More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Evan Wolfson

GET UPDATES FROM Evan Wolfson
 

The Freedom To Marry: What's Next After New York?

Posted: 06/25/11 08:12 PM ET

New York is not the first state to have its legislature end the exclusion of lesbian and gay couples from marriage, but this time is different.

With Friday's vote for families and fairness, the number of Americans living in states with the freedom to marry more than doubled, from 16 million to 35 million.

New York's embrace of the freedom to marry marks the first time that a Republican-led chamber of a legislature -- in this case the state senate -- voted to advance a bill to end marriage discrimination, and Republican senators provided the winning margin.

And New York's legislature becomes the first to pass a marriage bill without taking a detour through the temporary way-station of a civil union or domestic partnership. New York heeded the lesson of Vermont and other states that first experimented with civil unions, and embraced the full freedom to marry after concluding that these half-measures don't fully protect families or fulfill the constitutional command of equality.

Fifteen years ago, only 27 percent of Americans approved of ending discrimination in marriage. But as gays and lesbians have talked with family and friends about why marriage matters, hearts have opened and minds have changed. Today, that number has literally doubled. According to a recent Washington Post poll, and confirmed by five other national polls, more than 52 percent of the public supports the freedom to marry for same-sex couples.

Hitting a majority for marriage was a big milestone in this American journey of inclusion and fairness, but having New York end marriage discrimination is a turning point for the country. The world watches New York, and, as New Yorkers say, if we can make it here, we'll make it anywhere -- but only if the ever-expanding community of people who support the freedom to marry do the work to bring it home nationwide.

What will that look like?

We will secure the freedom to marry in more states. American history teaches that human rights and social justice movements must make gains at the state level, with some states serving as engines to tug the conversation and country forward. In every state (and every country) that has ended the denial of marriage to same-sex couples, support for the freedom to marry has only increased. People see with their own eyes that gays and lesbians in their state who get married share the hope and joy of other couples, and the heartfelt desire to make and strengthen a lifelong commitment to the person they love.

With each state win, we will inspire other states to follow. Republican support -- from Ken Mehlman, the former chair of the Republican National Committee, to Barbara Bush, the daughter of President George W. Bush -- was critical to passing the law through New York's Republican-controlled state senate. Democratic Governor Andrew Cuomo was the indispensable champion of the marriage bill, speaking often of the need for New York to live up to history and once again lead the way for the nation. New York's bipartisan triumph for the freedom to marry signals a major shift in the national political calculus for both parties and points the way to more victories.

We will continue to grow the number of Americans who support the freedom to marry. Not only is there now majority support for ending discrimination in marriage, but the freedom to marry is riding a demographic wave. Roughly 60 percent of millennials -- voters under 30, who represent the largest generation ever -- overwhelmingly support marriage rights for loving, committed same-sex couples. Their support ranges across virtually every demographic, including Republicans and even evangelicals. Elected officials looking to the future, let alone history, see voters -- Democratic, independent, and increasingly, Republican -- who want them to stand for the freedom to marry.

And we will tackle and end federal marriage discrimination. Under the so-called "Defense of Marriage Act" stampeded through Congress in 1996 -- before gay couples could marry anywhere in the world --tens of thousands of legally married couples are denied the 1138-plus federal protection and responsibilities triggered by marriage, including Social Security, immigration rights and fair tax treatment.

With court challenges mounting, the Department of Justice concluding that DOMA is indefensible under the Constitution, and the Respect for Marriage Act now pending in Congress to repeal DOMA, history's gaze now falls on our leaders in Washington, D.C. (where couples can legally marry, thanks to a legislative vote last year) to do their part in securing the freedom to marry.

President Obama has stated that his views on marriage are "evolving," and that "gay couples deserve the same legal rights as every other couple in this country." He has much to gain, and very little to lose, by joining the national majority for marriage and standing with the millennials, Democrats and independents who favor the freedom to marry, and the Republicans who have begun to speak with more clarity than he has. It's time now for the president, like all of us in New York celebrating our new statute of liberty, to say, "I do support the freedom to marry."

EVAN WOLFSON is the President of Freedom to Marry, the campaign to win marriage nationwide, and author of Why Marriage Matters: America, Equality, and Gay People's Right to Marry.

 

Follow Evan Wolfson on Twitter: www.twitter.com/freedomtomarry

New York is not the first state to have its legislature end the exclusion of lesbian and gay couples from marriage, but this time is different. With Friday's vote for families and fairness, the nu...
New York is not the first state to have its legislature end the exclusion of lesbian and gay couples from marriage, but this time is different. With Friday's vote for families and fairness, the nu...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 125
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
11:46 AM on 06/27/2011
The religious right is desperately thinking up their next fear tactic on how the “gays” will now destroy all of us.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bill J4321
11:40 AM on 06/27/2011
Every LGBT citizen should realize how lucky we are to be alive at this point in history. To be able to bear witness to our own emancipation.

It makes me feel a bit sad for those who came before us, that they did not get to see this day. I would love for Harvey Milk to have seen this happen. But since he can not, at least Anita Bryant has! (For those who don't know who Anita is, she's the Maggie Gallagher or the 70's.) I love that Anita Bryant gets to witness this, since she started much of the animus in this country toward us.

I honestly never thought I'd live to see this day. Thank you, Evan. Your work will make a difference in the lives of countless gay children who will not have to grow up believing that they are worthy of less and deserving of nothing just because their families and their society tells them so.

Thank you, thank you, thank you, Evan!

"You gotta give 'em hope!" ~ Harvey Milk
09:20 PM on 06/26/2011
Evan,
As a fellow native Pittsburgher, I can't thank you enough for your decades of tireless work on this issue. You are my hero!
daltexdude
Equality. Now.
08:55 PM on 06/26/2011
Congratulations to New York on a job well done!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Gary Dorrington
08:24 PM on 06/26/2011
Congratulations on doing the right thing New York, something that California failed to do. I'm sure now that gay marriage will become legal here now, if for no other reason than, not wanting to be outdone by New York.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Pam Herman
10:18 AM on 06/27/2011
There's nothing like a little friendly competition between states. :)
wsdave
Abusive or Insulting? I won't be responding.
08:23 PM on 06/26/2011
"...but only if the ever-expanding community of people who support the freedom to marry do the work to bring it home nationwide."

You mean get rid of every politician except Ron Paul?
05:49 PM on 06/26/2011
The rest of my day is pretty full but before I click out, I wanted to thank users Jon Eric Evans, TraceyES, leftLibertarian and sb1285n for a very stimulating exchange. I salute you and HP for a forum that doesn't mod to pieces opposing opinion but... still while maintaining a courteous environment.

In closing this out, I'd like to share a few views...

I think of humanity as something akin to an ongoing, biological experiment that has a beginning, a middle and an end. That ending is something that we are all working for; a place where all of our specie's many, many ills are finally cured and we have matured as a race to the threshhold of whatever awaits us.

We are a race of billions of people over thousands of generations that have all been plowing through time to a small point somewhere yet off in the distance. Things don't happen quickly but, they do happen.

Women's rights? Civil rights? The end of slavery? All of these were ideals for centuries before they were finally realized. Untold numbers who suffered through mankind's worst racial and gender specific concepts, were no less interested in liberation than those who finally realized it.

So, what we do today doesn't have to be for us. We just look at ourselves in the mirror and say, 'this isn't for me' and then our efforts are lifted to another level and what we do becomes vastly more important.

Thanks again :)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
john262
Elko, Nevada
05:02 PM on 06/26/2011
Has gay marriage ever been passed anywhere in the USA by a vote of the people? The answer is only once in Arizona, but then in a later election the voters of that state changed their minds and outlawed gay marriage. In every other state that has ever had the people vote on gay marriage it has been roundly defeated, including in blue states like California and Oregon. Everywhere in this country where gay marriage is legal it was done either by the courts or legislatures, not by a vote of the people. (I'm not sure of the process in DC but I don't think it was by popular vote there either.) So I don't buy this idea that the public supports gay marriage. You can word a poll to get almost any result you want.

And before the people decrying so-called "mob rule" and saying that human rights should not be up to a vote of the people show up, let me say this. My only point is to disagree with the implication in this article that the people now support gay marriage. I just don't believe it.
sej
nothin' micro about my biology
06:24 PM on 06/26/2011
Be careful what you wish for. Someday I may get to vote on YOUR marriage.
photo
Indaba
It's better to try than to hope.
08:52 PM on 06/26/2011
Gay marriage should not be up for vote. Social issues can be a challenge for someone who has not had exposure to a wide range of people, how they live their lives and the impact of laws. Gay marriage legality is a result of understanding by leadership about gay couples coming up against issues because of the lack of legality around the partnership as perceived by the current law. Public goods are bestowed on married couples and seeing that gay couples want to be eligible for those public goods too. It has been a great debate for all married couples to understand the value of marriage for society.
02:09 PM on 06/26/2011
One way or another, the rest of the nation will follow, eventually. Big step, here and glad to see it.
02:08 PM on 06/26/2011
Hmm. What's next? I'm going to guess... a Republican president and administration.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sf omega man
02:13 PM on 06/26/2011
Or not.
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
shutterbabe
Some people feel the rain. Others just get wet.
02:17 PM on 06/26/2011
Not on my watch.
04:09 PM on 06/26/2011
You already lost, you just didn't notice it
photo
change 2010
Welcome to Ameritopia!
05:54 PM on 06/26/2011
your watch is over.... just so you know
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TraceyES
11:59 AM on 06/26/2011
"The Freedom to Marry: What's Next After New York?"

California, hopefully. Marriage equality supporters in that state have fought so long and so hard and against such dirty tricks from the opposition, they deserve their (hopefully imminent) victory.
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
maxfax
Taa - dah!
11:35 AM on 06/26/2011
What's next? A huge pushback in red states?
photo
Vintage59
Reading is still the warp drive of IT
01:56 PM on 06/26/2011
They've never stopped pushing.
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
maxfax
Taa - dah!
02:19 PM on 06/26/2011
Watch and listen for the blame for disasters, catastrophes, or anything else on the passing of this bill from people like John Hagee, maybe Grant Storms.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sf omega man
02:14 PM on 06/26/2011
Uh, this was our pushing back against the red states. Enough is enough!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Zoe Brain
Girl Rocket Scientist
10:39 AM on 06/26/2011
And in another victory for Gay Rights, GENDA, the bill that would have removed Gays' rights to discrimina­te against Trans people, was throughly defeated. This took a lot of effort by Empire State Pride, as it passed the Assembly at the same time as SSM, and had even more votes in the Senate. There was a significan­t danger that it might be passed with SSM, but by unrelentin­g efforts by NY GLB groups to keep it buried, it didn't make it out of committeee with SSM. Well Done, Empire State Pride!

That's four years in a row that GENDA's been stuck in limbo after passing the Assembly! Now that SSM has passed, it's unlikely to make it that far again, so we can all breath easier.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sam Salinitis
read 1984.
10:07 AM on 06/26/2011
the next thing is --- singing were in the money ..making lots of money.......

America keep being ignorant and dumb.... New York can use all the money we can make off of ignorance....

that is how we saved teachers jobs, and fix our roads, and even pay for our corrupt politicians...lol

Revenue......
photo
SouthJerseySteve
Progressive isn't a dirty word.
09:48 AM on 06/26/2011
Since out of state residents can get married in NY, I hope there are a lot of law suites when these newly married couples come home to find that there marriage in NY means nothing in NJ, PA, FL, AR, AZ, CA, etc. and the federal courts (maybe Supreme Court?) get involved to wipe out DOMA once and for all. This is my dream.