iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Emily V. Gordon

Emily V. Gordon

GET UPDATES FROM Emily V. Gordon

Did You Know, Deep Down, That You'd Get Divorced One Day?

Posted: 04/ 4/11 09:25 AM ET

While at a recent fun dinner, some acquaintances and I were surprised to discover that three out of seven of us had been divorced. Some of us were remarried, some were freshly uncoupled, some were dating, and as the night got more and more dishy, one of the non-divorcees asked if any of us ever had a gut feeling from the start that the marriage was not going to work out. The three divorcees, bonded by our marital histories, looked at each other with dumb recognition. Yes, yes we'd all had reservations about getting married, tucked away in some tiny, shushed pit of our stomachs. We'd all been quietly scared of what we were about to do, and one by one we confessed our reasons for not listening to ourselves -- I thought it was too late to cancel, I thought that everyone felt scared and wrong on their wedding day, I thought marriage would be the thing to fix our relationship. Hindsight is always 20/20, but I imagine a lot of married and divorced people have insights to share about how they felt during their engagement.

Without further adieu, I address this post to the engaged people out there who are wondering if they're making the right decision.

So you're getting married?! That's exciting! Maybe you're planning a huge beautiful event, or maybe you're just having a small ceremony and going to dinner with your parents -- but no matter the size of the wedding, at some point it might start to feel like it's picking up a life of its own, steaming ahead no matter what. If you're wondering if you should be getting married, it's time for a gut check.

How do you know if what you're feeling is just pre-wedding jitters, which are totally natural, and not something more serious?

Take Away Distractions
No matter how busy you are, either planning your wedding or just going through your everyday life, it is more important than ever to take time for yourself. Not for manicures or video games, but to physically be with yourself. Set aside about 15 minutes a day that you just sit in a quiet, non-distracting place with your thoughts, and listen to yourself. What comes up? If things are nagging at you now, there is nothing that a party and some cake is going to correct, so instead of distracting yourself with wedding planning, give yourself time to respect any concerns you have about your marriage.

Put Your Emotions On Paper
How do you feel about being married to your fiancee? Quick, take a moment and write down every single emotion that you have when you think, not about your wedding day, but about being married. Take your time. When you're done, divide up those emotions into positive and negative ones, and check out your list. What themes do you notice? If you really want to get down to the nitty gritty, have your fiancee do this exercise as well and talk about the emotions you both come up with. If my ex and I had done this, maybe we would have seen that we both had the same concerns that we were just getting married because it was the age that a lot of people got married.

Why Are You Getting Married?
Now, I don't mean this in a sense of "why does marriage exist as an institution?" It's a wonderful institution, one that should be enjoyed by all people. What I mean is what made you decide to get married to the person you're marrying at this point in your life? Are you getting married because he asked you? Are you getting married because you've been together a while and you're of "marrying age"? Are you getting married because you want to start building a life with your partner, and this is a huge step in that direction? A lot of people end up getting married more out of expectation than out of passion for each other, but if your options have ever been "we either get married or break up," be careful. Marriage should be a new addition you add to the house that is your relationship, not the structure you impose on the house once it's already built. This is not to say that marriages based on practicality can't be happy and wonderful, but merely to say that what you want, deep down, should never be pushed aside for what you're supposed to want.

How Is Your Relationship?
Take a snapshot of your relationship exactly as it is right now. Freeze. What you must expect is that your relationship will be, no matter how fancy the wedding ceremony or how great the honeymoon, exactly like this for the rest of your lives. No changes whatsoever. Is that something you're okay with, or is part of you convinced that the relationship will evolve once rings are involved? Because I can tell you now -- time evolves a relationship, living together evolves a relationship, and adding responsibilities evolves a relationship. Marriage, on its own, does not. It also does not fix relationships.

Of the divorcees I know, the number one question that we all wish someone had asked us as we went headlong into marriage was, "If you could walk away with absolutely no consequences, would you do it?" Think about it honestly. When I worked with children in the past, I would watch them throw these epic temper tantrums, and out of desperation one day I asked a kid who'd been yelling and crying for about 10 minutes if he was tired and wished he could stop and pretend he never started having a tantrum. He looked up at me through tears and nodded, so I told him his secret would be safe with me. He got up and walked into another room, where I found him playing quietly.

Sometimes we put so much effort into things we're doing, like dating or wedding planning, that we don't stop to think about whether or not we even want the results of that effort. Marriage, even a happy and successful one, can be extremely stressful, but that stress is worth it if you're marrying the best person for you. I write this not in an effort to stop people from getting married, but merely to encourage people to take marriage incredibly seriously. There is nothing you can't walk away from, but if you think leaving a fiancee is hard, try leaving a spouse. Keep asking yourself questions and giving yourself gut checks to make sure you're making a decision that is best for you and best for your relationship.

We would love to hear your own stories of thoughts you had as you were preparing to walk down the aisle -- were you terrified, were you excited, were you trying not to think about it, and how did that correlate with the success of the relationship? Tell us in the comments!

 

Follow Emily V. Gordon on Twitter: www.twitter.com/thegynomite

While at a recent fun dinner, some acquaintances and I were surprised to discover that three out of seven of us had been divorced. Some of us were remarried, some were freshly uncoupled, some were dat...
While at a recent fun dinner, some acquaintances and I were surprised to discover that three out of seven of us had been divorced. Some of us were remarried, some were freshly uncoupled, some were dat...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 491
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (14 total)
10:21 PM on 04/18/2011
This article inspired me to write a post about how to relate - http://owenmarcus.com/?p=2312.

I know the more honest I am first to myself, the more honest I am with my partner.
08:54 PM on 04/23/2011
That's fine, but will she be honest with you? You got any idea how many women marry men they don't love? How's that for dishonesty?
09:17 PM on 04/23/2011
Probably as many men who marry women they don't love. We all need training in honesty. It is difficult telling the truth then it can hurt someone.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
WorkersUnited
10:44 PM on 04/08/2011
What a lot of people don't take into account regarding marriage is that we are living a lot longer than even a decade ago. The average life expectancy in the US is 79 years old now.

People aren't built to be with the same person for that long- especially if you marry in your early 20's. People change throughout their lives and marriage is a dying institution. We will probably go the way of Europe and just have a lot of cohabitation and common law marriages.
06:56 PM on 04/08/2011
I think one of the problems in society is that marriage is viewed as a means of self-fulfillment and it can't really live up to that over the long haul. If we changed our view of marriage as a means to serve others, then it doesn't disappoint because you never run out of opportunities to serve your wife and kids.

If you're divorced and don't want your kids to end up like you, share my book with them so the cycle doesn't have to repeat.

http://www.scribd.com/doc/44437016/Teenagers-Say-the-Darndest-Things

Good Luck,
Irwin
08:58 PM on 04/23/2011
"If we changed our view of marriage as a means to serve others, then it doesn't disappoint because you never run out of opportunit­ies to serve your wife and kids." Irwin

The above might as well read: "If we changed our view of indentured servitude as a means to serve others, then it doesn't disappoint because you never run out of opportunit­ies to serve your master and kids."
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
mombabytiger
Looking into the heart of an artichoke.
06:56 PM on 04/08/2011
I knew marrying my husband was wrong, but I did it anyway and because of the economy I'm stuck with him. Think carefully before you marry, and listen to that voice in your head. It's probably right.
08:59 PM on 04/23/2011
Sounds like a wonderful life.
03:08 PM on 04/08/2011
GREAT READ. It's been over a year since I've gotten divorced from my first marriage. I thought he was what I wanted. He was one to cat-around. I didn't learn of this until a year after we'd been married. I 'laid the law down'. I swore I wasn't going to end up like my parents, but I stayed with it. Over time I just grew from disgust, to resentment, to nearly hate. In my gut, even back to the moment he asked me, I knew a trip to the Big D was inevitable.. Why I did said yes anyway? I guess I thought he could get me out of the small town way of things. Move me near the big city. Or maybe I thought I wasn't going to do any better? Sad. Divorced changed me.. maybe not in a positive way. If I could go back, I would have said no.
01:01 AM on 04/21/2011
Very sad Alexis. Whether you marry again or not I hope you find a great guy. Good luck.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:37 PM on 04/08/2011
I knew, deep down, that I would not be getting a divorce. I didn't plan to ever get married, I didn't want to get married. But when I thought of living a life without her by my side, everything looked dark and hopeless. I proposed on a broad Mediterranean seashore with the sun glinting off the ocean and the white sand, stretching to the horizon. She gave me the biggest, happiest smile I had ever seen, and said Yes.

That was nearly 44 years ago. I love her still with all my heart, and she loves me. The future turned out to be bright and happy. I am grateful to her and her love more than words can ever say.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Venicelady
Ignorance is NOT bliss.
12:56 PM on 04/10/2011
What a nice story!
01:02 AM on 04/21/2011
Excellent. Happy for both of you.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
persuter
12:03 PM on 04/08/2011
I find it just simply bizarre that a couples therapist can be divorced. Honestly, Ms. Gordon, I don't mean any disrespect to you, but if I was looking for golf coaches, I'd look for someone who has a decent swing. If I'm looking for a cooking class, I want the teacher who doesn't burn scrambled eggs. Half the marriages in this country end in divorce - I don't think it's too unreasonable to suggest that the couples therapists should come from the OTHER half.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Venicelady
Ignorance is NOT bliss.
12:58 PM on 04/10/2011
One would think that people who are giving such advice would tend to have happy and stable marriages themselves. Otherwise, how could their advice be credible?

Totally agree with you.
09:06 PM on 04/23/2011
Well, their advice on what mistakes to avoid would be credible.

You know, been there, done that.
10:15 AM on 04/08/2011
I've wondered myself, since leaving my husband, if I knew from the start that something wasn't right. What's tricky is that current feelings color our memories so much more strongly than many of us realize. It's just too easy to say NOW that I knew better THEN. It's easy because it makes me feel like I've done the indisputably right thing by leaving. Did I really know better then, though? When I was married (for 13 years, many seasons of which were happy), I'd focus on my recollection of those glowing moments when I knew in my gut that he was the right man. Now I bring to mind those niggling moments when I felt a deep foreignness in him, like we weren't the same species and nothing could make us right together. I sometimes wish I'd known better then, but I can't help thinking the beautiful times I shared with this human being were worth it. Oh, crap, I'm officially a Garth Brooks song.
03:09 PM on 04/08/2011
LOL. Toby Keith wishes he knew now what he didn't know then too.. ;)
08:00 AM on 04/08/2011
I was never consciously aware that I thought I'd be divorced, and certainly, it's something that is just "not done" in our family. We dated for 5 years before getting married, and yes...I was thrilled to be marrying him. Looking back, however, there were signs of my reticence to embrace my married life: hyphenating my name on my drivers' license took over 2 years, I didn't pick up a copy of our marriage license until almost a year later. I had been battling health issues for years when we got married, and when I began to feel better and really embrace my life, and myself as a person...that's when things began to deteriorate. It makes me sad to think that the commencement of my life as a healthy and vibrant 30 year old was the impetus of my marriage breaking down. We just began to want different things: I wanted to travel and explore life and be around my friends and family, and he wanted to settle in to working on our house and starting a family. In hindsight, perhaps the lack of urgency in changing my name was my way of holding on to "me"; something that ended up being compromised after 6 years of marriage. I don't regret it; he's a wonderful man. But I will never do it again.
09:22 PM on 04/07/2011
I had that feeling, Had even broken off the engagement at one point. And now after 6 mostly bad years of marriage we are divorcing. And our daughter will be paying the highest price of all. I'm looking forward to telling her to trust her gut when it comes to choosing a partner.
03:43 PM on 04/07/2011
Yes, I knew that I was making a mistake. One day about a month before my wedding, I looked at my fiance and suddenly I knew in my gut that I didn't love him for a lifetime. My relatives attributed it to pre-wedding jitters. I wasn't strong enough to call off the wedding. The one positive aspect is that I had two children and am a grandmother of two.
07:50 AM on 04/07/2011
In my studies of ancient human patterns and history i have found that there is a time for a union between two people to take place and with a certain type of person that is destined to be your mate.
I also know that the moment of truth comes as you walk down the aisle to take the vows. There should be at this point a straw for the person to clutch such as an out. The wedding can take place but only be finalized 72 hours after the ceremony and by the signature of both parties involved. In allowing such a thing it removes the pressure of expectations of friends and family who have all some investment in the ceremony. At least they get what they came for and the couple taking the vows still have an escape clause should they need it.
There is a small voice in the back of your mind that warns you when you go down the aisle,,
A simple message comes to you. Don't do it.....!!!!
07:39 AM on 04/07/2011
I speak as someone who broke a long term relationship because of the marriage ultimatum. I subsequently met the right person. Aside from the stresses of the wedding itself, deciding to get married should be an easy and stress free decision. If anyone is having to rack their brain to make it, then you're not with the right person. Simple as that.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LeeScho
poised on a longing
10:32 PM on 04/06/2011
I married because after 18 years in and out of the relationship, I knew that marriage would be the final arbiter of the value and endurance of the relationship. We divorced four years later. I did not think that it would last that long - although it did not given its quality. I am neither for nor against marriage generally. It works for some and not for others. Happy hunting!
10:13 PM on 04/06/2011
Ahem. "Without further ADO," not "adieu."
11:57 AM on 04/08/2011
Thank you, had to be said.