More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Dylan Brody

Dylan Brody

Posted: August 30, 2010 02:49 PM

Last week a Pew Research poll showed that an alarming number of Americans believe President Obama to be a Muslim. An even more alarming number question his Christianity. Now, this commentator finds it offensive that this story is picked up by the mainstream media with no examination at all as to why it remains acceptable to equate non-Christianity with a lack of basic decency or why it is okay to demand things of our elected president that it would be illegal to ask in a private job interview. Nonetheless, let us set aside this commentator's issues for a moment and just deal with that Pew poll and its direct implications.

That there is widening belief in erroneous information is deeply disheartening. It reveals a widespread willingness to take as sacrosanct that which is implied by celebrities even when it contradicts a personal memory of events. Glenn Beck, Rush Limbaugh and the folks at Fox News are the primary forces dropping hints that our president's commitment to Christianity is in doubt. Surely the same audience taken in by Rush calling our president "Imam Obama" were also watching when that source of mis-infotainment attacked then Senator Obama's Christian pastor Jeremiah Wright as being anti-white. Not only is Obama a Muslim, according to Limbaugh, but the pastor of his Christian church is a racist, too. In fairness, let me say that when Limbaugh attacked Jeremiah Wright he made comments that suggested his form of Christianity was not proper Christianity and might even be disguised Islamic practice. It was just a suggestion, though. As always, he worked through innuendo. Rush implies what he is too cowardly to say, not because he values the truth, but because he values deniability when it comes to his perpetuation of falsehoods.

Is it legal to shout "People have suggested that there's a fire!" in a crowded theater?

When the location of Obama's birth was questioned, the Hawaiian hospital at which he was born happily provided a scan of the certificate. Those who questioned Obama's place of birth demanded to know why the original was not produced and, apparently, passed from hand to hand across the country for all to examine. Some of the people who aren't entirely convinced about evolution have some suspicions about the dangerous new technology of photo-imaging.

We all like to think that humanity is constantly learning, moving forward toward greater understanding of our world and our place in it. This is not the case. The ancient Greek and Egyptian civilizations almost certainly knew that the world was round and that the Earth traveled around the sun. During the dark ages, though, humanity returned to a Terracentric world-view in which the sun moved about an Earth presumed to be flat. Not only did progress cease, ground that had already been covered was lost to a populist commitment to willful ignorance. Those who dared to question this world view, wrong though it was, were ridiculed, discredited by the church, and sometimes burned for witchcraft. Such treatment was perfectly acceptable as the victims were, sometimes by their own tortured admissions, not proper Christians. I sometimes wonder whether many Americans are troubled by our own history of witch-burning or merely by the idea that some of the humans burned might not actually have been witches.

Obama is a Christian. I don't actually care that Obama is a Christian. I care that people who are bright enough to know otherwise are misled into believing that he's not. I care that a country that guarantees freedom of religion thinks it's okay to treat this question as an issue. I care that a portion of the nation has so given up on the basic tenets of Democracy that they would rather see their party win based on lies than lose based on the facts.

If those servants of the Christian right who seek to manipulate the political system really believed any of the claptrap they spout, clearly they would just be getting down to the business of finding out the truth of what is in Obama's heart the only way truly possible, the only way their torch-carrying followers will find credible. They need to find out if he floats.

 
 
 

Follow Dylan Brody on Twitter: www.twitter.com/dylanbrody

 
 
  • Comments
  • 9
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
05:45 AM on 08/31/2010
The man says he's a Christian so its not my place to say he's not. That being said, I've watched video of him mocking scripture implying that if we governed with biblical principles we would be stoning our children.

So I won't deny him a Christian lapel pin, only the basic understanding that Jesus took that stoning for us and our children. Kind of a basic tenet of the faith, might want to work on that one a bit?
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Dylan Brody
01:35 PM on 09/03/2010
I have not seen video of him mocking scripture. Though I will point out that the Christian right (I have no idea where you stand on political issues) seems to cherry pick which elements of the Old Testament to hold on to and which to let go. Garments of mixed fibers? No problem. Shellfish? No problem. Homosexuality? An abomination!
10:52 AM on 09/04/2010
I am Christian right, but I can see the excellent point you make. I must have read Romans chapter 14 over 3 times last night trying to come up with a concise answer for you. Verse 16 says, "Therefore do not let your good be spoken of as evil" and that is a warning to Christians that if they don't get the verses around it right, their good will seem to others as evil.
Verse 20 says, "All things indeed are pure, but it is evil for the man who eats with offense."
and 22 says, "Happy is he who does not condemn himself in what he approves".

I don't know if the homosexual can, 'eat without offense', eating being doing something the Law says not to. The vast majority of Christians have nothing against the homosexual, that is between them and God, the problem is when they want to teach our children it is right and something to be celebrated.

You see also within Romans it warns that if what I do might cause you to stumble I should keep it to myself. Not a great analogy, but if you were an alcoholic and invited me over for dinner I wouldn't bring beer and I certainly wouldn't attempt to convince you drinking was acceptable even though it is an acceptable practice.
03:12 AM on 08/31/2010
Yes, this is remarkable that so many people can incorrectly assign a religion to the President. The President is clearly a Christian and has been for a very long time. It seems impossible that so many people can incorrectly believe that Obama is a Muslim.

David Coleman
http://www.legallawyers.com.au
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Dylan Brody
01:36 PM on 09/03/2010
It is remarkable. But, to me, not as remarkable as the idea that we think it is okay to use this as a gauge of his basic decency or validity as an elected leader.
03:37 PM on 08/30/2010
Too bad the founders didn't say freedom from religion instead of freedom of religion. Wish I could find who said that religion will be the death of mankind.
03:29 PM on 08/30/2010
Another diversionary tactic by the right -- elections coming up and the old smear tactic rears its ugly head. Dylan, in this beautifully written article, you are appealing to our better natures. I hope your message gets through.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Dylan Brody
11:26 AM on 08/31/2010
Thanks, New York Girl! It's good to have you on board.
photo
Computer Geek
Logician Atheist Lefty
02:56 PM on 08/30/2010
The saddest part of this (at least for Americans) is that these are the people who will determine the fate of all of us (especially those of you who don't vote). Ignorance is an excellent way to cast a vote for an elected official, isn't it? Apathy to voicing your opinion through voting is a good excuse isn't it?

Beginning to see a reason why you should vote in EVERY election? Beginning to see why the top 5% are controlling the bottom 95%? Unless you tell these fascists that you aren't going to put up with it anymore - by voting - you can count on Medicare going away, Social Security, everything you have worked for. You will work until you fall over and die (or beg if you can't find work at 75) but don't worry, if you do get sick, you will die quickly as you won't have insurance or Medicare to actually see a doctor. Too bad about your children as they will die quickly as well. But then that's what happens in third world countries...