iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Glenn W. Smith

GET UPDATES FROM Glenn W. Smith
 

Rick Perry's Deadly Medicaid Dunking Booth

Posted: 07/10/2012 12:26 pm

Texas Gov. Rick Perry is turning the state's health care system into the equivalent of a deadly carnival dunking booth. Taxpayers will be forced to buy mandatory tickets to guarantee that some of their neighbors drown.

How did he do it? It's simple, really. By refusing to participate in federal Medicaid expansion, Perry (if the next legislative session approves his plan) will force local taxpayers to pay for otherwise uncompensated care provided the unlucky at public and private hospitals. Hospital district taxes will rise. So will health insurance premiums for those lucky enough to have insurance.

Perry is asking Texans to pay for the guaranteed suffering and unnecessary deaths of their neighbors. The same is no doubt true in the other states led by GOP governors hell-bent on opposing President Obama. Jonathon Swift couldn't imagine such a plot line.

A few years back, Texas' Republican state Comptroller, Susan Combs, estimated the annual costs of such care to run in excess of $10 billion. That means Perry wants Texans to pay ten billion simoleons for the pleasure of watching their neighbors disappear in his deadly dunking booth.

It's one thing for a people to sit passively while others suffer, rationalizing it as the fault of the irresponsible. It's quite another thing to pay one's own money to make sure the unnecessary suffering happens.

Did I mention that Texas has the highest number of uninsured in the country? Or that it provides the worst health care in the country according to the federal Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality? Since most developed countries provide better health care than the U.S., and since Texas is the worst in the U.S., it's not much of a stretch to say Texas provides its citizens the worst health care in the world.

Now we can add that Perry and his cronies actually want Texans to pay to maintain that dubious distinction. It's true that because Texas has in the past been so stingy with Medicaid that joining the rest of civilization might cost it $6 billion in catch-up money. Still, according to Texas' Center for Public Policy Priorities:

The Texas Health and Human Services Commission has projected that even with a large enrollment increase in Medicaid for poor adults, our Medicaid costs would only increase by $5.8 billion from 2014-2019, and the state would receive $76.3 billion in federal matching funds -- a net gain of $70 billion.

That's some carnival. Under the Perry plan, Texans will pay $70 billion over the next few years to make sure their neighbors continue to receive poor care or no care.

Participation in Medicaid expansion would help Texas hospitals. The Texas economy would be helped with the return of Texas' federal tax dollars. People, obviously, would be helped. Oh, and Texans could keep their billions they will otherwise spend on Perry's dunking booth tickets.

But all that is so much West Texas sand in the heads of Perry and his gang. What matters is that he be seen standing up to the alien in the White House. Playing to his party's crazies, Perry is seeking political advantage from the suffering of others -- and asking the rest of us to pay for it.

But this will only play to Perry's political advantage if voters remain unaware of what it means. When they learn that Perry wants them to finance the unnecessary suffering of others, the Texas governor might find himself, finally, tossed out of the pan and back to the Texas Panhandle where -- well, as it turns out his old neighbors there don't like him much either.

Medicaid expansion would cover as many as two million currently uninsured Texans. The federal government would pick up the entire cost of that coverage for the first three years, and 90 percent of the cost after that. Every state can get that deal.

Still, GOP governors like Florida's Rick Scott and Louisiana's Bobby Jindal are striking their anti-Obama poses, claiming that by not participating they are saving their states from financial ruin. Even their public claims are false, as Politifact said of Gov. Scott's preposterous comments.

And, typically, the costs of maintaining dysfunctional health care systems are not included in the analyses. When they are, the macabre insanity of America's far right is clearly evident.

 

Follow Glenn W. Smith on Twitter: www.twitter.com/glennwsmith

FOLLOW POLITICS
 
 
  • Comments
  • 110
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3  Next ›  Last »  (3 total)
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Carl Caroli
I just don't understand people
08:06 AM on 07/11/2012
The thing is, most of these idiot governors will be out of office before it really hits the fan.
photo
MarcDel
What a child should never see
07:28 AM on 07/11/2012
A bold move in the race to the bottom. Texas still leads and sadly other states often strive to run neck and neck with them. How often have we heard how other states have to compete with Texas in low wages, no unions, cuts in school funding, no social safety net, no insurance. What a model to strive to complete with...........
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
TXconfidnz
Schpelling Bea Regect
07:25 AM on 07/11/2012
Rick Perry = world class FAILURE

The state of the state of Texas:

Near the bottom:
— Tax expenditures per capita (47th)
— Percent of population 25 and older with a high school diploma (50th)
— Percent of poor people covered by Medicaid (49th)
— Percent of population with employer-based health insurance (48th)
— Per capita spending on mental health (50th)
— Per capita spending on Medicaid (49th)
— Percent of non-elderly women with health insurance (50th)
— Percent of women receiving prenatal care in first trimester (50th)
— Average credit score (49th)
— Workers' compensation coverage (50th)P

Near the top:
— Number of executions (1st)
— Public school enrollment (2nd)
— Percent of uninsured children (1st)
— Percent of children living in poverty (4th)
— Percent of population uninsured (1st)
— Percent of population living below poverty (4th)
— Percent of population with food insecurity (2nd)
— Overall birth rate (2nd)
— Amount of carbon dioxide emissions (1st)
— Amount of toxic chemicals released into water (1st)
— Amount of hazardous waste generated (1st)

http://shapleigh.org/system/reporting_document/file/509/texasonthebrink.p
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
NoPartyCharlie
02:49 AM on 07/11/2012
This is terrible. Also stop acting like there aren't any other ideas other than Obama vs. republicans. When Obama passed the individual mandate, it gutted 500 BILLION dollars out of medicare/medicaid. The Supreme court was presented with only TWO choices. Either a terribly reactionary decision, strike the whole bill out of existence which means that people with preexistening conditions are shunned, OR gut 500 billion dollars out of medicare by adding the individual mandate penalty. There was nothing inbetween, such as deleting the bad policies of the bill and keeping the good ones such as pre existing conditions and that health insurers have to pay 85 cents to the dollar for your actual care instead of 70 percent. If you don't understand why the mandate is corrupt, just know that it came out of Dick Cheney's think tank the Heritage Foundation. Stop whittling down the debate to Obama ( good) and the Republicans ( bad). Its more like Bad vs Badder
07:40 PM on 07/11/2012
Yep..the whole thing is corrupt...ask Mitt... he thunk it up!
whitebeach
Hey, buddy, can you spare a micro-bio?
08:09 PM on 07/10/2012
Yep, Jindal is running the same hustle here in Louisiana, where 20 percent of the population has no health insurance. At some point he'll probably take the money, same as he took the money that Mary Landrieu rightly secured for our state when she voted for the Health Care Act (for which, of course, she was lambasted as a prostitute by the likes of Rush Limbaugh). But when he does, it'll be announced on page 16 of some press release put out on the Saturday afternoon of a holiday weekend, and until then all you'll hear from Piyush Jindal is how fiercely we must resist everything to do with 'Obamacare."
07:41 PM on 07/11/2012
Same in Florida...looks like Moe Larry and Curly have all got the same idea... I can tell you which one is Curly... and its not Jindal or Perry.
photo
unitron
Reverse Chron Order never stays checked
07:46 PM on 07/10/2012
Maybe if Republicans go just a little farther with this willing suspension of sanity thing we can have them involuntarily committed.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:41 PM on 07/10/2012
Despite Governor Perry's stated opposition

so far Texas has sought and received $901,131,693 of federal funds made available through the Affordable Care Act.

Lune
photo
Feesister
You've got to give to get back
07:26 PM on 07/10/2012
The GOP won't be satisfied until the whole of this country is one big "Pottersville."
07:07 PM on 07/10/2012
No ,I live in Texas and that man is so racist; think back to his "special word rock" at his ranch house. What this is about is the hard core tea party republicans like Rick Perry do not want the Hispanic population to have insurance as they want to keep the poor very poor and desperate which equates to cheap labor! I believe he should be sued by the federal government for his mismanangement of Texas healthcare system which he and Gregg Abott state they can handle texas healthcare in house yet we are dead last in America. Numero 50 dead last.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
skylark
Tangled up in blue..
07:26 PM on 07/10/2012
Fanned and faved.
07:56 PM on 07/10/2012
I believe you have hit the nail on the head. Sadly ... by denying heath care to the poor, which is mostly minorities, the white rich class can stay in power. The Heritage report which states that Caucasians will become a minority by 2050 scares the daylights out of them. (btw, I am mostly white. ;)
06:50 PM on 07/10/2012
I absolutely abhor this man...Gov. Good Hair, as Molly Ivins used to call him. Over, and over, and over again, the people in this great state vote against their own best interests. I wish I understood why. Those of you not native to Texas really can't understand the truth to this article and many of the corresponding comments. Regardless of the incontrovertible evidence against Rick Perry's failed policies, Texans keep him in the Governor's Mansion and then wonder why our state is a laughing stock. Makes me angry, sick and extremely sad.
keithdengenis
Thinking... It's Patriotic
11:50 PM on 07/10/2012
Diebold voting machines plus, the "right people" overseeing vote counts and certifications of elections.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Teal-Nina
empathy is a virtue, not a slur
05:53 PM on 07/10/2012
Yes they are holding out so that they can rightgeously recind "Obama-care" and replace it with their excellent plan, ( which they refuse to disclose untill then) why? because Rep. Alan Grayson already defined their health care plan on the floor of congress... GOP plan: "don't get sick" ... and if you do "die quickly"
08:24 PM on 07/10/2012
Their plan is simple: Don't get sick. If you do get sick, die, and die quickly. (Thank you, Alan Grayson.)
fo3angels
Equality is only equality if it is for all
05:46 PM on 07/10/2012
Ah-HAH! I found an error of mine, with respect to the total cost of Medicaid nationwide. According to http://www.statehealthfacts.org/comparecat.jsp?cat=4, total cost of Medicaid, nationwide, was $389B for fiscal year 2011. New York had the highest part of that $389B pie, coming in at $52B. Out of that $52B, if the feds paid $1.20 for every $1 paid by New York (a common figure), New York paid $23.6B. And if the expansion increases the total bill a whopping 10%, that would make New York's total $57.5B, of which they would pay a whopping $5.57B after the expansion is fully implemented. Now, if the Governor of New York tries to say that his state 'can't afford' the expansion, when after fully implemented the budget item would be $18B LESS, then I call shull-byte on the whole mess!
05:25 PM on 07/10/2012
He will take the money. You can bet on it. He's just throwing some red meat to his growling angry base. He already has one hand behind his back open wide. Enjoy getting played right wingers....he doesn't fool me one bit.
05:19 PM on 07/10/2012
Simple answer is to move.
photo
RuthieBabe
My kids are alien scientists from Alpha Centauri.
05:43 PM on 07/10/2012
If you are poor, you don't always have the means or the money to do so.
06:20 PM on 07/10/2012
Not so easy to find a job elsewhere and sell a house that's probably worth less than the mortgage, and uproot from community and family.
photo
robadeau
Your labels have expired
06:51 PM on 07/10/2012
I'd do whatever it took to get out of Texas. The last time I was in Houston the air made my nose bleed and my lungs hurt. And that was ten years ago. Can't imagine what it's like now.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Obviator
04:51 PM on 07/10/2012
Seriously can't stand this guy. I am a native Texan and I am not the only one who can't stand him. He is a parasite and so dug in its hard to pull him out.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Haveissues
You well heeled big wheel, ha ha, charade you are
05:24 PM on 07/10/2012
I'm with you there fellow Texan. There are a few of us here.
photo
RuthieBabe
My kids are alien scientists from Alpha Centauri.
05:45 PM on 07/10/2012
I third it! I tried to vote him out last time. I am hoping next time there will be more of us and less of them and he will be thrown out.