Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
George Pataki

GET UPDATES FROM George Pataki
 

The Obama Administration's Systemic Failure on Terrorism

Posted: 01/06/10 07:31 PM ET

Following the Christmas Day near-disaster on an international flight from Amsterdam to Detroit, President Obama referred to a "systemic failure" of our nation's intelligence sharing. He is right in referring to a systemic failure, but it is not just in intelligence sharing. From day one, the Obama Administration's anti-terror policies have amounted to a systemic failure that have placed our country's security in grave jeopardy. As one who has seen and experienced the consequences of prior failures up close, I am urging the Administration to drastically change its approach to defending America.

Virtually every decision this Administration has made has placed American security at greater risk, since refusing from the very beginning to even acknowledge the existence of a War on Terror, or to call enemy combatants terrorists.

It is time for the Administration to wake up and smell the explosives.

It is time for them to acknowledge their mistakes and change course. Let me outline five specific actions that the president should take:

First, the decision to return six terrorists to Yemen last month was a mistake that should not be repeated. The Pentagon reported this week that one in five terrorists released from Guantanamo are either suspected or confirmed to have returned to the battlefield in places like Afghanistan. The president should suspend his effort to shut Guantanamo until we are certain of a secure alternative facility to hold all detainees.

Second, end the wrong-headed investigation of our own CIA officials. Against the strong recommendation of CIA Director Leon Panetta, the Obama Administration has begun an investigation into CIA agents who interrogated terrorists, even though this action was rejected time and again by prior Justice Department officials. The September 11th attacks were largely the result of a weak intelligence apparatus, and this Christmas Day near-disaster again was again a failure to appropriately share intelligence. The decision to investigate those devoting their lives to protecting us is an example of left-leaning political correctness run amok and greatly hurts morale at that agency at a time when we need a strong CIA more than ever.

Third, treat our military with respect and honor, not as criminals. Yes, we need our military to be professional, respectful and honorable, and they are. But to court-martial Navy Seals -- among the bravest of the brave, who are willing and prepared to die for our country -- because a barbaric terrorist complains of a bruised lip is absurd and unconscionable. What's next? Assault charges against the brave passenger who foiled the Christmas Day bomber? We count on our military professionals to protect us. They should be able to count on their government to support and stand with them against America's enemies.

Fourth, reverse the decision to treat Khalid Sheik Mohammad as a criminal defendant instead of a terrorist. He was captured while continuing to fight a war against us that he acknowledges, even if the Obama Administration refuses to acknowledge the same. As the mastermind of the September 11th attacks, he does not belong in our civilian court system and should be prosecuted under the military tribunal system created for this purpose. To give this butcher and his followers a global media forum to act like victims and spew their hate defies logic. It will inflame anti-American actions across the globe. To show the world such a weak, politically correct response to terrorists makes America and Americans less safe. This is an unprecedented, dangerous mistake and I implore President Obama to reverse this horrible decision before it is too late.

Finally, fire Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano and replace her with a competent professional. I have met Secretary Napolitano and found her to be a perfectly nice, reasonable person. But on homeland security, she like the rest of the Obama Administration has been consistently wrong. From confidently asserting "the system worked" in the wake of the Christmas Day near-disaster, to her previous assertion that returning American servicemen and women were prone to right-wing terrorism and presented possible threats to our safety, she has consistently proven that she does not get it and is not up to the challenge of protecting Americans from terror threats.

I could go on. Failure to let Army officials know of the potential dangers prior to the Fort Hood massacre; calling the Christmas day bomber an "isolated extremist" although he was associated with the same radical Yemeni Islamist cleric who instructed the murderer at Fort Hood; issuing a hard timeline for troop withdrawal from Afghanistan at the same time as we are implementing a limited surge... The point is clear. Every week adds more to the growing list of missteps and mistakes made by the Obama Administration that greatly weaken American security and undermine our ability to identify threats and prevent terrorist attacks.

By taking the five steps outlined above, the president would demonstrate to the American people and the world that he understands the threats to our security and is willing to do what it takes to defend and protect our country.

 
Following the Christmas Day near-disaster on an international flight from Amsterdam to Detroit, President Obama referred to a "systemic failure" of our nation's intelligence sharing. He is right in r...
Following the Christmas Day near-disaster on an international flight from Amsterdam to Detroit, President Obama referred to a "systemic failure" of our nation's intelligence sharing. He is right in r...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 230
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (5 total)
11:16 PM on 01/07/2010
""The point is clear. Every week adds more to the growing list of missteps and mistakes made by the Obama Administration that greatly weaken American security and undermine our ability to identify threats and prevent terrorist attacks.""

Well being the first target of hundreds of thousands fanatics, 2 failed attack in 9years isn't that bad for US security gov policy, is it?

putting Obama or any other to the trash for this, is irrational!

the only place that is terrorists prouf is MARS, even them gets some lil terrorists bots rolloing over their landscape! duhh
07:00 PM on 01/07/2010
This article is a perfect example of why Republicans cannot be trusted with national security. Not one of the things he mentioned are that much different from actions taken by George Bush. Yet somehow these actions taken by a Democratic president is dangerous while similar actions (not to mention the much stupider ones) by a Republican president were perfectly acceptable. As long as Republicans see national security issues as an opportunity to fundraise and take political pot shots at the other side, they should have no say, no voice, and no role in any decision making.
06:36 PM on 01/07/2010
I read articles with the same content as this one every few days on the Wall Street Journal. The authors don't think the question of "Why do they attack us?" is interesting or important. If anyone raises it, that person is denounced as an appeaser or worse. Do they really think we can continue our present policies towards the Muslim world and also prevent some Muslims from willingly sacrificing their lives in order to due great damage to the USA? I am sure that there are more now that have the potential for doing that than before 9/11.
06:58 PM on 01/07/2010
Helen Thomas asked that question at the white house briefing a few minutes ago. She tried to push for an answer, they refused to give her one. If you can find a video please watch.

The briefing was immediately after Obama's speech.
07:55 PM on 01/07/2010
Thanks codycap. I found Helen's frustrating 2 minutes here, http://www.c-span.org/Watch/Media/2010/01/07/HP/R/28090/Pres+Obama+We+did+not+connect+the+dots+on+the+attempted+bombing.aspx starting about 19:40. Mr Brennan's non answer sounded just like something GWB would say. Obviously, the question is considered a 3rd rail thing, by both Democrats and Republicans.
08:01 PM on 01/07/2010
Found it. starts at minute 19

http://www.c-spanvideo.org/program/291121-2
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Craig Lane
05:40 PM on 01/07/2010
Chew it Pataki! IDIOT!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
04:57 PM on 01/07/2010
So to sum it all up, you hate America and want it to be something other than what our founders fought and died for.
04:22 PM on 01/07/2010
The majority of republicans think we rode around on the backs of vegetarian tyranosaurus rex , and that the earth is only 10,000 years old.... Oh ya the worst terrorism attack in the history of our country happened on there watch , enough said no thanks Mr Pataki!!
05:35 PM on 01/07/2010
Actually, they say the earth is 5,000 years old.
08:56 PM on 01/07/2010
Actually they believe that intelligent human life is 5000yrs old not the physical earth itself, this is where the christian bashers always get it wrong.
photo
ljmck
Stand Up, Show Up, Speak Up
04:02 PM on 01/07/2010
It's the Republican side of America that the rest of the world dislikes the most--the me first, materialistic, superior, militaristic, profits at any cost, environment destroying, know-it-all, bragging, holier than thou, I own the world, heedless, ugly American.

People still want to come here, but most immigrants do not end up being Republicans. Fewer and fewer Americans end up being Republicans!

So you just keep telling us how it is, Mr. Pataki. We're taking notes on how not to behave.
photo
ljmck
Stand Up, Show Up, Speak Up
03:39 PM on 01/07/2010
There is nothing wrong with refusing to glorify terrorists by giving them the most scary name you can think of. What you call them and how you counter them are two different things. But Republicans are always hung up on appearances, so I see your point.
1. Right, let's just keep every detainee forever. Even if they can't be charged and prosecuted. That will surely end all terrorist impulses in the future.
2. Why would we want to ask questions about how the CIA operates?! After all, it never makes mistakes. Or is it your position that we can ask, but we shouldn't ask officials?
3. How dare you say President Obama doesn't treat our military with respect. If laws are broken, the perpetrator should be addressed by the proper courts, military included. That's American justice, Mr. Pataki.
4. The courts of one of the world's great democracies are not competent to address the crimes of an accused terrorist? You've got to be kidding.
5. You might have a point on this one, but let the evaluation take place instead of making a snap judgment from outside. It might turn out that she was sabotaged by Republicans who "burrowed" themselves into positions from which they can't be fired. Ya never know.
As for your other assertions, you seem to believe that information always got to the proper place in previous administrations, especially Republican ones. Balderdash. Nothing about the timeline in Afghanistan is hard and fast, to my regret.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TJCole
02:59 PM on 01/07/2010
Bush and Cheney Invaded, the Wrong Country...!

Try and find that anywhere else in history..?

I think it's unique...unprecedented...singular...
03:18 PM on 01/07/2010
I can't stop grinning.

So horrible its hilarious.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Doug Compagner
Are you better off now or four years ago?
04:48 PM on 01/07/2010
The American people elected the wrong president & vice president in 2008...Our kids, grandkids, and great grandkids will suffer for many years to come.
05:37 PM on 01/07/2010
Sorry, but you have the election year / years wrong. That would be 2000 and 2004.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TJCole
10:31 PM on 01/07/2010
At least Obama was elected...!
photo
HUFFPOST PUNDIT
Jannsmoor
01:21 PM on 01/07/2010
The entire purpose of Osama bin Laden and al Qaeda was to create enough fear that America would bankrupt itself fighting wars in tribal countries.

You can fully count on the Republicans to assist al Qaeda by constantly trying to 'terrorize' Americans. How else could they have lied America into the insane, incredibly expensive ($3 trillion) and illegal war in Iraq? Only by fanning the flames of terror.

George, Osama was praying for people like you, and you have delivered.
01:14 PM on 01/07/2010
Republican hypocrisy has no limits, no shame.
02:17 PM on 01/07/2010
I completely agree.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
glitz
Campari with a twist...
01:00 PM on 01/07/2010
The biggest problem we have with fighting terrorism, is too many cooks in the kitchen. Too many bureaucrats who know everything. Too many 6 figure CEO's working at Department of Homeland Security. Too many old politicians trying to maintain their importance. Too many agencies competing instead of working together. Too many dollars spent on technology instead of the field. And finally too much totally worthless information that wastes time that should be spent on facts.
12:46 PM on 01/07/2010
Torture must be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law.
12:45 PM on 01/07/2010
"It is time for the Administration to wake up and smell the explosives. "

Comical

I swear republicans are like little children.
04:28 PM on 01/07/2010
Extremely frightened little children.