iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Hermene Hartman

GET UPDATES FROM Hermene Hartman
 

The Plight of Father Michael Pfleger

Posted: 05/10/11 10:27 AM ET

2011-05-06-pubpagemichaelpfleger.jpg

Father Michael Pfleger follows the priesthood in the tradition of the Baptist ministry of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. He is an advocate, a personality and an out of the box thinker. He is a leader, not an obedient bureaucrat.

Pfleger was strongly influenced by Dr. King. As a young man, he witnessed the marches for open housing, where he saw his white neighbors, friends and clergy become terrorists as King and other Blacks marched in his then neighborhood of Marquette Park in 1966.

This march, according to King, was the worst of any that he participated in because of the physical abuse. King was hit in the head with a stone.

Protesters' cars were turned over and burned, as was the case with Andrew Young, who was at that time a King aide. Whites climbed trees to call blacks monkeys and niggers and to tell them they would never live next door.

This was Pfleger's introduction to the Civil Rights Movement.

He saw King go undisturbed by the chaos, remaining focused on his goal. King had been hit, but remained unraveled.

It was from this experience that Pfleger decided he wanted to be a priest. He wanted to be about the business of social justice. He committed on that day his life's work to the clergy.

A Man of Action and Advocacy

But Father Pfleger's advocacy has caused constant conflict and irritation with and for the Catholic Church, of which he is a part of, but not of it.

Cardinal Francis George, his superior, has problems with Father. He has been Archbishop for the past 14 years, but retires this year and I think he's determined to take Pfleger with him.

George is a Catholic traditionalist and believes he should be obeyed. Surely the Cardinal finds Pfleger troubling. Pfleger has been at St. Sabina, on Chicago's South Side, for the past 30 years.

It is Catholic tradition to reassign priests every seven years, perhaps after a one-time renewal, so Father is long past his service commitment.

The Cardinal wanted to send Pfleger to St. Leo, a school just blocks away from St. Sabina, that is challenged and which serves African-American youth. But Father refused the position, because he is not an "educator."

He is a priest, a community organizer of the best order. He has stamped out cigarette and liquor ads and stores and gangs in the area.

Cardinal George, last week in a most insulting way, brought in Rev. Andrew Smith to assume "pastoral" duties at St. Sabina while Pfleger is on suspension. Smith is a Black priest, but will never ever fill Father's Pfleger role, and he knows it.

Pfleger has built a church based on activism. He follows Jesus in the name of his challenge and advocacy, and not just ceremony.

Father Pfleger is a change agent. He has demonstrated such with his life's work in the Auburn Gresham community by making it safer, economically viable, with improved housing, and by making his church relevant and involved.

He has extended the church beyond the confines of Catholicism and attracts all. He has expounded and expressed the Black plight and become a national figure with his commentary.
A "Black" role model, Father Pfleger is one of one and more recognized than the Cardinal.

His program in February, where he brings in national figures from all walks of life to lecture, reaches beyond the church and into the larger Chicago community with much acclaim.

Pfleger has been political and usually on the right side of the issue for Black America. He has not cared about being popular, but more about being right. He has challenged and pushed the envelope.

And now in his moment of fire, where are we, as this White man who is not Black has not only stood tall, but sometimes lone?

This priest is not a Black minister, but has accepted "our" clergy tradition as his own and created something special in his priestly protocols. Where are we as a community in support of him?

Good Priest vs. Bad Priests

Cardinal George may be a good right catholic, but he is dead wrong. Pfleger has been critical of the rigidness of the church in not including women in its hierarchy and other ancient, out-of-date practices that have resulted in the Catholics' loss of membership.

The priests are guilty of allowing their pedophilia to get out of control, as it was imposed on children in disgusting ways. Guilty priests who were reassigned and had their negative behavior protected were not severely dealt with and often even ignored.

Sometimes these deviant priests were elevated within the ranks, as opposed to being suspended and permanently dismissed.

Father Pfleger is being punished for his good behavior, while some of the deviant priests were promoted to escape the consequences of their deviancy.

The move is now on Father Michael Pfleger over whether to stay or to leave the Catholic Church.

Personally, I hope he leaves, so that he can start a new church, where a new flock, in addition to the St. Sabina congregation, will gather and where he can have freedom. I would join.

His style is of the kind for the mis-churched and un-churched. Leaving the church would allow full inclusion of his ministry, where we probably would be able to appreciate him more than within the confines and framework of religiosity.

Father Pfleger needs to be free of the Catholic restriction. In a real way, his circumstance is the definition of what is really wrong with the Catholic Church.

 

Follow Hermene Hartman on Twitter: www.twitter.com/Hermene Hartman

 
 
  • Comments
  • 37
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
03:53 PM on 05/19/2011
Hermene, you're way off base here. Michael Pfleger has overstayed his welcome at St. Sabina for at least 20 years. Priest rotate parishes as you noted primarily to not allow for a "cult of personality" to ever take place. Those who say they will leave with Michael over this simple protocol may leave the Church on their own volition, however their "faith" is centered around the words and actions of a temporal person, not the Church which Christ instituted to Simon Peter as his successor and in the upper room with the Apostles at the Pentacost. Priest take an vow of obedience to their shepards, the Bishops as successors to the Apostles, and Michael has selfishly placed himself above the Church when he made that ultimatum in vain of leaving. Cardinal George did the right thing even though you think it wrong as the Church is not a democracy but a hierarchical institution and has always been such since the beginning (See the Epistles to Timothy and read about St. Ignatius of Antioch for yourself). The Cardinal is his boss, if anyone of us told our boss "no, I don't think I want to do what you employ me to do and I'll just rant about it on the radio" we would be fired in a heartbeat. He is being treated the same as every other priest and you call it "unjust". Please remove the "race" component and judge it strictly on merit.
09:07 AM on 05/11/2011
Shouldn't George or could someone reading this, explain why this is a catholic rule that a priest must go if their perishners want him to stay? How long does George get to stay, before he should go? I knew of another priest who wanted to get a law degree so he could counsel the poor people in his perish, they said it is not his job, and asked him to leave, yet priests listen to confessions and counsel them to pray. I have never heard a police officer say ok, I will not take you to jail because you prayed.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Hermene Hartman
07:11 PM on 05/11/2011
I like your comments. The question is Why is Father being punished and for what. The Cardinal exhibits poor judgement.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
gregcurts
Any belief worth having must survive doubt”
03:45 AM on 05/11/2011
They should throw him out and be done with it. He has had 30 years in one Parish. Time to go.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
OldGent
Alwayswatchin
02:36 AM on 05/11/2011
Even if he did, he would be forcing his parish to leave the religion with him. My answer is NO. The Catholic Church doesn't deserve to get off easy again. He can and should be allowed to stay in one parish. They left Father Damian stay with the Lepers in Hawaii and Sister Theresa do her thing. They certainly allow Father Pfleger to be his parish guiding light and mentor. He is political and so is the Cardinal. The difference is the Cardinal hobnobs with the rich people and Father Pfleger mentors those with no clout or ways to make their community better without the help of the church. Seems this is the reason why the Catholic Church has been losing parishioners, too stern about even listening to them or their problems. BTW just for the people who see Father Pfleger with influential people, they choose to walk with him and his humaneness. He sure doesn't have money to pay them to do it. Strong people draw strong followers. Most people just patronize the Cardinal which is probably what irks him.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Hermene Hartman
07:12 PM on 05/11/2011
I agree. Thanks for writing.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Bude
My Brain Hurts!
01:17 AM on 05/11/2011
Would he be better off without the catholic church?

We all would.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Hermene Hartman
07:13 PM on 05/11/2011
Not necessarily. Father should just be treated fairly and rewarded for the work he has done and not punished, I think.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
VOTER
Freedom from fear - the philosophy of human rights
01:01 AM on 05/11/2011
I hope Father Pfleger leaves the priesthood.
Rents an apartment in St. Sabina's Parish and
continues his good work for and with the people of St. Sabina's Parish.
Not only will he be helping his parishioners, but he will becomes a Daily Thorn
for Cardinal George and all of the RC Authoritarians who have forgotten how to live
Christ's teachings.

All the best, Father Pfleger!
02:33 PM on 05/11/2011
But he won't do that. He was given the option to move a block away to St. Leo High School. Pfleger is just using this as an opportunity to gain more attention.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Hermene Hartman
07:13 PM on 05/11/2011
Amen.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
VOTER
Freedom from fear - the philosophy of human rights
12:22 AM on 05/12/2011
Amen!!!
I do hope things work out well for Father Pfleger and the good people on 
the South Side, especially the parishioners  at St. Sabina's.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DemFem
11:50 PM on 05/10/2011
If Fr. Pfleger decides to leave the Catholic Church, he might try the Unitarian Universalist Church. There he could believe whatever he wanted to and work toward social justice and would be warmly welcomed to do so.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
my4salebox
Everyone is PC, especially those offended by PC.
01:35 AM on 05/11/2011
I'm an atheist, but I would not oppose visiting a UUC--though I find the purpose of worshipping an evil god at the same time being good, decent, open human beings at the same time a little odd.

My local UUC does a lot of great work. Too bad about the delusion, though.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
DemFem
02:18 AM on 05/13/2011
UUs don't tell you to "worship" anything. That's up to you. In fact, there's a lot of atheists at my UU church. We believe that we are all on our own spiritual journeys & we come together in the spirit of love to do good for our fellow man.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Hermene Hartman
07:15 PM on 05/11/2011
He will be successful where ever he goes.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Realist1965
11:24 PM on 05/10/2011
Clearly written by a non-practicing and/or non-believing Catholic. Entitled to your opinions but do not spice them with self-interpreting Catholic doctrine. No one man is greater than the church, including this one...especially after the lengths he has benefitted from to be outside the norm. Anybody protesting his removal should seriously re-consider their commitments to Jesus and the Catholic Church. This is truly black and white, and color has nothing to do with it.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
VOTER
Freedom from fear - the philosophy of human rights
01:19 AM on 05/11/2011
"........especially after the lengths he had benefitted from to be outside the norm."
Good Grief!
How has Father Pfleger benefitted?
Does he live in a Mansion?
Does he have a chauffeur driven limo?
NO. That's Cardinal George living the Good LIfe.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
my4salebox
Everyone is PC, especially those offended by PC.
01:33 AM on 05/11/2011
I agree. This man is clearly too good for the Catholic church. Good point.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Seaniebhoy
03:58 PM on 05/10/2011
It was a nice article, and I can see how the confines of the Catholic Church can be frustrating....but I would appreciate you citing a source when laying a charge as serious as promoting pedophile clergy up the ranks...I have heard that they are transferred to different Parishes but if the writer simply invented this fact then she should be ashamed.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
VOTER
Freedom from fear - the philosophy of human rights
01:08 AM on 05/11/2011
I'm not going to get links, but you can Google for information.,
Several pedophile priests, worldwide,  were made Bishops.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
wbthacker
Can YOU pass the Turing Test?
02:43 PM on 05/10/2011
Uh... so?

If Pfleger no longer finds Catholicism in line with his beliefs, he's free like all other Americans to choose a new religion. He's also free to try to change Catholicism in his own image, if he prefers, and Catholics are free to reject him.

None of this is any of my business. I'm not acquainted with Pfleger and I'm not a Catholic. So it's not clear to me why Ms. Hartman posted this, a private issue, here in a public forum. Honestly, it sounds like sour grapes, especially when Hartman plays "the pedophilia card".

"Father Pfleger is being punished for his good behavior, while some of the deviant priests were promoted to escape the consequences of their deviancy."

This is entirely consistent when you realize that the main goal of the Catholic Church (and most every other church, too) is to preserve itself as a powerful institution. From your description it sounds like the church doesn't think Pfleger's ministry is orthodox enough; from their view he is harming the church by changing it, so they'll move him where he'll be invisible and powerless to do more harm to the church. That's EXACTLY how they reacted to the sexual abusers. They weren't promoted to benefit the children, but rather to benefit the church.

If you don't like that, Catholicism probably isn't for you.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
my4salebox
Everyone is PC, especially those offended by PC.
01:37 AM on 05/11/2011
Catholicism is all about the money. And you can't exactly keep money when you keep leaking it out to pesky people in need.

So he isn't a good fit for their institution. The world is better off with him continuing his work without them.
04:41 PM on 05/11/2011
You may apologize for your slander now please.

"I would say that a Church that seeks to be particularly attractive is already on the wrong path, because the Church does not work for her own ends, she does not work to increase numbers and thus power. The Church is at the service of another: she serves, not for herself, not to be a strong body, rather she serves to make the proclamation of Jesus Christ accessible, the great truths and great forces of love, reconciling love that appeared in this figure and that always comes from the presence of Jesus Christ. In this regard, the Church does not seek to be attractive in and of herself, but must be transparent for Jesus Christ and to the extent that she is not out for herself, as a strong and powerful body in the world, that wants power, but is simply the voice of another, she becomes truly transparent for the great figure of Christ and the great truth that he has brought to humanity. The power of love, in this moment one listens, one accepts. The Church should not consider herself, but help to consider the other and she herself must see and speak of the other." - Pope Benedict XVI
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
wbthacker
Can YOU pass the Turing Test?
01:18 PM on 05/12/2011
Apologize for what, John? Most of my posting was actually in defense of the RCC's right to be jerks. What's your complaint?

Nor do I see the purpose of your quote. I said the church's main goal is to preserve itself as a powerful institution. Bennie agrees All he adds is that the reason the RCC wants this power is so they can use it for God, not because it lets them live like royalty. It's just a coincidence that it does both.

So when the RCC punishes a rebel like Pfleger, or quietly shuffles a pedophile into a less conspicuous job, it's just as I said. Their first goal is to prevent harm to the church. Myself, I think this is because Catholic leaders enjoy their power and prestige. If you want to believe Ratzinger's claim that they're really collecting that power and prestige for the irall-powerful and glorious God, feel free.

By the way, I also have a bridge for sale, are you interested?
photo
VA Jill
I'm not perfect and neither are you
12:24 PM on 05/10/2011
Typically, the RCC caring more about "appearance" than it does about loving and helping one's neighbor.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rwextthoughts
slowly the swamp is draining
12:00 PM on 05/10/2011
you know,,,, I wanted to come on this thread and throw a little sarcasm and jeer,,,,

But , instead , as a life long conservative Catholic, I pretty much agree with everything written above
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Hermene Hartman
07:41 PM on 05/11/2011
Thanks so much.
11:47 AM on 05/10/2011
I am completely baffled by this post. How can Pfleger be a good priest while in violation of his promise of obedience AND the Profession of Faith AND the Oath of Fidelity he has made in order to have the office of pastor?

"With Christian obedience I shall follow what the Bishops, as authentic doctors and teachers of the faith, declare, or what they, as those who govern the Church, establish.

I shall also faithfully assist the diocesan Bishops, so that the apostolic activity, exercised in the name and by mandate of the Church, may be carried out in communion with the Church."

Is he a man of his word or not?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
my4salebox
Everyone is PC, especially those offended by PC.
01:39 AM on 05/11/2011
I'm sorry you can't see that making an oath to the "good" God of the New Testament does not jive with what the Catholic Church does as a whole.

The "good" God of the NT wants money to be spread out to help. The RCC wants to KEEP the money and KEEP people in perpetual need.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Hermene Hartman
07:43 PM on 05/11/2011
Thanks for writing.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Hermene Hartman
07:42 PM on 05/11/2011
He is of his word and of good deed. He has not violated anything.
01:16 PM on 05/13/2011
You may agree with his course of action, but it is simply dishonest not to acknowledge that his course of action is in violation of the promises he made at his ordination as well as the oath of fidelity and profession of faith which he gave in order to be named to the office of pastor.

Your failure to recognize his betrayal of the obligations he placed on himself to the Catholic Church and its hierarchy shows that the article in question lacks the honesty to be taken seriously.
04:13 AM on 05/16/2011
I normally don't read the HP for obvious reasons. . . . But I just want to say that as a Roman Catholic, this article seems like nothing more than someone ranting about her misconceived views on Catholicism and the Church. I also live in Chicagoland and have seen priests come and go with reassignment. I agree with Father John in that Father Pfleger is not keeping true with his promises to the Church at his ordination. The vocation for priesthood is to also be a teacher of the Catholic religion, and he obviously is not doing a terribly good job of it to his parishioners. The writer of the article barely talked about what even sparked the controversy, including some of the offensive quotes attributed to the priest. The thing is, people reading this article should not take it in as having an ounce of truth--which should already be evident if they are familiar with what Catholicism is about in the first place.