iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Earl Ofari Hutchinson

GET UPDATES FROM Earl Ofari Hutchinson
 

Why Trump and the Birthers Won't Go Away

Posted: 06/01/2012 7:00 pm

President Obama was indeed prophetic when he said at a press conference a year ago that his release of his long form birth certificate would not convince countless numbers of anti-Obama skeptics that he was a bona fide American. Nearly a year after the president called it right on the bogus issue, the Public Policy Polling survey of GOP voters in Georgia, Tennessee and, more troubling, Ohio, because it's the key battleground state, found that more than one third of GOP voters still didn't believe he was born in the U.S. The same high degree of doubt about Obama's birth likely would be found among GOP voters in other states. Billionaire professional Obama basher Donald Trump almost certainly knew that, and that he spoke for untold millions when he calculatingly lashed out at Obama again with the phony birther charge.

Before Trump shoved the issue back into public debate, the hope was that despite the president's warning and fear, and the negative poll findings, that birtherism had become a nonissue. This seemed even more the case when GOP presidential candidate Mitt Romney, and the top GOP presidential contenders during the GOP primary campaign, all publicly rejected the birther claim about Obama.

But their public rejection of it as Trump has amply shown won't put the issue to rest simply because birtherism is a serviceable political chip for the GOP. In the months immediately before and after the president released his long form certificate, bills were introduced in 14 states that required presidential candidates to show iron clad proof of their U.S. birth. None of the bills passed. However, the mere fact of introducing the birth certificate requirement legislation in these states was just enough to continue to fan the flames of anti-Obama sentiment. There's even more to this apparent crackpot stuff.

The scurrilous ultraconservative attack line against Obama from the moment that he announced his presidential candidacy in 2007 is that he's unpatriotic, a closet socialist and Islamic radical. This fit in with a tact that the GOP has honed over four decades and that's to assault Democratic presidential candidates and presidents, and that's character attack, character attack, and character attack some more. This ploy sows public seeds of doubt about Democrats even deeper, deflects attention from the real issues of the economy, health care, education and foreign policy concerns. In the case of Obama the birther issue has an added pay-off; it reinforces the latent and overt bigotry among many GOP voters, and more than a few Democrats. That was sadly apparent in polls that show some Democrats still won't back Obama solely because of race. White Democrats in a recent Democratic primary in West Virginia went much further than anti-Obama racial talk and gave a white Texas felon running against Obama a significant number of their votes.

Add to that the legion of websites, bloggers, the conservative site WorldNetDaily, and the pack of right-wing talk show hosts, including Fox's Sean Hannity, that relentlessly pound on the issue. They are read, watched and listened to, and believed, by millions of Americans. The birther issue is and always will be alive and well with them. It's driven in part by naked racism, and in part by the GOP's loathing of Obama's economic policies, and moderate political views.
The emergence of massively funded Super PACs may give yet another potential potent push to the birther issue as a weapon against Obama. A few GOP connected Super PAC bankrollers have floated straw man issues such as Obama's long severed tie with his former pastor Jeremiah Wright and the non-revelation that Obama once smoked pot to test whether these slurs would touch a public nerve. They didn't. But it's still early in the stretch drive of the 2012 presidential campaign. There's little doubt that the search is on with a vengeance to scrounge up any piece of political muck that can be funded and pounded into a video hit against the president. The birther issue almost certainly will fit into the dirty attack campaign somewhere.

Obama hit Romney hard for his schmooze with Trump at the very moment that Trump blathered out again the zany birther line. The aim was to link Romney by association with birtherism despite Romney's public disavowal of it. The president was right to go on the attack against him on this. But no matter, birtherism is just too juicy and too battle tested an issue not to revive in some way especially given the fact as Obama sadly noted when he released his certificate that so many want to believe the worst about him. Trump certainly knew that. That's why neither he nor the birthers will go away.

Earl Ofari Hutchinson is an author and political analyst. He is a weekly co-host of the Al Sharpton Show on American Urban Radio Network. He is the author of How Obama Governed: The Year of Crisis and Challenge. He is an associate editor of New America Media. He is host of the weekly Hutchinson Report Newsmaker Hour heard weekly on the nationally network broadcast Hutchinson Newsmaker Network.

 

Follow Earl Ofari Hutchinson on Twitter: www.twitter.com/earlhutchinson

FOLLOW POLITICS
President Obama was indeed prophetic when he said at a press conference a year ago that his release of his long form birth certificate would not convince countless numbers of anti-Obama skeptics that ...
President Obama was indeed prophetic when he said at a press conference a year ago that his release of his long form birth certificate would not convince countless numbers of anti-Obama skeptics that ...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 62
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
07:08 AM on 06/24/2012
This is the only way this has been can remain relevant to the insane segment of this country. This blow hard needs the attention with his mid-level of intelligence.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
charleyvldm9
He thinks outside the box.
12:57 PM on 06/05/2012
It does'nt matter what nonsense anyone comes up with, there will always be a few million followers,do you remember the world was gonna end last year, and Elvis is still alive,and...and...you finish it.
03:35 PM on 06/03/2012
It would be nice if they actually talked about why the idea of birtherism is still standing. No mention of joe arpario and his evidence, whether you agree or not with him, he should still be mentioned as he is a big pusher in the birther movrment. linking it so strongly to trump just discredits this articles points
11:41 AM on 06/04/2012
Arpario was a few months back, and Huffington Post did cover him at that time. This current article is about Trump now taking the stand, but his reasonings for that are unrelated to Arpario.

Furthermore, Arpario did not actually release any new evidence in his investigation. He simply reworked evidence that had already been looked over (and discredited) and presented it as "new and startling". So he hardly deserves anymore news coverage.
03:34 AM on 06/07/2012
"dDscredited?"" Really? LOL! Please show us credible analysis which refutes this:

http://obamaballotchallenge.com/more-news-on-3-31-12-arpaio-investigation-press-conference-on-obama-ineligibility
03:51 AM on 06/07/2012
He did confirm the same conclusions, via the "Cold Case Posse" investigation. What was added was the following:

1. First official investigation
2. Corroborated past findings
3. Ran exhaustive tests to eliminate alternative theories attempting to discredit previous findings
4. Strengthened case, via proper use of rules of evidence and chain of custody.
5. Publicized the heck out of it due to his high profile of him, Jerome Corsi and now Lord Christopher Monckton and Trump. More are coming on board as they see the handwriting on the wall and blood in the water.
photo
fredrdr
Let us dare to read, think, speak and write.
02:54 PM on 06/03/2012
Fair points, but you did forget one. The RW called him a Kenyen Anti-Colonial. I may be wrong, but wasn't this country founded on anti-colonialism?
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
11:03 AM on 06/03/2012
Its once again become clear that if they tell a lie often enough and it makes some visceral connection which is the rejection of Obama in the white house for obvious reasons along with a little politics, they will believe it no matter how spurious. That is why the right funding all these coming attack ads is especially dangeous to our form of democracy. If so many of them can be blatantly antiscience its easy for them to drum up all sorts of negative press about Obama. Its sad, for in reality, the real discussion is more about the proper size and role of the federal government versus states rights, a topic we periodically revisit since the writing of the constitution. If we could get beyond the people involved and deal with the real questions we would be better served.
03:37 AM on 06/07/2012
We're the ones with the science. You are whistling in the dark. Your guy is finished, ineligible, incompetent, damaging to the USA. The people are finally catching on. Enjoy your last few months of pretending that things are fine,
08:50 AM on 06/07/2012
oh own up to your sides constant malarky and spin of the facts. That is all we ask.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
05:48 PM on 06/02/2012
Re: "Why Trump and the Birthers Won't Go Away"

It's because the mindless media kept repeating none-sense birther stories created by the conspirators like Trump and his birthers movement.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
DantesE
03:37 PM on 06/02/2012
This is the same conundrum myth robme has had from the start.
He can not flat out repudiate trump and the other birthers since most of his "base" are brithers. Add to that this so called base is not too happy with him to begin with. Remember that even unopposed robme could not get 42% of this base to vote for him.
At the same time the independents that he NEEDS to win are not birthers. By trying to pander to both these diametrically opposite factions he not only reinforces the flip/flop label he loses the respect of those voters who may not agree with him on this stand but still respect him for making one.
In this both the President and Ron Paul have much in common. While I may not agree with some and in Paul's case most of what they stand for I can still admire and respect the fact that each of these men have the honor, integrity and courage to stand for what they believe in popular or not. Ron Paul and his supporters in particular are to be admired for continuing to fight a seemingly hopeless battle without compromising what they believe in. These are all things myth robme and the rest of the teabaglicons know nothing about.
03:41 AM on 06/07/2012
Romney realizes that the proofers are rfght, but lacks the balls to come out and take a position. So, he uses Trump, Arpaio, Lord Monckton
http://venturacountyteaparty.ning.com/profiles/blogs/lord-christopher-monckton-and-author-tom-ballantyne-speak-in-vent

... and millions of others as his stalking horses, while "leading" from behind, a technique also used by. Mr. Hopey-Changey.
RealistBC
Micro-bios must pass muster.
03:08 PM on 06/02/2012
If Obama had any real and significant successses to run on -say, reducing real U6 unemployment by half- there is nothing the Republicans could use to stop a massive re-election landslide. Instead, Obama kissed and played nice with the Republicans, who proceeded to besmirch his character all over the map.

As Mark Twain once observed, a lie will race around the world before the truth can put on its comfy shoes. As I add, unless that truth is so overwhelmingly beneficial to the vast majority that no one believes the lie from personal experience Obama doesn't have such a truth to offer. Just words. Again.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
DantesE
03:48 PM on 06/02/2012
It is amazing to me that the people who belittle the President's accomplishments never mention the 100% solid opposition to ANYTHING he has tried to do. Who would have believed that teabaglicons are willing to destroy the country in order to oppose an African American in the White House?
RealistBC
Micro-bios must pass muster.
04:09 PM on 06/02/2012
It is amazing to me that Obama supporters forget all the times Obama caved in to GOP demands and then slapped us for complaining about it. If Obama were bold as FDR was, and if Reid wasn't fitted with a glass political jaw, they would have adopted Senator Harkin's proposed filibuster rule change, ended the paper filibuster and secret hold, and forced Republicans to actually stand and deliver their failed positional crap.

But no! You O-bots want to play the GOP's victims once again and excuse that loser in the Oval Office. You deserve a President Romney
05:21 PM on 06/02/2012
"Obama kissed and played nice with the Republicans"

What planet are you on?
photo
fredrdr
Let us dare to read, think, speak and write.
02:52 PM on 06/03/2012
I read and research and also listen to RW radio. He tried to comprimise and the RW chickhawk hosts laughed.
cat3
United We Stand
12:45 PM on 06/02/2012
Ironically, after almost 4 years, this and Rev Wright are the only things they have to try to discredit President Obama. If after all this time and all their millions they can't find anything else, I'd say we are fortunate to have such an honest and outstanding man as our President.
How many of of the people making accusations could live up to the scrutiny he has been given and come out as clean as he does.
RealistBC
Micro-bios must pass muster.
04:12 PM on 06/02/2012
This is because the corporatist SCrOTUS is about to eviscerate the only accomplishment Obama has: the mandated health insurance industry profit protection program. What good things that bloated bill delivered (and there were some) are all going to go down in flames along with the unconsitutional mandate to purchase private products and leave him with nothing but three-plus years of excuses about Republican bullies.
photo
fredrdr
Let us dare to read, think, speak and write.
02:53 PM on 06/03/2012
I think he has a couple. Osama who Bush said he could care less about. Pulling out of needless wars.
photo
studioh!
bridging the snarchasm
12:16 PM on 06/02/2012
"I don't know nuthin' bout birthin' Presidents, missy"
photo
Gestas
Mountain Man
11:56 AM on 06/02/2012
The Birthers won't go away, because the Republicans (R) think we are all stupid...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
daddyo1109
Denial ain't just a river in Egypt.
11:49 AM on 06/02/2012
We don't have to wait for the Birther issue to pop up, we just bring it up whenever we can! So get out in front of it, and make a law about it and be done with it. Then when someone like McCain who wasn't born in the US, or Romney whose father was born in Mexico, tries to run for President we can wave this new law in their face and say No Way, Dude, you have to be born in the USA.
It's very difficult to explain to the regular US citizen that there are legal opinions and precedents that define "Natural Born Citizen". The US Constitution didn't codify it because the colloquial meaning at that time was probably, "non European Free Man"! Maybe it's time to get this decided with a Federal Law.
08:38 PM on 06/10/2012
Well, start on Rubio first. The Mexican Nationalization act in the 1940's meant that George Romney was a citizen (not natural born), therefore Mitt is a natural born citizen.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
alumcreek
sorry to see humanity repeating errors ad nauseam
11:48 AM on 06/02/2012
Notoriety is Trump's life's blood. He feels as though he ;acks substance unless he is the news so he has to say and do anything he can to keep himself in the public's eye.

As soon as the media stops reporting on this issue he will seek another one. He has to remain a sought after loony guest on news programs or he will be forgotten and that must never happen.
08:39 PM on 06/10/2012
He does seem like a compulsive publicity hound.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
SonnyBono
Cogito ergo sum ​​liberalis
09:32 AM on 06/02/2012
Mr. Hutchinson - the real reason the birthers and their blather won't go away is because in 21st Century America, it is not considered polite in most circles to wear your klan robes in public in broad daylight.