iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Greg Carey

GET UPDATES FROM Greg Carey
 

Imagining the First Christians

Posted: 08/20/11 12:10 PM ET

During the first session of introductory New Testament courses, I often invite students to imagine a different world. After introductions, the distribution of the syllabus and other preliminaries, students ponder: Imagine a world in which the average life expectancy for women is 25 or 30 years, where men's average life expectancy is more like 40. Imagine a world in which the average woman must complete pregnancy at least five times -- just to hold up her share of the population. Imagine cities in which perhaps one in three inhabitants are slaves. Imagine living on a street lined with four- or five-story apartment buildings, a street only six or eight feet wide and served by no public plumbing. Imagine living with no meaningful police force, where the strong almost always get their way and violence frequently resolves conflicts.

What would religion look like in a world like that?

Religion offered two major benefits for most people in the Roman Empire: protection and belonging. You and I may have learned about the classical Greek gods in high school, but the early Christians (those who were not Jews) inhabited a richly populated spiritual universe. Local gods, regional gods, professional gods, family gods and household gods expected recognition and required satisfaction. Evil spiritual forces also lurked, threatening to harm the unobservant. Acknowledging the gods, whether through direct personal worship or through public festivals and ceremonies, provided protection for households and communities. Moreover, honoring the gods fostered community, as trade guilds, burial societies, ethnic groups, and extended families linked religion to their diverse group identities.

Earliest Christianity offered one alternative movement in that complicated spiritual economy. Emerging from Judaism, a significant ethnic and religious minority identity in its own right, the first churches stood among those ancient religious movements that offered individual mystical experience, promised the ability to transcend death and cultivated alternative communal relationships. Their competition included popular philosophical movements that trained people to discipline themselves in order to transcend suffering and respond to Fate (capital F) with freedom and equanimity.

Those earliest churches displayed one particularly remarkable trait: a passion to keep in touch with one another. We see this most clearly in Paul's letters, many of which include greetings and news from cities all over the eastern Mediterranean world. Paul sends and receives reports from one city after another. He praises the believers in Thessalonica, capital of Macedonia, because their reputation has spread not only throughout Greece but also "in every place" (1 Thessalonians 1:8). While in Ephesus (modern Turkey), Paul receives news from Corinth (in Greek Achaia; 1 Corinthians 1:11-13; 7:1). To Rome he sends representatives from Corinth and its suburbs (Romans 16:1-2). As Paul raises money in Corinth, he reminds the believers there of the generosity he has received from other regions of Greece (2 Corinthians 8:1-7).

We occasionally receive brief glimpses of the passionate regard these early Christians held for one another. We cannot confidently identify the location to which the Gospel of Mark was addressed, but the story pauses for one telling detail. The Romans compel "a passer-by," a certain Simon from Cyrene, to carry Jesus' cross. This is how the story identifies Simon: "It was Simon of Cyrene, the father of Alexander and Rufus" (15:21, NRSV). Cyrene was in Libya, and apparently Simon had moved to Roman Palestine, but for our purposes that's not the point. Imagine Mark's first audience as they hear the story for the first time. "It was Simon -- you may know him. You certainly know his sons Alexander and Rufus."

Perhaps Alexander and Rufus are in the room when the story is read. Perhaps their names evoke warm memories. Somehow Simon's accidental brush with Jesus has created a legacy. Two of his sons -- Did he have only two? Did he have daughters? -- stand among the prominent believers a generation later. This little aside in Mark's Gospel reveals the importance of such relationships for the earliest Christians.

The New Testament's very existence testifies to how passionately the earliest Christians kept in touch with one another. Some people imagine a group of powerful old men selecting the New Testament books in a smoke-filled room. That's not how things happened at all. The formation of the New Testament largely emerged organically. Imagine a church in one city, which might share a copy of Mark's Gospel with another church that lacked it. Imagine churches distributing their copies of Paul's letters with one another so that eventually most of the churches have the same collection. For the most part, the New Testament canon grew from the books that were the most widely read and treasured.

By a certain point in the second century, it seems most every significant church read and possessed copies of the four Gospels, Acts and 10 letters attributed to Paul. Other books also circulated, but less evenly. Some of these made it into the canon while others did not. The primary factor in their inclusion was their widespread use.

Imagine, again, how these books circulated. No class of professional scribes had emerged in the early churches. Instead, individuals copied their manuscripts by hand. They used extremely expensive writing materials such as papyrus and animal skins (parchment), which required a lengthy manufacturing process. They found ways to circulate these documents with one another over vast distances in challenging travel circumstances. These believers, most of whom had never met, went to such great lengths to share these resources because they cared deeply for one another.

In my next post I'll reflect on the diverse people who populated those earliest churches.

 
 
 

Follow Greg Carey on Twitter: www.twitter.com/GregC666

During the first session of introductory New Testament courses, I often invite students to imagine a different world. After introductions, the distribution of the syllabus and other preliminaries, stu...
During the first session of introductory New Testament courses, I often invite students to imagine a different world. After introductions, the distribution of the syllabus and other preliminaries, stu...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 421
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (6 total)
06:25 PM on 08/25/2011
The books of the New Testament were indeed dictated by one man, Irenaus, the first Catholic Bishop (although at the time they weren't known as Catholics); He said that the books, Matthew, Mark, Luke and John, formed the four pillars of the Church. He blasted many books extant at the time including The The Apocryphon of John , the Gospel of Thomas, the Apocalypse of Paul, the Apocalypse of Peter, The Gospel of Truth, and many, many more that the Christians we now call Gnostics were using at the time.
It's easy to discover more by reading Elain Pagle's work.
Also, look for Irenaus, The Canon of Truth, and the Battle Against Gnosticism. Irenaus waged a war against Gnosticism and its writings.
The four Gospels did not arise organically as Mr. Cary would have you believe. Perhaps he is unaware of the Nag Hammadi Library

Irenaeus of Lyon, "An Ancient Indictment and Overthrow of the Falsely Named 'Knowledge'"
photo
Danish Lass
Think before you speak.
09:49 AM on 08/25/2011
In other words, nobody had the opportunity to be lazy.
02:28 AM on 08/25/2011
If it had not been for Constantine, most of us today would have never even heard of Christianity.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:01 PM on 08/24/2011
were not the fist people to be called christian in syria? the first church est'd in antioch...
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
10:24 AM on 08/25/2011
"It was in Antioch that the disciples were first called Christians." Acts:11:26
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:02 AM on 08/25/2011
oh ty. i will keep that noted.
photo
warloch2
Spraying cold reality from the hose of truth.
03:58 PM on 08/22/2011
Here is something to think about:

http://youtu.be/iGf4sMVC7so

:-)
11:58 AM on 08/22/2011
"Imagine a world in which the average life expectancy for women is 25 or 30 years, where men's average life expectancy is more like 40. "
The problem with statistics like these, people forget that it's coverage a wide range of death possibilities. If you have population of five women -one who dies of chickenpox when she is three, another dies from falling out of a tree at 7, another dies of the flu at 12, and the other two live well into their 70's, you suddenly have an "average" life expectancy of about 33 years! If you managed to live through childhood, you could easily live into your 70's. After all, how old was Saint Paul when he was killed?
12:47 PM on 08/22/2011
That's actually incorrect, for women at least. Many, many women died in childbirth during this era, which is a large part of the reason that the average life expectancy for men is so much higher.
storeysound
Zippy the Patriot?
04:22 PM on 08/22/2011
Not to mention the fact that the high incidence of death during childbirth continued right through the 18th and well into the 19th century in the Western world - and continues today in many lesser-developed parts of the world, where sanitation and medical practices are basically the same as they were at the beginning of the Common Era.
09:13 AM on 08/23/2011
Sorry, but that's a "Hollywood" myth. Yes, women died in childbirth. Women still die in childbirth -but it was hardly that large of a number. I'm not saying that it shouldn't be taken into consideration -just that people have a tendency to over estimate the amount and don't take the time to look at actual Roman medicine. The Romans were -for the most part- where we were back around 1910 or so. They understood cleanliness very well and had some comprehension about infections. They also knew how to deliver babies. What may actually contribute more to the numbers is the rate of infanticide. Female infants -unfortunately, just like today- where thought less of and were more likely to be left out for "exposure".
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
12:56 PM on 08/22/2011
About 59 years of age.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
edmundpua
observing life
11:34 AM on 08/22/2011
ah imagination... it can get random..

Funny how the almighty God choose to preach to his followers only 2k years ago, Shouldn't God be laying down the rules day one when God created humans like millions of years ago?
Shouldn't God be creating more advance and 'perfectly' programmed and obeying humans in the first place ?
Shouldn't the humans be living more than 25 year then but rather forever and ever in the first place, rather than the cumbersome transition into the spirit world and into heaven?

This God indeed a playful one
11:30 AM on 08/24/2011
"Shouldn't God be creating more advance and 'perfectly­' programmed and obeying humans in the first place ?" Where would the free will be then?

"Shouldn't the humans be living more than 25 year then but rather forever and ever in the first place, rather than the cumbersome transition into the spirit world and into heaven? " They do, in part. How could you know the transition is so "cumbersome", I'm just interested...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
edmundpua
observing life
03:06 PM on 08/24/2011
ah i'm just trying to make some sense into this imagination called religion. so this god is all powerful and all knowing + knows the future +can read our thoughts ? what hasn't god set with fool proof set of commandment to each and everyone here ? since god is omniscience and already knows all our choices .. ..i find free will somewhat lost.

if god really want us to obey,
shouldn't every person on earth be given exact same guidelines to follow ? but instead we are faced with countless variations in religions, with so many proclaiming god spoken to them .new and old testament- be The one and only testaments. shouldn't everyone intelligences be created equal?

from a carbon based body transitioning to a question mark, thats not cumbersome ? so i can imagine out there there is a brain/soul copier ? logging our every thoughts so it can be risen when we are dead to sit beside god.

anyways it's just some random thoughts of mine late at night....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
educatormary
Always encouraging inquiry and introspection
08:29 AM on 08/22/2011
Thanks for the article; I look forward to seeing what else you have to say about early Christians.
photo
Indigo1941
Time traveler.
08:14 AM on 08/22/2011
Primitive Christianity was probably much as you say, quietly celebrating their Lord and their circle of fellow believers. After Constantine established that cabal as the state religion, things changed so profoundly that it's unlikely the primitive Christians would have recognized it. The thing is, Christianity as we know it today is Constantine's state religion repeatedly reworked to fit into a social structure and has no solid grasp of what worship might look like without the state hovering nearby to endorse it. Consider only how desperately our succession of presidents in the US mouth the empty words "God Bless America" for fear of not giving the Christians their little wink, and you see how empty of the primitive spirit the existing forms of Christianity really are.
tino2892
In the beginning was the Word
12:13 AM on 08/25/2011
"Primitive Christiani ty was probably much as you say, quietly celebratin g their Lord and their circle of fellow believers. After Constantin e establishe d that cabal as the state religion,"

Wow, nice way to just brush aside 300 years of persecutions, tortures, deaths and savagery. Go read Fox's Book of Martyrs ( and no it has nothing to do with Fox News) and think about what you said. These Christians were being rounded up, set on fire, thrown to wild animals, stretched to death by horses, all because they refused to deny the name of Christ. And 300 years later, when the Church withstood all the wrath of the Romans, the Church grew and grew. It was then Constantine converted. but 300 years after. Thats longer than our country has been in existence.
11:16 PM on 08/21/2011
They say St Joseph Jesus father was married before (wive died I do not know) but Joseph had children from that marriage. Later St Joseph, married the Blessed Virgin Mary mother of Jesus. So Jesus had step brothers and sisters. Yes in those times brothers and sisters also meant those who were in the same  community living and community of the same Church called each other Brothers and sisters. So Jesus thou it seems,  had step brothers and sisters then if true. They say James the Just was the brother or step brother of Jesus next in line to take over would be  James the Just. Whom was called a very Holy man, but was not apostle to Jesus, came to be High Priest of the Christianity Church of Jesus.  In Judah religion if a Father dies, then the eldest son becomes Head of the family, when the eldest son dies, then next the brother in line becomes the Head of the family, then it continues. Priest blood line continues as Head, Jame the Just would fit that if he was the Step Brother of Jesus or real brother to be Head of and take over authority and Leadership. Interesting. Joseph and the Blessed Virgin both came from Royal Blood lines of the Priestly and King David.
11:09 AM on 08/22/2011
Hard to imagine Joseph having already fathered other children, since they're never once mentioned in the nativity scenes or Jesus' early childhood stories.. It seems far more likely that James et al were brothers and sisters of Jesus, the children of Joseph and Mary.
storeysound
Zippy the Patriot?
04:28 PM on 08/22/2011
Who is "they"? People trying to explain away the references to Jesus' brothers and sisters in an attempt to justify the "Ever Virgin" status of Mary even though there is no Biblical support for it? "Ever Virgin" is a total construct of the church in the period around the Council of Nicea, and lacks any scriptural basis.
02:22 PM on 08/21/2011
Christianity was not Legal under the Roman Empire. Not till Emperior Constantine endorsement of the tradition, was a turning point for the early Christianity, but not till 313 AD did Constantine issue The Edict of Milen -Legalizing- (history records, documented),  Christian Worship in the Roman Empire was now Legal. James ruled as Bishop of Bishop over the Christianity Church of Christ In Jerusalem as High Priest after Christ death for  32 years. James died in 62 AD, then shortly followed the death of St Peter in 64 Ad and then following that shortly after, the destruction of the Temple in 70AD after was destroyed by the Romans. Love all
10:14 AM on 08/21/2011
Also Churches that were already established did not hear about Christ but worshiping at that time God. One Church of Athens who's altar sign read, "To our unknown God" Peter went to spread the word of Christ at which all apostles did the same and were persecuted for, did so orally, spreading the Christianity of Faith of Jesus Christ. Paul does not come in till 11 or 14 years later after Jesus death. Paul was more educated then the apostles, thus the letters. But Paul seeks out St Peter and James the Just in Jerusalem,  who James the Just,  was at that time called the -Bishop of Bishops, who was k11led by the Pharisees the Ariann priest of the Temple, died in 62 AD and Peter in 64 Ad, Temple was destroyed in 70 Ad by the Romans. St Paul had to report to James the Just and Peter to become a follower of Christ and approved by them. For all Jews knew Paul very well, he persecuted and k1lled thousands of Jews. St Paul would not be accepted by followers of Christ, why St Paul in his letters is always defending himself to Christ followers.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
syntax facit saltum
We do not live in a 2 story universe
11:40 AM on 08/22/2011
The Athenian pagans had an altar to "an unknown god" -- not the Christians.

The dispute Paul had with the other apostles had to do with the status of gentiles with respect to what was called "the Way of Life" (Christianity).
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
02:36 PM on 08/28/2011
Hello Syntax, how's it going, what's new?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
StevenM
High School Chess Coach
10:06 PM on 08/23/2011
Much of what you wrote is either factually incorrect, or imaginative speculations without any facts for support. But the biggest whopper is: "One Church of Athens who's altar sign read, "To our unknown God" ..." which referred to a pagan altar not a Christian Church. Furthermore, no such inscription has been uncovered in Athens by archaeologist.
09:59 AM on 08/21/2011
Rome offered what? Protection? Security? 
Scholar Karen King, found in "Women in Ancient Christianity"- Paul letters offer some important glimpses in the inner workings of ancient Christians churches. First theses Christian groups did NOT own Churches, church buildings, but meet in groups, Homes of Woman (wealthy or otherwise) no-doubt- in part to the Fact that Christianity was- NOT Legal in the Roman World Empire and part because of enormous expense to such fledgling societies.
Woman played a Key Role, took leadership, in house, home churches.
Paul letters and in Acts bare truth and facts to this. Paul tells of woman who were leaders of such home churches-Prisca, Junin, Julis, Nereus sister who worked as missionaries. Emplifying woman their great prominence roles, their was Mary Magdeline and many more woman. Acts 174-12, Acts 16:15, Corinthians 16:19, Colossians 4:15, later first Century work  also - Didache-to christian prophets.
And also first earliest Christians communities looked upon the Books of OT as sacred scripture and read them at their religious assembles. What is made clear, Hegesippus, (Eusebius, Josephus, Church History. Note also James the Just, not a apostle after Christ agreed upon by all Apostles was Called the Bishop of Bishop, Christ church after Jesus death and recorded mention in bible Paul sent money to this Church. There was also many who called them self Christians who rose up after Christ but not all accept all that was spoken about Christ, many believed he was a prophet, some believed in the virgin birth some did not, many different Christian groups also.    either. Much was done orally, were poorly educated, could not read also.
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Grada3784
Dogmatic Dictators, believers or not, not welcome
09:26 AM on 08/21/2011
Those few still in undesecrated graves are probably spinning at high speed over what christianity has become.
08:41 AM on 08/21/2011
Roman Empire was in constant war with believers, pagans faith was the way to go then in Rome and christian were not accepted with such beliefs. Roman protection kidding right? Christ was crucified, was he not and arrested by Roman Soldiers? Rome ruled by military oppression over all citizens. Sorry do not agree and much is lacking and there were no books after the time of Jesus, much was spread orally by apostles before their death and after the apostles death, and the Temple was destroyed in 70 AD. Paul wrote letters yes but that was even years later. People were poor and and lacked education in the millions and could not even read, there were many different kinds of Christians also and uprising wars all over.