Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Duane Elgin

GET UPDATES FROM Duane Elgin
 

Hunger Games -- The Price of Failed Transition

Posted: 04/16/2012 10:43 am

The film The Hunger Games presents a heroic struggle in a world that has failed to make the transition to some form of sustainable prosperity. People are barely surviving on a ruined Earth and in a society that has regressed to ritualistic, annual killings for past misdeeds.

This is a horrifying view of the world ahead, particularly because it has a ring of authenticity -- we know that a future this terrifying could await us if we continue along our current path of climate disruption, resource depletion, species extinction, unsustainable population, and more. To turn from this path of collective ruin, it is vital that we step back and take a fresh look at the story of the human journey. We face big challenges and it will take an equally big vision to transform conflict into cooperation and draw us into a promising future.

A future of conflict and suffering is easy to imagine while a future of harmony and health is still a vague and unformed possibility in our collective imagination. Yet, there are numerous and compelling stories of great transition. These deep narratives describe how the world is in a predictable time of transition to a very different future, one that can only emerge if we consciously choose it. If we are to choose a promising future, there may be no more vital task than discovering the narratives that weave together the threads of the human experience into the larger tapestry of our collective journey.

An important starting point is to remember that we humans almost went extinct roughly 70,000 years ago. All of the people who now inhabit the Earth are descendants of a single community estimated to be fewer than several thousand persons who migrated out of Africa roughly 65,000 years ago. From a handful of survivors, we have now become an Earth community of 7 billion persons and we will likely reach 9 billion before stabilizing! Humanity has experienced extraordinary success and now completely dominates the Earth and its future.

The first step in creating a positive future is to imagine it. If we can visualize a future of promise, we can create that future.

One vision of promise is the view that humanity is maturing as a species and we are now going through the growth pains of our collective adolescence. Our self-image could therefore be that of a young species that is capable and gifted with untapped potentials. Instead of returning to a regressive and repressive society as in The Hunger Games, we could recognize and dive into the predictable struggles and turmoil of our adolescent years as a human community. Once we do, we will be on our way into our early adulthood and a concern for the well-being of the Earth and the long-term future of the human family.

To explore the story of "humanity growing up," as I have traveled in different parts of the world giving talks about the future, I have often begun with a simple question for the audience: "When you look at the overall behavior of the human family, what life-stage do you think we are in? In other words, if you estimate the social average of human behavior around the world, what stage of development best describes the human family: toddler, teenager, adult, or elder?" I give people a few minutes to discuss this among themselves and then we take a vote to see what people think or intuit.

When I first began asking this question, I had no idea if people would understand it or how they would respond. To my surprise, around the world, nearly everyone immediately understands this question. With little hesitation, people consistently vote that, as a social average, the overall human family is in its teenage stage of development. To illustrate, in 1999 I posed this question in New Delhi, India, speaking with an auditorium filled with several hundred young schoolteachers who were just graduating from college. There was no confusion about the question. The overwhelming majority voted confidently that the human community is behaving like it is in its adolescent years. I have received similar responses from business leaders in Brazil, spiritual leaders and futurists in Japan, and audiences of all kinds in Canada, Europe, and the United States. All have immediately responded in the same way: approximately three-quarters vote that, as a social average, the human family is in its adolescent stage of development.

Many people were quick to point out that this is a social average and therefore some people and cultures are well in advance of this stage. However, around the world, there is clearly a shared understanding that, putting us all together, the human family exhibits many adolescent behaviors.

Although many people described our species behavior as rebellious, reckless, and short-sighted, many others also pointed out beneficial aspects of the adolescent stage of development. Adolescents have a huge amount of energy and enthusiasm and, with their courage and daring, are ready to dive into life and make a difference in the world. Many teenagers also have a "hidden sense of greatness" and feel that, if given a chance, they can accomplish great things.

As the perfect storm of a world-systems crisis converges around us, and as we understand no outside force is coming to rescue us if we ruin the Earth, we can make the fiery rite of passage through our species adolescence and into our early adulthood. In shifting from our species adolescence to early maturity, we can seek a new relationship with the Earth, one another, and the universe. If "hunger games" are the price of a failed transition, then "sustainable prosperity" is the reward of a successful transition.

These narratives are extremely valuable because, without a story to give us a sense of collective orientation, we are lost. When we are lost, it is easy to be frightened and to focus on security and survival, to look for threats, and to pull together into "safe" enclaves. A story of the larger human journey that awakens our collective imagination could take us into another direction -- it could serve as the social glue that pulls us together in common effort. We may think we do not have that story now -- so we tend to fall back on old policies, old histories, old customs, old institutions, and old dreams. However, the story we seek is already present in our direct life experience! We contain within ourselves the wisdom of what is most valuable to grow from adolescence into adulthood.

In the weeks ahead, I will explore other stories of "great transition" that are drawn from the open-source Great Transition Stories website.

Duane Elgin is an internationally recognized author, speaker, and trans-partisan activist for media accountability. He is the author of Voluntary Simplicity, Promise Ahead, The Living Universe, and other books. His website is: www.DuaneElgin.com

 
 
 

Follow Duane Elgin on Twitter: www.twitter.com/DuaneElgin

The film The Hunger Games presents a heroic struggle in a world that has failed to make the transition to some form of sustainable prosperity. People are barely surviving on a ruined Earth and in a so...
The film The Hunger Games presents a heroic struggle in a world that has failed to make the transition to some form of sustainable prosperity. People are barely surviving on a ruined Earth and in a so...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 20
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
01:33 PM on 05/14/2012
Loved hearing you speak at the GATE Conference. I will contact your organization directly regarding a project I am currently working on.
thanks so much for your wisdom and insight.
Best,
Susan
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Duane Elgin
Speaker, author, trans-partisan media activist
12:28 PM on 05/16/2012
Thanks Susan. I looked at your 'Hot Flash Films" site and appreciate the depth and compassion of your creative inquiry!
04:32 PM on 05/04/2012
I so blame you for my new reading addiction! I do not know if it is a welcome by-product or not, but I read your blog entry this Monday morning and I am already starting Mockingjay, the third book in the trilogy. I find so many analogies I just cannot keep up with my mind. Thank you, I had been through a particularly rough week and your thoughts about narratives opened up whole fresh perspective.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Mike Schwager
Mike Schwager began his communications career at a
01:29 AM on 04/29/2012
It takes an Elder like you, Duane, to provide perspective. And what among other things does the Elder offer? He/She imparts a sense of Life's utter preciousness, and encourages the capacity for others to love more, to be kinder, and to appreciate the human and non-human life forms that inhabit our dear planet! :)
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Duane Elgin
Speaker, author, trans-partisan media activist
01:14 PM on 05/01/2012
Thanks for your affirming comments Mike!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Boie
Co-author of CONSCIOUS EVOLUTION: THE DANCE OF INT
11:42 AM on 04/20/2012
Ah--the importance of story...Last night we watched "Warhorse"...painful to watch...yes...Spielberg's hard work has done it again... my inner distillation as I wake this morning is that even through all our dark history, the spark of pure love survives...
--bss
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Duane Elgin
Speaker, author, trans-partisan media activist
07:32 PM on 04/23/2012
What a powerful and beautiful insight: "...even through all our dark history, the spark of pure love survives..."
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Boie
Co-author of CONSCIOUS EVOLUTION: THE DANCE OF INT
02:21 PM on 04/18/2012
Dr. Elgin, thank you for your efforts. I want to participate in your story-telling project. There are benevolent whisperings of many into the ears of many today. You are creating a great 'venue' here.
When I was in college in 1967, I noted that William Golding's Lord of the Flies was required reading in the high schools. I felt so bad about that and felt I must protest. I felt I must write something. about what
that horrible story might be doing to growing minds. It was as though Niebuhr were whispering in my ear, " We, as humans, create ourselves according to the image we hold of ourselves...," and I began to dig into the writings of those scientists who observed innate cooperation in the 'natural' world. I wanted to offer an argument to Golding's thesis that humanity is depraved and doomed to failure. (I did write that long paper and it was very well received…will try to locate the old onion skin copy and post it somewhere now!) In 2010, as I was standing at the counter in a local bookstore, I noted that Golding's awful story is still on the required reading list in high school English classes. I could hardly believe my eyes! Still I try. In the opening lines of my preface to Conscious Evolution: The Dance of Intuition and Intellect (Sheldon Stoff and Barbara Smith Stoff--published in 2010) I again repeat these words by Niebuhr.
--Barbara Smith Stoff
08:29 AM on 04/18/2012
Duane, I am in agreement that humanity is at the most critical fork in the road it has ever faced. Humanity is the first specie to have developed the global technology to wipe itself out, ending its 75,000 years of most recent evolution.

So we either continue our present devolving path of You OR Me tp become a failed species.... or else we create and live inside a new story. This story must be a story of You AND Me, as Buckminster Fuller exhorted forty years ago. It must be a story of compassion for each other and based on the two tenets that resources are sufficient and that we are all connected...to each other, to nature and to spirit.

This story, for me, might read like this: A future where very child born is wanted, nurtured and supported to pursue his or her unique path – in an environment of safety, opportunity and creativity – and living fully in joy and respect for life.

HarveyWAustin@Yahoo.com Surgeon, Agent for Conscious Evolution and Founder of the Archimedes Writers Group
photo
hopedance
publisher and screener of films
12:11 PM on 04/16/2012
Thanks Duane for your commentary. One such positive story is a film from France that has been basically "censored" in countries like Russia and France. It is The Green Beautiful which people can see in its entirety at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fyiyYrkzPbQ&list=UUWi3gpZW46Tv1P2zvLHB6pg&index=1
- Bob Banner of HopeDance
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Duane Elgin
Speaker, author, trans-partisan media activist
01:27 PM on 04/16/2012
Thanks for the pointer Bob. I will look for the movie.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
OneVoiceRising
10:49 AM on 04/16/2012
Oh goodness, I am so excited about this! I have been searching and searching for storytelling from a more positive perspective regarding our transition to a New Way. Thank you -- I look forward to reading your next installment, and have *liked* the Facebook page.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Duane Elgin
Speaker, author, trans-partisan media activist
11:18 AM on 04/16/2012
Thanks for your support! It really helps to spread the message by pressing the "like" button on the Facebook page for "Great Transition Stories": https://www.facebook.com/GreatTransitionStories
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
OneVoiceRising
01:54 PM on 04/16/2012
I would love to have a section devoted to Great Transition Stories at an online magazine I've been working toward for a while, as an offshoot of Wishadoo -- Our Collective Good. I'm primarily curating news and articles now but would love to highlight original content, especially Great Transition Stories.

http://www.ourcollectivegood.com/

When people of like mind (and heart) read the stories and want to explore the topics further, a group module is available at Wishadoo where we can do so...with each group essentially having their own micro social networking site with many tools and features. I find such groups are more conducive to ongoing discussion than public comment areas or even Facebook (though Facebook is a wonderful way to spread news and information).

If I can be of service in any way, including through Wishadoo and/or Our Collective Good, please let me know. :)
photo
hopedance
publisher and screener of films
12:19 PM on 04/16/2012
thanks for this.. yes there are numerous stories, they just wont be in our adolescent media.. HopeDance has been spreading the positive news genre for almost 20 years. YES has been doing a remarkable job and the Positive News is both in Europe and in the US now... Once we get a positive idea and it goes viral, that can give us courage and enthusiasm for change, both personal and cultural. Is it no wonder that the mainstream print media is failing and it has little to do with technology. If they gave us what we really need, inspiring and positive stories, they would come back big time.. Remember when the Yes Men came out with their spoof of a NY POST newspaper with all sorts of deliriously happy and positive news that left people wondering and shocked as if it was really true?! Dont believe me,,, then see it for yourself : http://theyesmen.org/blog/screwed ....
from Bob Banner, publisher of Critique for 10 years on exposing consensus reality and another 20 years on HopeDance: radical solutions inspiring hope....(http://hopedance.org/)
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Duane Elgin
Speaker, author, trans-partisan media activist
04:04 PM on 04/16/2012
I really appreciated your comment Bob and would like to offer only one addition in parentheses, "Once we get a positive idea and it goes viral, that can give us courage and enthusiasm for change, both personal and cultural. Is it no wonder that the mainstream print [and television] media are failing and it has little to do with technology. If they gave us what we really need, inspiring and positive stories, they would come back big time."