More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Harlan Green

GET UPDATES FROM Harlan Green
 

Let's Put Americans Back to Work

Posted: 11/16/11 06:31 PM ET

It's becoming evident that rather than the political gridlock, such as the congressional supercommittee's obsession with spending cuts, we need to worry about economic growth and jobs.

There are some very good ideas on how to bring back economic growth and jobs, as in President Bill Clinton's newest book, "Back to Work". And economists such as Christina Romer, former Chairman of Obama's Council of Economic Advisors, in a recent New York Times Op-ed are pleading with the Fed's Ben Bernanke to actually target a growth rate that will both create jobs and keep inflation within a manageable range.

What? You mean the Federal Reserve's QE-1, 2, and 3 buying of securities wasn't doing just that? Well, no. It has accomplished the goal of keeping both short and long term interest rates low, but that hasn't done anything for setting expectations of higher growth. In fact, the Fed just downgraded its own predictions of future growth. If anything, such low interest rates reflect deflationary expectations, which is the real problem. Companies won't hire if they can't raise prices, while consumers' incomes fall in such an environment, stifling demand.

Dr. Romer and other major economists are beginning to insist the Fed should actually set what is called 'nominal' (i.e., before inflation accounted for) Gross Domestic Product growth target at the long term growth rate of around 5 percent. That way, expectations are raised for economic growth, without abandoning an inflation target of say, 2 percent, the current Fed inflation target.

How else can we boost demand for goods and services that is the actual driver of economic growth? We have discussed in a prior column how necessary it is for consumers -- who power 70 percent of growth -- to spend more, which in turn creates greater demand, which in turn creates more jobs in a virtuous circle. But they won't if their confidence remains low, which surveys show causes them to spend less.

Former President Clinton has much more to say in "Back to Work" that directly addresses how to put Americans back to work, and he should know.

"During my administration we had four surplus budgets and began to pay down the national debt," he says; we eliminated sixteen thousand pages of federal regulations; we cut taxes on the middle class, working families of modest means, and income from capital gains; we reduced the size of the federal workforce to its lowest level since 1960, and the economy produced 22.7 million new jobs."

How did he do it? By emphasizing cooperation rather than competition between government and the private sector.

"I believe the only way we can keep the American Dream alive for all Americans and continue to be the world's leading force for freedom and prosperity, peace and security," said Clinton, "is to have both a strong, effective private sector and a strong, effective government that work together to promote an economy of good jobs, rising incomes, increasing exports, and greater energy independence."

Why is strong government so important? It is what engenders both business and consumer confidence, which are still at record lows. And without that confidence, consumers won't spend to keep up demand, as we said, and businesses won't hire in anticipation of higher growth.

2011-11-14-Confidence
Graph: Econoday
Confidence from both the Conference Board and University Michigan surveys has remained at recession levels since 2008, really. And we know it a major reason for such low confidence is both political gridlock, and the S&P downgrade of U.S. Treasury bonds to AA+. This is what it means to lose confidence in our institutions, readers. Also, the subprime debacle that brought on the housing bubble caused a major loss of confidence in our Too Big To Fail financial institutions, which were allowed to gamble with their investors' monies, and then be bailed out by taxpayer money. But the mood measures have stood in contrast to strength in consumer spending. If recent gains for confidence can be extended in the weeks ahead, the economic outlook as well as expectations for holiday shopping will improve. Some thawing in the jobs market may be helping with sentiment. So confidence has to be restored in all of our institutions if we want to bring back economic growth.
"What's the smart, effective way to do that?" asks Clinton. "With a strong economy and a strong government working together to advance shared opportunity, shared responsibility, and shared prosperity? Or with a weak government and powerful interest groups who scorn shared prosperity in favor of winner take all until it's all gone?"
Studies have shown that only by sharing prosperity can we really create strong economic growth. And right now we rank near the bottom in income inequality, according to the much cited CIA World Factbook. So there is a lot of work to be done to restore confidence in Americans' future.


 

Follow Harlan Green on Twitter: www.twitter.com/HarlanGreen

 
 
  • Comments
  • 26
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
04:15 PM on 11/18/2011
let's be real, until the free trade with china is eliminated, there will be no job creation in this country. millions of low skilled, living wage jobs left because of it, and they will not return as long as it is cheaper to make somewhere else. so, either we reestablish protectionist tariffs, or learn to live on the $400 a month the chinese earn. modern corporations have forgotten the lesson henry ford learned. you can't sell products to people who don't earn enough. when he raised his wages to $5 a day, his fellow industrialists wanted to tar and feather him. because they would have to do the same to attract good workers. and soon, the economy was booming. workers who earn more spend more. workers who earn less, spend less. china never replace us as a consumer economy, because of their low wages.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Joe Goforth
12:46 PM on 11/18/2011
And we know it a major reason for such low confidence is both political gridlock, and the S&P downgrade of U.S. Treasury bonds to AA+

It's called spending to much money and creating far to much debt. Ron Paul will balance the budget.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TruelyFedUp
Ethics is nothing else than reverence for life.
10:08 AM on 11/18/2011
And...

So, by giving them jobs instead of land and the resources they needed to become self sustaining Roosevelt created nothing more than a nation of trained dogs ready to go to war in the name of "paitriotism". Had the same effort gone into creating free eco villages built and run by the residents and their families it is unlikely that we would even have a war. Men would not be interested in leaving families and land they controlled and that sustained them. Being thrown back into unemployment and hunger after the camp terms ended made them perfect candidates for further enslavement in a war machine.

We don't need no stinkin' jobs! We need land and the resources to make ourselves self sustaining, truly free men - then all our energy, creativity and joy can go to creating an economy and a government that serves US.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TruelyFedUp
Ethics is nothing else than reverence for life.
10:07 AM on 11/18/2011
"Studies have shown that only by sharing prosperity can we really create strong economic growth."

Then let's get expert at sharing prosperity and "REALLY create strong economic growth".

Last night I watched the PBS film Civilians Conservation Corps about Roosevelt's solution to the poverty and desperation in the 30s. His solution was to create work camps all over the United States and he put millions of men to work repairing the environment that had been destroyed through deforestation. The previously starving and desperate men were given 3 great meals per day, 6 hours of labor, new clothes and a wage of $1 per day, plus an education if they wanted it. These previously starved and desperate men were thrilled to have food, to learn to live with others of every background and to get trained in the discipline of work. They made an enormous contribution to the improvement of the environment. Later, they were well trained for fighting in the 2nd world war and moved smoothly into that role.

To be continued...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Joe Goforth
12:47 PM on 11/18/2011
If Americans didn't get assistance from the Government they might be inclined to go pick and grow their own food.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
kamact
Market Observer
09:34 PM on 11/17/2011
Money is like blood,...It has to flow to be healthy,...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gerald4
licensed mechanical and electrical engineer
07:33 PM on 11/17/2011
THE FOLLOWING ITEMS ARE THE MAIN REASONS FOR THE LACK OF JOB CREATION ACTIVITY IN THE USA?

US labor costs many many times as much as Foreign Labor according to the DOL website:

ftp://ftp.bls.gov/pub/special.requests/ForeignLabor/ichccpwsuppt01.txt

The cost of Extended Unemployment Benefits, National Healthcare Reform, vacations, holidays, sick pay, and social security costs are also added to US company payroll costs and economically preventing the location of new manufacturing jobs into the USA, and/or preventing the keeping of existing US jobs in the USA.

The increasing cost of compliance with existing and future environmental laws is deterring the creation of any new jobs the USA.

The cost of electrical energy that is generated in the USA in compliance with US EPA regulations was at many times the cost for the same amount (kilowatt hour) of electrical energy in most Asian countries and is still about twice the cost of US electricity

50fen/kwh = 0.078666 USD/kwh compared to $0.13-$0.15 kwh in USA

http://news.xinhuanet.com/english/2009-11/19/content_12492364.htm

The EPA is the main cause of the high electrical costs in the USA.

These costs are hindering the US businesses that are economically competing for obtaining manufacturing jobs for US citizens in the USA instead of those businesses having to relocate or create those jobs in/to foreign nations as allowed by US FREE TRADE AGREEMENTS.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
HarlanGreen
11:47 AM on 11/18/2011
And so you want us to live and earn same as Chinese workers, and breathe in their polluted air?? Wow, so disband the EPA, right, so we can regress back to the jungle!...wrong answer. Government isn't the problem--it's the 1% who have stolen from the rest of US.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jondrea Smith
untied dog in a dogmatic society
12:25 PM on 11/18/2011
"Not even a dog sh*ts where he sleeps..." --My mama

Without some type of environment consideration for the rampant industrialization that you laissez fair folk advocate, the Mississippi would look like the late 18th century Thames. I mean there's a flotilla of trash in the pacific the size of friggin Texas, and you believe that the answer is further deregulation? Sorry, but the world cannot be your hog-waller....
05:09 PM on 11/17/2011
The answer is simple and could be implemented over night. Huge taxes on the wealthy used to invest in infrastructure, reduce foreclosures and increase after tax spending of working class Americans. Since we have nearly laissez-faire capitalism in this country it will only take the wealthy 5 or 6 years and they will have gotten all of that money back in their bank accounts anyways; but, at least we would have some good years of prosperity for America's working classes and better roads and energy sytems to show for our efforts. Now we have nothing to show for the huge tax cuts and military spending by the Republicans over the past 30 years.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TruelyFedUp
Ethics is nothing else than reverence for life.
10:22 AM on 11/18/2011
This a loser's and a serf's strategy (sorry, I certainly don't mean that YOU are a loser or a serf!). But you are asking for crumbs as though there is no other option. Watch this video on the Civilian Conservation Corps that Roosevelt set up in the last depression. Starving men were so thrilled to have food and good work to do that they were prime candidates for being sent to war when the first handout ran out. Our government has had every opportunity to set up America as a nation of truly free men by simply releasing the land and resources so we the people can make ourselves self sustaining. If the basics of life were our BIRTHRIGHT instead of a privilege we earn by toeing the corporate line for THEIR handouts we would have a nation of truly free men and women with the time to be creative, productive, and enthusiastic about life for OUR benefit, not theirs.
12:19 PM on 11/18/2011
Capitalism is a casino game rigged to favor the house (those who already have capital). The only couter balance to the destructive mal-distribution of wealth that results from capitalism is a strong government that redistributes the wealth generated by capitalism in a way that ameliorates the most harmful aspects of capitalism, the lack of food, shelter and medical care for the large percentage of people who do not/ can not succeed in this type of system.

My belief in progressive tax rates and redistributive government programs is to save the best parts of capitalism from being destroyed by the worst parts.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gerald4
licensed mechanical and electrical engineer
03:59 PM on 11/17/2011
Consumer demand is strong, and is being met with foreign made products, because almost all US consumers demand the lowest proce for each purchase.

US consumrs will almost always NOT PAY anything EXTRA for any US made product.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Jerry Jablonski
06:40 PM on 11/17/2011
A poor economy and stagnant wages will force consumers to purchase the most economical product. Additionally, It's becoming difficult to find products made in the USA. Being in the trades, I have always favored the Carhartt line of work clothes. Carhartt now produces a lot of it's product in Mexico. On another note, a lot of what I am reading points to consumer demand growing but not where we need it for enough growth to reduce unemployment.
OnTheRoadAgain
Sister, this Kool-Aid tastes funny.
07:33 PM on 11/17/2011
In ~2003, I hauled a load of shoes out of the Bass "factory" in ME. The building was %90 empty, and the remaining 10% was a warehouse for the Chinese made stuff.
photo
guveqzero
Inventor and Innovator
08:39 AM on 11/17/2011
I don't get it. We saved the banking system and the wealthy with trillions from the federal reserve. It didn't work. And, the whole process is actually called fascism, government and corporations working together. Changing our government to be more like China is also very late in the process and our politicians aren't that smart, tough, or honest. You can't regulate criminals of white collar crimes unless you are prepared to put them in jail. This is something that China does with a firm hand. Are we ready to do the same? No, I think not.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
HarlanGreen
10:07 AM on 11/17/2011
Fascism means a weak government, owned by Oligarchs, who want no regulation or taxes except to maintain the military . Strong government is when it takes back the power from Wall Street and corporations. That is what Clinton accomplished, in spite of impeachment attempt by the religious extremists. It will take a populist movement to bring back government by the people, for the people. Politicians are only as smart as their electorate, and there has been too much apathy of voters lulled by the false good times. Maybe our youth are finally waking up to the fact, as in OccupyWallSt. China is run by the communist party, rather than its people.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
TruelyFedUp
Ethics is nothing else than reverence for life.
10:29 AM on 11/18/2011
And we keep being sold on "The American Dream" as if getting wage handouts from corporations is the best we can do for ourselves. Through usurious interest and bailouts we have paid in full for America and we need to claim it as our own. No more mortgage payments, no foreclosures, no more credit card debt = no more liability to corrupt extortionists. We should own outright our homes, the land and the resources of America and should be working together to create an end to wars, a clean and healthy eco system and to be self sustaining BEFORE we recreate our government and our economy to serve US.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ringo3khan
08:34 AM on 11/17/2011
When there's no prosperity there isn't anything to share.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
HarlanGreen
10:10 AM on 11/17/2011
That is the point--most of the 'pie' has gone to corporate profits and the wealthiest, who don't want to share it. It will take time and hard work to bring back prosperity all of US.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gerald4
licensed mechanical and electrical engineer
07:49 PM on 11/17/2011
Without profitable US businesses, US corporations, and US businessmen, there will not be any jobs for US citizens (in order to create wealth for those businesses), except for tax payer funded jobs which will disappear if businesses stop creating NATIONAL WEALTH that can be taxed to pay for government activities.

The US government must stop creating new legislation that drives US businesses and US jobs to foreign countries.

The US government should repeal the laws that they created that caused US businesses and US jobs to relocate to foreign nations.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
HarlanGreen
10:26 AM on 11/17/2011
Great article on what happened to prosperity, and why it's no longer shared--http://www.businessweek.com/magazine/how-inequality-hurts-the-economy-11162011.html