More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Frank Sesno

GET UPDATES FROM Frank Sesno

Bugging Out: Could Climate Change Make the Insect Instinct Go Haywire?

Posted: 09/16/11 12:09 PM ET

Gardening in a suburban area is more difficult than most people imagine. There are problems with soil quality and plot space, water and weather. But nothing is more menacing than the docile deer. Decades of development left the deer virtually unthreatened by natural predators, and the arrival of humans and their gardens provided a boom time for deer populations. What makes them such a menace, though, is their fondness for my flowers.

In response to this increase in deer-related garden vandalism, I started purchasing "deer-resistant" plants designed to pass under the radar -- and teeth -- of these hungry forest dwellers. I've adapted to a new reality, just as the deer have. We often forget how lots of creatures are adapting -- from humans relocating to get away from cold winters or hurricanes to moths growing darker wings in response to growing pollution levels.

Amy Seidl, the author of Finding Higher Ground: Adaptation in the Age of Warming, puts adaptation in a climate context. She notes that several species, from the pine beetle in Colorado to cold-weather birds, are changing their migratory patterns in response to climate conditions. "Animals won't be the only climate migrants if local climates begin to change" she writes. "As temperatures rise, the distribution of species will shift."

Enter Jessica Hellman of Notre Dame University. In a recent submission to Planet Forward, Hellman discussed her efforts to encourage "assisted migration" in some bug populations threatened by the rapidly changing climate. Hellman constructed climate-controlled biospheres in a laboratory environment -- a test tube planet, with chambers representing everything from deserts to marshes and temperate forests. By moving her test bugs between these environments, Hellman hopes to better understand how humans might move animals out of environmentally declining areas and adapt them to new homes.

"When we think of conservation biology, we think of polar bears," Hellman said in her submission to Planet Forward. "But in terms of the functioning of biological systems, insects are where it's at. They pollinate, they carry disease, they have economic impacts on crops and timber, and they're very susceptible to climate change."

Hellman's climate-controlled biomes are a novel way of understanding whether our insect relatives will thrive or struggle in new homes and her work is already yielding interesting findings. Hellman's bugs proved able to carve out a life in environments very different from their homes, but the actual act of assisting their migration may be more complicated in the real world.

Even though the bugs proved skilled at adapting to a laboratory environment, it may be tough for a relocated species to survive in the wild. New predators, unpredictable weather patterns and the continued encroachment of human development threaten the newly-migrated insects.

Our adaptation to a changing climate isn't that different from the pine beetle or the moth. If Hellman is correct, the deer that moved in on my garden may be just one of many animal species in the process of migrating to better environments. But will they survive? Will they thrive? And will our ability to move them make people less concerned about the changing climate? Just because we can change rooms doesn't mean we can stop worrying about the rest of the house.

 

Follow Frank Sesno on Twitter: www.twitter.com/planet_forward

 
 
  • Comments
  • 10
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bogstomper2
A secular conservative
07:06 PM on 09/16/2011
"I've adapted to a new reality, just as the deer have."

The deer around here are certainly adapting. They're more like a community pet herd than a wild population.

With regards to climate change and insects, the Texas drought has been instructive. Even though it's a short-term event in climate terms, it's had a noticeable effect on the insect population. For example, bees and spiders are almost gone, but the wasps are doing well, at least in my area. That's a profound change is a short period of time, and we're still looking at decades of warming to come.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:53 PM on 09/16/2011
Please acknowledge the obvious - that permanently destroying millions more acres of wilderness for Big Solar, Big Wind and Big Transmission is hardly a way to "help the adaptation" of anyone, including ourselves! Aside from killing off our bats and raptors - the 2 best ways to control insects, rodents, vectors and diseases - these industrializations of open space lock species into non-biodiverse, rapidly depleting petting zoos instead of allowing them the range of motion and variable landscapes they need to access, not to mention breeding partners which are not their siblings!

The built environment is beyond ripe for efficiency upgrades, clean, point of use solar power production and passive heating/cooling that will take an enormous amount of demand out of our electrical grid (and gas/oil "grid"), without killing off the exact things we should be saving. PLEASE, when you advocate for "sustainable" or "renewable" policies, be clear that our open spaces and migration corridors, especially the new ones that are needed, are NOT RENEWABLE and can not be destroyed for Big Energy profits.

Local is, once again, the answer.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Craig Bovia
Vermont, 1791, women can vote, no slavery allowed
02:39 PM on 09/16/2011
Progress need not come with destruction.
Fanned
Linus521
In wildness is the salvation of mankind
08:55 PM on 09/16/2011
Wow, Sheila, you appear to be learned in the science of ecology. What insight and intelligence in recognizing, nothing and no issue is as vital as saving the Earth's ecosystems and their biological diversity as you mentioned. The constructions of all the new alternatives kill ecosystems and biological diversity equally as well as oil fields and oil spills. When man deforests terrestrial ecosystems and forests for the construction of windmills and solar panels in wild places, he is killing the natural sequesteration of the heat trapping gases while releasing the stored C02 and methane into the atmosphere, defeating the purpose of alternatives. And, chain saws and deforestation heats up and dries out the climate!

All species of plant and animal biological diversity are the creators and saviors of the Earth's ecosystems, in the eco-nomics of oxygen releasing, moderation of the climate, the balancing of the gaseous composition of the atmosphere, rainfall, the nitrogen cycle, the entirety of the Earth's biogeochemistry, and all ecosystems have feedbacks and loops to the atmosphere and to the climate, to name a handful of ecosystem services, created by bats, raptors and all native species of animals and plants.

And all ecosystems, altogether, create the biosphere/ecosphere or the life zone of the Earth!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:39 AM on 09/17/2011
thanks, Linus, although I can't really take the credit for knowing about ecology - I have some really, really smart friends!

thanks for speaking out for ecosystems! fanned!
Linus521
In wildness is the salvation of mankind
01:50 PM on 09/16/2011
And, in SoCal, our magnificent, native old oaks are being ravaged by an out of control beetle, quite unnaturally! It appears, the entire west is under siege by exploding invertebrate populations, some of which are also our native invertebrates or biological diversity. And, no one understands why. Why are so many species of invertebrates out of control?

Quite naturally, ecosystems are in the business of regulating and checking all natural, native species. Some suggest, global warming is producing a longer and warmer breeding season, thus more and more insects. However, this could be symptomatic of ecosystems crashing. What of our native species that regulate and trim the populations of invertebrates, like birds, frogs and lizards?

We know frogs are falling extinct, globally and reptiles are not far behind. Many species of birds are in decline. Could this be a contributor? Reptiles are very sensitive to temperature changes, and science is worried about several species of lizards because of global warming.

Ecosystems also help regulate the climate and what is sitting on the Earth also impacts climate. It appears, when science maintains, they have no analogues as to what is occurring all over the planet, they are perplexed too. Regardless, it appears, life as we know it is changing.
photo
Dahveed
step softly & speak easy
12:52 PM on 09/16/2011
Recently I hiked in the Front Range near Boulder and in RMNP and saw dead pines everywhere. Pine Bark beetle devastation in the national park is unbelievable. Rangers were giving tourists lectures on it. Despite their efforts at containment, the beetle may end up killing all the pines.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Craig Bovia
Vermont, 1791, women can vote, no slavery allowed
02:40 PM on 09/16/2011
Hopefully, the pines will somehow adapt
12:19 PM on 09/16/2011
Yes it will. This is what makes it even funnier (although not really funny) to hear when deniers talk. It is as if everything will remain constant while humans continue to destroy the earth.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Craig Bovia
Vermont, 1791, women can vote, no slavery allowed
02:41 PM on 09/16/2011
The deniers figure that they will be dead when all the stuff happens, so they don't give a damn.