More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
Holly Sidell

GET UPDATES FROM Holly Sidell
 

Dating And Facebook: 'It's Complicated'

Posted: 11/16/11 04:37 PM ET

I'm dating someone I am crazy about. We've met the parents, we've made plans to meet all the friends, we've discussed our future together. We're in it and we're happy. I couldn't wait to declare our love for each other by sharing it with the world on Facebook (because how else does one declare their love if not through social media?)! "Babe, I posted our picture! I'll tag you in it so your friends can see it too!"

SILENCE. PAUSE. LONGEST 30 SECONDS OF MY LIFE. "Umm... ummm.... I'm going to hold off on putting anything about you on Facebook for now. It's not that I'm not crazy about you, it's just that I have my reasons." Whhhaaaat? WHY!? NOOOOOO! Cut to slow motion close up of Holly's heart sinking and blood rushing to her face and stomach forming chunks of burning hot puke. Cue Netflix unleashing its latest movie releases into my mind: he has a girlfriend and I'm the other woman, he's ashamed of me and doesn't want anyone to know about me, he's just not really that into me, he's only using me and saying whatever he needs to say to keep me around, he's dating lots of other girls who he tells all the same things to ... and worst -- he's hiding something from me.

I know, it's stupid. It's Facebook. But the reality is that Facebook has become a part of relationships, like it or not. A place of declaration or rejection. Yes, we've attached meaning to it. Sorry, but it's the truth. It's just the way it is. Deal with it.

I started falling down to the "dark" place. I was so hurt! Why didn't he want to share me with the world, the way I wanted to share him!? All of my inherent defense mechanisms came out: I wanted to shut down, I wanted to try to make him jealous, I wanted to act like I didn't care, I wanted to contact some of his "girl" friends on Facebook and find out dirt, I wanted to just be over it ... But then, after many many many deep breaths and smacks out of it from my friend Shannon, I came back to myself -- why was I having this reaction? That's what I needed to look at. None of the other stuff was real, or true. The only truth was that this triggered panic in me. So, why?

FEAR. That's why. Fear that this magical relationship I thought I had was totally made up in my head. Fear that the man I think is my soulmate doesn't think the same about me. Fear that I'm going to lose something so precious to me. Fear of abandonment. The real issue wasn't really that he wouldn't put me on Facebook. The real issue was that I attached meaning to his action (or rather, inaction). And that meaning I attached was that he's not as in it as me, that I must have been making this whole love thing up in my head, and that he obviously doesn't like me as much as I like him. WHOA. That's quite a conclusion to jump to without any substantiated evidence!

Once I knew what was coming up in me and why, I could deal with it and stop being a victim. I could take responsibility for my emotions, deal with my emotions and not blame him. I could actually hear what he had to say about why he didn't want to put anything about me up on Facebook right now (his reason was very rational and valid, by the way, and I totally get it). I could reconnect with my knowing that I have no reason not to trust him. I could take a step back and look at things for what they are. And, then, I could breathe again.

Thanks, Mark Zuckerberg, for the spiritual lesson. But really, I guess, we can turn anything into a way to better ourselves or transform ourselves. Anytime we start to spin out of control and start falling into our "dark" place, we can choose to take a look at WHY we're going there and what's coming up for us rather than blaming something external. Stop and ask yourself, "Really, do I have any proof that the conclusion I'm jumping to is true?" Stop and ask yourself, "What is this person or situation really bringing up in me that I need to look at?

 

Follow Holly Sidell on Twitter: www.twitter.com/HollySidell

 
 
  • Comments
  • 10
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
12:21 AM on 12/05/2011
Hi, Holly! You are so adorable! Your boyfriend has his reasons for not posting you as his girlfriend and those reasons simply will not change. However, do not doubt that his love for you is true. When I fondly recall my relationship with your current boyfriend, I think of a humming bird; it's motionless for just a few moments then dashes away to the next bright red flower. The motionless moments are precious. Love and enjoy him now, as his essential nature is unable to be still for too long. I miss his Puer archetypal spirit (eternal youth) and that is what makes him so truly special.
It looks like you have a great career going and I wish you only the best in the future!
Warmly, Lynn Penrose
Los Angeles
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Holly Sidell
Happily Ever After is a Choice
06:38 PM on 11/21/2011
Thanks all for looking out and for your input! It is now a moot point as we have officially broadcast our relationship status to the world on Facebook like the "facebook sheep" our generation have become... but at least I'm a happy sheep :)
07:50 PM on 11/18/2011
sounds fishy to me..go with your 1st instincts!
03:18 PM on 11/18/2011
My grown-up mind can not conceive of ever wanting to broadcast my dating life on Facebook. But I would be suspect of someone who withholds the reason for their own objections. The refusenik in this tale does sound manipulative.
12:15 PM on 11/18/2011
It is key to look within yourself and stay on top of why you're feeling a certain way in most situations. But, in this one that you speak of, sounds to me like your boyfriend IS indeed shady and you're making excuses for him. Did you ask what those "reasons" are? Usually, when a man makes a situation out to be complicated, it's not. There probably is another woman -- sorry to say. Whether he's currently with her or not, he's hiding something. Not only from the two of you (or more), but from himself.

I say...keep your eyes open and always trust your instincts. Your man should want to share you with the world. If you're not a terrorist of a pubic enemy, then what real valid reason does he have for not sharing the existence of your relationship?
10:47 AM on 11/18/2011
soft, what light through yonder window breaks...
it is the east and according to some cold, web page description---
it's complicated. -Wm Shakespeare 1608

her hair was long
her foot was light
her eyes were wild
her Twitter feed is mean
-Keats 1813
09:50 AM on 11/18/2011
I think Facebook is like a double-edged blade. I have never reacted the way Holly did to the news, but I have had women refuse to add me to their friends list, to share photos of us and introduce me to their online friends.

I would never fault them for not advertising our relationship if their motives were rational and reasonable.
photo
french queen13
my beloved is mine and I am his
02:58 AM on 11/18/2011
I was hoping you were going to say your boyfriend doesn't use Facebook and wouldn't touch it with a ten-foot pole. The breaches of privacy and the hypocrisy of the people running that site are frightening. The breaches of privacy I've experienced; one only has to read the news to know about the hypocrisy. For example: Courbet painting of nude woman with - gasp - pubic hair gets taken off, and accounts posting it are closed. Jokes about rape, and pro-rape sites, are left up for weeks and months, however many complaints are made.
12:08 AM on 11/18/2011
Omg I just went through the same thing. My boyfriend and I have been dating for over 8 months and he had been off facebook (4 months before we even met) and decided to go back on. When he immediately didn't want to be "in a relationship" with me on fb I totally took offense. I tagged him in numerous pictures and called him angrily about why it didn't show up on his page etc etc. He was like "it's only facebook ...do I need to get off?" That's when it hit me ... we women are so ridiculous sometimes!!! I know all his friends, I've met his immediate family and extended family, I know who all his exes were and he purposely sat me down and we went through deleting all his exes tags and pics from his page. So why was I being so ridiculous all because he didn't want to "declare" it on that silly internet? Yeah once I smacked myself out of it I was fine and have been ever since.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Holly Sidell
Happily Ever After is a Choice
04:00 PM on 11/20/2011
Yes, totally! Seems like we went through the same process.