iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Mehmet Oz, M.D.

GET UPDATES FROM Mehmet Oz, M.D.
 

The Consequence Of Sweetness: There's No Such Thing As 'Just A Little Sugar'

Posted: 02/12/10 08:39 AM ET

I want to introduce you to a brave woman at the hospital where I work. Her name is Laureen. At 34 years old, she was an active nurse -- vibrant, full of life and a volunteer EMT. But now, 10 years later, she spends three days a week tethered to a dialysis machine to rid her blood of impurities that her failed kidneys can no longer process. She has lost parts of both her legs. Her body is slowly turning on itself and each and every day revolves around managing the disease that ravages and scrapes away at her insides: diabetes.

Laureen was on "The Oprah Winfrey Show" last Thursday, courageously sharing her story. Even though it's very personal, Laureen told her story because she doesn't want others to go through what she has gone through. And there are almost 60 million potential diabetics who can watch and benefit from her experience -- though it doesn't have to be this way. One of the most painful things about her situation is that it could have been prevented. That's right -- Laureen's disease trajectory could have been slowed, stopped or even reversed through lifestyle and diet choices.

As a surgeon I have operated on thousands of people whose hearts were destroyed by diabetes - about 25 percent of all the patients I see are diabetic. Most of them could have prevented their fate.

But as the tragedy of this news sinks in, the alarm bells are ringing. Here are the statistics: there are 24 million diabetics in this country and about six million of them don't even know it yet. These are people whose blood sugar is over 125. They will most likely find out when other complications arise such as impaired kidney function, vision problems and, of course, heart disease. Even scarier is that there are 57 million pre-diabetics who are at a crucial fork in the road. Their blood sugar is between 100 and 125 and they stand at a juncture where some simple lifestyle changes and mindful diet choices will lengthen their lives and save them a world of suffering. Nearly half of Hispanic and African American children born this decade are projected to get diabetes. The CDC estimates one third of all Americans will develop diabetes and live 15 years less while losing immeasurable quality of life.

No public health problem compares in scale.

Diabetes will bankrupt our healthcare budget if left unchecked. It costs us $175 billion now to treat this killer and its complications, and that's expected to double in 25 years. Despite the best devised policy plans to manage the economics of healthcare, all solutions will fail unless we address the root causes and engage in widespread awareness and prevention. It starts with education -- you must know what this disease is, who is at risk and how to prevent it.

There are two types of diabetes. Type 1 is also called juvenile diabetes and you are born with it. It can't be reversed but it can be managed. Only 10 percent of diabetics are Type 1.

Type 2 is the culprit in 90 percent of those 24 million cases and 57 million pre diabetics in danger of slipping into full blown disease.

Type 2 takes root when fat stored in the abdomen -- belly fat called omentum -- poisons the pancreas and causes it to stop producing insulin or the insulin in your blood cannot deliver glucose into your cells. Without insulin you cannot process sugar and without glucose your cells have no power supply. Belly fat is a huge problem in America, with 60 percent of our population overweight. Any casual stroll down the street will reveal the prevalence of omentum in our society. The reason for the drastic increase is a perfect storm of poor diet and sedentary lifestyle. Our ancestors usually had little food and had to work very hard to catch or kill what food they could. As a result our bodies are designed to survive scarcity and famine. Now with food available virtually unrestricted our biology is outpaced by this abundance, and overeating creates disease. It happened incredibly fast.

Why is diabetes so destructive? Quite simply in both Type 1 and 2 your body can't metabolize sugar, leaving it to float in your bloodstream. Sugar in your blood is like shards of glass scraping the inner lining of your arteries. The scrapes heal with scar tissue and cause blockages. Smaller blood vessels in your feet close completely and cut off circulation, resulting in amputation as the tissue dies and becomes infected. The coronary arteries scar and cause heart attacks and stroke. These sugar shards damage kidneys so severely they shrivel and die and patents often wind up on dialysis.

Here's the catch: The symptoms are reversible.

Right now the average American eats 140 pounds of sugar per year, which is 40 pounds more than when Oprah and I were born 50 years ago. Sugar is hidden all kinds of places that you least expect -- condiments such as salad dressing and ketchup, peanut butter, and of course juice and soda. To be competitive and make things taste better, food companies have added more and more sugar. The intention wasn't to hurt anyone, it was just to get you to like their food. We have slipped into a cultural acceptance of "a little sugar" - a little in our coffee, a little on our cereal, and it all adds up. The consequence of all that sweetness is obesity and rampant diabetes.

But back to the good news: 90 percent of diabetes is preventable and the symptoms are reversible. Let's go through a few risk factors and action steps:

First, the warning signs are constant thirst, frequency in urination, feeling tired, frequent infections, tingling in the toes, and vision problems. If you have any of these symptoms, see your doctor.

Risk factors are a big belly which blocks insulin, a sedentary lifestyle and a family history. When we refer to a "big belly" we mean one that measures more than half your height. If you are five foot 10 inches, (70 inches) your waist should measure no more than 35 inches at your belly button. Another rule of thumb is a woman of average height should weigh less than 150 pounds for optimum health.

Can we change our biology or our genes? No. But we can nudge it in the right direction. Avoid "white" foods -- those with enriched flours, pasta, obvious sugar and rich starches like potatoes. Avoid high fructose corn syrup, which is found in everything from condiments to bread. You can just read the label to see what's in a food item. Exercise - a lot! Start by walking and set a goal of 30 minutes three times a week of vigorous walking, then move gradually into an exercise program.

Also, know your numbers. Speak with your physician about your risk factors and a screening - just about anyone can get tested for free. This is one of the most important decisions you can make for your health and your children's health. You owe it to yourself and your loved ones. It's not just a little sugar!

 

Follow Mehmet Oz, M.D. on Twitter: www.twitter.com/droz.com

I want to introduce you to a brave woman at the hospital where I work. Her name is Laureen. At 34 years old, she was an active nurse -- vibrant, full of life and a volunteer EMT. But now, 10 years ...
I want to introduce you to a brave woman at the hospital where I work. Her name is Laureen. At 34 years old, she was an active nurse -- vibrant, full of life and a volunteer EMT. But now, 10 years ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 574
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (10 total)
08:26 AM on 02/18/2010
Waaaayyyy late to the party on this but Dr. Oz did I really just see that you wrote:

"Type 1 is also called juvenile diabetes and you are born with it".

Are you kidding me? Why are you spreading such nonsense. You may have a genetic predisposition to developing type 1 diabetes but you are not 'born with it'. How can those of us who have children diagnosed with type 1 diabetes expect others to understand when we have doctors out there spreading such bull. Ugh.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Nicole Dixson
02:10 AM on 02/17/2010
My father died of kidney failure from Type 2 diabetes last year at the age of 76. My father did not fit the profile of a Type 2 diabetic. He stood 5'8" and weighed at various points 145-160 pounds. I stand 5'2" and weigh 109 pounds yet I was told by UCLA Medical Center that diabetes appeared to be in my future and was advised not to gain a lot of weight and eat only complex carbs, no simple carbs. This was while undergoing testing to be a kidney donor for my sister. What advice is there for me? I am doing all the right things, I exercise 5-7 hours a week and eat pretty well. A lot of the advice I see is always for a person who is obese. What does a person who has no weight to lose do?
08:21 AM on 02/16/2010
I don't get the whole sugar shards theory. Unless you're dumping crystalline cane sugar into your bloodstream (bypassing saliva, stomach acids and the rest of the digestive system) it makes no sense .
How could sugar after ingestion retain a crystalline shape and start cutting and scraping your arterial walls? This is a novel theory and we should be skeptical of it.

Most sugar (esp. the sugar we ingest unawares) is from corn syrup anyway.
What is of interest there is that heavy corn syrup use came on the scene at the time the diabetes epidemic began.
Also, I have read that corn syrup contains mercury as a byproduct of refinement. Mercury is prob not good for the organs esp the pancreas.

We now over vaccinate our newborns and small children (alot of harmful ingredients in vaccines), and we have our main sweetener manufactured (in a dirty way) out of corn. Start the inquiry there, because the introduction of heavy vaccination and heavy corn syrup added to foods arose in the same time frame. Let's say around the first Bush admin (1988)

What is a more sensible approach to consuming sugar, 'white' foods' and other simple carbs is to add some fat to the mix, like butter, cream or oil, to slow down the foods conversion into glucose.

Slow it down and you won't get the spikes and crashes, and your pancreas won't over generate insulin and become stressed.
09:08 AM on 02/15/2010
What really needs to be looked at for kids is the school lunches. They are EXTREMELY HIGH in fat, calories and CARBOHYDRATES! A lot of kids are developing type 2 diabetes, something that was UNHEARD of years ago. Take a good look at our schools. The lunches are high carb, high calorie and high fat, most of its processed food. Then they take out recess. MOST elementary schools have cut WAY down, or even cut it out, on recess because they just don't have the time in the day to get all the teaching that is required of them My daughter has Type 1 diabetes (not related to food, or laziness, its an autoimmune disease, completely different than type 2 except for the fact that it effects the blood sugar.) Because we have to count carbs and match her insulin with the amount of carbs she eats I've very aware of how many carbs are in the school lunches. an AVERAGE lunch from school is 90 carbs, for ONE MEAL. That was over her average for the ENTIRE day. When she started school I expected her insulin needs to go down as she'd be more active in school, WRONG. They went WAY up. Her dr. said that this is typical because they sit way longer at school than at home. Her patients that have Type 2 usually gain wait and have a hard time at the beginning of school because they aren't as active.
09:10 AM on 02/15/2010
Cont. from above... Type 2 is on the rise in youth. But so is Type 1.. they don't know why.. they don't know the exact cause. Years ago most kids that were diagnosed with type 1 were in their teens, early 20s.. Now little ones, like my daughter, are being diagnosed. She was 2.5 at diagnoses. She was in a 'clump' of kids that were all diagnosed within a month span. MOST of those kids were little, 2-8.. unheard of.. This is why they think it was an illness about 18month prior to showing the signs and getting sick, that the autoimmune process started.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Infostream
04:44 AM on 02/15/2010
The shell game of blaming one kind of calorie source is stupid. When I was a kid we had bacon and eggs with the yolk, toast with real butter, bologna sandwiches with mayo for lunch and whole milk, and lots of red meat and potatoes for dinner, lots of Pepsi with cane sugar and there was no obesity epidemic. And if you asked someone why people get fat they'd say "they eat too much and don't exercise enough". Nowadays everything is soooo complicated, one day its sugar, the next it's fat, the next it's carbs then chinese food, then italian food, plus a million hyped excuses about genes and thyroid etc. It's a bunch of BS so Dr Phil and Oz and Oprah can get ratings and sell books and people can stay in denial that THEY EAT TOO MUCH AND DON'T EXERCISE ENOUGH.
07:31 AM on 02/15/2010
Take your fingers out of your ears and stop singing lalalalalala
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
tanx8
What is this fancy box?
02:12 AM on 02/15/2010
Everything i eat is laden with sugar, absolutely everything. I don't drink water, i only drink chocolate milk, soda, and juice 7 times a day for the last 11 years (im 21). I eat far too much chocolate and sweets each day. I've never had any cavaties in my teeth, but i've had high cholesterol for 5 years.

But I weigh 95 pounds, does that mean i can still develop type 2 diabetes and heart disease (i thought only obese people suffer from it)?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gavrielle
Empty... Empty... Empty...
07:24 AM on 02/15/2010
YES! My brother in law, who's always been thin as a rail recently developed type 2. He was a sugar junkie, like you. It may take years, but you are setting yourself up for some serious problems. Some people can eat as much as they like and never gain weight, but that doesn't mean they can eat whatever they like and not have any consequences.
07:32 AM on 02/15/2010
Yes
11:28 PM on 02/14/2010
That's why a vegetarian diet is hard to beat. Try "The gorilla chef" for some great recipes.
11:15 PM on 02/14/2010
We are trying to solve a problem by looking at the problem, we need to be creative. Trying to shame those with diatetes into action by showing them the consequences of the disease is futile because you are dealing with ADDICTION. And the addiction is socially acceptable and its food. You see, if an addict quits cocaine or alcohol because they know it is destructive they never need to use ever again. But food you will always need on a daily basis. Food is the new narcotic for our feeling of worth, not being enough, lack of self, not being heard, lonliness, lack of purpose, emptiness etc

When a people in society are fulfilled, living a life of purpose and being present we do not gorge ourself to the point of full because one is not filling an emptiness that is never filled with food but it certainly helps to mask it. Food is our source of comfort and a great distraction of what you should do , could do but don't in life. It also helps us swallow our words down to our stomachs of what we could say, should say but don't.

The problem of diabetes runs a lot deeper than just food and exercise .....and we all know it -but we don't know how to treat emptiness ....we need to acknowledge their pain and help people to feel more fulfilled and purposeful. Then food because a source of nutrition rather than a source to self medicate.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Nelson Montana
Artist, Author, Composer
09:47 PM on 02/14/2010
But doc, you know that diabetes is more a matter of obesity, lack of exercise and genetics. It's like high blood pressure -- it isn't caused by a lot of salt, it's just that a lot of salt is bad if you have it. Same with sugar.

All food turns to glucose and starchy carbs which are the highest glycemic
turn the fastest. And that includes baked potatos, pasta and rice. Yes, even brown rice.

Bottom line: it's the same message we've been hearing for the last century. Everything in moderation. A life without an occasional slice of pizz or a cookie is not worth living. And I seriously doubt you'll live that much longer without them as long as the rest of your diet and lifestyle is a healthy one.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gavrielle
Empty... Empty... Empty...
09:29 PM on 02/14/2010
I'd be more inclined to respect Dr. Oz if he came out in favor of the low carb diet that could prevent this massacre from continuing. Yes, a slice of whole wheat bread is better for you than a slice of white bread, but the end result is the same. You might just as well have eaten a tablespoon of sugar, because the carbohydrates in the wheat bread are the same as in the white and they store up as saturated fat in the belly the exact same way.

The high carb/low fat diet touted by the health food industry is what's been killing us, because it's based on bad science with little or no proof that it actually works. A government panel in the late 70's came out in favor of it and by the 1980s obesity and type 2 diabetes started to increase. Now it's at epidemic proportions and spreading around the world.

In the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition: http://www.ajcn.org/cgi/content/abstract/ajcn.2009.27725v1)

Results: During 5–23 y of follow-up of 347,747 subjects, 11,006 developed CHD or stroke. Intake of saturated fat was not associated with an increased risk of CHD, stroke, or CVD.

Conclusions: A meta-analysis of prospective epidemiologic studies showed that there is no significant evidence for concluding that dietary saturated fat is associated with an increased risk of CHD or CVD.
10:03 PM on 02/14/2010
Absolutely no one ever became obese or developed diabetes from following the high carb/low fat diet unless they were doing so in an unhealthy manner & not exercising enought. The only mistake of the nutritional advice of those times was in failing to point out that some carbs are healthier than others, that calorie consumption must be balanced with calories burned, and that exercise is an essential component of good health. A healthy high carb/low fat lifestyle includes plenty of exercise, high-fiber grains, a variety of fruits & veggies, healthy fats & lean proteins. This can never make you obese if you are not consuming more calories in a day than you burn. And if you are not obese the likelihood of developing type 2 diabetes is drastically reduced. Most people who have gotten fat, & I know this from experience, did so because they overindulged in stuff like fast food burgers, pizza, doughnuts, candy & snack chips on a regular basis & lived a sedentary lifestyle. When I eat healthy & exercise, I have no weight problem. There has also been an increase of lots of other bad things since the 70's, such as drug use, crime, too much TV, overshopping, overspending. All are indicative of our increasing overindulgence in all things pleasurable & addictive as a society. I believe all of this is a symptom of our craving to fill our emotional & spiritual emptiness.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gavrielle
Empty... Empty... Empty...
11:43 PM on 02/14/2010
Moderation in all things is important. So is exercise. But you can't mandate that people exercise. Therefore, a better diet for those who are mostly sedentary is high fat/low carb. Health food nuts and exercise junkies have their own set of troubles - and no guarantee that they won't keel over from a stroke or heart attack, either.
03:40 AM on 02/15/2010
Whole wheat bread (complex carbohydrates) is in no way just the same as starchy foods like white bread. The end result may be the same (glucose), but the process of breaking down complex carbohydrates means a much slower release of glucose uptake into the blood stream (lower blood-sugar levels = less desensitizing of cells to glucose = lower risk of becoming pre-diabetic). It also takes more energy (calories) to break down the complex carbohydrates. Nothing is wrong with carbohydrates. It's the TYPE of carbs that you intake which is key. The low carb freaks won't eat a healthy pear because of the natural sugars in it or a healthy bowl of oatmeal. I understand what your getting at by the low carbs for avoiding diabetes, and of course staying away from starches and soda and cookies/deserts all the time is going to keep blood sugar levels from spiking like crazy, but classing all carbs (even whole grains for goodness sake) as bad I can't agree with.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gavrielle
Empty... Empty... Empty...
07:18 AM on 02/15/2010
Of course you can eat pears and whole grains in small amounts when low carbing. Only those who cannot tolerate ANY spike in their blood sugar levels have problems with these types foods. But to try to convince people that a high fat, low carb diet will kill them, when there is no proof - just the opposite in fact - is unconscionable. A low carb diet, done properly, has been proven to lower blood pressure, lower triglycerides and lower cholesterol. See this study published last month in the Archives of Internal Medicine (http://archinte.ama-assn.org/cgi/content/short/170/2/136?home). But you won't find most doctors willing to discuss alternatives to the health food industry's favorite hobby horse. Why? Because they make too much money off the illnesses created by the low fat, high carb diet. Not to mention that sports medicine is a booming business.

The point is, that refusing to give people an alternative that might better suit their lifestyle isn't fair. You cannot mandate exercise, and for some people it isn't even an option. And if regular exercise isn't an option, some would say lower your caloric intake. How low can you go before you make yourself sick?

Also, in case you were replacing carbs after exercising, here's an article based on a new study that says this might not be good for you: http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/booster_shots/2010/01/skimping-on-carbs-after-a-workout-may-have-health-benefits.html.
08:47 PM on 02/14/2010
Well, I know that I will be pilloried for bringing this up - but, there are no consequences that will keep people from the bad habits that lead to these diseases, in fact, once they do get sick and start costing the "system" untold billions of dollars, they are completely and totally taken care of. So they enjoy themselves to the max all the way to the freebies at the end of the line. It's a system that completely robs them of ever achieving their innate potentials in any way shape or form. The only challenge is getting to all the free medical care and benefits before they drop dead. Liberalism at its most perverse. All the lecturing in the world won't stop them from slamming down the goodies and the smokes and the booze and the drugs, now, every chance they can get. They are looking for every excuse to prove it's "not their fault." Which is only the case about 5% of the time.
01:04 AM on 02/15/2010
Actually 'not their fault' would be much higher, at least in 10% of the cases of diabetes, which are Type 1 diabetics. Its an autoimmune disease, it has NOTHING to do with food, exercise, junk food etc.. the ONLY thing it has in common with type 2 is the fact that it effects the blood sugar. You can't prevent, stop or cure type 1 diabetes. In MOST cases people with type 2 diabetes its 'not their fault' either. THIS is what is wrong with this country.. when everyone hears the word 'diabetes' they think of fat, unhealthy people that are couch potatos who do nothing but eat and sleep. Do you know how many times I've been asked what I fed my then 2 YEAR OLD to make her develop diabetes? do you know how many dirty looks, and nasty comments I've gotten when people here my daughter has diabetes? Do you know how many people blame ME, MY HUSBAND and MY DAUGHTER for her diabetes? She has a LIFETIME of correcting people on a DAILY BASIS that she did NOT cause her disease. Infact, an ILLNESS when she was 12 months old CAUSED her diabetes. It started the autoimmune process, the one that attacked her beta cells (those are the ones that produce insulin) causing them to slowly stop producing insulin. If someone was diagnosed with cancer, would you say it was there fault? or how about someone that has lupus, or asthma? did these people cause their diseased?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Moonspirit48
Happy to be alive ...
01:47 AM on 02/16/2010
I am so sorry that you and your family have to suffer with this disease and that your little girl will suffer most of all. I hope you do not follow the American Diabetes Assn. diet as they are clearly locked in with big pharma to keep you sick. My prayers are with you.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Moonspirit48
Happy to be alive ...
01:45 AM on 02/16/2010
There are a lot of people who are not getting free health care with their diabetes or any other disease. And losing 15 years on average of quality life because of diabetes sure doesn't seem like people want to get this just so they can rob the system before they drop dead. What distorted, twisted thinking!!
07:56 PM on 02/14/2010
Yes obesity & type 2 diabetes are an epidemic in this country, yes this is alarming, yes we need to do something about it by improving our diets & increasing our exercise. But it is also not necessary to go to extremes. And demonizing any one food or ingredient, including sugar, is going to extremes. People can successfully eat a healthy diet that includes sugar, in moderation. Type 2 diabetes is usually the result of obesity, the likelihood increases if you have a family history. If you eat a balanced, healthy diet that includes plenty of fruits & vegetables and get plenty of exercise, you won't be obese or even overweight & you most likely will never develop type 2 diabetes. Including small amounts of sugar in your daily diet & occasionally indulging in treats made from sugar is not going to cause diabetes in most otherwise healthy people.
09:45 PM on 02/14/2010
He didn't say eat zero sugar. Unfortunately, without really hitting the nail on the head, Dr. Oz is addressing the absolute ubiquity of sugar and corn syrup (especially HFCS) in most food products found in your typical grocery store. People can, as you say, "successfully eat a healthy diet that includes sugar in moderation" - if they avoid most of the foods that fill conventional grocery store shelves and cases. Dr. Oz sidesteps the issue with a free pass to the food conglomerates: "The intention wasn't to hurt anyone, it was just to get you to like their food." No sir, their intention was to profit, regardless of the cost. It may not be malicious, but it sure isn't noble.
11:23 PM on 02/14/2010
I was going by the title, the assertion that "There's no such thing as just a little sugar". Of course there is. The "hidden sugar" in such things as ketchup & non-sugary breakfast cereals, etc. is unlikely to lead to diabetes or obesity in an of itself. If one routinely consumes them as part of a high-calorie diet that exceeds what your body is burning in a day & you are not exercising, that's where the problems come in.
07:53 PM on 02/14/2010
Are you all awared that Anthem Blue Cross is outsourcing to overseas non-US licensed doctors to make coverage decisions on requested medical services??
07:41 PM on 02/14/2010
Keep yelling, doc. One of the horrors I have of universal care despite my deep support of it --- is the obesity levels of Americans. You can see it in the entertainment articles where 'fat' is the new norm and posters snark on anyone who actually looks fit.

I was diagnosed with diabetes last year.... it was a bit of d'oh moment. But I've gone from 230lbs to 195lbs. Adjusted to a low-carb diet, dropped my cola habit, and exercise regularly. My blood numbers all read 'healthy-normal' now with some help from metformin and my life-style changes.

The "d'oh" is that I could have avoided the diabetes by doing all that in the first place.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
happycat
No bio needed. My cuteness speaks for itself.
08:08 PM on 02/14/2010
Excellent comment. Please keep on doing what you are doing to stay on the right track.
05:09 PM on 02/14/2010
Thanks for the reminder, Dr. Oz. I would like to say, however, that education is not the only thing we need to help reverse this trend. We also need money.

You mention that half the Hispanic and African-American kids born this decade will probably get diabetes. That frames the problem better than anything. This is a disease that poor and minorities (frequently poor) get. They don't have the budgets for healthy food - their choices are usually pre-packaged and full of HFC, highly processed starches and fat. Fresh produce, whole grains and meats are more expensive, and sometimes even hard to come by in poorer neighborhoods. Add to that the problem of sedentary latchkey children who aren't allowed outside to play while their parents aren't home.

I wish you and other doctors would talk to Congress about this problem. Even if we had Universal Health Care, the diabetes problem you're discussing won't be solved, because no one wants to fund the preventative measures.

Rather than the White House and Congress letting the lobbyists for big pharm and insurance companies control the discussion of health care, why not let lobbyists for the grocery stores and food producers have a say?
09:11 PM on 02/14/2010
As a child growing up in Appalachia, we ate oatmeal (which I still love) beans, rice, eggs, canned milk and apples and occasional oranges. Lot of greens in season which we "put up" for the winter. All available everywhere, just buy the fruit in season and in bulk. Problem solved. We did not demand that our keepers and overseerers "fund" us. Teach people what they need and the rest is up to them.
Recently, I was at an hotel breakfast buffet where we observed a young AA girl fill a cereal bowl to the brim with bacon 3 times and wash it all down with a couple of giant colas. Yet the choices for fresh healthly food at this event were endless. Her mother ate the same thing, except she added sausage. It goes without saying that they were both already obese. Think they'll be needing your tax dollars real soon?
10:41 PM on 02/14/2010
I grew up in the South, myself. My grandparents grew up on farms with chickens, gardens, and sometimes a milk cow. I inherited not the chickens and milk cow, but the gardening and ability to cook and store food for myself. Part of what you are pointing out could be helped with education as Dr. Oz advocates; part of it though, needs more.

Many people don't know how to cook anymore, except for judging how long to run the microwave. Cooking equipment can cost a bit - not a ton, but when your budget is so small to begin with, a pressure cooker is essentially out of the question. People in lower income brackets live from day to day or week to week; there is not the option to buy in bulk.

cont...
10:41 PM on 02/14/2010
...

I think there has been much knowledge lost between the time you and I were growing up and what is happening now. Teaching people how to make meals out of dried beans, oatmeal, ham hocks and so forth will help, but accessibility is necessary, too. These foods need to be available. An example of what I'm talking about is the problem in large urban areas - "Detroit – a city of some 830,000 people – has no major grocery store chain within its boundaries...92 percent of food stamp recipients purchase their grocers from a liquor store or a gas station or a pharmacy." (http://www.cbsnews.com/blogs/2009/09/03/couricandco/entry5286352.shtml?tag=contentMain;contentBody) Certainly, Detroit can be seen as an extreme example, to some degree, but, there are plenty of other poor urban areas with similar problems - high rent & high crime for grocery stores and money & transportation difficulties for residents.
01:09 AM on 02/15/2010
Take a look at the school lunch programs. They are EXTREMELY high in carbs. My daughter went from eating 65-80 carbs a day (she should have been having more, especially since she's underweight, but not that big of a carb person) to 150 carbs on average. the only difference? SCHOOL LUNCHES!
11:23 AM on 02/15/2010
That's a great point. What they serve in school lunches is generally thought of as junk food in my family. And when you consider that's the healthiest meal of the day for some kids, that's pretty bad.