More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Gary Hart

GET UPDATES FROM Gary Hart
 

God, Human Folly, and Laughter

Posted: 12/31/11 11:59 PM ET

There is a story, now somewhat legendary, that John Kennedy once gave as a birthday present to his friend and court jester Dave Powers a silver mug with this engraving:

Only three things are real: God, human folly, and laughter. Since we can do nothing with the first two, we must do what we can with the third.

Serious people increasingly find American politics an exhibition of human folly. And, though certain conservative forces have sought for some time to insert God into the equation, it borders on sacrilege to lay at His doorstep this human folly brought on as much by the God-politicizers as anyone.

Arguably the most profound political question of our time is how to treat with the ultimate seriousness it deserves a political process that seems to wish to spiral downward with almost demented insistence. Great leaders, including great presidents, inevitably have their flaws. This is so because they are humans and thus subject, to greater or lesser degrees, to errors of judgment and performance.

But what can account for the virtual disappearance of greatness in presidents, senators, members of Congress, governors and others? Thoughtful observers have sought to explain this by combining the disappearance of privacy, an intrusive media, exorbitant campaign costs, and the overall loss of dignity and respect for leadership. It goes without question that many of the best, the most capable, the most honorable people in our society shun elective and, in too many cases, even appointive office.

Is it possible today to be a visible public servant and retain a sense of honor, dignity, and self-respect? All the leveling forces at work in our society would seem to answer no.

To follow the Kennedy prescription, then, is to resort to laughter. And many are doing so. Edward R. Murrow has been replaced by John Stewart and Walter Cronkite by Stephen Colbert. Thus laughter is not only the best medicine, it is the most effective way of responding to human folly on a political scale.

Students of American history know this is not without precedent. Ridiculous eras in times past have always produced a Will Rogers or even a W. C. Fields. Such figures have served our nation well and enabled us to laugh our way through tough times. But, sooner or later, reality requires us to confront our conditions and devise solutions or find those who can. When the laughter dies, as inevitably it must, we are still faced with unemployment, homelessness, hunger, and sickness.

For many of us, politics is not the art of making the rich richer in the hope they will dispense a farthing or two in the beggars cup or the church collection plate. A thousand points of light do not begin to dent the misery abroad today in every American city and throughout our countryside. Politics, to paraphrase one of Plato's dialogues, is the art of caring for souls.

So, while witnessing widespread human folly and praying that a kind God will somehow raise up great leaders, we must laugh. But, as the great bards of history have demonstrated the proximity of comedy and tragedy, let us late at night in the privacy of our own dwellings shed a tear for those whom Fortune has not favored, for the impoverished child who has yet to learn the cause of our laughter.

~ Kittredge, Colorado

 
 
 

Follow Gary Hart on Twitter: www.twitter.com/gary__hart

 
 
  • Comments
  • 83
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
themodernleader
05:27 AM on 01/02/2012
Gary Hart. Our nation is atop a powder keg of superfluous humanity ready to explode. All that is missing is the incendiary mix of ideology, charismatic leadership, scape goat and event or action. Our self-possessed leaders do not recognize that unemployed millions subjected to boredom and solitude or meager opportunity will find purpose through a mass movement of true believers and the call of the wild towards the values and goals of a thousand year new order that destroys the corrupt present for the opportunities in an unimaginable future of new ordered opportunity and action. Our leaders have no notion of how close this nation is to the destruction of a mass movement of fearful, fanatical, true believers in some absolute doctrine of a final solution. You may wish to inform them that the first agenda is to place 30 million superfluous humanity into positions of necessary work that restore their confidence, esteem and mental balance.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JFoxCPT
11:14 PM on 01/01/2012
"Politics, to paraphrase one of Plato's dialogues, is the art of caring for souls."

I like what Gary Hart is saying here -- the humor of a Stewart, a Colbert, is an antidote to the arrogance and certainty relied upon by ideology preventing us from finding a range of possible responses to the problems we face. These humorists point out the absurdity of calcified thinking. We need someone to show us when the "joke" is on us. Laughter gives me fresh air and in that a humility and some joy that makes growth possible.
10:06 PM on 01/01/2012
I don't think corporate fascism, illegal aggressive war, the globalized leveling of the people's labor and income, the owning of the people's revolutionary institutions by gross and demonic powers, and the largest penal colony in the world are folly. How about calling it what it is, a violent madhouse?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Michael D Ballantine
Former Presidential Candidate - Amer Elect 2012
09:24 PM on 01/01/2012
There are no great people, only ordinary people who do extraordinary things. When times are good, we don't look for a great leader, we look for one with competence. When times are bad then we clamor for someone to help us overcome the bad times. All of our great leaders have had their own foibles and today's leaders are no different. The media spotlight illuminates every twist and turn they have taken in their lives providing a level of scrutiny that goes beyond fairness and instead presents an ordinary human whom we believe incapable of surmounting the odds we face.

A great leader requires an honest open relationship with the people to build trust. It's the opaqueness that creates the uncertainty that causes us to question our leaders. It's one thing to hold your cards close to your chest and quite another to obfuscate the truth. The American people can forgive almost anything, except lying. The dissatisfaction with our current leaders simply stems from that simple fact, many of them are lying. We use euphemisms like flip-flop, spineless, or pandering to be polite but the simple fact is that the candidate is lying to the American people. Show me an honest candidate and I'll show you a winner, that is why the establishment is terrified by Ron Paul.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TheOin2012
My micro-brew is empty.
09:51 PM on 01/01/2012
There are extraordinary people with greater skills and talents than others. Beware the false equivalency of leveling.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Michael D Ballantine
Former Presidential Candidate - Amer Elect 2012
12:45 AM on 01/02/2012
There are people with specific talents but no one is Superman and the federal government is too big for a Superman to manage alone. I think the cabinet is actually more important than the President.
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
themodernleader
05:42 AM on 01/02/2012
The great leader both teaches and learns. He always brings every citizen to his rights, duties, prospects and opportunities through unity and common purpose and goals. Concomitantly, he learns the best sense of purpose and possibilities of the people---their collective wisdom and prescient solutions to national problems. Courage, integrity, and honor are assumed virtues of leadership at all levels, starting from the top.
photo
modeforjoe
We had the experience, but we missed the meaning
09:02 PM on 01/01/2012
A Zen approach to our troubles will not work this time around.
shylove2
warfare state is pathological
08:40 PM on 01/01/2012
No it is the hubris of supposedly bringing our democrazy to other countries as an example of leadership and public involvement when we have an avowed desire to spread disinformation at home and around the world for our wars of multi-national corporate world order without borders interests in mono-cultural dominance... and the one war party agenda that propelled Iraq and Afghanistan since Carter and Brzezinsski with Stepford Presidents stepping carefully in each other footstep and huffing and puffing on the same misinformation line...
leading finally to a direct violation of international law makeing the absurd claim of fear of imminent attack and the annoucnement of Condoleezza Rice and othere that international law doesn't really apply to us. Then turning around and demanding Iran prove the neagetice of not planning for nuclear weapons based on a treaty we say is really not applicable in the new age...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
atexasdem
Pointing out the foolishness of republican voters.
08:28 PM on 01/01/2012
As I read the comments below I am struck by two things:
1) Everyone is looking for a "savior". Someone to save us even if it's from ourselves.
2) Everyone seems to ask or expect something from government by by connection, country.

1) It has been my experience that blessings tend to come most often when we put forth our own great effort. If I wait for someone to "save" me I find it works best only after I have exhausted all avenues to save myself. If I am drowning it is best to do all I can to save myself rather than just laying back waiting on divine intervention.
2) This country was built on sacrifice. People working together to achieve common goals. Have we lost this? I remember well the words of John F. Kennedy. " Ask not what your country can do for you, ask what you can do for your country". Those words should be burned into the minds of every American. What have you done to make America a better place? What have you done to make America a better place for your children and grandchildren?
Individuals may not always prevail in every debate. Like any great team, defeat must only make us more determined. Before anything though we must all be Americans first. Does it really matter if we win the ideological battles if in the end we lose our country and all that it stands for?
10:20 PM on 01/01/2012
Thanks for that.
photo
Cameron Hoppe
Where's your evidence?
07:52 PM on 01/01/2012
The problem, IMHO, is that we live in an incredibly complex physical universe, and have incredibly complex societies and economic systems. Many, many people have no ability to grasp it, refuse to make themselves capable, and just want to be told their willful simplicity is enough to master it all. As a result the discussion becomes incredibly empty, incredibly boring, too simple to be anything close to real. Seriously, I pay no attention to our "leaders"; it's too insanely boring.
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
themodernleader
07:26 PM on 01/01/2012
About 1979-1980, Eric Hoffer posed the same question to me in private conversation.. Why are there no great leaders on the human stage as in the middle of the century? Although I was on the cusp of discovering the nature of leadership, I told him I didn't know and asked him his opinion. He said that since nobody had come up with any explanation he believed that any guess or hypothesis was legitimate. Therefore, I share with you this explanation Great leadership became the casualty of the rise of "women's lib". I was nonplused and incredulous. How so, asked I? All great men have women surrounding them, messaging their fragile egos. With women's liberation and female equality, women quit their role of telling potentially great men of their extraordinary leadership potential and so on. Therefore, potentially great men never emerged. I followed up by asking what he thought would arise. He replied the thought that the next great leaders will be women. He ended by describing some of their strengths. Events have not entirely dismissed his thesis. Margaret Thacher and Hillary Clinton are notable examples of decisive leadership. So are some legislators and organization CEOs. However, the manly Ronald Reagan was a great leader in persuading the American people to pursue the path of deregulation and unwound capitalism and unrestrained monopoly. My own research, I believe, is closer to the truth.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Sock De Jour
Democracy is an illusion
09:30 PM on 01/01/2012
Furthermore, I disagree with Hoffer's assertion that the women's lib movement was even mildly related to the lack of leadership shown historically, within the last several decades. It stems from a convergence of factors...

The military industrial complex controlling foreign policy for profit and global hegemony. The gradual erosion of all the gains made by Labor and the Communist party, in favor of complete corporate control. This was easily achieved through the evolution of television, propaganda, media control, empty showmanship, greed motivated capitalism, and the personal and collective narcissism that results.

Our cultural immersion in materialism over our connection to nature and the inability to satiate that constant quest for the novel, is steering Western culture and corporate controlled capitalism toward a precipice. Our disconnectedness to our own surroundings, and our ambivalence towards our environment and the conquering and ravaging of it, rather than a smooth integration within it, could well be mankind's ultimate downfall.

I for one, am not willing to accede to this collective irresponsibility, short sightedness and willful ignorance in the face of all we've learned from history, philosophy and science.

It's past time for a paradigm shift, in all areas and every single archaic and outdated power structure, globally. We have the technology to throw away the shackles of representative democracy, the coercive farming and exploitation of human beings for profit, and embrace a real democratic movement for the first time in history.

We need to demand it now, universally.
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
themodernleader
10:15 PM on 01/01/2012
 You have some worthwhile points.  However, I have learned of value from science except to recognize how dangerous are many of its ideas.  The study of history, especially the causes of  rise and fall of great civilizations is a worthwhile enterprise for people interested in not making the same egregious decisions.
   We must not discard our constitution.  Rather we must live and work together within its framework.  Permitting one person or one elite sect or privileged population to command the rest is a direct assault on our constitution and civilized  leadership.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
patricksmom
Extreme cat lover
10:19 PM on 01/01/2012
With you.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tulsey
I was Bill Hicks.
07:14 PM on 01/01/2012
A shout out to a "higher Power" is cool, an answer is not.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jesuswasademocrat
06:13 PM on 01/01/2012
I laughed at Sarah Palin when I thought she was just a one off. I laughed at Michelle Bachman as an embarrassing anomaly from poor Minnesota. I laughed at Sharon Angle and Christine O'Donnell as lunatic fringes that couldn't possibly succeed. I stopped laughing when Alan West, Joe Walsh and other Tea Party freshmen started having an impact on the legislative process. I didn't laugh much during the Wisconsin attacks on unions or red state attacks on voter rights. I'm not laughing at the impact that Citizen's United is having on this election cycle. I admit to a lot of laughter at all of the Republican debates, but it is a grim, gallows sort of humor. Unless we find a way to get money out of politics and return to truthful reporting of the news, this comedy is going to become a very dark tragedy.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PatWard
model for Rodin
06:27 PM on 01/01/2012
Well stated. Fan #96 will follow your other posts.
photo
Thinkster
I Think, therefore I POST!
07:59 PM on 01/01/2012
Let's make it 97. F&F.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
OleProfessor
"Ours is not a system based upon trust"
06:13 PM on 01/01/2012
God has never Spoken to Anyone...we must end that Myth...

We are a spec of dust even within our own solar system let alone this Universe...

All Religions are nothing more than Tribal Cults...

I'm not saying there is no Consciousness that we call God, just that we are not the center of it's interest or central to any plan just a small insignificant part of the material Universe...

We're on our own and if we were gone tomorrow this entire planet the Universe would continue and our demise would go unnoticed...

All Organized Religion is perverse, corrupt and an enclave for division within the family of man...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Marc1940
06:28 PM on 01/01/2012
I agree with you but when will humans realize these facts? It can only be the the chance of an afterlife. Academia is too mum on the subject. They know but are afraid to go down that career-ending path.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PatWard
model for Rodin
06:30 PM on 01/01/2012
Agreed and fanned
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PatWard
model for Rodin
06:07 PM on 01/01/2012
Senator Hart I have always had the utmost respect for you, but on this point we disagree. Laughter at this point in our journey indicates surrender to the awful mess created through the continuation of politics as usual. This is a pivotal time . The polarization of wealth is a very dangerous thing, as history tells us time and again. Occupy Wall Street is not laughing, and all the night sticks, pepper spray, arrests, imprisonments and denigration of their persons cannot kill an IDEA whose time has come.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Katherine Schock
Over the hill,liberal,organic gardener
08:54 PM on 01/01/2012
Great assessment, fanned!
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
stop the oligarchy
05:09 PM on 01/01/2012
There have been periods of less folly, for instance under FDR. Then, America was fighting against folly. Even today there are politicians that aren't fools. In my opinion, Hillary wasn't a fool and should have become president. But serious threats made against her and dirty tricks, blackouts, and slanders -- often involving the bought-and-paid-for foolish, lying media -- made her lose to Obama. For every (negative) article about Hillary, there were ten articles praising Obama. Obama was portrayed as a rock star. Hillary was portrayed as boring and old school. So my point is that it isn't easy to be an honest politician today where dirty tricks, bribes and thuggery is the norm and all we have is a dishonest media. People will have to wake up from their folly without the media.

I think Ron Paul is the best Republican candidate at the moment and the corrupt Republican Party and the financial elite seems to have been caught off-guard. They didn't intend to allow somebody potent into the race that weren't corrupt or controllable.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PatWard
model for Rodin
06:34 PM on 01/01/2012
Hillary was done in by Citizens United and so were we.
10:12 PM on 01/01/2012
The Citizens United Decision was after the campaign, it had no effect on Hillary.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
tulsey
I was Bill Hicks.
04:49 PM on 01/01/2012
During the depths of the civil war one of Lincoln's crew busted on him for always crackin' wise. Abe's reply "At times such as these, the choice is often either laugh or cry."