iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Frank Morgan

GET UPDATES FROM Frank Morgan
 

Why a Laptop Is Not a Computer

Posted: 07/24/2012 3:03 pm

The personal computer unfortunately has lost one of the most basic and useful features of the earliest computers. Let's say you're surfing the web. You find something and want to copy both the web address and a few lines for a friend, but you can copy only one thing at a time without opening up your clipboard. So you copy the web address (from which you can always get back to the page). Meanwhile you spot another interesting link to something else for a different friend. But now if you copy even just the web address it will overwrite the other web address. So maybe you open another page on your clipboard and get distracted or maybe you just forget and overwrite your first address and by the time you realize it you can never find it.

Or maybe you copy something you'd like to keep for a while to share with everyone you write to. But if in the meantime you use copy and paste for something else, it's gone.

It wouldn't have to be like that. From the beginning one of the most fundamental computer operations, y = x, put whatever was in the x register in the y register. A register was like a clipboard, only you had as many as you wanted, and you could call them x1, x2, ..., or whatever you wanted. COPY just means "Clipboard" = "Whatever is Highlighted." PASTE means "Next on screen" = "Clipboard." Our laptops (and desktop personal computers) should have lots of clipboards and lots of COPYs, maybe Copy1, Copy2, Copy3, ... . The first interesting thing you Copy1. The next Copy2. The next Copy3. Your laptop would remember them all separately. Then later you can Paste1 or Paste2 or Paste3. There would even be a special command PasteAll that would put them all on the screen open in front of you.

If you'd just been to say bridge nationals, you could write a few pertinent sentences, Copy9, and paste them into lots of correspondence with Paste9. Or if you're working on something that uses a certain special symbol a lot, you could Copy8 it, and then just Paste8 it whenever you need it.

Incidentally this feature is available as aliases in my beloved mail application Eudora, which unfortunately doesn't run under the latest Mac operating system.

A laptop's long-term memory is huge, and it never forgets as long as it lives. But a laptop's short-term memory, in the form of copy-paste, can remember only one thing at a time. That's got to change.

 
FOLLOW TECH
The personal computer unfortunately has lost one of the most basic and useful features of the earliest computers. Let's say you're surfing the web. You find something and want to copy both the web add...
The personal computer unfortunately has lost one of the most basic and useful features of the earliest computers. Let's say you're surfing the web. You find something and want to copy both the web add...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 14
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
treemeizer
Stardust, temporarily human.
11:52 AM on 07/31/2012
Am I missing something here? What does a software copy/paste limitation have to do with laptops not being computers?

This article is completely incoherent, the feature you seek could be implemented if more people wanted it, and has absolutely nothing to do with using a laptop over a desktop computer.
11:16 AM on 07/30/2012
I made an account for the sole purpose of commenting on this article. Congratulations, you got a conversion not because of an impressive piece of journalism, but because of my astonishment at this spectacularly misleading and uninformed article.

This writer turned his frustration of not being able to copy and paste more than one line into an insult directed towards the mechanical marvel that mobile computing is today. As I'm sure you've heard many times before, the laptop or mobile phone you're probably reading this on is many times more powerful than the supercomputers of just a decade ago.

Just to drive this point home for the author, the 4 gigabytes "memory" that the average laptop computer has today can hold over 530,000 pages of copied text. More than enough for this author to make use of.

Mind you that is the random access memory (ram) that the writer is lamenting about and doesn't even touch on the hard disk space on your computer which, although is slower to read than ram, is still measured on the order of microseconds and would work perfectly fine for copying and pasting text. Take the number of pages mentioned above and multiply it by any number between 100 and 1000 and you can imagine the scale we're talking about.

So please, don't blame it on the technology, and instead try a little bit harder to find an application that supports the features you are looking for. Belittling the technology for a user interaction
photo
treemeizer
Stardust, temporarily human.
11:50 AM on 07/31/2012
Couldn't agree more.
08:20 PM on 07/28/2012
If I know I need more than one thing I open up wordpad and copy and paste to there. Wordpad can copy images and website data too. Or I could just do a screencap if I need a visual record. Either way, if you think computers are the one failing you, you've got another think coming, you are failing at using a computer to its potential and will soon find yourself like an old grandpa shaking his fist at the damn computer.
02:42 PM on 07/26/2012
How about ClipMate? Been using it for years. It seems to do what he needs.
http://www.thornsoft.com/
08:27 PM on 07/25/2012
Interesting article, though poorly written as it seemed to fail to offer a solution. How laptops fit in here is beyond me, the only real difference between a laptop and a desktop is size and customization of hardware... but I digress.

Let's talk programming, doc. What you're describing with "x1, x2, x3" etc., is a problem that would be easily remedied by putting an array into the clipboard feature. Then, hitting Ctrl+P could bring up a menu with a list of array entries since the current boot.

Not that hard, bro.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Querent
I say the things that have to be said.
06:34 PM on 07/25/2012
Savvy Clipboard gives you all that functionality and more for a few bucks. Every microprocesser ever made has multiple registers. You may be good at math, but you don't know jack about computers.
08:27 PM on 07/25/2012
+1
06:14 PM on 07/25/2012
This guy is a professor of math and doesn't seem to understand the difference between hardware, software, programs, and operating systems.
12:24 PM on 07/25/2012
Use Linux. But what does have to do with laptop or desktop?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
MSROADKILL612
love auto biographys. any appS to write mine?
04:14 AM on 07/25/2012
Fail to see the relevance of "laptop". R U not talking about operating systems?
cosmicdart
paragon of paradigms
01:54 AM on 07/25/2012
I simply copy things into a world processor file on my hard disk and then retrieve 'em later.
photo
phal4875
The world is run by cats; we just feed them.
11:51 AM on 07/25/2012
I do the same, but that has never seemed to be ideal.
04:25 PM on 07/24/2012
I totally agree Frank, and until Microsoft "introduces" clipboard history, I'll be using ClipX (http://bluemars.org/clipx/). I have no connection to it, other than being an avid user.