iOS app Android app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Ellen Breslau


What Are Mothers-In-Law Afraid Of?

Posted: 08/09/2012 9:32 am

What are mothers-in-law afraid of? For many, it turns out, it's their daughters-in-law.

When I asked a writer friend of mine recently about her relationship with her daughter-in-law as it relates to her grandchildren, she barely skipped a beat before saying, "My motto is: Keep your wallet open, and your mouth shut." It surprised me at the time, but as I began to talk to other mothers-in-law, I found that the sentiment is hardly unique. (I myself am a daughter-in-law, and when I told my own mother-in-law about the conversation, she smiled then laughed what seemed to be the laugh of someone who could totally relate!)

Over the past two months, I've been on a mission to find a writer to blog for about her relationship with her daughter-in-law -- nothing scandalous, no dark secrets, just the normal ups and downs that come with the territory. Go to any parenting site and you'll find lots of daughters-in-law weighing in on the good, bad and ugly of dealing with their mother by marriage. I wanted to turn the tables and hear the other point of view. In fact, we already have a chat group on of 3,000 mothers-in-law who regularly discuss everything from long-distance grandparenting to how much they can discipline their grandchildren.

I've approached dozens of writers, and the response has been the same -- "Our relationship is too delicate," "It will do more harm than good", and the neutralizing, "We have a great relationship -- there's not much to say." I'm not suggesting that all mothers- and daughters-in-law have terrible relationships -- in fact many get along great -- some even better than with their own moms. But the relationship between a mother-in-law and daughter-in-law is like no other that we experience, especially when grandchildren are involved. A daughter-in-law can often feel like she's not doing enough for the kids in the mother-in-law's eyes, or worse, that she's doing it wrong. A mother-in-law can feel like she's unwelcome -- she's in the way, she's commenting when she shouldn't, she's overstepping her bounds.

The more I began to ask people about the relationship, the more I began to see what lies at the heart of the matter: mothers-in-law are afraid. Yours may come off as being in-your-business and opinionated, but really, she's afraid of being shut out. She clams up and "opens her wallet" as my writer friend said, in order to preserve the peace. Because if she doesn't do that, there is the possibility that she can kiss the grandkids goodbye. Though most people probably don't consciously think of the scenario this way, grandkids are for many grandparents, their biggest joy. And that joy can be taken away in an instant by the parents of the children. Translation: Don't annoy your daughter-in-law or there could be hell to pay.

So what's a mother-in-law to do? I asked the followers of our Facebook page what they do to make their relationship with their daughter-in-law run smoothly. Within minutes of the posting, we had loads of comments that ranged from the practical, "Be her friend, not her mom," to the philosophical, "Respect the fact that she is your son's wife, and treat her how you would want your MIL to treat you," to the often-cited "Mind-Your-Own-Business," to the perplexed, "I wish I knew." To me, when it comes right down to it, it's a matter of respect -- respect that your mother-in-law is afraid of you, her daughter-in-law, and you'll cut her more slack; and mothers-in-law, respect that your daughter-in-law knows what she's doing, and she will embrace you. Until then, I'm still searching for a blogger.

Earlier on Huff/Post50:

Loading Slideshow...
  • Child Care

    Eleven percent of grandparents have a grandchild living with them -- this jumps to 19 percent for African-American grandparents. Of the grandparent who have a grandchild living with them, 43 percent are the grandchild's primary caregiver. Some 16 percent of grandparents provide daycare services for their grandchildren when parents are at work or school.

  • Listening

    More than 80 percent of grandparents report speaking to their grandchildren on the phone at least once a month and more than a third communicate through new technologies such as e-mail, Skype, and text messaging. Some 58 percent of respondents said they speak to their grandchildren at least once a week.

  • Financial Help

    Forty percent of grandparents reported spending more than $500 on their grandchildren over the last 12 months. They widely report spending beyond traditional gifts, most noticeably contributing to education costs (53 percent), everyday living expenses (37 percent) and medical or dental costs (23 percent). <em>Flickr photo by: <a href="" target="_hplink">AMagill</a>.</em>

  • Discussing Values

    The majority of grandparents in the telephone survey indicated that they have discussed morals and values (78%) and religion or spirituality (66%) with at least one of their grandchildren. Other topics include peer pressure or bullying; illegal drugs; and drinking and alcohol use. Thirty-seven percent report discussing dating or sex with at least one of their grandchildren.

  • Sharing Religious Tradition

    As a corollary, nearly half (47%) indicated that they have attended religious services with their grandchildren in the past six months. <em>Flickr photo via: <a href="" target="_hplink">cogdogblog</a>.</em>

  • Having Fun

    About two-thirds of grandmothers said they take their grandchildren shopping (versus 58 percent of grandfathers); 63 percent of grandmothers cook or bake with the kids, versus 48 percent of grandfathers. Men were more likely to do physical activities with grandchildren -- 63 percent versus 56 percent of grandmothers.