293
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Highlights
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (5 total)
12:19 PM on 10/03/2012
I really want to thank those who had relevant comments against this authors assertions. I have frequently disagreed with points he has made but wasn't gifted with the words to express it. Thank you for making your statements; i agree wholeheartedly.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:22 PM on 08/13/2012
So do people who are lambasting this author, see any legitimacy in anything he has written? If you don't then perhaps you are naive and need to take off the Obama rose colored glasses. The examples that Dr. Watkins provides of the teacher treating her child in a class differently (in a negative sense) or the coach being harder on his son on the team, is appropriate and on point, in light of Obama's response. It is something we as blacks do around other cultures quite frequently - in our jobs and in social settings. We want to show 'others' that we are not like "them", or simply want validation from whites and other non-black groups. Think about examples you have seen in your own life (people acting as if they don't listen to a certain genre of music, engage in certain activity that might be readily associated with blacks, or on a more profound level, people taking the opposite view than their true view on social issue affecting blacks). As Dr. Watkins alludes, it is simply pandering to whites (or another race) to either distance ourselves from the "whole" or simply to curry favor. The article is well written. Sometimes the truth cuts deep.
photo
LogicMeetsHumor
Don't touch my food!!!
12:53 PM on 08/13/2012
Holy sh*t...

It's like I wandered into the land of Cries, Moans & "We're Owed" Speeches...
11:58 PM on 08/12/2012
I have told black people time and time again, that Barack Obama does not relate to they way that the majority of us had to grow up black and in America. He grew up in a number of other countries, the midwest, and then in Chicago (a northern city) in his early adult years. He was raised by his white family. While he may have witnessed some of their struggles, he probably could not point to any of their struggles to find work and/or being poor etc as being in direct relation to their race or history in this country. The average black person that was raised in this country has had had to witness their parents struggle partly because of their race, history, prejudice, and disparities. We have a different racial sensibility than he does. I would say a potentiated one at that. He was still a light-skinned mixed ethnicity child at that. ANd just because we call him black, who is to say that he like so many of us doesn't have a negative self-concept surrounding his blackness. Can anyone say Tiger Woods. Just cuz he married a brown girl don't mean nothin. Michelle helped his butt out. ANd he couldn't get to where he is today if he was married to a white or other race woman. Black women (or black people in general) really wouldn't appreciate that and white people would be fearful of it and resent it.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
charlesamerica
06:23 PM on 08/12/2012
Let understand that this is hardball and white have fared better under these condition and that there are blacks who are doing OK we have not insured the weaker of us can survive another for year of this gridlock.

Black have watch the White House like it is a reality show and convincing themselves that Obama can pull a rabbit out of his hat, but unless he has both Houses of Congress the Tea Party is not allowing anythings to help black recover. Understand that there are actual still about 20 plus million unemployed America as they only count 14 million because they have stop looking for jobs.

So we are going to have at this rate somewhere around 54% of all black lose their homes, so what to come out of those households of bitter parent and children. Your black children are in danger because who do they come in contact with.

What is Obama policies going forward as Chicago is worst now than before Obama was elected. The black male HS graduation rate is under 35% and it the second largest black populated area, and its Obama backyard!
12:56 PM on 08/13/2012
The better question is: What are black people doing to ensure that they keep their homes? What are black people doing to ensure that the cyclic "bitter parent and suffering child" syndrome which exists in the inner city is repaired? What are black people doing to ensure that the people on the streets whom their children come in contact with won't be harmful to their children? What are black people doing to ensure that the black male HS graduation rate increases? This is where I have an issue with the views that most Black people have. These things exist because black people in the inner city have succumbed to a generational sense of desperation, fear, and hopelessness. Using your own words, they expect Barack to "pull a rabbit out of his hat" and somehow save the black community. Barack should be empowerment, not a crutch. Most of the issues you mentioned, WE have the power to change. These inner city issues you mentioned are not something he caused or can fix. Black parents need to get out of their houses and take their kids to school. Black people in the inner city need to be more present in their communities, and in their child's lives. Black people need to ensure that their children know that education comes first. Barack can't change this type of stuff. We must.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
charlesamerica
06:04 PM on 08/12/2012
Obama got an obligation as the first black because he is black and there is not getting around it. Regardless of whether or not he says he was trying to pass certain thing that would have created better situations for blacks, his downfall is that his term had a part one and part two, where in part one he could have passed programs to help blacks yet it was his decision not to pursue them but instead go with the pretty girl to porn (health care) because history he taught would judge his better.

However it was Health Care that case the 2010 loss of the Congressional House as the Tea Party put it on him and now even if he does win again I predict that he a lame duck from day one because the Republicans as now have the ability to block everything they want too.

This was high stakes gambling and I believe we have lost because there has been to much black wealth loss and Obama has done nothing to recover proven crimes that have occurred, and now will never get the support needed in a second term to correct what he should have done in the very first two years. His tries have been failure and close is only good in horseshoes.
photo
littlebrowngirl
Brevity is the soul of wit - Shakespeare
05:22 PM on 08/12/2012
If clinton said he was not just the president of white American, would that be a cause for controversy?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
charlesamerica
08:54 PM on 08/12/2012
Clinton did not say this nor did any other President make this comment so it cannot be applied even for a hypothetical conversation. Obama is black or part and must understand his dual obligation and nobody said it was going to be easy!
04:25 PM on 08/12/2012
The way I see it, politics is not this warm and fuzzy, Ive helped you, so therefore you owe me image that we want it to be. Its brutal, its nasty and promises are left at the white house door. (Maybe Im slightly cynical). The fact of the matter is this, there is strength in numbers and a unified voice. African Americans may have the numbers to back up their their mission, but they lack a unified voice. There are so many different issues that have been touted as important, that the President wouldn't even know where to begin if he wanted. The lack of proper organizing around a specific issue is what removes African American concerns from the top of the priority list -- it would be difficult and dare I say, impossible to please everyone. And though many of us don't want to accept it, African Americans will vote for Obama for reasons beyond what he does for them politically. The majority of American Americans have solidified their support and their vote for the President, so can you blame Obama if he sees no reason to waste political resources on a population that will vote regardless of what does or doesn't do for them? Given the warm fuzzy feeling people have about Obama, I can understand how that can be upsetting, but when viewed from a political lens, his actions make logical sense.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
charlesamerica
02:21 PM on 08/12/2012
Dr. Watkins, what I am asking is that you help me get an audience with the black community and Secretary Donovan and let discuss how it is that black homeowners are being foreclosed upon when it is a fact of Ginnie Mae Mortgage Backed Securities program the the Notes of our loans are signed in Blank and relinquish to Ginnie Mae with all financial interest in the loans. Now as with UCC 3 Ginnie Mae does own the Notes but not with the ability to foreclosed because they did not purchase the loans.

I just happen to be the only black that was allowed to work in a bank as a Prime/FHA?VA mortgage loan officer as the other blacks hired were working in the subprime divisions or broker shops as it gave America the impression that black were well represented in the Prime mortgage area.

I have been doing is researching how it was the Ginnie Mae pool works exactly, and have found that Ginnie Mae has absolutely no legal standing to foreclose and cannot request that a servicer foreclose because as a non-lender who also does not purchase the loan does not have a valid servicing agreement to foreclose or even have been accepting the monthly payment paid by the homeowners.

Hundred of billions of dollars of black folks have been stolen by our own Government by way of Ginnie Mae!
photo
ginadeoliveira2008
Seen a shooting star tonight and I thought of you
01:30 PM on 08/12/2012
Dr Watkins, sorry to say that-- you don't seem prepared to have a black President. It's still early for that in history if we are to believe your arguments.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ggranny
02:24 PM on 08/11/2012
Dr. Watkins, I am a former subcriber to your site "By Any Means Neccesary." Your negative view of the president was more than I wanted to read coming from a black person. I was always reminded of the "crawfish analogy" that so many people of all races are familiar with in regards to the unity and/or the lack of unity when it comes to African Americans. The Congressional Black Cauacus started out being Hillary supporters and did not warm up to the President intil AFTER the American people elected him as their candidate...and just like you, the CBC appear to have been ticked off every since then. Hillary raced-baited Obama while CBC members stood with her. Now that he is elected...instead of you, CBC out there encouraging voters to vote you throw out this kind of rhetoric as if the other CHOICE will be better for the same people you, West, Smiley and others claim to be concerned about...I say hogwash...how much are you getting PAID? The damage you could do is much worst that what the likes of Palin, Limbaugh, Romney, Ryan and others have dove done. Shame on you and others like you! Obama/Biden 2012!
02:10 AM on 08/13/2012
I couldn't agree with your premise more...what Dr. Watkins and his minions have done and will continue to do is mislead, misinformation and mistake themselves as the voice for Black America...when nothing could be further from the truth.
It's always easy to point fingers at others when you've failed to live up to your own responsibilities...and Dr. Watkins has been seeking this audience for quite some time...sad, but true.
Instead of challenging Black Americans to live up to the "shining example" set forth by this nations first president of color...and take some personal responsibilities for a change..these "self-annointeds" deliberately, without any remorse or hesitation continue to direct the unsuspecting to hate, despise and blame everyone else for their failures...and President Obama is the easy target...from the left & the right.

We were once a better people and nation than this...and if we don't make the "change" necessary now to set our course in the right direction while President Obama is still president. ..November 7th will be too late.

We failed the president, the country and ourselves by doing this exact same thing for the midterms...and we've seen the devastating results...now if we blow this general. election ...be prepared to live with the lifetime of dire and detrimental results...because you'll deserve it.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ggranny
06:58 AM on 08/13/2012
I wholeheartedly agree with you! Let's get to work! Obama/Biden 2012!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:49 AM on 08/13/2012
There is no "voice of Black America" and certainly Dr. Watkins is not aiming for that position. However, if we pay attention of what he actually wrote and his right to write it, then the matter becomes more clear. The notion of who Dr. Watkins speaks for is a distraction unworthy of further comment. If what he says does not relate to you, does not make it wrong or the end of the word. It just doesn't fit into your world view.
photo
Hershel Daniels Junior
I am President of Friends of the African Union htt
04:10 AM on 08/11/2012
The substance shown by what he has done for the 38 million African Americans [Blacks] by saving the USA's financial, manufacturing and public civil infrastructure. We had just arrived in mass positions in the later two and both where headed to serious job losses without his action.

At the same time, we as a black people had no current unified platform when we had the power during his first two years. I grew up in Shaker Heights and it was given that "never again' meant US foreign policy by America's 6 million Jewish American was meant support for Israel was number one on any agenda hence AIPAC's power. Where was the Black leaderships energy - siding with Latino's on immigration was a big issue. Even the failed trillion dollar War on Drugs didn't attract much attention to the Black political leadership when they had the power much let alone them shaping a conversation on reparations till this year when it has no chance in this Congress.

We attended the 09 CBC as part of the National Fairness and Growth Campaign an pointed out the facts of the situation. The CBC Chairwoman was kind enough to give our spokesman the floor during the plenary session and he stopped the house with the recitation of our condition. The result? No change is policy and or use of the power they then held as chairpersons of congressional committees ie to set the committee agenda and use of the power of a congressional subpena.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
FloridaLAW
This Day, This Moment, Right Now!
08:39 AM on 08/12/2012
You seem to conveniently exclude the president when you describe "black leadership". How can you do that and expect to have any credibility at all? I agree that Black Americans don't really have a choice regarding our presidential vote. Either you vote for Obama, who has done some marginal things that indirectly effect the black community, or you vote for Romney, who we all know would do everything that he can to help rich Whites at the expense of minorities and the poor.

Having said that, it still doesn't mean that we shouldn't hold the president accountable. Ask about economic conditions in the black community and his response is that he's not the president of black America. Meanwhile, he has had no problem going to bat for gay and hispanic interests while he's been in office, especially the former. Has he ever told the gay community that he's not the gay president? Has he ever told them to stop whining and take off their bedroom slippers? No, these are words of contempt that he saves exclusively for the black community because he takes our vote for granted.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:23 PM on 08/12/2012
Vote Romney and rid your self of the illusion. Remind yourself of any other constituency that the President has declared himself "not the President of". You've got something in common with them.
12:30 PM on 08/13/2012
How exactly are YOU holding the President accountable? Please point me to the ACTIONS you have taken to insure that President Obama addresses the NEEDS of the Black Community. Where is the comprehensive Black Agenda that you supported. Explain to us how the President ignored your agenda in favor for the gay agenda?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
stonemann
To argue with an idiot, can mistake you for one.
04:03 AM on 08/11/2012
I think we can both agree if the infrastructure bill, sitting on the Speaker’s desk since last August, the thirty job bills that have been blocked, single payer or the public option had been passed, the Clinton tax rate had gone in effect on the top earners, and incentivizing companies from shipping jobs overseas had all been done, our communities would be a hell of a lot better, don't you think? Congressional Republicans have blocked all of this and Mitch McConnell told us why. Though no President is perfect, including this one, you assail him over the real problem. On top of that, he’s got his own racism to deal with, the insane number of filibusters, code words like communists, Kenyan and Muslim, birther theories and segregationists throw- backs that are seething because he's in the White House. Then, there's the explosion of militias...and the daily death threats. There’s nothing wrong with being critical of the President, I am, but let’s put most of the blame where it belongs.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ggranny
02:26 PM on 08/11/2012
Thanks...great reply!
05:07 PM on 08/12/2012
Thank you for an excellent post, stonemann. It really irks me when I hear people like this writer who are supposedly intelligent conveniently forget that the President himself is being racially profiled (yes, he is) and disrespected by the Repubs. He essentially has to work harder than any US president in recent history to get anything passed in congress where the default response is "No" to anything the President brings forward.
09:31 PM on 08/10/2012
Great article!
08:34 PM on 08/10/2012
This article is, sadly, a reflection of the mindset that many older African Americans have. A great deal of African Americans voted for Barack Obama under the impression that he would be some great "Black Messiah", a great Black hope who would champion the cause of African Americans only and bring us to some cultural promised land. A powerful black example of Noblesse oblige. Now that none of that has come to pass, so many African Americans are angry with Barack and are blaming him for not being the Black Messiah they'd hoped for. Barack is right. He is NOT the president of Black America. He is the president of the United States of America. He is leader of the entire country, and as such his focus must be on the entire populace, not limited to one race. When he was sworn into office, he accepted the task of leading and helping ALL of America. The question of what he will do to help black businesses is inherently flawed in that is supposes that his focus is black businesses. As it relates to entrepreneurial development assistance, Obama's focus should be on the entire American diaspora. Black Americans, especially older Black Americans, are upset that Barack has not become the great black hope they wanted. Black Americans, need to realize he is not the Black messiah. He is the president. And as the leader in the Oval Office, he reflects not one cultural community, but the entire American populace.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
FloridaLAW
This Day, This Moment, Right Now!
08:56 AM on 08/12/2012
The entire premise of your argument is based on false assumptions. Noone is claiming that Barack Obama should solve ALL of the problems in the black community or bring us to some "cultural promised land". When the LGBT community has pressured the Pres. to respond to their agenda he has responded. Did anyone accuse gay Americans of expecting him to be the gay president? The exact same can be said for Latinos. Jews expwect him to pay special attention to Israel's needs. Look, anytime a community gives 90% of their vote to get someone elected they have a right to hold that person accountable for delivering results. So when someone points to 50% unemployment in some black areas and says Mr president what are you going to do about that, it's a totally and completely legitimate question to ask. Being president of all Americans means you don't have the luxury of ignoring the black community. We didn't elect a black messiah, we elected someone we thought understood the needs of our communirty.
01:18 PM on 08/12/2012
Incorrect. My "assumptions are based on perceptions which I have witnessed first hand in a number of African American communities. As an African American man, I have been privy to decision process which guided most of my friends/families and have sweeten this mirrored online and in travels. Comparing the LGBT community or Jewish community voting for Barack to the African American community voting for himleads to a disconnect. Barack has little in common with the Jewish our LGBT communities. He is not Jewish, nor is he gay. He does however identify as African American, the media identifies his as black, and the black community identifies him as black (despite his biracial heritage). The black community in my observations, clung to this and voted for him under the impression that he would work primarily on their behalf. This perception which is at the root of the current hissy fit, if incorrect. He should not focus merely on one community simply because a majority of that community voted for him. Rather that community should have voted got him in the hopes he would with for the entire American community, not merely one racial community.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:27 PM on 08/12/2012
"Being president of all Americans means you don't have the luxury of ignoring the black community. We didn't elect a black messiah, we elected someone we thought understood the needs of our communirty."

I thought that this should appear again, it is as concise and down to earth in regard to this matter as one will find. Having realized this is a call to turn up at the polls, everyone, and focus on your local reps at every level. Whoever wins this election, your strength is going to have to come from the bottom up.
photo
ginadeoliveira2008
Seen a shooting star tonight and I thought of you
01:27 PM on 08/12/2012
A serene and wise voice. How do African Americans expect a black President to behave in accordance with his tittle if not by being the President of the whole nation? You have a white America, a black America, a Jewish America, an Italian America, , how many Presidents will you need? The very definition of a melting pot is a pot, mixed, together.