More

Harry Shearer

Harry Shearer

Posted: October 5, 2009 12:55 AM

New Orleans: Who Calls the Shots?

What's Your Reaction?

The good news: one day before the office was to expire, President Obama extended the life of the Gulf Coast Recovery "Czar" (don't tell Glenn Beck) for another six months.

 

The bad news: according to her interview with Sunday's Times-Picayune, the occupant of that office, Janet Woodka, who supposedly should be coordinating the efforts of federal agencies to facilititate and accelerate Gulf Coast recovery, and should be advocating for that cause with the powers that be, doesn't know who those powers be:

 

She is one of many people advising the president about what he should do and see while in New Orleans, but she does not know who ultimately calls the shots on that.
"I don't even actually know who that person is, " Woodka said. "Maybe it's the president himself."

Follow Harry Shearer on Twitter: www.twitter.com/letwits

 
 
  • Comments
  • 31
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:46 AM on 10/07/2009
"Maybe it's the president himself."

Harry, Harry, Harry. The woman has only been on the job since March, and she's been really really busy. There was a hurricane in New Orleans, or hadn't you heard? And you expect her, with a plate that full, to know who's in charge?!!! In only seven months time?!!! You are so negative!

Seriously, this kind of incompetence would be funny if so many lives weren't at stake.
She reports to Secretary of Homeland Security Janet Napolitano, and has a direct line to the White House. I imagine her sitting at her desk trying to guess who the mysterious person in charge might be. Maybe they told her, but she's bad with remembering names, and was too imbarrassed to ask. I think we all know how awkward that can be.

I see, from her appointment announcement from last March, that part of her duties as coordinator between the feds and local and state autorities are "restoring and protecting the environment," as well as coordinating the building of "better and stronger levees."
I wonder if anyone has told her that "better and stronger" has turned into "not technically superior?" I suppose it doesn't really matter, because, after all, who would she report it to? Ugh!
01:59 PM on 10/05/2009
Is this W's idea of a premium [langapie(sp?] to Pres Obama for buying Afghanistan & almost all of W's failed policies & initiatives?
photo
Bienville
Make levees, not war
01:31 PM on 10/05/2009
Oy. NOLA. We want to tax people who consume too much food (i.e., overweight) and are apparently a burden to the health care system, but we have no problems with rebuilding a whole city that is destined to once again be hit by hurricanes because it is below sea level and cost local and federal governments billions of dollars. I love Le Show, Harry, but your incessant cause to rebuild NOLA at our expense (i.e., levies!) is getting old.
02:34 PM on 10/05/2009
So we should let NYC sink, too, eh? And we should ignore it when the ACE takes our money and does not do the work? And , lest we forget, the city of NO is INLAND, and NOT at risk from sea storm surges, only the ones caused by poorly built (by the ACE) and maintained (anon) freshwater barriers and canals. Please do not tell us you listen to Le Show, when you so obviously don't, or you would know these facts...
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Harry Shearer
02:42 PM on 10/05/2009
I'm glad you like Le Show, but a couple of facts: more than half of populated New Orleans is at or above sea level (according to latest findings by Tulane University, released March 2008), and the cause of the flooding in 2005 wasn't a hurricane (it would have caused nothing more than "wet ankles" in NO, according to the ILIT report, had not the federal levees catastrophically failed).
03:12 PM on 10/06/2009
Agreed. It was the levees.
Were not the levees built, planned and constructed by the government?
Did not the government know that a category 5 hurricane would put the levee's at risk?
Did not the local/state/federal government make the call to "risk" a category 5 storm, because the odds were relatively low that such a storm would strike New Orleans in any given year?
Just pointing out that, sure, we need to build the levee's right this time, but let's not forget that it is our old friend the government that let us down on the levees.
I'm sure in the future, all levees built anywhere there is a risk of catastrophinc flooding by our friends, the government, will be built properly and prevent a Katrina like occurrence.
The Katrina disaster was merely one of the few, very rare, government failures.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Stuart
11:21 PM on 10/06/2009
Forget the sea level argument. The Netherlands, also "destined" to be struck by hurricane-force storms from North Sea, has areas relatively lower than even the lowest parts of settled New Orleans. They also enjoy flood barriers that actually work as specified.

Or take the argument inland: THe Corps of Engineers can build dams 800 feet high and people--perhaps even some of the indignant posters here--settle in the river valleys below and live happily for decades. So how is it that the same Corps of Engineers couldn't put up a 15 foot floodwall that could withstand water lapping three feet below the top for a few hours?

Go yet further inland. Has anyone done a cost accounting to the American taxpayer for all the hydration projects out West? How much is it costing the United States to green up the golf courses in Palm Springs or flush potties in Phoenix? I'll bet it's far pricier than the fifteen billion most experts agree would keep New Orleans as dry as...well, the Netherlands, for starters.

I'm a New Orleanian, but because I'm also an American you won't find me complaining (much) about my tax dollars going to support people living in the desert.
photo
LMPE
I connect the most dissimilar things
01:16 PM on 10/05/2009
OK, can we just move NOLA to someplace far inland, so that hurricanes don't hit it?

Oh, wait a minute. I forgot that the people in control of its economy don't want any change!
01:39 PM on 10/05/2009
LMPE, if exposure to hurricanes were a reason to relocate people out of New Orleans, then we might as well relocate everyone who lives in an area when events can be described by a scale, be it Saffir Simpson, Richter or Fujita.
02:35 PM on 10/05/2009
NO IS inland...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
JL-Sosa
(Nothing offensive here...)
12:49 PM on 10/05/2009
It is plain to see that what we need is an advice czar for the the recovery czar...

Technically, shouldn't she be called a Czarina? Now there's a piece of choice advice!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
10:48 AM on 10/05/2009
The end of the Bush era was supposed to be (among many other things it hasn't been) the end of appointing incompetents to posts that are supposed to be important. "Meet the new boss, same as the old boss."
03:14 PM on 10/06/2009
What a shock, The government is not the messiah and savior of all?
Who would believe that another government appointee might not be up to the task?
Wow. Who could have seen this coming?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
04:24 PM on 10/06/2009
Expecting competence from government appointees is hardly the same thing as expecting these people to be "messiahs and saviors," although it certainly seemed as if the Bush/Cheney crime syndicate were determined to set the bar so low that mere ability to do one's job would look like a miracle (if we had ever seen it). Putting people in place who knew how to do their jobs was one of the changes we were led to expect from the Obama administration--not miracles, not superhuman abilities, but simple competence.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
CrescentCityRay
12:08 AM on 10/07/2009
VeryFair, please try to understand that New Orleanians and our politicians have no choice but to accept whatever flood protection system the Corps decides to provide. That is precisely why many of us flooded New Orleanians are rebuilding our homes with living quarters raised above the flood line from the federal levee failures.In my family, we actually keep life jackets on the coat rack and a pirogue on the porch. I kid you not.
09:50 AM on 10/05/2009
This is highly disturbing to hear, especially since it's Congress that decides if and how New Orleans will be protected from storm surge.

Responsibility for storm surge protection got taken away from New Orleans (and nearby St. Bernard Parish) in 1965, and now those citizens are at the mercy of Congress, and ultimately the POTUS.
10:17 AM on 10/05/2009
Yes, Obama is supposed to be the Commander In Chief, yet appears to be getting all his direction from the Corps of Engineers, hence a Gulf Coast Hurricane Recovery Trip to the New Orleans Disaster Ward Thingy Place... a trip that doesn't include the Gulf Coast or Hurricane Recovery.
The Hurricane hit Mississippi and the Corps of Engineers hit New Orleans.
We survived the hurricane...
Go Figure...Go Fish!
As Harry described in one post "Going Insider", after a labyrinth of playing cards and who'dats, he finally met with the President's Word on this --and who did THAT turn out to be? You guessed it, our Exquisite Corps!

Everyone is saying we should be Nice to the President when he comes to town.
But, I really think our attitude towards his bourgeois naivete regarding the Flood of New Orleans does not matter, because he and his "people" don't seem to be listening to We The People.
While there is no cause for Rudeness, I am just about tired of Obama's Game and think he now owes us more than a few explanations about the Corps of Engineers continued Bad Engineering Scams --not more full court press partays.

We have problems in New Orleans:in-operable pumps, un-repaired bad flood walls, millions of dollars getting shifted around from project to project.
He has had the OSC Report on this (again posted by Harry) on his desk since JUNE.
We need Answers and we need Action from the Commander In Chief.
08:35 AM on 10/05/2009
I hate to say it but what gies around comes around. Louisiana's are famous for this type of shenanigans and you know what I am saying. They are just giving it back to us the same way : in spades. I think compaining abut this is a bit disengenuous. If Louisinana did not keep seeing the most unbelievabe crapola you can;t even make up in your wildest dreams they would think they woke up on Mars.
photo
Bienville
Make levees, not war
11:43 AM on 10/05/2009
I can safely say that I have no idea what you are "saying."
photo
Bienville
Make levees, not war
08:31 AM on 10/05/2009
Some "czar"!

Maybe someone should tell Beckie how little power some of these people really have.
07:43 AM on 10/05/2009
I guess I should be shocked at this development, but after watching the developments in NO since Katrina; and after spending a VERY frustrating 3 months there last year to assist in rebuilding efforts; and after watching Obama's NON-response to the situation you have covered so well.......NOTHING shocks me about this! A VERY VERY VERY SAD SAD SAD situation!!!
On the other hand, our world seems to be one in which not only most of us don't know who is in charge ANYWHERE of ANYTHING; judging by the health care/Wall St./Afghan debacles, NOBODY ANYWHERE wants to take RESPONSIBILITY for ANYTHING.