More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Hal Donahue

Hal Donahue

Posted: February 23, 2011 03:15 PM

Last week, I viewed Walter Reed Army Medical Center from the inpatient perspective. The amazing dedication and commitment of all the staff reaffirms my belief in military health care. Even as this medical center is being resurrected at a new facility, the current staff concentrate on patient care. Apprehensions and uncertainty exist; some issues are being addressed and others ignored as the closure deadline approaches. Talking with staff and other patients, three issues caught my attention.

1. United States Marines

More wounded marines are patients at Walter Reed than Bethesda Navy Hospital. During my stay, five Marines were inpatients and 70 Marines were outpatients receiving housing and health care. A universal comment from many Marines was that patient care and support are outstanding. Most preferred Walter Reed over their experience at Bethesda Naval facility.

Staff attention and respect for these wounded warriors reaped high praise. One Marine mentioned that "they get it over here." The Marines praised the Walter Reed food service and their almost around-the-clock availability. When asked about returning to Bethesda Naval Facility, they mentioned two major challenges.

Proposed housing for wounded Marines is located far down hill from the new medical center on the Bethesda facility. The Marines are concerned that the housing location prevents easy access to facilities. When asked about shuttle service around the Navy grounds, their immediate response was that two handicap positions existed per shuttle meaning very long waiting times.

Normally this would not be a handicap for any Marine, even one with limited mobility. However, access around the Navy facility is problematic for the handicapped often forcing warriors to mix with vehicular traffic. One travel estimate from quarters to treatment facilities is an incredible 40 minutes.

2. Food Service

Bethesda Navy food service is limited with little food service to outpatients and families on weekends and evenings. Our wounded and ill are presently forced to travel long distances off campus to quietly dine together or else eat at the 'food court', which is fast food and not always available. Before, great frustration was voiced by Walter Reed food services staff. Coordination with Navy was limited and facilities at the new Walter Reed were only to be slightly expanded with continued limited hours of operation.

2011-02-22-fbchwayfinding.gif Finally, a first glimmer of hope, Walter Reed food service personal are enthusiastic now. New Walter Reed food service appears to be rising to old Walter Reed's standards of excellence. "We will get the food service up to the present standards we have here, but it can't be done in the time left to meet the BRAC deadline." according to one source. When pressed as to why the change, their impression is the Joint Task Force National Capital Region Medical (JTF) wrestled control from the Navy inside the new hospital. Several triservice personnel believe the JTF is rededicated to building the best facility and staff possible.

Further, cautious optimism exists for saving the Walter Reed Warrior Transition Brigade, one of the most successful in the Army, serving all military family members and scheduled to disappear. Hospital staff praise this brigade highly and value its critical support.

3. Traffic and Handicap Entry and Exit

Construction could begin at most entrances to the Bethesda Navy Facility just as the new Walter Reed National Military Medical Center opens its doors. This appalling mismanagement appears the result of Bethesda Navy officers shirking responsibilities to our wounded, sick, staff and their families. Is the situation serious? Very, when asked, an anonymous Navy health care provider answered via E-mail:

"...It's already starting. Four of my morning patients couldn't get here and then couldn't get parking on the base. They were all 1.5 hours late for their appointments. Too late to turn the ship around until we and the county are really ready..?"

When the additional staff, patients and families appear, chaos is near certain. Refusal to discuss construction with other services and local governments, while stonewalling progress toward resolution, caused this debacle.

Perhaps senior Navy leadership really "don't get it". These are primarily Army and Marine wars. No slight to the other services, our Marines and Army, including their senior leadership, have 'skin in the game'. Navy health care providers and many specialties do 'get it' every bit as much as their Army and Marine counterparts. Senior Navy leadership appears to be failing them. Just as the Navy failed all private and public health care by stifling lessons learned from Congressman Murtha's tragic death.

The New Walter Reed National Military Medical Center must be about caring for the entire military family's wounded and sick. This is the mission to be accomplished. Military service agendas cannot be allowed to subvert the mission. The Joint Task Force shows signs of realizing this and now, with the authority to take action within the walls of the hospital, they can execute the mission. Some Navy leadership certainly does not appear to put mission first. The entire campus should be designated a joint base rather than a Navy facility.

 

Follow Hal Donahue on Twitter: www.twitter.com/haldonahue

 
 
  • Comments
  • 11
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Hal Donahue
Concerned citizen tired of the lies
05:11 PM on 02/28/2011
Just so everyone knows. I did hear from the Navy and I have accepted their invitation to visit. I will keep everyone up to date as events unfold
06:42 AM on 02/25/2011
Mr. Donahue, We read your post with great interest and thank you for your commitment and interest in military healthcare. Unfortunately, your column contained some factual errors that we would be glad to discuss with you at your convenience. We would also welcome the opportunity to host you at the National Naval Medical Center to discuss your concerns, provide a tour and let you speak with our staff of Army and Navy medical professionals to show you the great work that is occurring there in supporting our wounded warriors and their families. You may also be interested in hearing that the U.S. Navy and Navy Medicine are very much in the fight today. The Navy has approximately 14,600 Navy personnel currently deployed ashore in the U.S. Central Command area of operations and the Navy Medical Department provides all healthcare to both Sailors and Marines around the world, whether it is in garrison, on the deckplate of warships at sea or on the battlefields of Afghanistan today. We look forward to hearing from you.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Hal Donahue
Concerned citizen tired of the lies
05:25 PM on 02/25/2011
My public e-mail is dhue@mindspring.com please do feel free to contact me. I would love a visit and will gladly provide a correction if necessary and appropriate.
I am very well aware of the fine work performed by Navy medical personnel at all levels of patient care. I have been their patient and I have watched them perform in harms way. There are no more dedicated people. My point is that Navy senior leadership at least in health care has created a debacle at Bethesda and has been doing so since BRAC implementation began. This piece is but one of a series of pieces I wrote on this ongoing affair. I look forward to hearing from you.
11:32 AM on 02/27/2011
Sounds great. I'll send you a note and we'll set something up.
04:29 PM on 02/24/2011
For the past five years, Marine Parents Purple Heart Family Support volunteers have helped to address the situation of limited weekend meal availability at Bethesda Naval Hospital by serving dinner one or two Sundays a month to families of the wounded, outpatients, and staff. Last year we served more than 2000 meals. We thank our generous donors and California Tortilla for their sponsorship, and we welcome more donations that could make it possible for us to be there more often. It's the least we can do for the families of the wounded warriors who have done so much for our country. For more information on our organization, visit www.marineparents.com.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Hal Donahue
Concerned citizen tired of the lies
06:58 PM on 02/24/2011
Susan, I know and I thank you and others who have stepped up to meet the need. I guess my point is that the need should not exist. Our Marines and other members of the military family, whether a WWII vet or a mother of a severely wounded military person, should never have to rely of volunteers such as yourself for basics. Folks like us should be able to provide 'extras' to help see our people through the tough times. Just my thoughts. But thank you so much for all that you do.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Cleverboots
07:11 PM on 02/23/2011
Where's Gates when he's needed? Thinking about his retirement?
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Hal Donahue
Concerned citizen tired of the lies
10:13 PM on 02/23/2011
I suspect inundated by trivia but if you saw the NYT today, the Navy has institutionalized 'misinformation' - it betrays the mission
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Cleverboots
10:52 PM on 02/23/2011
Thanks for your reply and the heads up. Haven't seen today's Times. Didn't you and I just have a similar conversation a few weeks ago? Sec'y of the Navy AWOL again?