iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Georgianne Nienaber

Georgianne Nienaber

Posted January 9, 2009 | 12:13 PM (EST)

Exclusive Interview: Congo Rebel Leader Accused Of War Crimes Tells His Story (SLIDESHOW)


Congo rebel leader General Laurent Nkunda has been accused by human rights organizations of ordering his troops to rape and murder civilians and pillage communities. Huffington Post contributors Georgianne Nienaber and Helen Thomas traveled to Nkunda's compound in Kivu province, Congo, to interview Nkunda face-to-face.


On the eve of Congo peace talks this week in the Kenyan capitol of Nairobi, the BBC reported that Congolese rebel leader Laurent Nkunda had been dismissed as commander of the National Congress for the Defense of the People (CNDP). Nkunda insisted that he was still in power and that the removal was just a rumor.

The rival who challenged Nkunda's leadership was CNDP military chief of staff General Bosco Ntaganda, who accused Nkunda of obstructing peace efforts in the region on January 8.

This is the second time in recent months that Ntaganda has caused a controversy. In October, the general signed a statement announcing Nkunda's death, according to AFP reports.

The Democratic Republic of Congo has been at war since 1996. The United Nations peacekeeping force in the region (MONUC) claims that it is over-committed and cannot maintain protection for the local populations from the confrontations between the Congolese Army (FARDC), the CNDP, local militias (Mai Mai), and the remnants of the Interahamwe (FDLR) who are responsible for the 1994 genocide in Rwanda.

In January 2008, the Congolese Army and General Nkunda signed the Goma peace agreement, which fell apart eight months later, displacing over one quarter of North Kivu Province's population of 4 million people. According to Human Rights Watch, a total of 1.1 million people are displaced in North and South Kivu Provinces.

Nkunda's rebel delegation is in Nairobi for another round of UN-brokered peace negotiations, which began on Wednesday. The talks had been suspended in December.

The innocent victims of this war are civilians who are caught in the crossfire. Much information in this region is based upon rumor, and people in eastern Congo seem interested primarily in seeking safety from the fighting. This has resulted in severe overcrowding of the Internally Displaced People camps that have been in place since 1996.

Conditions in the camps are no better than that found in barnyards, and newborn infants are seen sleeping on beds made of lava rocks, with barely a piece of cloth for covering.

1 / 8
General Laurent Nkunda is the Tutsi leader of the
National Congress for the Defense of the People (CNDP) in eastern Congo.

Nkunda stated in an interview with Australian and American journalists on Saturday January 3 that he recognized the Congolese people have paid the price for a decades' worth of war.
Photo by Georgianne Nienaber

Image courtesy Georgianne Nienaber

The following interview was obtained with General Nkunda at his compound three days before the BBC reports of his ouster. To date, Western media reports have been very unfavorable to Nkunda and the CNDP, including accusations of mass rapes and killings. Nkunda said he agreed to meet with Nienaber because he said he "was aware" of her reports on nature conservation from the region.

Question. Would you say that you have been portrayed in a negative way in Western media?

Nkunda. They cut my voice and they speak on my behalf. Journalists tell what they think will be sensational.

Q. Are you the man to provide the leadership to develop Congo?

N. I never talk about an individual when I talk about change or about leadership. I always talk about a spirit. Because a man cannot do, but a spirit can do. If you can find leadership, leadership can change Congo, but not a leader.

Q. There have been terrible stories about how women are treated in Congo, especially how there have been mass rapes.

N. You are in the area under CNDP control. Ask the women who have been raped.

I cannot believe that they are raped here and then going to be treated in Goma or Bukavu. But if you go to Goma or Bukavu [under FARDC control] you are going to see hospitals full of women raped. Go to Rumangabo and they will tell you that the area under CNDP control is the most secure area in Congo.

They say that we massacre Hutu tribes. The executive secretary of CNDP is a Hutu.

Q. Can you tell the world what happened at Kiwanja?

N. Kiwanja was liberated by the CNDP on the 28th of October, [2008]. We were in Kiwanja for one week without any killing, any rape, any looting. One week later the government [FARDC], along with Mai Mai, attacked Kiwanja and they occupied Kiwanja for 24 hours. My forces went back [withdrew] from Kiwanja. And in 24 hours, 74 people were killed.

And before we came back to Kiwanja the governor of Goma, in the morning, announced that in Kiwanja there were massacres. When I heard on the radio that there were massacres in Kiwanja, I called my guys [soldiers] on the ground and said, "Where are you?" They said, "We are in Rutshuru." I said, "Who is doing this?" They said they did not know, that they were in Rutshuru.

So we went back to Kiwanja on the afternoon of the 29th, or the 27th. [Nkunda leans over to check dates with an adviser.] We went back 24 hours later and some people were killed in the crossfire. To that we can testify. Because the Mai Mai, they do not know how to shoot; they shoot where they want and when they were retreating they were shooting.

And we saw that even the Hutu community in Rutshuru wrote a letter about that and they gave it to [unclear] and said they were not killed by CNDP.

Q. Do you have a copy of that letter?

N. Yes, I do.

Q. May we have a copy?

N. You will have a copy.

The same scenario was prepared in Goma. When we were around Goma, my intelligence services told me that there was a plan to kill people in Goma that night so that they could blame the CNDP. That is why I told my guys to not enter Goma.

I was informed that there was a plan for FARDC [the government forces] to kill in the night. Those who were in charge of the killing never knew that we withdrew. But I told MONUC [UN mission in DRC] that I was going to withdraw from Goma for 12 kilometers.

On that night, 64 people were killed in Goma.

Q. The other charge against you is that you ordered the refugee camps destroyed.

N. Please understand. Yes, there were internally displaced people in Kiwanja. When I came. I went to the camp and I told the population there, there are no houses here. You are in the rain. Please go back to your homes. I will take charge of your security. Please go home.

On the following morning they said Nkunda forced people to leave. I am asking people to go to their HOMES! MONUC has been unable to take charge. So it is a crime because I am asking them to go to their homes?

One day I told the person responsible for OCHA; the one in charge of humanitarian affairs, if we do a study in the camps around Goma, in each week there are about a hundred people dying from different diseases.

In four years, CNDP has been accused of killing 100 people. But you are killing one hundred people each week in your camps.

Who is the criminal?

Q. Can you explain the military ethic of your soldiers?

N. Rape will be punished by firing squad. This is known. And two weeks ago [approximately December 21, 2008] two officers were executed for this.

Q. Who executed them?

N. Other soldiers of the same rank. They were second lieutenants and they were killed by second lieutenants.

These are strong measures, I know.

Q. Some people call this a war for minerals.

N. How can you fight for your own minerals? [Laughter] If this were about minerals, I would not be here.

You see minerals are being exploited by China, by Belgium, by South Africa. Petrol is under French control, uranium under American control, copper under Belgium, diamonds under Jewish, and gold under South African control.

Q. Have you met personally with Alan Doss [MONUC]?

N. No. We talk only on the phone.

The first time I talked to him was in January when we were in Goma during the peace talks. One day I told him, you are coming with your tanks to ask us to shut our mouths.

And so you ask me to not fight. I said to him bring other tanks and other aviation forces because we will fight until we will be free. You want me to be a slave, an economic slave to China, I will not accept this. I'll fight till I die, then my brothers will continue to fight, and my elders will fight and my son will fight.

Q. So does China's influence concern you now?

N. Yes of course because we are going now into economic slavery. If we accept this Chinese contract it is the end for Congolese.

Q. Have you heard President-elect Obama's statement about Congo, that this is just an ethnic conflict?

N. He has to raise his thinking about Congo. If I could meet him one day, I would tell him that it is not a matter of ethnic conflict, it is a matter of leadership.

The world is talking about a black person in power, but Americans didn't vote for a black man, they voted for an American showing the capacity to rule. But they are talking about a black person. No, no, it is not that. On his identity card it doesn't say 'black'. When the American people were voting, they voted for an American.

Q. What are your views about Human Rights Watch?

N. I will tell you, they are writing from the UK and from the US and they are not on the ground.

I even talked to Anneke van Woudenberg. She came to see me in Masisi but after leaving here and then writing their things I had to call her back and say, "Why? You were here, now what are you doing?" She always says that the information is from "reliable sources." But all these reliable sources are unidentified.

Q. General, is there anything you want to say to us that we didn't ask you about as a last question?

N. I can say that what Congo expects from the world is help to be free from the leadership it is currently under. Instead of bringing so many troops, we want to have well-trained and equipped soldiers in Congo. Instead of spending money on MONUC we want to have roads. Instead of bringing ex-pats from elsewhere, we want well-trained leaders for Congo. Help Congolese leaders to have a vision for the country that is good for the people.

####

Georgianne Nienaber is a regular contributor to the Huffington Post. She has written a biography of murdered primatologist Dian Fossey and has spent considerable time in African conflict zones since 2004.

Helen Thomas is a print and radio journalist in Australia. Her interest in African affairs stems from her involvement in an organization that seeks to provide a more balanced portrayal of Africa in the media. The confusion shrouding the Congo crisis compelled her to travel to the region herself to gain a first-hand insight of why one of the most resource-rich countries in the world continues to wallow in war, poverty and suffering.


Congo rebel leader General Laurent Nkunda has been accused by human rights organizations of ordering his troops to rape and murder civilians and pillage communities. Huffington Post contributors Georg...
Congo rebel leader General Laurent Nkunda has been accused by human rights organizations of ordering his troops to rape and murder civilians and pillage communities. Huffington Post contributors Georg...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 53
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
02:39 PM on 01/18/2009
Very interesting interview, Georgianne. Thanks for your courage in going after it.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Georgianne Nienaber
Author, Investigative journalist
10:17 PM on 01/18/2009
No courage was needed. Nkunda has a disciplined, professional, army and is a welcome break from the thugs waving Kalashnikovs, drinking, demanding bribes, killing and looting that passes for the Congolese army. I felt totally safe, the villagers in occupied territory seemed relaxed..women did not run for their lives when the military came down the road..it was like night and day. Meanwhile MSM posts from Dakar and Kinshasa and does not go in to take a look around. I doubt that Nkunda rearranged the entire countryside for our visit!
04:40 PM on 01/23/2009
Dec 2/3rd 2008, I ate and spoke for 40 minutes with Laurant Nkunda. It was obvious to me that while he was a commander he was never the less a humble man slow to take offennce and his heart is good.
He longs for justice for congo.
His recognition that USA voted for an american leader rather than a black man reveals that he is a sensitive man of wisdom.
When we asked "how we can pray for Congo?' , he said " pray that God will rule over Congo, not laurant Nkunda or one of his family but that God will rule".
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Georgianne Nienaber
Author, Investigative journalist
07:11 PM on 01/23/2009
You had same experience as I. I believe Rwanda is trying to sacrifice Nkunda in order to save face with the west.

Then, there was the final question to Thomas and myself from Nkunda. "Would the new Obama government listen to what we reported with an open mind for the Congolese?" I replied that I was very small but that I would shout in a loud voice on behalf of the Congolese people. I also told him that I did not know how I would do this.

Nkunda told me, and I will never forget this, “Don’t worry about what you will do. You are “doing” now. By coming here, by speaking on behalf of the Congolese people when you write about the conditions in Goma and in the camps, by speaking openly about this, you are doing. You are doing.”
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Georgianne Nienaber
Author, Investigative journalist
03:46 AM on 01/14/2009
Sorry for the delay, but i just got out of country. In response to questions, let me say that General Nkunda speaks fluent English and no translation was necessary. There is a 5,000 word transcript of the seventy minute interview and also a HighDef video tape which is on its way to London for editing and possible YouTube distribution. In addition, we are working on official translation of document (in French) submitted by Hutu Mayors of Kiwanja community which lists all of the dead, injured and their ages, as well as supporting testimony that the CNDP was not responsible for the massacre. The document was originally copied to Human Rights Watch.
01:35 PM on 01/10/2009
There's always two sides to everything.
02:20 PM on 01/10/2009
no one here is interested in any side. Maybe if they changed the title of the article from the Congo to Israel/ Palestine people would pay attention to something real as opposed to the religous mess in the Mid East
12:30 AM on 01/10/2009
The level of misinformation and ignorance about this region is astounding - it also explains the frustration that comes with not getting the full story. The full story has to begin with (like it or not) the horrendous and violent history of the Congo right after the Belgians left. I know this because my father lived in Goma as a young man and was raised in that period.
How do you explain the $2 billion budget UN peacekeeping forces have spent on that region with no success whatsoever! As someone who has worked at the UN in New York, I can confidently tell you that maintaining this insane war, maintains all the UN workers and their livelihoods. If I had time (night shift) I would list the number of American companies, and senators doing business with Kabila today - Dont get me started with France - who supported the Interahamwe that flocked to Congo after the killing fields of 1994 in Rwanda - and you think President Kagame is going to wait for the UN to do its job?
Why is it that it is so simplistic and so easy to sweep things under the rug when it comes to Africa? Its just so convenient to say its all "ethnic killing" ..You just need to watch from the small, shabby airstrip near Mbujyi Mayi and see for yourself the planes that are landing and you will see why this man Nkunda is raving mad - sometimes there just no words.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
sweetiebird
10:54 PM on 01/09/2009
Thanks for posting this story Georgianne. It helps shed light on a conflict that solely receives attention in much of the media because of its impact on the mountain gorillas, and not because of the devastating effect that the war is having on the people who reside in the Congo, especially the innocent women and children who are being raped and murdered.
08:10 PM on 01/09/2009
Where are the links to the video of this conference which you wrote of? Do you have them or not?
09:03 PM on 01/09/2009
berlin conference of 1884 to avoid conflict b/w european powers.
06:13 PM on 01/09/2009
congo and africas problem started with berlin conference,where european powers divided africa into bits and pieces not minding language and cultural barriers,e.g tutsi are minorities like three or four countries.it was divided for explotation by europeans for europeans .congo was a personal property of king of belgium who massacred the population,the violence has being tranfered generation to generation.the people that created the problem must stop playing lip service and africans must start thinking strategically about proper intergration of the whole continent,if not more warlords are going to be produced with the help of the big coporations that it favours for the continuation of the status quo.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
loki
cheap politicians for sale
06:08 PM on 01/09/2009
Its kind of aggravating knowing that the organization that was put in place to protect us against political leaders or dictators, presidents, kings and queens, who might commit crimes of war and inhumane acts upon people, is the same organization that goes after the little guys with vengeance, but ignores the largest and more destructive than all the small fries put together. Bush will walk, while they will make the little, but none less guilty, be propped up to show that they occasionally do what they are suppose to do. As usual, the most deadly walks because they have more money and support from other corrupt people
05:29 PM on 01/09/2009
If Nkunda was backed by any of the "outside intervention" i.e. U.S.A, France etc He would be praised as a liberator (puppet to facilitate further looting) i.e in point Laurent D. Kabila
You can always refer to the late President Lumumba at the time of independence in the 1960, who was assassinated by then a C.I.A. effort in cahoots with then puppet Mobutu, who turned out to be the worst U.S. investment in Africa for a good 3 decades as a dictator (32 yrs) sounds familiar?
This is someone who loves his country and wants it to regain its pride and you really think he’s a favorite to anyone with their influence in HIS country that generates billions of billions of dollar.
Only to leave HIS country-men in shacks and succumbing to the worst living means known to humanity.put it into perspective, a senseless Iraq war (Bush family enticed revenge), Jews and Palestinians fighting (did I mention good chance a diamond-mine somewhere around the Kasai province funding this bully-conflict)
07:03 PM on 01/09/2009
You have simply got to be kidding me. First of all, Nkunda is supported, financed and handled by Rwanda, which led by Paul Kagame, which is the United States strongest ally in the region. So Nkunda is definitely linked - tangentially - to the same super-powers that you claim he is being vilified by.

Second of all, Laurent Nkunda and his Rwandan allies take advantage of the profits from Coltan mining, AT THE EXPENSE of the Congolese people, the rightful owner of those minerals. Additionally, his soldiers are just as reckless, and as insiduously perverted in their behavior as all the other forces present (including the Congolese Armed Forces, and MONUC), so as a Congolese man, I am insulted that you want to raise this murderous war-criminal to the level of a hero for me and my country. It insults me on a number of levels, but particularly in as much as it insults my intelligence, and the lives of all those who have been martyred by his senseless, needless war.

Third, another commenter stated that this issue is only complicated for Anderson Cooper. As much as I love beating on the MSM, this is one where Anderson Cooper is right. It is a complex issue. My problem is often that people in the West do not recognize the complexity of the issue, and refuse to treat it with the depth, the care, the scrutiny and the importance it deserves.
08:55 PM on 01/09/2009
...and Nkunda also in cahoots with Museveni of Uganda!
05:08 AM on 01/10/2009
Let's stop knocking Kagame. What he has accomplished in the years since the Genocide is truly amazing. He has brought a level of democracy and stability to a country that was devastated. In my estimation he is the best ruler in Africa. In my estimation, he is one of the few leaders in Africa that really gives a damn about his people and country.

Probably the best thing that could happen to that part of the Congo would be that it came under the control of Rwanda. Maybe then some progress could be made. The Congo is a huge country with many divergent tribes and cultures. Its infrastructure is almost nonexistent. It needs to be broken up into manageable parts based on its natural tribal boundaries if possible if it is ever to have stability, peace and prosperity. As is true in most other African countries, free, open and HONEST elections need to be held and governments that truly are trying to help all their people instead of a cliche elected. There is old saying "How do you eat an elephant?" the answer "One bite at a time". It is time that all the people of Africa had a fair bite of the elephant, not just the few in power at any one time.
photo
The Lorax
Obama/Biden 2012!!! Fired Up. Ready To Go.
04:03 PM on 01/09/2009
I wish them all good fortune and to someday see an end to the conflict. I have friends from that area... they came to the US to keep their kids from this violence. I can't even imagine what it's like.
03:42 PM on 01/09/2009
As usual Georgianne did an outstanding job and asked the really important questions.

As hard as it may be to understand the solutions for the DRC are not that difficult to develop nor understand unless you are Anderson Cooper and the war story or the story of all the failure is the only story that fits your bias.

Good reporting.
03:31 PM on 01/09/2009
A photo of Laurent Nkunda with Betty, his pet "goat," also appeared in the NYTimes a couple of weeks ago, but Betty's actually a sheep. This point is really insignificant when compared to the scale and extent of human suffering in the Congo, but accuracy is accuracy.
photo
The Lorax
Obama/Biden 2012!!! Fired Up. Ready To Go.
10:16 PM on 01/09/2009
Good point nonetheless.
03:04 PM on 01/09/2009
I believe he also made the following comments.

The CNDP does not torture, never has and never will. (He has a personal memo from John Yoo which defines torture as that which other people do.)

The CNDP has a unitary executive structure and in the course of the war the Chief (also known in local patois as the Decider) has unfettered power to protect the state, revolution, or kleptocracy (whichever is applicable).

The Geneva Convention and the Universal Declaration of the Rights of Man are quaint documents and really not applicable to the CNDP's heroic struggles against Africano Fascists, terrorists, and dead enders.
02:53 PM on 01/09/2009
The Congo war is an ignored holocaust. Shame on us all. Gen Nkunda is Pres Kagame's tool, he is very unpopular in Congo. He has goals that are unachievable, unless the Congo is willing to divide the country into 3 parts and give a sepatate territory to the Tutsis in the western part of the country. The Congo is a failed state and is in my opinion ungovernable in it's current state. The country has no roads, bridges or viable infrastructure. The cheapest means of transport is by air or it's close to unnavigable rivers. The central govt run by Kabila has no real influence in big chunks of a country the size of wesern Europe. It's minerals and timber are meanwhile plundered by the warlords with no benifit to the locals. Not to mention the humanitarian crisis and war crimes aganist humanity, what a mess. Obama should not down play this as just an ethnic conflict, it has a potential to be a real foreign policy headache for him.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
binq56
Curious and curiouser.
02:22 PM on 01/09/2009
Very interesting interview. It does make me question what we hear every day in the news. It could be, however, very much a delusional, Balgo-type defense of himself in the face of overwhelming evidence to the contrary.