Eat The Press

Entries from Friday December 1, 2006

What's In A Name? The Civil War Non-Story Story

Washington Post   |  NBC

NBC'S decision on Monday to actively label the violence in Iraq a "civil war" triggered a rush by other media outlets to weigh in on the term and the relative merits of its use and non-use. Matt Lauer said that "armed militarized factions fighting for their own political agendas" fit the bill; White House spokesperson Tony Snow said that, no, it didn't, because this was "sectarian violence that seems to be less aimed at gaining full control over an area than expressing differences," which certainly helped clear things up. Since then, media organizations have rushed into the breach to furiously debate which label to use, creating the biggest story this week with the smallest amount of something actually happening. Congratulations! Below, we look at who's using which label in this ongoing, um, "continuation of politics by other means":


  • NBC: Lauer explains further: After "much careful deliberation..." Label: "Civil war," dammit. MSNBC thinks so, too!
  • Fox News: "Civil war" is a euphemism for "failure of US policy." "We're unwilling to fall into that tender trap." Plus, non-Iraqis are involved — which is why there was never a Spanish Civil War, right? Label: Anything but "civil war," which wouldn't be so bad after all.
  • Washington Post: "We just describe what goes on everyday. We don't have a policy about it." Though they will use the term "close to a civil war." But they don't have a policy about it! Label:"Sectarian violence," in print; "Absolutely the level of violence equals a civil war" when Dana Priest is on Chris Matthews.
  • Katie Couric: "Just what makes a civil war? Scholars say...at least a thousand people must have died, at least 100 from each side." You don't need to be a scholar to know that that's the case in Iraq. Even so... Label: None. Way to straddle that fence, CBS.
  • Reuters: "So whose arguments hold more weight?" Label: "Civil war," with citations.
  • Financial Times: "The civil war in Iraq is likely to deteriorate..." Label: A "disingenuous" "civil war" full of "failures" with no "silver bullet." (Zagat rating: 23.5)
  • USA Today op/ed: There is mayhem, therefore there is war. Label: "'Civil war' doesn't begin to describe the chaos in Iraq"
  • CNN: Divided, says the Media Matters blog, quoting correspondent Michael Ware: "You dare to go out and try to go to work or, indeed, shop at a marketplace and you will know that this is civil war." Label: Ware: "Civil war." Correspondent Bob Franken: "Sectarian war." Anderson Cooper: "Sectarian violence." Chyron: "Civil War?"
  • Associated Press: Still debating, says the Guardian. "There are different views in the newsroom." Label: "We don't preclude saying civil war in our copy, if a correspondent thinks it appropriate. But we don't want to go out and declare it a civil war." Yes, because whether or not its a civil war is completely up to you.
  • New York Times opinion page: "At this point it is hard to tell who is more out of touch: President Bush, who continues to insist that Iraq has not descended into civil war..." Label: "Civil war." But more importantly, Bush is now "the demander."
  • Thomas Friedman: "Here is the central truth about Iraq today: This country is so broken it can't even have a proper civil war." (But give it 4-6 months...) Label: "So many little pieces." All of which are flat.
  • L.A. Times: "The Times was the first major news organization to formally adopt the description when it began to refer to the hostilities as a civil war in October, without public fanfare." The Times was also the first major news organization to smugly point this out. Label: "Civil war," four times a day.
  • Dan Froomkin:"It's a Civil War, Stupid!" (See lede: White House, he's talkin' to you.) Label:"Civil War," stupid.
  • Daily Show: "The phrase 'civil war' conjures horrible jaw-dropping images of bloodshed...no one needs that image." Label: "Ongoing scuffle between sectarian groups." No, "the internal sovereignty challenge." No, "the faith-based melee." Because why choose just one?

Nick Douglas

permalink

hurricane season.jpg

from NewsBusters.com

Media Mea Culpa: Hurricane Season Passes Without Incident, But Why Is Williams Apologizing?

Newsbusters   |  Harry Shearer/HuffPo

Newsbusters points out that Brian Williams closed out his broadcast from Jordan last night with a mea culpa of sorts, noting with relief that the hufficane season had passed without any actual hurricanes despite dark predictions from his and other networks. Said Williams: "Finally tonight, we have a confession. We got something wrong," admitting that the stream of "dire predictions" reported earlier in the season "wasn't even close" to the relatively mild season that just passed. But what did Williams get wrong? Here's how he opened his May 31, 2006 broadcast:

Good evening, and we are indeed back in New Orleans tonight because this is the eve of the start of the 2006 hurricane season. Along the way, we hope to answer the question: Are they ready for another one?

Pretty fair question at the time, considering that the word on the street was that actually, no, they weren't ready for another one.

Continue reading this post...

permalink

Daily Show.JPG

Daily Show Update: Steve Bodow New Head Writer; Simpsons' Josh Lieb Joins As New Co-Exec Producer

Huffington Post   |  Rachel Sklar

Update on yesterday's story on "The Daily Show" shakeup, now confirmed: Yesterday, news broke Ben Karlin, co-executive producer of both The Daily Show and The Colbert Report along with Jon Stewart , had resigned his position, and would be replaced by current head writer David Javerbaum. Today we bring word of Javerbaum's replacement at the head of The Daily Show's crack writing team: writer Steve Bodow (below right), who has been part of the show's Emmy-winning team since early 2002 as working as a journalist (New York, Salon) and theater director in Manhattan before joining the show. As well, The Daily Show is also bringing on former Simpsons and News Radio writer/producer Josh Lieb as a co-executive producer, joining Dan Sterling and Kahane Corn, as we reported yesterday.

Meanwhile, Javerbaum will continue to attend to his musical theater career as Cry-Baby steve bodow.jpg(scored with composer Adam Schlesinger of the Fountains of Wayne and with book by Tony-winning Hairspray duo Mark O'Donnell and Thomas Meehan) prepares for a spring workshop and a subsequent run on Broadway (once a theater can be secured). Those unwilling to wait until spring to enjoy the Javerbaum's musical stylings need look only as far as Stephen Colbert's "The Adventures of Tek Jansen," for which he wrote the theme song ("Neutral to the Slimth!"). Sing along here.

permalink

nicholas-lemann.jpg

Columbia

Columbia Journalism Dean Endorses Truthiness

NYT   |  Radar

Bad: Radar yesterday broke an embarrassing story about Columbia's Graduate School of Journalism students cheating on an exam in an ethics course.

Worse: The New York Times today prints a follow-up story, writing in the lede, "Cheating on an open-book, take-home exam in a pass-fail course seems odd."

So horribly wrong: The dean of the journalism school (pictured) tells the Times, "It is not like law school, where fine differences in points make all the difference in the world."

Nick Douglas

permalink

More Of Us To Love! "Eat The Press" Welcomes Melissa Lafsky And Nick Douglas

Huffington Post   |  Rachel Sklar

mel lafsky.jpgnick-redbull-small.jpgIt is with delight and excitement that we proudly announce two new talents joining "Eat The Press": Melissa Lafsky and Nick Douglas. Both will be ETP's brand-new Contributing Editors, filling out the site and providing more up-to-the-minute news, chatter, and the other two things it says up on the top there. Melissa, the eponymous proprietor of Opinionistas and a clutch contributor to ETP and HuffPo so far, will continue to offer scoopy , original reporting and smart , newsy commentary. Nick, a recent and welcome gift from Gawker media, will continue to be on top of the 24-hour news cycle in matters media/new media/technology and the convergence thereof. Nick, who is indeed of more, er, tender years than some of us who shall remain nameless, cut his teeth at Blogebrity and moved on to be the founding editor of Valleywag where he archly covered the Silicon Valley scene, news- breaking and beat-covering with insight and wit. Also, he said he would introduce me to the Google boys.

In addition to Nick and Melissa, ETP will continue to benefit from the insights of semi-regular contributors Ankush Khardori and Sven Hodges, which, come to think of it, makes Nick the only non-lawyer on the ETP roster. Consider that a ringing endorsement for the practice of law. (We will also happily continue to welcome submissions from other crack contributors Alex Koppelman, Maureen Miller, Jamie Frevele, Patrick Waldo, Dan Shanoff and Danny Shea whenever their busy schedules allow).

A note: This beef-up of ETP resources has been in the works for a while, based on my inability to cover the Media Loves Showtunes beat on my own (that Jim Romensko is always nipping at my heels, dammit!).The fact that we're announcing just as HuffPo makes waves as the newest force in cutting-edge political reporting is actually a coincidence, though obviously one with the same root causes.

So that's it! Watch for new and exciting features on ETP going forward, plus our trademark non-stop Shamu coverage, as weirdly relevant today as it ever was. The ETP team is grateful for your readership, and looks forward to serving you going forward, because you are weird and relevant, too.

Rachel Sklar

permalink

lenore skenazy.jpg

from creators.com

Surprise Ax: Daily News Fires Lenore Skenazy, Longtime Columnist And Newsroom Reality Show Stalwart

NYPost

Surprise news at the News: Longtime and award-winning columnist Lenore Skenazy, has been axed. The paper has declined to comment on the reason, but the NY Post's Keith Kelly reports that newsroom insiders say it's a case of budget cuts over loyalty. Skenazy, who has been with the news for over 13 years (over 17if you count freelancing, notes Kelly) is syndicated in about two dozen papers, has won numerous awards, and was featured prominently in this summer's short-lived but much-hyped newsroom reality show "Tabloid Wars."

Kelly points out that this move means that the Daily News, which bills itself as New York's "Hometown Paper" is "without a woman columnist other than gossiper Joanna Molloy, who co-writes the column 'Rush & Molloy.'"

This is the second surprise ax this week after Life & Style editor in chief Debra Birnbaum was unceremoniously dropped by Bauer publishing.

permalink

russian forbes.jpg

from WSJ.com

Russian Forbes Under Fire For Controversial Story; Mag Pulled, Reinstated

WSJ

From the WSJ: The December issue of Russian Forbes was pulled this week after its cover subject, the billionaire wife of Mosco'ws mayor, obtained a leaked copy of the story and threatened to sue and demanded that the publisher yank it, causing the editor to resign in protest. The U.S. version, which cedes editorial control to Axel Springer under the license but provides 40% of each issue, demanded that publisher Axel Springer AG reinstate the magazine, and late yesterday, they agreed.

Billionaire Yelena Baturina, owner of sprawling conglomerate Inteko and wife of Moscow Mayor Yuri Luzhkov, is worth $2.4 billion. A quote on the cover was initially at issue, which said "I am protected"; the actual quote was "Like any investor, I am guaranteed protection of my rights." The cover quote was corrected but otherwise the story is to be published unchanged.

Baturina and Luzhkov have successfully sued newspapers previously over allegations that her success is due to her husband's influence and position. Press freedom in Russia has been under attack of late, particularly at Forbes after editor in chief Paul Klebnikov was gunned down downtown in July 2004. Earlier this fall, trusted and critically-acclaimed journalist Anna Politkovskaya was similarly gunned down; both were apparent contract killings.

permalink

Media Blogroll

Chatter

Romenesko Gawker TVNewser Wonkette Crooks & Liars CJR Daily Drudge Dealbreaker Dealbook Defamer Deadline Hollywood Daily Mickey Kaus Jeff Jarvis Radosh James Wolcott IWantMedia The Slot Bloggermann Jake Tapper Blogging Baghdad Russert Watch Jossip Mediabistro The Media Mob at the NY Observer The Transom FishbowlNY FishbowlDC FishbowlLA GalleyCat Reference Tone Panopticist The Minor Fall, The Major Lift Penguins On the Equator Gelf Magazine- Gelflog Animal (New York) White House Press Briefings Altercation
Page Six Liz & Cindy NYDN Gossip Intelligencer Reliable Source Patrick McMullan

Analysis

Jack Shafer Howard Kurtz WWD Memo Pad NYO Off The Record Broadsheet Gail Shister Keith Kelly NYT Business/Media Jay Rosen’s PressThink Fine on Media Simon Dumenco’s Media Guy Jon Friedman Media Matters The Guardian (Media) NRO Media Blog Columbia Journalism Review On The Media The Public Eye The Daily Nightly Today’s Papers Regret the Error Dan Froomkin David Folkenflik

Commentary

Slate Salon New York Magazine The New Yorker The New York Review of Books The New Republic The Nation Harper’s The Atlantic Monthly The Virginia Quarterly Review Vanity Fair Esquire n+1 The Believer

News

The New York Times The Washington Post The New York Observer The LA Times Time Newsweek US News & World Report Wall Street Journal Editor & Publisher NY Daily News NY Post USA Today NY Sun Times of London Financial Times The Smoking Gun McClatchy
NBC ABC CBS CNN Fox News MSNBC NPR Air America BBC C-SPAN Al Jazeera
AdAge Broadcasting & Cable MediaPost MediaWeek Variety Entertainment Weekly Folio:
HuffPo Home