More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Greg Mitchell

GET UPDATES FROM Greg Mitchell

Twice Cursed: The Man who Survived the A-Bomb in Hiroshima -- and in Nagasaki

Posted: 08/14/11 06:50 PM ET

When I was a kid, my best friend Paul, in his animated way, told me (more than once) the story of a Japanese man who supposedly arrived in Nagasaki one day and while walking along a road told a friend about the unearthly bright flash he had seen in the sky over Hiroshima just three days before. Then it appeared again and the man said, "Just like... that!"

Of course, I knew that Paul was making this up. It certainly never appeared in any of my school books (but then so much else about the atomic bombings was also omitted, as I detail in my new book) . Imagine my surprise, many years later, when I learned, while visiting Japan, that the tale was basically true. A dozen or more Japanese men and women (the number is contested, because some were pretty distant from the blasts) are indeed considered "double hibakusha" -- survivors of both bombs.

I even got to interview one of them in Nagasaki.

Two atomic weapons have been used in wartime, and Kenshi Hirata, a diminutive, sad-faced accountant, experienced both of them.

When the bomb hit Hiroshima on August 6, 1945, Hirata was at work at the Mitsubishi shipyards two miles from ground zero. He escaped serious injury, but after wandering around the center of Hiroshima for two days, searching for his wife, he'd seen and smelled quite enough death. Somehow some trains were still running and he caught the first one leaving for his home town: Nagasaki. He carried with him the bones of his wife.

When it reached Nagasaki at 10:30 the following morning, he headed for home, a half-hour walk. His mother was relieved to see him, for she had heard that a new type of bomb had been used in Hiroshima. Hirata excitedly started describing the frightening white flash he had observed in the sky three days earlier -- when he saw it again through the front window about two miles away (so my friend's story was not so far off).

As one of the world's leading authorities on the effects of the atomic bomb, Hirata was a good man to have around the house. Grabbing his mother, he dove under a table as their windows blew in.

"The bomb that makes this white flash must be following my every step," Hirata thought afterward, as they cleaned up the broken glass. This time he did not go out and wander around the epicenter, his curiosity about new weapons that flash in the sky and blow out windows two miles away pretty much satisfied. He did not leave the house for weeks. "I did not want to see such sad, miserable sights again," he told me.

One had to appreciate the absurdity. Twice cursed or twice blessed? If you were A-bombed twice within three days, and survived, and went on to live a full, healthy life, would you consider yourself doubly unlucky or doubly lucky? "I felt so dishonored that I had to experience the atomic bomb twice," Hirata said, explaining why he had not talked about this until recently. "It's nothing to be boastful about. I could not talk to anyone about it because almost no one else met the bomb twice. So there was no one who could sympathize with me."

Greg Mitchell's new book is "Atomic Cover-Up: Two U.S. Soldiers, Hiroshima & Nagasaki, and The Greatest Movie Never Made."

 
 
 

Follow Greg Mitchell on Twitter: www.twitter.com/GregMitch

 
 
  • Comments
  • 10
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Peabodies
We are the Many. They are the Few.
10:51 AM on 08/15/2011
Thank you, Greg Mitchell, for this extraordinary account. I enjoyed your interview on Democracy Now, a few days ago. The horror of nuclear bombs came through loud and clear.
09:56 AM on 08/15/2011
I lived in Japan in the sixties and there was a club of double survivors (I do not know how many members). Hiroshima and Nagasaki are close together and many Hiroshima survivors had families in Nagasaki and went there when their city was destroyed. It goes without saying that they were rural folks to survive in the first place. I met a couple of these people and they had no animosity toward the United States just sadness for their loss. Both of them worked in a shipyard (SSK) in Sasebo and were very lucky to be a member of the club they belonged to!
09:29 AM on 08/15/2011
Incredible. Japanese culture is such that the dishonor would certainly overshadow any gratefulnes of survival.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
RButler
"Who wouldn't love a person who had a pony?"
02:06 AM on 08/15/2011
I saw an HBO documentary on survivors of the 2 atomic bombs that fell on Japan. The most remarkable thing was hearing through translators a complete absence of anger or bitterness at what they suffered through. An old Japanese woman who had some fingers missing, smiled at times throughout the interview recalling her experience as though it was a minor misfortune. I don't know how prevalent that lack of anger toward Americans is throughout Japan, especially for those alive during the war but it is an interesting phenomenon. I know. They started it and all that but these were civilians who suffered from the bombs.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gschear
Buhbye D. Rehberg, Sincerly, Bozeman MT
08:44 AM on 08/15/2011
As of WWII there really ceased to be civilians. A nation at war's "civilians" wave the flags, cheer the parades and produce the weapons that eventually are discharged upon themselves. This ladies stoicism probably reflects that knowledge that there are no innocents if you embrace nationalism. If you don't want to be injured in the game then refuse to play. Being a pawn in a chess game is stoopidity. Think for yourselves and one day Nationalisim will die. "Imagine there's no Countries."
12:54 AM on 08/15/2011
You are all aware that some US servicemen, who were part of the occupation forces in Japan following the war, died as a result of exposure to radiation. Many were unaware of the extent of their exposure until years later when they had families and post military careers that were cut short.
11:46 PM on 08/14/2011
So now some of them have lived through Fukushima, too. Fukushima's effects will probably (but not for sure) be slower and more insidious. But just as devastating, if not more.
07:14 PM on 08/14/2011
Stay away from this guy.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
Dosadi
Political agnostic
06:54 PM on 08/15/2011
He and that forest ranger that got hit by lightning 7 times should start car pooling.
07:01 PM on 08/14/2011
The magnificent absurdity of humanity is all I can think of. Tragedy and comedy, really two sides of the same coin.