iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Edwin Okongo

GET UPDATES FROM Edwin Okongo
 

Blame Legal Immigrants Like Me for Taking Your American Jobs

Posted: 06/18/2012 5:05 pm

I am probably the only immigrant willing to admit that we are to blame for America's high unemployment. But it is not undocumented immigrants like the ones whose children President Barack Obama said he's not going to deport who are taking your jobs away. Believe me, you don't want the jobs those immigrants do. It's legal immigrants like me you should be blaming for your plight.

Soon after I arrived from Kenya nearly 20 years ago, I began to work in the kind of jobs you'd expect a new immigrant to take. I scrubbed pots and pans, floors, and toilets at various restaurants. I stocked supermarket shelves. I guarded buildings and parking structures. And I scrubbed pots and pans, floors and toilets again.

Unsatisfied, I registered with a temporary staffing agency in California's Silicon Valley. Because I had no experience, the only jobs they could give me lasted between a couple of weeks and three months. But they all added up and gave me the experience I needed, and before long, I had a one-year contract assembling computer hard drives at IBM. My next job was at Applied Materials, one of the largest corporations in Silicon Valley.

Instead of bussing tables and driving hotel shuttles, dealing with irrational customers who thought that just because I spoke with an accent I was an idiot, I was driving forklifts, taking warehouse inventory, using computers, and attending daily meetings. I was getting paid overtime. I was living the American dream. But shortly after, a series of unfortunate things began to happen to make me question my understanding of what the American dream was.

It began with my first layoff from Applied Materials, after one year on the job. Fortunately, the economy picked up fast and they called me within a few months. During my second stint I climbed up the ranks to become a supervisor. Life was good. Seeing no need to go to college, I dropped out.

But then 9/11 happened.

Two months later, I was jobless again. A few months after, they called me back again, this time through the same temporary staffing agency that had opened my door to Silicon Valley. When in 2003 they told me that they'd be letting me go a third time, I knew there had to be a better way.

I could have applied for another warehouse job elsewhere like most of my American coworkers, but I was tired of being kicked around. Instead, I decided to take a hard look at my life. I began by asking myself why I had come to America. If all I ever wanted to be was an unskilled laborer, did I really have to leave Kenya?

I came to America to get something no one in my family had ever had: a college degree. Anything less would have been unacceptable. I returned to college, got my bachelor's degree, and later went to graduate school.

My story is not unique. That is the path many immigrants take. The ultimate goal of many of them -- even those who are undocumented -- is to earn a degree from an American college.

We refuse to accept that a life spent in an unskilled job is a lifetime in the American dream. To us, such jobs are launching pads to greater things -- transit vehicles to the American dream. Even when we come to America in our 30s and 40s, we are not afraid to enroll in college, or to acquire some form of formal training. Tell us that you won't recognize the degrees we acquired in our countries of origin and we'll start college afresh. Because of this spirit, we are lawyers, professors, doctors, scientists, inventors, nurses, teachers, engineers, and entrepreneurs.

You remind us every day that this is the land of opportunity. You wave your flag and tell us that this is the best country in the world.

We agree.

It's about time you started believing in what you tell us about America. Instead of demonizing the defenseless guys breaking their back to get food to your supermarkets, demand that legal immigrants like me give you back your jobs. But to get them, you must work as hard as we have to qualify for these jobs.

It's a shame that many Americans think that what makes America great is the fact that one needs not have a college degree -- that the dream is to sit back and demand that some government bureaucrat create a job for you.

Talk about handouts!

We immigrants are often shocked when we learn that a majority of Americans have never been to a college classroom. That needs to change, if this is country is to remain great.

The choice is yours: You can work as hard as we immigrants have, and take maximum advantage of this country's abundant educational opportunity, or you can take the easy way out and continue to moan about undocumented immigrants. (They aren't going anywhere, so there is plenty of time for you to use them as scapegoats).

You can start by demanding that your government invest more in your children's education, and less in foreign wars -- many of which have created the unbearable conditions that have forced us to flee to America to take your jobs. Until then, we'll continue utilizing the wonderful educational institutions your hard-earned tax dollars have built and continue taking your jobs.

Writer and humorist Edwin Okong'o teaches at the University of California, Berkeley. He invites American children to his classroom so they may one day reclaim their jobs from immigrants.

 
FOLLOW POLITICS
I am probably the only immigrant willing to admit that we are to blame for America's high unemployment. But it is not undocumented immigrants like the ones whose children President Barack Obama said h...
I am probably the only immigrant willing to admit that we are to blame for America's high unemployment. But it is not undocumented immigrants like the ones whose children President Barack Obama said h...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 236
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (5 total)
09:23 PM on 07/08/2012
Kudos to Edwin. Provoking article!
03:18 AM on 07/06/2012
I agree, all immigrants should be put on hold until America is up and running again. Oh, and illegal immigrants take good paying jobs from Americans in the millions. I live in Southern CA, and personally know illegals who work for such companies as AT&T, Verizon, Comcast making 75k plus a year, due to management/HR looking the other way from citizen documentation!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
03:42 AM on 06/25/2012
I do find the majority of Mr. Okongo's comments ' arrogant ' and ' condescending'.

However, more disturbing to me is that as a college professor his ' mind-set ' may have an influence over many of our children.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:41 PM on 06/25/2012
Because only native-born Americans are allowed to be "'arrogant' and 'condescending'", like always claiming America is number one in everything even when in contradiction of all empirical evidence.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wC8ovJYAU3U
11:41 AM on 07/09/2012
America has changed - it is now a land of FREE welfare and endless entitlements for illegal aliens. We remain NUMBER ONE in giving a free ride to foreigners, all at the expense and demise of the United States of America.
05:44 PM on 06/26/2012
You should be more disturbed about the 'mind-set of the Kardashians over many of your children.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
11:17 PM on 06/29/2012
Depends on the age of child you are speaking of - if they are of the age that the parents still have a say then it is the parent's responsibility to simply not allow them to watch any programs that the parents 'deem' inappropriate.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
whoBBoo
Just because you don't agree with my statement doe
10:36 PM on 06/24/2012
Awwwwwwwwww, Obukabuka, regardless of what you say, the bottom line is; you are jealous because we are American, and you're NOT
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Robyn Singleton
screw you guys, Im going home
09:31 PM on 06/24/2012
Wow.. You just insulted America.. Go back to your own country you jack hole
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Robyn Singleton
screw you guys, Im going home
09:26 PM on 06/24/2012
Looks like someone needs to go back to school
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Robyn Singleton
screw you guys, Im going home
09:21 PM on 06/24/2012
Really? Being a veteran IS an achievement .. Don't be all pissy because you couldn't do it
photo
Hoodooman
Non-Aggression Principle
02:04 PM on 06/24/2012
If you are a legal immigrant, then you are a fellow American. So there would be no need to state "your American jobs" as they are your jobs too.
10:15 AM on 06/24/2012
Congratulations on your success. You're living the American Dream.
02:07 PM on 06/22/2012
I can't believe some of the comments on this thread.

Edwin -

Welcome. Many thanks for doing it legally, and respect for your hard work and results. Nope, i sure don't blame you for the plight of the jobless here. You've earned your positions via your hard work. Don't blame the majority of the jobless here either. There are still so only so many positions available. I'm in a state with one of the highest unemployment rates in the country - that's because there just aren't enough to go around, not because the native citizens and legal immigrants are lazy.

However -

As a legal immigrant, i'd be guessing that you were employed at the going, or at least legal minimum rate. So you wouldn't have been undercutting the market. I'd bet that you pay your taxes. I'd bet that you arrange to pay for your own medical coverage and that of your family (if not covered via your job).

A college education is wonderful, but not mandatory. Many kids i know can't dream of being able to afford it, instead they start businesses or go to a trade school, so they can be hired at an excellent wage when out. So go easy.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Edwin Okong'o
08:14 PM on 06/22/2012
Thanks for the kudos, but I don't remember saying anywhere that college is mandatory. What I said was that if any immigrant should be blamed for taking American jobs, it's legal ones like me, not the undocumented. And I added that for that blame to stick on me, the blamer must be qualified for my job.

I guess I should have said that I couldn't afford education either, but I worked and took loans that will take me decades to repay. Politicians have done a very good job convincing us that college is for "snobs" and that anyone highly educated is an elitist. Between that and keeping tuition ever rising (15% in the last year alone) they have succeeded in making us stay away from college. There result? They and the corporations that fund them can turn around and pay us minimum wages because we didn't go to college. Again, I'm not saying that everyone should go to college; I'm saying that a country with a college degree rate of under 30% can't sustain itself in this competitive world.

And by the way, it took me more 10 years to get my Bachelor's degree, one night class at a time.
09:20 PM on 06/22/2012
I disagree with you about legal immigrants taking jobs. You're competing fairly on an even foot. You're not undercutting.

And again, there is a middle ground between getting a college degree and working minimum wage jobs. Trade school is one alternative, where graduates are qualified for jobs that pay quite a bit more than minimum.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:34 AM on 06/25/2012
TO: Edwin Okong'o :

Concerning poster Indy 500 comment to you : He did not state that you stated that college is mandatory. He was stating that per his opinion - college is not mandatory. Also, just for your future use - Where you used 'there' - it should be 'their' .
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LaFemmeSASE
09:28 AM on 06/22/2012
I like your argument but the tone is offputting. Though you raise some salient points it would be difficult for people to understand them if they perceive they are under attack and have closed off their minds to anything you have to say. There are many other ways to encourage people to be more competitve so they can gain professional employment without belittling them in the process.

I agree with the message but not the delivery.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
chevyliddle
what's a micro-bayou?
10:08 PM on 06/22/2012
My thoughts also.
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
08:16 PM on 06/21/2012
Yes there are a lot of people who migrate to America. I have no problems with other cultures at all. But I seem to think that those jobs that no one wants to do ....as a proud American.....people from other cultures are not afraid to do. They will take these low paying or low level jobs as stepping stone to somewhere else. Also i have seen many people come to America to get a better education....and they do become better. They become our computer programmers and doctors. So can we appreciate those people who want a better life when coming here? Or do we mock them when they take the jobs we are too proud to take...!!
03:15 AM on 06/22/2012
this is bs. who do you think held those jobs before these people hopped their behinds over here. AMERICANS, that's who. african americans built this country on their backs, to say the least, and all we got was a swift kick in the butt. the real task is to develop the country you were born in, (your roots), but that's too hard,acting like you don't have the brains to do so, so you run over here. it's easier when your survival is due to another man's blood, work, sweat,tears,courage,and years. you come over here talking mess, like you really have done something. newly arrived so-called immigrants ( since 1965) have been a business move for white america, for nearly 50 years, that's why they hid it under the (civil rights act), and also a calculated move to knock african americans, out the box, by the good ole boys of that era. well they messed up. america is a immigrant hot mess powder keg, getting ready to blow the lid off america, straight to hell. immigration, whether, so called legal, or non- legal is not natural. the creator put everyone where he intended them to be,whether you sink or swim. it's up to you. africa is the wealthiest continent,but you have to come to america to get a job/education, what a pity. the bible quotes, that men shall enjoy the fruits of their labor, not someone else, these immigrants did not labor for america. i'm so glad he's watching.
08:27 AM on 06/22/2012
I have to agree with you ...that Arfican Americans have struggled and continue to accept low-paying jobs. Everyone can become successful. How many black doctors and lawyers are there...? Many...many !! I am not trying to knock any ones culture or race. I am saying that everyone has an opportunity to get a job and an education here in America..!!
I am an American and very proud. I am married to am immigrant and have been for over 18 years. So I support immigration...!!.
05:55 PM on 06/22/2012
"immigration, whether, so called legal, or non- legal is not natural. the creator put everyone where he intended them to be,whether you sink or swim. it's up to you".

Why do you suppose the european founding fathers of America chose to leave their birthplace in europe and journey across an ocean to a new and somewhat strange land?
photo
shawshank
The unseen ones prop up the visible world...
07:46 PM on 06/21/2012
It's hard to appreciate a success story, even that which shows admirable traits, when it is cloaked in arrogance and gloating.
12:40 AM on 06/21/2012
You can tell people who are not use to having anything...they always have this type of attitude.
Now they are better than everybody else....
12:19 PM on 06/21/2012
I now understand why you only have five fans....