iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Elizabeth Jayne Liu

GET UPDATES FROM Elizabeth Jayne Liu
 

Her Father, My Father

Posted: 05/04/2012 9:00 am

"Where's your dad?" Cal's friend once asked her while on a playdate. There was nothing mean-spirited about the question. It was just one 7-year-old asking another in a curious "My dad's at work; where's your dad?" kind of way.

Very matter-of-factly, my daughter, Cal, replied, "I don't have a dad. If my mommy gets married, then I'll have one."

Cal didn't bring it up for the rest of the afternoon, but at bedtime, she told me God wanted to know when I would be getting married.

"God... or you?" I asked.

"I guess me. Maybe I can pray about it."

I didn't know what to tell her, so I said it would be okay to talk to God about wanting a dad.

I didn't have a father growing up, either. My parents weren't divorced, and they lived under the same roof, but Dad wasn't present most of the time. Even when he was there physically, he wasn't interested in participating.

He wasn't interested in being interested.

On the rare occasion when he spent time with us, I tried to draw out the excursions. We took a few road trips as a family, and I studied maps and guidebooks for weeks beforehand in hopes of finding additional detours. One more afternoon. One more memory.

A few months after Cal asked when I would be getting married, I reconnected with a high school flame. After a whirlwind romance, we got married.

My husband is an excellent father. He adopted Cal two years ago, and the transition from being a duo to a trio has been smoother than I ever dared to hope.

Sometimes, I do comparisons in my head. I think about Cal, who knows with confidence that if she needs her father to be somewhere or do something, he will be there. He will do it. It's an easy assumption she makes, and he's happy to oblige. There is a comfortable casualness between the two. Once, he forgot to load her backpack into the car trunk before driving her to school in the morning -- a fact the two discovered in the school parking lot 20 minutes later. Even now, she jokes with her dad about "not forgetting my stuff... again." She says it with a look of disapproval. He solemnly nods. Then they both laugh.

I think about my own father, whom I saw for the last time in 2000, when I was 19. My parents were finally getting divorced after being together for 20 years, miserable for 10. I came home to help my mom pack and move to another state. The morning my parents signed the divorce papers, I helped my brother load up the last of the boxes into the moving van, hugged my dad, and told him that I would call him soon.

In the following months, I left him several messages, but he never called back. I rationalized. I reasoned. Maybe talking to me would remind him of his failed marriage. Maybe seeing me would make him sad.

Four years later, I decided to reach out again. I looked up his new phone number on the Internet. He picked up on the third ring, and I was relieved when he sounded happy to hear from me. I didn't ask why he hadn't returned any of my phone calls. I just wanted to put the past behind us and move forward. During the half-hour conversation, we didn't get into a deep discussion, but he asked if I was doing okay. I told him that I was fine and that I missed him.

I offered my phone number. He accepted. He said he would call soon because too much time had passed, and he didn't want us to be strangers.

"I would like that, Dad."

Until recently, I had two cell phones. I had the first one for 10 years, and it's the number I gave my father. The other, I got after marrying my husband five years ago, and it's the one I use every day. Friends stopped calling the first phone years ago so I considered disconnecting it, but I'm unable to give it up.

Sometimes, a week or two passes before I check my first phone, which is permanently plugged into a corner of my bedroom. I flip it open, hoping to see a message or even a missed call notification.

I've waited eight years for my dad's phone call. I'm still waiting.

Having a parent who doesn't share the same interest in having a relationship is confusing. It's embarrassing. And it hurts. My father's absence is so complete that I sometimes wonder if I imagined his existence.

When I am asked how this makes me feel, I shrug it off. The experts say that the opposite of love isn't hate, it's indifference. And that's what I outwardly try to portray: an air of indifference. A façade of growing past the rejection into a well-adjusted adult who won't fight for someone who doesn't want to be around.

I'm happy and relieved for my daughter, who will have a different experience than I. But a part of me is sad that I didn't have a wonderful father like she does, and my fear is that the chances of it happening are, as the days go on, getting slimmer.

Recently, I was in bed because of severe allergies. My husband told me to take it easy and said that he would get Cal -- who is 12 now -- ready for school. I watched him brush her hair into the saddest ponytail I had ever seen. It was crooked and not all the hair made it in. When he was done, Cal turned to me. "See, Mommy, I told you it would work if I prayed."

For five years, she had held our conversation inside, believing her prayers brought her a father. Not just any father, but a dad who will love her always, in all ways.

For more by Elizabeth Jayne Liu, click here.

For more on becoming fearless, click here.

 
FOLLOW HEALTHY LIVING
 
 
  • Comments
  • 30
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
08:13 PM on 06/17/2012
Here on Father's Day, this especially made me cry. So beautifully written. So honest. So real. So profound. I have a father, but the relationship has changed dramatically since my mother died. Ironically, when I needed him the very most, right? I am so happy for your daughter that she will not know this pain.
http://whattheflicka.com/survival-of-the-mommy-est/acceptance/
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Elizabeth Jayne Liu
12:44 AM on 06/18/2012
I loved your piece on What the Flicka. I have also realized along the way that although I'm supposed to be the one watching out for my daughter, sometimes, she's the one who is the stronger one and the protector.
02:06 PM on 06/17/2012
I am sad for your father. He's clearly missing out on a wonderful daughter.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Elizabeth Jayne Liu
02:29 PM on 06/17/2012
Most appreciated on a day like today. Thank you.
06:54 PM on 05/23/2012
I remember this post. Heartbreaking and full of hope.
Cal is an amazing kid and you are an amazing mom, I am so happy that Harv came back to you life, it was obviously meant to be. He is Cal's dad.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Elizabeth Jayne Liu
01:13 PM on 05/24/2012
R, Thanks so much for the kind words. I wholeheartedly agree. Harv was always, always meant to be Cal's dad. I am proud that she will have such a strong male role model in her life.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
George Molho
Author & kidnap survivor, "While I hope I breathe"
10:48 PM on 05/08/2012
I love your honesty. A living story. As a first time reader I am hooked on the sublime nature of your writing. Thank you so much for sharing this story.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Elizabeth Jayne Liu
12:01 AM on 05/09/2012
George, thanks so much for the encouraging feedback.
03:18 PM on 05/08/2012
This is what blogging (writing) should be about. Not SEO, keywords, and hot topics - but honesty. Expressing that which can only be expressed through the written word. Terrific post.
07:33 PM on 05/08/2012
Thanks so much for the kind words, Dan.
09:39 AM on 05/08/2012
My favorite thing you've ever written. Well done.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Elizabeth Jayne Liu
11:34 PM on 05/08/2012
Many thanks, Jeff.
05:19 PM on 05/07/2012
What an incredibly moving story. As I’m sure you know I am an avid reader of your blog; it was the very first one I decided to follow when I got into blogging last year. What you write is often hysterical and usually involves poking fun at yourself. I’m sure some of it is just for fun, but if you’re anything like me you mask your insecurities about what you see as your “short comings” in humor. Well let me just tell you that you are one of the strongest women I have ever had the pleasure of knowing (even if it is only through cyberspace). You started down a very scary, wrong path in life and literally through sheer will have come father than I’m willing to bet you ever thought you would.
I mean look at you… Every time you talk about Cal she sounds like a smart, well-adjusted girl; in case you don’t know YOU’RE responsible for that. You have a wonderful and loving husband who is the amazing father that Cal wanted; the awesome person you are made that happen. You started writing a blog that has seen all kinds of success. You’ve been published, you wrote this article for the Huffington Post, etc. All of this happened because of your talent and ability to draw people in with your writing. Whether it’s the crass, hilarious stuff you put on your blog or a serious piece like this, you can write your butt off woman.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Elizabeth Jayne Liu
12:04 AM on 05/09/2012
I love this just as it is...but I doubly loved it when you took the time to send me the full comment. xo
03:40 PM on 05/07/2012
Thank you SO much for sharing this. You are my favorite.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Elizabeth Jayne Liu
12:05 AM on 05/09/2012
It took me a while to work up the guts to share it, but I'm glad I finally did it.
12:59 AM on 05/05/2012
The phone permanently plugged in to a corner of your bedroom. Wow. A beautifully written, eloquent piece.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Elizabeth Jayne Liu
12:06 AM on 05/09/2012
Beth! Thank you. Hope to cross paths with you again soon.
09:02 PM on 05/04/2012
A beautifully written post. The idea that Cal held that prayer in your conversation inside brings tears to my eyes. I am so sorry for your pain. You feel the repercussions of his actions, but it is really him who is missing out on an amazing woman and her family. xoxo
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Elizabeth Jayne Liu
12:07 AM on 05/09/2012
I still hold out hope. But I think, sometimes, we all hope for things that don't come.
07:34 PM on 05/04/2012
Your yearning for a loving father brought tears to my eyes. I'm glad that you have a wonderful marriage and family.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Elizabeth Jayne Liu
12:08 AM on 05/09/2012
I'm grateful to have now what I didn't have then.
03:54 PM on 05/04/2012
Love this! Your father is missing out in a big way. So glad Cal isn't.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Elizabeth Jayne Liu
12:09 AM on 05/09/2012
Me too, girl, me too. Miss you!
12:19 PM on 05/04/2012
This was so powerful and sad and beautiful all at the same time, Elizabeth. I know that pain of having an indifferent parent. My parents and I stopped talking when I had my son. My dad was so upset that I'd gotten pregnant out of wedlock and that *GASP!* it was with a black man.(I'm white, not that it matters)
Luckily, when my son's father and I broke up, I moved back to MI a year and a half later to be close to family and start a life with my now husband. My parents started calling again and we have mostly fixed that broken relationship. I still have the emotional scars though.
You and Cal are so lucky to have a good husband and father in your lives. Something too many women take for granted. I have one, too. My hubs is a wonderful man and is trying to be the best father to my son that he can be. It's not always easy, but in the end, it will be worth it.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Elizabeth Jayne Liu
12:12 AM on 05/09/2012
It's so apparent what a wonderful man your husband is by the things you write about him. I fee like I've gotten to know a little through FB, and he *does* seem incredibly kind and, let's not forget, funny. Kudos to the men who step up to the task of being a great dad.
11:35 AM on 05/04/2012
Beautiful. Just beautiful. Family comes in many shapes and sizes, and I am so happy that you and your daughter found that missing piece of your family's puzzle. I am also sad for you that your dad doesn't want to be part of your wonderful life, though. Much love Liz!
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Elizabeth Jayne Liu
12:14 AM on 05/09/2012
Amen. Our family has been pieced together by birth, choice, and chance, and I'm so glad that Cal will experience something different and wonderful.
11:32 AM on 05/04/2012
This is one of my favorites. It hits home and I love and appreciate your honesty. Things and relationships in life don't usually get tied up neatly with a bow
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Elizabeth Jayne Liu
12:15 AM on 05/09/2012
...no matter how much we want them to be neat and tidy. So true.