More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Ellen Smith

Ellen Smith

Posted: September 17, 2010 02:01 PM

Federal investigators searching for the cause of the April 5 Upper Big Branch Mine disaster have collected evidence suggesting that the mine owner, Massey Energy, failed to adequately control coal dust.

During a Friday morning press conference, the federal Mine Safety and Health Administration said it has collected 1,803 rock dust samples from the mine, and so far 79 percent of the rock dust samples are not in compliance.

"It's fair to say coal dust played a role, but we have to evaluate the coking process," said Kevin Stricklin, who heads MSHA's coal division.

MSHA started taking rock dust samples every 500 feet beginning at the mantrip where some of the miners were found, and then decreased the space of the rock dust samples to every 100 feet. Then, as MSHA got to the working section, the investigators took samples at every cross cut.

When asked about the reliability of the samples, Stricklin said they are reliable because "the explosion would have used up some of the combustible content in the rock dust samples," so the samples may actually show less explosive content after the explosion than before the explosion.

MSHA said 90% of the investigation is complete. MSHA has collected 260 pieces of evidence, 183 documents, 3,000 underground photos with up to 20 teams underground doing their work.

The agency has also been able to pinpoint the exact time of the explosion at 3:02 p.m. and forty seconds.

MSHA said it still cannot find one methane detector from the longwall face. It has found five detectors from headgate 22, two from the headgate of the longwall, one from the longwall face, three on the mantrip where some of the miners bodies had been found.

The agency said it still has to clear water from headgate 22.

MSHA said it is considering questioning Massey Energy CEO Don Blankenship, but only if questioning can help in the investigation, and that it is planning a public hearing.

 
Federal investigators searching for the cause of the April 5 Upper Big Branch Mine disaster have collected evidence suggesting that the mine owner, Massey Energy, failed to adequately control coal dus...
Federal investigators searching for the cause of the April 5 Upper Big Branch Mine disaster have collected evidence suggesting that the mine owner, Massey Energy, failed to adequately control coal dus...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 5
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Daniel R Cobb
01:50 AM on 09/20/2010
MSHA's questioning of Don Blankenship should be under oath. This blowhard has a history of giving flippant remarks to reporter questions and flagrant fabrications in his public statements. Massey Energy (I believe it was Blankenship) tried to blame the blast that killed 29 miners at the Upper Big Branch Mine on an unforseeable methane pocket. But evidence shows that methane sensors are often disabled at Massey mines, THIS EXACT MINE was cited for safety violations over 1,300 times in the fiver years before the blast -- hundreds of times for excessive methane buildup. Massey Energy has repeatedly shown a flagrant disregard for miner's safety and the law. This industry has been poorly regulated for decades. See Crandall Canyone Mine. Unless things change, more will perish. http://www.themine-thebook.com
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:29 AM on 09/18/2010
Underground miners should be replaced by robots, until we're weaned from fossil fuels.

A search of Irobot's web site for mining doesn't show anything yet:

http://www.irobot.com/
iRobot Corporation: Home Page
12:06 AM on 09/18/2010
Well stated,Ms. Gordon. One of the saddest aspects is that Massey Energy will walk from this with no more than a tap on the wrist,and Don Blankenship will "retire" with a hefty severance. All with little or no outcry from the local populace or politicians,save for the families of those lost.

A question for the staunch RW and TP crowd: How in the hell does your conscience not bother you as you clamor and rant for more deregulation in this and so many other unsafe industries(among the few we haven't given away) in this once-great nation? Even if it's only by a sense of proxy, you have blood on your hands.

I'm not seeing a whole lot of clamor from the Left or Progressive ideology(or the current administration) to demand justice for the miners or the 11 Deepwater Horizon employees or the many others lost,and who will be lost as time goes on,either.

I would perhaps consider Unions to be the voice of the workers left,but if other Unions are anything like what the current UAW has become,the worker's voices will be stifled. Just look at what's occurring at the Indianapolis GM Stamping plant for proof of what the UAW has regressed to. A topic for HuffPost to look into,perhaps?
08:21 PM on 09/17/2010
All that money; all those tests-to prove what we knew the day of the explosion.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
02:42 AM on 09/18/2010
So sad!