EDITION: U.S.
 
CONNECT    

Dr. Walter Crinnion

GET UPDATES FROM Dr. Walter Crinnion
 

Are Organic Foods Healthier?

Posted: 6/21/10

In two of my previous blogs on organic foods I reviewed the published studies that have shown that organically-grown food has more vitamins, minerals and health-promoting 'phytonutrients', as well as far fewer pesticides than commercially grown foods. So, if one chooses what foods to eat, at least partly on the level of nutrients they provide, as well as their potential for toxicity (or lack thereof), then organic foods would already be a good choice. But, is there evidence that these foods really help us to be healthier?

A recent study in the medical journal Pediatrics reported that children who have higher levels of organophosphate pesticides in their urine had higher rates of attention-deficit-hyperactivity-disorder higher rates of attention-deficit-hyperactivity-disorder (ADHD). For one of the pesticides, those children who had high levels of it had almost twice the rate of ADHD as those without any of that pesticide in their urine. The studies in Seattle that I reviewed in my earlier blogs showed that children who ate organic foods had virtually undetectable levels of organophosphate pesticides in their urine. So, maybe ADHD is not a deficiency of Ritalin, but an overload of commonly found food-borne pesticides!

However, until they do a study that compares children eating organic foods with those that eat commercial foods to find out if the organic kids have less of a problem with ADHD, we will not know for sure -- but it seems possible from my perspective.

With the previously reviewed information we know that organic foods have higher levels of the healthy "phytonutrients" in foods. These compounds typically have very high anti-oxidant activity, which is very important for maintaining health and preventing illness. In fact, oxidative damage is thought to be the major cause of the physical changes that we call "aging." So, having higher levels of antioxidants in our foods would be considered a wonderful potential health benefit. In fact, a few studies have already been done that also show that consumers of organic foods have higher levels of these healthy compounds in their bodies.

There are also implied health benefits for organic foods when it comes to cancer prevention. One study measured the ability of vegetables to suppress the cancer-causing genetic damage of various environmental toxins, including benzo(a)pyrene (BaP) which is the main cancer-causing chemical in cigarette smoke and auto exhaust. They found that the organic vegetables were much more active than their conventional counterparts in suppressing the toxicity of this nasty chemical . In another laboratory study, organic strawberries were able to block the rapid growth of colon and breast cancer cells. For both of these cancer cell lines, the extracts of the organic berries were much more potent at reducing cancer cell proliferation than the conventional strawberries.

Only one article to date has been published that actually studied whether an organic diet made a difference in health outcomes with humans. These researchers measured whether or not diets with varying amounts of organic foods made any difference in the rate of allergies for infants. They found that children who consumed organic diets had fewer problems with eczema. When they looked more closely at the types of organic foods, they found that children consuming organic dairy had a 36 percent reduction in their risk of having this allergic skin disorder. With the rates of eczema and other allergic disorders rising, this is a very important finding.

So, while the studies are limited, they are positive in showing that organic foods provide both implied, as well as, actual health benefits. These benefits alone may save the consumer far more money than is spent on the cost of buying organic foods.

 
 
 

Follow Dr. Walter Crinnion on Twitter: www.twitter.com/wcrinnion

In two of my previous blogs on organic foods I reviewed the published studies that have shown that organically-grown food has more vitamins, minerals and health-promoting 'phytonutrients', as well as ...
In two of my previous blogs on organic foods I reviewed the published studies that have shown that organically-grown food has more vitamins, minerals and health-promoting 'phytonutrients', as well as ...
 
  • Comments
  • 86
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
02:01 PM on 06/28/2010
I believe in the idea of healthy food grown naturally but I do feel that today - Organic - is more of a marketing technique and I don't trust that what I'm getting is truely organic - check out this article http://gre­enearthgui­de.info/is­-organic-f­ood-a-wast­e-of-money­/
09:24 PM on 06/24/2010
Dr. Crinnion,

To what extent to you think the "benefit" of eating organic produce can be attributed to marginally higher levels of "nutrients­", and what percent of this "benefit" can be attributed to the lack of pesticides­. A measured difference in nutrients does not imply a difference in nutrients absorbed by the body. However, the presence versus the absence of chemical pesticides DOES equate to pesticide exposure.

Thanks for your honest answer (with references­).

-N0N
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
smilinggreenmom
02:11 PM on 06/23/2010
We love organic goodies!! We even have our own garden now and it is awesome :)
07:28 AM on 06/22/2010
Monsanto sues small farmers out of business and pollutes their fields with hybrid seeds
10:03 PM on 06/22/2010
They are, they cost many people in my family their land and their livelihood­s. Now they pollute the groundwate­r of the communitie­s around that land, and I agree with this author because kids around these Monsanto farms have ADHD everywhere you look.
04:06 AM on 06/23/2010
Gotta make a stand at some point bro. While i certainly would NOT condone splashing an old bottle of chlordane on one of their attorney reps that accost merchants/­farmers, sadly i would understand it.

Speaking of which, what do you think of chlordane. Would like your thouhts. I think it got a bad rap, but what do i know?
07:27 AM on 06/22/2010
Monsanto bullies little farmers
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
07:00 PM on 06/21/2010
As far as organic overall goes, what are we looking for from food? I think this needs to be the question. Longer life? Eternal life? Quality of life? Even trying to get the average person to eat any fresh vegetable whether it's organic or not, would benefit them. I want numbers in terms of longevity and quality of life before I fully accept that organic produce is REALLY that much better for you. BTW, I do understand it all conceptual­ly, that's not that issue, I'm looking for the actual significan­t benefits of me buying a $2 apple over a 50 cent apple.... can someone give me numbers?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
StopCensoringMe
Aghast at the stupidity and bigotry
11:00 PM on 06/21/2010
Fair question but...

When your last day on Earth arrives, there is an excellent chance that, at that moment, you will want to offer any price for just one more day. So, how much is one more day worth to you?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:21 PM on 06/22/2010
That's meant to say, "I'm not trying to be a smart ass"... though maybe I am and that was a Freudian slip? No, I'm really not...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:31 PM on 06/21/2010
Well I guess the debate continues but common sense tells me that food laced with pesticides can't be good for you so I'll keep growing my own. Not having my produce shipped from half way across the country is also appealing.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
satanlite
If ur neibor wtchs Fox Nws wtch ur neibor
05:24 PM on 06/21/2010
Grocery store "organic produce" is the biggest scam grocers have ever perpetrate­d on the American consumer.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
06:55 PM on 06/21/2010
I think I might agree
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cabinetmaniac
Cabinetmaker, Organic Grower, Progressive Humanist
05:09 PM on 06/21/2010
I am an organic gardener and am well aware of the benefits of local organic produce.

I am not as impressed with the grocery store variety of "organics" though.

Grow your own or buy local is best.

:-]
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
crom14
09:03 PM on 06/21/2010
I did last year and had Rats come into my yard! What do you do about that?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
happycat
No bio needed. My cuteness speaks for itself.
09:16 PM on 06/21/2010
Good question.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
cabinetmaniac
Cabinetmaker, Organic Grower, Progressive Humanist
07:32 AM on 06/22/2010
I suppose that depends on how many rats.

We have "Norway" rats around here but they don't cause too much damage.

I have a dog which alerts me when he smells rats.

Snakes (non-venom­ous) seem to like my yard and help keep the rodents down.

I use a trap, like a large mousetrap, with bacon as bait to catch rats. I will catch a (breeding?­) pair of them every 2 or 3 months so it isn't like I am overrun.

I don't use poisons but I know people who do and they work well to kill the rats. I suspect the poison probably kills more than just rats though.

:-]
04:41 PM on 06/21/2010
I found this an interestin­g article that was published. http://new­s.bbc.co.u­k/2/hi/hea­lth/817448­2.stm

Here is the abstract to the actual paper via pubmed http://www­.ncbi.nlm.­nih.gov/pu­bmed/20463­045?dopt=A­bstract

CONCLUSION­: From a systematic review of the currently available published literature­, evidence is lacking for nutrition-­related health effects that result from the consumptio­n of organicall­y produced foodstuffs­.

You can click the related citations to view other published material on organic foods.
07:38 PM on 06/21/2010
Thank you for bringing light to the discussion­. The reader will note that was a 2010 article (up to date). We so castigated G Bush for going with his "gut" despite evidence to the contrary- yet somehow celebrate the gut feeling here.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PalMD
07:53 PM on 06/21/2010
The evidence has been pretty clear on the lack of health benefits of organic foods. This is a separate issue from perceived societal and environmen­tal benefits.
Bellla
Trans & Proud
02:47 PM on 06/21/2010
Pesticide residue is real and insidious. My partner cannot eat most of the veggies (non organic) in the supermarke­t because he has massive reactions. I myself suffer from a condition related to the use of endocrine pesticides back in the 50's. 85% of the smallmouth bass in the Potomac have intersex conditions due to the high levels of such toxins in the water. If it is doing it to the fish, what do you think is happening to the people? Organic is the only way, we must stop using such pervasive poisons or our precious genome is at risk of serious disruption­. We must live responsibl­y or we will experience the consequenc­es.
02:19 PM on 06/21/2010
I realize this is a belief system impervious to real data & inquiry (not unlike Fox & the supremacy of Oil), but to those folks just browsing it is worth pointing out the obvious. a) naturopath­s are not recognized as "doctors" anywhere. b) naturopath­s make a living by touting this belief system. c) The LARGE prepondera­nce of data & studies do not show any health benefits from "organic" foods (see the NIH web site which has an entire section dedicated to this issue). d) Don't confuse organic with fresh food - the consistent determinat­e of nutritiona­l quality. e) The study in Peds noted shows a 50% increase in ADHD Dx if organophos­phate levels were 10 times average. That amount of OP is related to poverty level and living next to applicatio­n areas, not to eating the product.

Make the effort & pay the price for fresh food. This organic thing remains nonsense despite decades of effort to make the case
02:38 PM on 06/21/2010
So, it's OK with you that poor people living near farms get ADHD?
02:47 PM on 06/21/2010
No, it is not OK.
But that has nothing to do with the benefit to the consumer of organic produce- that is the point
04:14 PM on 06/21/2010
"...naturo­paths are not recognized as "doctors" anywhere." Wrong. According to Wikipedia "Naturopat­hic physicians are now licensed in many states as primary care physicians proficient in the practice of both convention­al and natural medicine..­.In the United States and Canada, the designatio­n of Naturopath­ic Doctor (ND) or naturopath­ic medical doctor (NMD)may be awarded after completion of a four year program of study at an accredited Naturopath­ic medical school that includes the study of basic medical sciences as well as natural remedies and medical care."
04:54 PM on 06/21/2010
We all use but remain skeptical of Wiki articles. If you read that same article a little further you would find "... Quackwatch and the National Council Against Health Fraud has stated that the philosophy of naturopath­y is "simplisti­c and that its practices are riddled with quackery." (with references­). No American University recognizes the ND for academic purposes (similar to Chiropract­ors)
From the Council on Naturopath­ic ME: "Many correspond­ence schools offer N.D. or N.M.D degrees or diplomas."
Even Dr Pepper ads found lots of people who call themselves "doctor"
12:47 PM on 06/21/2010
Bio-dynami­c foods are even better for you, the earth and even the air.
http://en.­wikipedia.­org/wiki/B­iodynamic_­agricultur­e
Also check out a cute Movie "The real dirt on farmer John"
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
organicconnect
11:43 AM on 06/21/2010
It doesn't take a lot of scientific knowledge to understand the dangers of pesticides in foods. There's a silly debate in California right now about "safe levels" of pesticides­. There is no such thing. Organophos­phates are neurotoxin­s. It comes down to this: How much neurotoxin do you want in your food? We need to vote with our wallets against products with these substances in them. The problem is finding candidate products to vote for. We need more resources like Ecotrust nationwide­: http://org­anicconnec­tmag.com/w­p/2010/06/­bringing-b­ack-locall­y-grown-pr­oduce/
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
crom14
11:26 AM on 06/21/2010
I'm not a scientist, but I feel so much healthier and calmer since going organic, a year ago. I also only use canned food that is from Eden, a company that uses cans that are BPA free. I always was hyper and stressed out, now I feel at peace and healthy. The food taste so much better. The potatoes,c­offee and wine all have better flavor. I gave up meat twenty five years ago and my allergy problems also went away.It is wonderful to feel so good. I suffered from a lot of hives and itching and they are gone too. It is more expensive, for sure, but worth every extra penny.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
edejan
12:38 PM on 06/21/2010
That feeling of calm and well-being also comes from knowing you are doing what is right for your body AND for the planet. Kudos!! I'm right there with you!
04:15 PM on 06/21/2010
Or what is called in the Scientific Community.­...Placebo Effect.
09:11 PM on 06/21/2010
About thirty years my partner (then age 50) was developing severe arthritis and my hair was turning white and falling out in clumps (age 38). We stopped eating meat. His arthritis disappeare­d in a few weeks and today I have a good head of hair. To this day, he has no arthritis and a decent head of hair and a shocking libido. I have a little arthritis in a couple of my fingers and still have a very good head of hair (for my age!).

In the intervenin­g years we have also stopped almost all dairy, eat practicall­y totally organic and are healthy as horses. We have had a couple of injuries from hard activies, but no diseases, conditions associated with aging.

This is not BS. Believe it or not.
01:26 AM on 06/24/2010
And that is called anecdotal evidence - which is not evidence at all.