iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Ethan Rome

Ethan Rome

GET UPDATES FROM Ethan Rome
 

Will Attacking Planned Parenthood Create Jobs?

Posted: 02/16/11 02:42 PM ET

The House Republicans seem to be saying yes. Apparently, they think that taking away women's access to reproductive health services is an important way to create jobs and get the economy moving again.

That may explain the urgency of Rep. Mike Pence's disgraceful legislation to defund Planned Parenthood and other providers by stripping them of Title X family-planning funding, since creating jobs is the stated priority of the Republicans in Congress. The Republicans also want to take away the cost-savings and consumer protections in the new health care law, the Affordable Care Act, because this too will apparently create jobs. This is the same GOP that wants to undermine the new law, including re-opening the abortion compromise that maintained the prohibition against federal funds paying for abortions. This is so important to the Republicans that they made one of the bills relating to this issue H.R. 3, among the very first taken up by the House in the 112th Congress. No wonder people are asking Speaker John Boehner, "When are the jobs?"

The GOP is gripped by two obsessions -- rolling back the clock on women's health services and giving control of our health care back to the insurance companies. They want to take us back to the days when insurance companies could deny your care because you have a "pre-existing condition," drop you for getting sick and jack up your rates whenever they feel like it. They want to return to the time when being a woman was a pre-existing condition. They want to entirely eliminate family planning funds. When it comes to health care in general and women's health in particular, the Republicans don't have a legislative agenda to move forward - just a fixation on tearing things down and moving backwards.

Meanwhile, the Republicans aren't doing a single thing to create jobs. They're too busy trying to put the insurance companies back in charge of our health care. They're too busy going after vital health care institutions like Planned Parenthood. They're too busy trying to get between a woman and her doctor. That is especially galling because the insurance companies have made decisions about our health care for decades. Thanks to the Affordable Care Act, those days are over. Now the House Republicans want to be the ones making those decisions for women. This is nothing short of a war on women and their health care. And it's happening in state capitals as well as Washington, D.C.

This hypocrisy is extreme, even by the standards the Republicans have set since taking control of the House. Take Speaker Boehner's less-than-authentic comments on the matter of the President's religion and birthplace. He has said again and again that he doesn't want to tell the American people "what to think" -- or tell members of his own caucus to stop lying about these basic matters of fact. The Speaker's line is offensive -- a transparent wink and a nod to those who continue spreading lies about President Obama to intentionally stoke the flames of the far right.

One question comes to mind: If Boehner is not willing to "tell people what to think" about something so important and basic as the legitimacy of the president of the United States, why is it okay to tell women and their doctors what to do?

Seriously, enough already.

Cross posted on the NOW! Blog


 

Follow Ethan Rome on Twitter: www.twitter.com/@HCAN

 
 
  • Comments
  • 67
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
12:39 AM on 02/20/2011
I am a very conservative democrat, and this is precisely why i will never call myself a republican. please explain to me how it is fiscally or socially sound to cut funding for the largest provider of contraception, sex education and health care to women who can't otherwise afford it?? if this actually passes through legislation (and i have faith that it won't) i would like to say that i would sit back and laugh as all the republicans watch the statistics on teen pregnancy, abortion rates and welfare recipients rise in the absence of Planned Parenthood, but i will be too busy crying as i look at my paycheck and see the enormous increases in taxes that are being taken out to pay for these things.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ninetailedfox
banning people.....so childish
09:27 AM on 02/18/2011
Attacking christianity and christian dogma may not create jobs, but now people tend to forget that the revisionists, the history destroyers, the flat earth society, were always christians. We arent out of the dark ages yet, as much as people would like to believe we are somehow a progressive culture, if that were the case, we wouldnt allow christians to infringe upon the rights of everyone else.
itolduso
lateral thinker
12:00 AM on 02/18/2011
The Republican's actions are responsible for creating more than a 'job' for me........they have given me a 'mission'........ to protest, speak out, and fight every small minded, hypocritical, selfish, shortsighted, and undemocratic policy proposal they bring forth. Judging by current activities in Wisconsin & Ohio, I don't think I'm the only one they've inspired.
11:31 AM on 02/18/2011
You define the leftist agenda as one of morality, but as Grover Norquist recently remarked, "The left is comprised of competing parasites." Wealth redistribution appears to be the highest priority amongst those on left, and seeing the public's unwillingness to continue to pump more money down these rabbit holes, the public employee unions are throwing the loudest temper tantrum to ensure that they are the alpha parasite.
itolduso
lateral thinker
12:08 PM on 02/18/2011
My agenda is not based on 'morality' , rather, it's a matter of good business sense. It's about not sacrificing the future for short-term profit. It's about 'investing' in the things that are important- protecting your natural resources, increasing the education & skills of your workforce, understanding that 'labor' is just as (if not more) vital to my success as 'equipment', & just as worthy of maintaining & keeping strong & healthy......it's understanding that a strong, prosperous community is a 'business asset' that is worth nurturing, protecting, and contributing to....and that a fair, well regulated system ensures opportunity for all to grow together, as opposed to some growing at the expense of most.
09:35 PM on 02/17/2011
the dems have been in control of the house and senate for 4 years, and had the potus for the last 2, so, with obamatrons horrific spending, I ask you where are the jobs? no during the nov2 landslide to elections that will be landslide in 2012 again, we the conservative majority elected officials to stop the obama agenda first and foremost, which will help jobs. we will abolish obamacare, the EPAs power grabs, the FCCs power grabs, the czars, the spending, the overpowered unions, and what ever else this american hating potus shoves down our throats. have a great day.
04:55 PM on 02/17/2011
I am a Republican and I don't want to get rid of a woman's right to choose- however, I don't want to pay for it out of my pocket. Abortion should not be used as birth control, but only used when a woman's life is in jeopardy, which is extremely rare. If someone wants an abortion, go for it but pay for it yourself.
04:47 PM on 02/17/2011
When a child is conceived, its "name" (DNA-?) is recorded in God's Book of Life, and because it didn't mature as expected, it is automatically recorded in The Lamb's Book of Life.
itolduso
lateral thinker
12:12 AM on 02/18/2011
Please explain how some can fight so hard to save the fetus....and simultaniously seek to destroy it's future.
11:18 AM on 04/09/2011
Because you seem to think you can determine everyone's future. That is the beauty of it all. You cannot know what those futures hold. The people being aborted may very well have been the ones that solved some of the most complex and distressing problems of our times. You are in no position to judge anyone's future.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
myth buster
02:18 PM on 02/18/2011
But woe to the one who raises his or her hand against the child in malice, for "It would be better for that one to have a millstone tied around his neck and be cast into the sea."
04:44 PM on 02/17/2011
Think this thru once.

We are missing 50,000,000 citizens since about 1975.

If they were here, they'd probably buy something, which of course has to be manufactured. They might want or need a house or a car, and so on.
07:56 AM on 02/18/2011
Oh, dear, me.

If they were here, you're probably right that some of them would buy something. Some others would be unemployed. Some others would be selling crack. Some others would be soldiers, policemen/women, doctors, lawyers. Some others would be pimps, porn stars, etc. Some would be born to loving families, who were ready and able to care for and raise a child, while others would be born to parents unprepared for parenthood.

I can guarantee you this, however. Whatever good may or may not have come from ending abortion in this country, I can assure you that it would also bring more than its fair share of ill. You should Google "Ceaușescu".
01:40 PM on 02/17/2011
I just searched HuffPo, and found that there is NOT ONE SINGLE story on here about Live Action and their LIES about Planned Parenthood! Excuse me, but this tactic of LYING as pimps an hos, getting featured on Breitbart and FOX, then passing through the GOP and weak-willed Democrats' desks to defund a community based non-profit that actually helps people, has already happened to Acorn and it is happening again, and yet the Huffington Post has NOTHING to say on this story? This article here barely scratches the surface in what should be a front page expose! Come on Huffinton Post, get on the ball, FOX news is already rolling with it.
12:02 AM on 02/18/2011
Can you provide specific examples of how Live Action has lied, and/or how the tapes they produced, which clearly showed that numerous Planned Parenthood offices in three states were just "cool" with underage illegal sex slaves? I thought this was an organization which protected women. That's the message that the left has been brandishing like a billy club these past 3 decades. But apparently Planned Parenthood's primary mission is to sell abortions. It appears to be the only mission. Meanwhile taxpayer dollars pay half the bills! What a great scam. I wish I was that clever, but then there's that pesky "having a human soul" bit to get in the way for most of us.
07:58 AM on 02/18/2011
kungfoochimp, I'm curious what you think PP should have done in those circumstances? Perform a citizen's arrest? What? What is is exactly that you think the videos revealed about PP?

They reported the encounter at each and every site that Live Action visited, in accordance with the law.
12:27 AM on 02/20/2011
you want specific examples of how Live Action lied?? ok... how about the fact that someone went into a PP clinic claiming to be a pimp. lie. someone went in claiming to have underage girls working for him. lie. someone claimed that they had potentially received an STI from an underage girl. lie. the whole premise of the tapes is a lie.

and no...'numerous PP offices in 3 states were not cool with it'. one employee acted in bad judgement and she was immediately terminated. all other employees gave the proper information and then contacted authorities, including the FBI to notify them.

and please educate yourself before you comment. no taxpayer dollars go to fund abortions, at PP or anywhere else. all this ridiculous bill does is cut off funding for services that prevent unintended pregnancies (i.e. birth control and sex education for women who can't otherwise afford it), hence, preventing the need for abortion.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Kara Kramer
09:48 PM on 02/16/2011
Perhaps they're trying to create jobs for back street abortionists and funeral parlours.
12:07 AM on 02/18/2011
Oh, you mean like Dr. Kermit Gosnell? The Philadelphia abortionist who was recently charged with 8 counts of murder - seven of which were nearly full term babies he delivered, then cut through their necks with scissors? The guy that kept trophy feet of some of the babies who's necks he severed in cold blood, while the PA State Dept of Health looked the other way out of political correctness? Tsk....I know what you mean Kara!
07:59 AM on 02/18/2011
And Dr. Gosnell has... what, exactly, to do with the current discussion?

There are dirty cops in the world; does this mean we should disband our police forces? I thought not.
08:55 PM on 02/16/2011
Thank you! This is what I've been saying for the longest time! Republicans got elected with one set of public priorities and a second set of private priorities--and those voters who expected that they would follow through with their jobs-creation strategy need to pay attention and vote these turkeys out come November. Spending time trying to quell women's and children's health initiatives is not what they were elected to do.
12:08 AM on 02/18/2011
I pictured the mom from "What's Eating Gilbert Grape" when I read your comment.
photo
George Hanshaw
There are none so blind as those who will not see.
08:04 PM on 02/16/2011
We are currently borrowing 43 cents of every federal dollar spent. The deficit is now $1.65 Trillion annually and the accumulated debt is over $14 Trillion.

Not a single economist from either party believes these trends are sustainable or that taxes can be successfully raised to cover our existing expenditures.

Government funding simply HAS to be cut. We have no other options.
09:34 PM on 02/16/2011
Raise taxes on the wealthy.

Option One.
photo
George Hanshaw
There are none so blind as those who will not see.
11:34 PM on 02/16/2011
Oh, you can RAISE taxes. That's the easy part. Actually collecting revenue from those raised taxes is more difficult. By and large te federal government has never been able to raise much more than 20% of GDP from taxes EVER. Even when the top rate was 91%.

The average has been about 18%.
09:38 PM on 02/16/2011
Start with the military, not negligible spending.
I suspect you are simply reinforcing your own family planning prejudices.
Women should be informed and have access to all options
Not just the ones bible thumpers approve of.
photo
George Hanshaw
There are none so blind as those who will not see.
11:26 PM on 02/16/2011
“Start with the military, not negligible spending."

Negligible? No.

Enough (even if you took it all?) No.

We have a $1.65 Trillion deficit. Even if we ELIMINATED the military, it's less than a Trillion.

"I suspect you are simply reinforcin­g your own family planning prejudices­."
Well I think you are ignorant. In fact I've DONE abortions (granted, only in the first trimester). All you have to do is grasp the cervix in the 12 o'clock position with a toothed tenaculum, dilate progressively with Hegar dilators and when the cervix is sufficiently dilated insert a curette and curette carefully in a 360 degree circle. Once you've heard the sort of scratchy, sandpaper-like noise the myometrium makes when you've scraped off the endometrium, you can scarcely forget it.

"Women should be informed and have access to all options"

Hey, that's like motherhood and apple pie. Who could disagree. The thing is, we don't have enough money to run the government. Some things people have to pay for on their own.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Devontate
PrObama
07:04 PM on 02/16/2011
Thank you!!
I heart male feminists. My fondest hope is that the GOP is showing its true colors, and its constituency will slowly start to defect, the more moderate among them anyway. I hope this is just a show of their defiance in the face of progress that they know they cannot stop.
12:18 AM on 02/18/2011
I've been asking people this question for a long time, and few seem willing to answer it. What is the end point of this "progress"? I am picturing some sort of Logan's Run domed city with uniforms and bad food.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ninetailedfox
banning people.....so childish
06:45 PM on 02/16/2011
Planned Parenthood gives people jobs. Sounds to me like the Christians just want to attack an issue that bothers them.
12:25 AM on 02/18/2011
I am not a Christian, but I oppose abortion, as well as the death penalty. I oppose abortion because the baby is innocent. I oppose the death penalty for the same reason - we accidentally kill innocent people from time to time. So why should I be expected to pay for someone's abortion? Even if they use the tax money to nominally pay for other bills, it's all one big pot of money in the end. I don't want to make abortion illegal. There are some people who should not be parents, and not enough people will adopt, so it's a necessary evil (albeit a very ugly one). But don't make me pay for it.

I picture some culture in the future being told that "in the American culture it was quite common, and acceptable for mother's to kill their unborn babies. It wasn't out of necessity due to poor living conditions, warfare, or lack of food. Babies were considered an inconvenience."
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ninetailedfox
banning people.....so childish
09:25 AM on 02/18/2011
a fetus is not a baby. As much as I despised Hitler, Goebbles said one wise thing: A lie told many times becomes the truth. I guess that is what is going on in American society, people have told lies so often that people tend to forget that the real liars are christians.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
FL TallMan
Disabled Vietnam Vet
06:18 PM on 02/16/2011
The GOP is supposed to be against BIG government. But, how much bigger can the government be than when it dictates what a woman can legally do with her own body.

With the current proposals from the Republications - defunding Head Start, eliminating Planned Parenthood, reducing student lunch programs, denying child health care - they want to direct everything a woman can or can't do once pregnant, but their caring ends at birth.

Hey Repubs: Get out of the examination room! Get out of the doctor's office! Get out of the private lives of women! Get out of women's wombs!
09:52 AM on 02/17/2011
You're missing the point. Whether you agree with it or not the proposal is to shrink govt and govt spending. No one is saying the govt should dictate what a woman can do. All the GOP is saying is that taxpayers should not fund Planned Parenthood. The organization can continue to operate in any fashion it chooses. To suggest this would be growing govt is patently false.

I see bot sides of the argument. In my opinion PP offers valuable services to women, but taxpayer funds should never be used for abortion.
01:35 PM on 02/17/2011
Sure, so instead of using tax funds to provide poor, vulnerable, and disavantaged women contitutionally protected health care options, we should instead give $700 billion of our tax funds to the "poor" "suffering" class of people who make $250,000 a year.
11:30 AM on 04/09/2011
How hypocritical. Abortion funding by the Federal government is what gets inside women's wombs, Silly. People against that funding are asking the government to stay OUT of those wombs for 9 months, only.
05:20 PM on 02/16/2011
Yes, attacking planned parenthood, literally and figuratively, will create LOW WAGE jobs.