iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Glen Browder

GET UPDATES FROM Glen Browder
 

The South's New Race Game: Hard History, Ugly Democracy, and Practical Politics

Posted: 06/10/2012 12:15 pm

At his 1963 inauguration in Montgomery, Governor George C. Wallace pledged racial defiance forever in the heart of Dixie:

"In the name of the greatest people that have ever trod this earth, I draw the line in the dust and toss the gauntlet before the feet of tyranny... and I say... segregation today... segregation tomorrow... segregation forever."

A few short months later, in his "I Have A Dream" speech in Washington, Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. articulated an alternate vision of Southern race relations:

"I have a dream that one day the state of Alabama, with its vicious racists, with its governor having his lips dripping with the words of interposition and nullification, will be transformed into a situation where little black boys and black girls will be able to join hands with little white boys and white girls and walk together as sisters and brothers."

Neither of these guys -- the two most prominent protagonists in Southern racial history -- had a clue back then about how Alabama and the South would look a half-century later. Little did Wallace and King know that, as I will illustrate, both races would embrace ironic and un-visionary accommodations in the 21st century.

King was killed by an assassin's bullet five years after his "Dream" speech; so he never saw the fruits of his labor. Wallace was shot and paralyzed a decade after his inaugural remarks about "segregation forever"; he died years later, a changed politician and repentant man grieving about his role in history and history books.

So, what would I tell King and Wallace about Alabama and the South if somehow I could communicate with them today? How would I explain -- from my perspective and position inside Southern politics -- about where we are now? And how did we mangle history and democracy to get here?

A Tale of Hard History, Ugly Democracy, Practical Politics

Sadly, I would have to admit to them that racism extends into the new century. But I also would relate an intriguing story of evolving race relations in this region.

That story -- as told in this series of posts -- is that the South changed unpredictably and considerably, for practical reasons embraced by both blacks and whites, since the civil rights movement; and in many respects, this region now practices an ironic but somewhat normalizing version of national politics.

Then, for rhetorical purposes, I would ask Dr. King and Gov. Wallace to imagine Rosa Parks finally agreeing to ride in the back of the bus, now equipped with La-Z-Boy recliners across that back row. Imagine Bull Connor serving Southern sweet iced tea to demonstrators as they stroll amiably along the sidewalks of Birmingham. Picture the Bloody Sunday marchers being shuttled respectfully from Selma to Montgomery by Alabama State Troopers in air-conditioned squad cars, lights ablazing and sirens ablaring.

Or, I would tell them to imagine George Wallace cheering Tuskegee and Alabama State at the annual Turkey Day Football Classic and Martin Luther King tossing the ceremonial coin for the Auburn-Alabama Iron Bowl a couple days later?

And all of these "imagines" occur under the vigilant and approving guidance of the Civil Rights Division of the U.S. Justice Department.

A Striking Evolution

Such conjured scenarios are weird exaggerations. But they serve to emphasize a striking evolution in Southern politics. A new race game prevails in this part of the country in the 21st century. In a land still wrought with race and racism, white and black cultures now co-exist, often co-mingle, and routinely cooperate in strange, unprecedented fashion. Clearly the game favors white majorities and their conservative priorities, but black minorities now participate and their concerns sometimes take center stage with constructive outcomes .

Of course, there's not much public talk among the politicians themselves about a new system of race relations, especially if the conversation smacks of race-mongering or unprincipled racial compromise. Southern officials -- black and white -- have to be wary in their comments, lest they offend mainstream society or run afoul of their own racial constituencies. So, even while pursuing positive change, they tend to respect the norms and traditions of the divided cultures, negotiating contentious problems on an ad hoc basis, sometimes openly and sometimes privately, and in a way that allows personal political flexibility or, if necessary, tactical resort to the old ways of Southern history.

So, What Is Going on in the South?

I am no longer a practicing participant in contemporary Southern politics, and surveying current officials about this phenomenon would probably prove useless. But I am sufficiently wired into the regional system through focused observation and informal conversation with friends and associates to have a continuing, solid basis for my assessment of the new racial relationships.

The academic community and professional media have yet to focus on this aspect of black-white relations; obviously, there's no proclaimed code of procedures for such politicking. Therefore, it is difficult to articulate -- clearly, concisely, and authoritatively -- the changed role of race in real Southern politics.

But I will try, in this eight-part series of posts, to explain the new system as a sophisticated yet awkward and sometimes unsavory -- but generally biracial and functional -- accommodation of regional change among both Southern politicians and the Southern people.

Some readers will be appalled (and even angered) by this series; but they'll likely derive a better understanding of contemporary developments in this part of the country. And I hope that this series will evoke a candid discussion of racial politics in the rest of America.


Disclosure and Acknowledgement: This series includes edited, updated material from one of my books: The South's New Racial Politics: Inside the Race game of Recent Southern History (2009): and portions of these posts will be included in an upcoming book. I'm grateful to NewSouth Books for allowing me to borrow from those publications for my discussions on the Huffington Post.

 
 
 
FOLLOW POLITICS
 
 
  • Comments
  • 169
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
11:52 PM on 06/12/2012
And yes, I am Black., with many stories to tell from Freetown, Africa, to Plantations in South Carolina, to Greensboro, Alabama, and then my birth going forward in Birmingham from the back to the front of the bus, and unfortunately there are unsung, unrecognized real Civil Rights Leaders, who, but for them, Rev. Martin Luther King, Jr., would not have been successful in Birmingham..
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
kolay1629
10:43 AM on 06/22/2012
I live in a small town in Tennessee and the good ole boy network is thick professional black people cannot get a decent job without a solid connection. Even if they get a job they will be only token in the place and have to tow the line under much scrutiny. Racism is alive and well in the United States.
11:25 PM on 06/12/2012
Having been born and raised in Birmingham, Alabama before intergration, and yet having lived the American Dream, I can tell you that 21st Century Birmingham, Alabama is segregated while in intergration. Yes, there is a Black Mayor,Chief of Police, Fire Chief, Board of Education, etc., However, the enitre county of Jefferson, inclusive of Birmingham, is effectively run by Jefferson County Commissioners. In fact, and in reality, it is as if time has stood still economically.

Yes, there are numerous well educated Black residents, but unfortunately these "leaders", many of whom are the children of past Civil Rights Leaders, have forsaken the struggle.

In 2013 the City will be celebrating the 50th Year Anniversary of the Civil Rights Act,and the Mayor announced that he is looking for many other "notable" dignitaries. It will be a dog and pony show, but those people who actually felt the chains, the dog bites, and the indignities of living will behidden away. But anyone with bi-focals will see a City in limbo.

I met a black man who was arrested because he had no running water in his home, so, I hope that your is fact and truth based.

The reliable rumor mill has reported since the fifties that Bull Connor was engaging in some unsavory things in parts of Black Birmingham, and was often heard saying that he was "directed" to put on a show for the cameras. I don't know this to be true, but the rumors have been ofetn repeated.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Duddly Dooright
05:54 PM on 06/12/2012
Tell me where the race riots were in the 60's. Not the south.
02:32 PM on 06/11/2012
Mr. Browder, why not induce true & full history of mankind? Seems to me if everyone knew the true nature of man and how we came about, there'd probably be not much racism at all, & we might get along. On all sides of color. All human life started in Africa according to history right? Many migrated north in the cold atomsphere for centuries right? Pigmentation and other things took effect to slowly change the staus of men along with other factors right? If this is all right, and had we been teaching this type of history all along the way, the world might not be moled the way it stands today. I'm not racist because i know this. We all derived from one status. Man. Were all brothers & sisters. There's other causes that cause divides & racism. Designed teachings from those in power. Fearful people not understanding one another. Intimadating figures, Mad men who are being unjustly treated. I look at all sides of cultures & race. I don't blame anyone for their mind manipulated views towards other races. I blame controllers who've designed, induced, & still brainwashing society & pitting us against one another!
03:25 PM on 06/11/2012
You must not be from the South. I'll wager $1K that white Southerners would ever believe, much less allow to be taught, that the human race began in Africa.
photo
LeftRightCenter
Imagine a world w/no hypothetical situations...
05:55 PM on 06/11/2012
i don't care what anyone says ALL BLACKS are from the south ~via~ AFRICA
07:18 PM on 06/11/2012
Lol! Youre right bro! Born & raised in Detroit. That's one bet i'd never take! I agree. The majority would never believe such a thing. Guess just take care of the ones we love that means something to us. Can't ask for much more in today's rat race Lol !
photo
Summer of 69
Shenanigans & Chicanery
10:37 AM on 06/12/2012
Actually, hasn't the "Out of Africa" theory been under fire lately from DNA testing and anthropological evidence?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
BiggpussJr
pissin em off one comment at a time.
10:46 AM on 06/12/2012
No it hasnt.
12:33 PM on 06/13/2012
This is what i live for, dialog Lol! Actually i'm not sure Summer. That's why i put question marks behind the questions Lol! I will look further into this DNA & anthropological evidence. I hope my findings bind us in this manner. I hope it turns out were all connected. I will really begin my quest to unite Lol!
Emereaux
Cerca trova
12:53 PM on 06/11/2012
I look forward to reading more of the series.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
thebearclaw007
Is your conscience functioning properly?
12:32 PM on 06/11/2012
"Wallace was shot and paralyzed a decade after his inaugural remarks about "segregation forever"; he died years later, a changed politician and repentant man grieving about his role in history and history books."
The destiny of all racists as they prepare (on their deathbed) to enter hell.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:18 PM on 06/11/2012
Fifteen years since he has held any political office in Alabama... The last thing that anyone wants to hear is a old white guy, out of touch with the current political system in Alabama, much less America, wax on about what he had seen in his experience with racial animosity....This guy IS the problem.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lrobb
Gold Standard = four paws and a tail
01:17 PM on 06/11/2012
Actually, those who know the system are the most able to explain/evaluate the system. Anyone who chooses to ignore the system usually comes up against it with fatal effects.
11:19 AM on 06/11/2012
I've been reading the comments which comes from all sides ( and cultures) in America. Too bad this type of truth discussion doesn't go on throughout society; maybe we could get to the bottom of our problems.

This site reminds me of Black History Month where the educational programs that discuss the reality of our history in America is shown at 2 O'clock in the morning! (Lol); I laugh to keep from crying.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lrobb
Gold Standard = four paws and a tail
01:24 PM on 06/11/2012
A very good resource for understanding the anthropology of how we got where we are and why is Colin Woodward's book "American Nations."

The original 13 colonies and their back countries were settled by incredibly diverse people. That the North thinks the South is intellectually dim goes back to the 1690's. That the South thinks the North is same goes back to 1710.

The North was settled by people who came here to escape the Church of England. The South was settled by the younger sons of English gentry. You really think this has no effect in current politics?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lrobb
Gold Standard = four paws and a tail
02:08 PM on 06/11/2012
Bless you for noticing. Whether or not you acknowledge it, you may be an historian. If you have never considered this, perhaps you should.

I was actually an US history major at UCSB in 1969. History does not allow for politics--it is what it is. It either happened or it did not.

You might want to look at Colin Woodward's book "American Nations." It is one of the best explanations I have found for the present toxic polaritization. It is an explanation of the cultures which founded America and how they have influenced it since.
11:02 AM on 06/11/2012
hopefully this series won't be another "the south aint so bad after all" one. blacks should have left the south 150 yrs ago and went to the east and west coast,with a strong presence in the great lakes area they can have the south.the country is racist all over but in the south the game is super rigged,you can't even defend yourself down there,or get money. the south basically sucks to me,i feel the aura of hate when i go there. that fake paula dean attitude is the worst they smile and make nice,knowing they would hang you at a bbq for no good reason.
hroark314
The handle says it all, doesn't it?
10:25 AM on 06/11/2012
'Therefore, it is difficult to articulate -- clearly, concisely, and authoritatively -- the changed role of race in real Southern politics.'

I don't want to be critical of this eight part series before reading at least a few more posts, but I'll say this. Browder's first post was anything bu clear or concise. He spent 925 words informing us that he'll be writing about the politics of race in the South without expounding on the topic itself at all.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lrobb
Gold Standard = four paws and a tail
11:21 AM on 06/11/2012
It is called a "teaser." The whole point is to get E-Mail addresses where he can send notifications his next blog in the series has arrived. In this way he builds up his on-line presence and possible elevation to "pundit" status on the news program and lecture circuit.
hroark314
The handle says it all, doesn't it?
01:16 PM on 06/11/2012
Thanks for the info - I didn't know how the business behind this worked. I still think the piece was a bit long on words and short on teasing.
photo
victorianism
Theultrathinnothingnesshasabeautifulendforusall.
11:49 AM on 06/11/2012
Maybe he sounds (in choosing his words) a little bit academic, lyric, and somehow platonic, the wording of his this post is surely one of the best I have ever come across.

Try not to be so mean, please. Let's wait and see how he runs through those historically always problematic racial issues up to the now still unpleasant realities between races. Anyone who actively and positively chooses to discuss these subjects deserves tremendous credits. The nation needs such a systemic analysis from a real experienced specialist like Mr. Glen Browder so badly right now.
hroark314
The handle says it all, doesn't it?
12:42 PM on 06/11/2012
I don't think I was being mean - just critical of his exposition. I'll read one or two of his posts as they come out, but I thought this piece fell into the bucket of 'many words written, little actually said.'
03:12 PM on 06/11/2012
Thank you for shedding a bit of light on his post. Yes He is a bit academic in his approach and will turn off many of the readers I know here. Perhaps Mr. Browder should at least use a more reader-friendly approach,
photo
Gaaltero
Conscious Black Man
10:17 AM on 06/11/2012
The South is racist everyday of the week. The North sometimes takes weekends off.
accelerando
my micro-bio is empty
09:57 AM on 06/11/2012
the two great southern racial proxy wars right now are the interconnected issues of property tax reform and school choice. Whites who send their kids to private schools resent having to pay for the public ones. The private schools need ever more revenue to keep up, but can't raise tuition above the pay grade of their many lowish wage workers, esp in rural areas. This even though they stick the public schools with all the black, poor, and disabled students who push down the statistical averages even in schools where a very good education can be had. The whole issue is cloaked in baroque prose and garbed in the neo-conservative dress worn by the GOP down here.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lrobb
Gold Standard = four paws and a tail
10:49 AM on 06/11/2012
Why then did the vast minority population of DC go up in arms when the Democrats eliminated their school choice programs? Allowing parents to take their children out of failing schools , give them an education stipend and put them wherever the parent thinks they can learn the best does far more for poor minority children than wealthy white ones--who are usually not found in failing public schools in the first place.
photo
Basil08
Zero tolerance for "truthiness".
12:03 PM on 06/11/2012
"does far more for poor minority children.."

Except the ones (the majority, I might add) that did not win the "voucher lottery" and are continously stuck in the poor, failing schools. Would be nice to, instead of giving money to poor students to attend private schools...fix up the public ones so ALL kids can have access to a decent education, and not just the ones who were lucky enough to have their "name come up" for a voucher....
Emereaux
Cerca trova
12:55 PM on 06/11/2012
Very well put! F&F
photo
Robert McGehee
I used to be indecisive...Now, I'm not sure.
09:10 AM on 06/11/2012
In the early 70's I went to Montana to visit an Air Force buddy. I had never been there. Now, my friend had given me a really hard time about the way we southerners treated blacks, in spite of my insisting that not all southerners behaved as he insisted. He also claimed there was absolutely no racism in Montana. One of the first things I noticed was that there were also very few blacks in those days. One evening as the sun was going down, we were walking along the main street of the small town where he lived. Coming toward us was a Native American gentleman, long braids hanging over his shoulders. My friend just stopped dead in his tracks on the sidewalk, forcing the Native American to step off into the street to pass. As he did so, my friend said quite loudly, "almost sundown, and all of them are supposed to be out of town." I lit into him about that, but he just looked at me puzzeled and said that "Negros are human beings. Injuns are mostly animals."That was when I really understood racism.
photo
victorianism
Theultrathinnothingnesshasabeautifulendforusall.
12:01 PM on 06/11/2012
'My friend just stopped dead in his tracks on the sidewalk, forcing the Native American to step off into the street to pass'---here it is: doing nothing means more racism.
photo
HHGodd
We will move FORWARD without you!!!
08:40 AM on 06/11/2012
I can agree that racism is far more prevalent in the south. But one of the most racist cities in the country is a northern city: Boston, Mass.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
PolecatMtn
07:26 AM on 06/11/2012
MLK, Jr. said that racism would eventually be worked out in the South...but he said that in the North it would continue to prevail.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Brady McElligott
Political parties exist for their own preservation
01:14 PM on 06/11/2012
That is because in the South, the slave/slaveowner type of racism was a way of life that everyone grew up with, a way of life that officially ended by law, and is still dying away (thank God). In the North, the racism was taken by choice, and continued by choice, as "unwritten law".