iPhone app iPad app Android phone app Android tablet app More

Featuring fresh takes and real-time analysis from HuffPost's signature lineup of contributors
GET UPDATES FROM Howard R. Fradkin, Ph.D.
 

Why 200 Men Are Speaking Out on 'Oprah'

Posted: 11/05/10 01:31 PM ET

Oprah Winfrey dared speak the truth of her sexual abuse many years ago, giving millions of women permission to acknowledge their abuse. Today (Nov. 5) and next Friday (Nov. 12), Oprah has chosen to join forces with Tyler Perry to open doors for another huge group who need understanding and healing for the sexual abuse they've suffered: men. I honor the bravery and genius of Oprah and Tyler, who both dared to dream that they could help men heal by creating a safe enough place to tell their stories.

The sheer numbers of male survivors are staggering; according to most researchers, one in six men has been sexually abused by age 18. The estimates go up to one in four when you add in victims of covert non-contact abuse. Our culture teaches men to keep their abuse secret for many complex reasons. They learn that they aren't supposed to be vulnerable; they learn they should be in control, so it's impossible to be a victim; they might wrongly blame themselves for leading someone on; many mistakenly fear their abuse makes them gay or less masculine.

I hope these blocks are removed when "The Oprah Winfrey Show" gathers 200 male survivors of sexual abuse for a groundbreaking discussion. I was invited the day we taped this show (the second episode airs November 12) and I can tell you that this show was not only historic; it was a miracle only made possible by incredibly strong men. I'm a psychologist who has worked with over 1,000 male survivors in my career, and this was the most powerful, inspiring day I've ever spent.

When we rode to the taping, we felt the anticipation, but also the heaviness. As the cameras rolled, we stood holding a photo of ourselves at the age at which we were first abused. It was an incredibly powerful moment. As we looked at the sea of innocent young faces, the tragedy of our molestation and abuse was blatantly evident: so many dreams shattered, so many young men's lives irrevocably changed. Then, you could literally feel the release in the room as one man after another bared his soul's darkest secrets. Men of all ages and races shared a common bond, and each felt the powerful healing that can only occur in community. Together, we entered a zone where we felt safe enough to tell the world we were abused, we are healing, and we are here to join hands with all of our other abused brothers who deserve to release their shame and heal.

If you are a man who doesn't watch "Oprah," I invite you to make an exception, especially if you're a man holding your secret or you have a son. You'll find a brotherhood and hope when you find the courage to reveal your truth. Gay partners and wives, please watch, too, and discover hope for you too. There are resources available to you, including MaleSurvivor (www.MaleSurvivor.org). Dare to dream you can heal and fully recover.

 
Oprah Winfrey dared speak the truth of her sexual abuse many years ago, giving millions of women permission to acknowledge their abuse. Today (Nov. 5) and next Friday (Nov. 12), Oprah has chosen to j...
Oprah Winfrey dared speak the truth of her sexual abuse many years ago, giving millions of women permission to acknowledge their abuse. Today (Nov. 5) and next Friday (Nov. 12), Oprah has chosen to j...
 
 
  • Comments
  • 397
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »  (9 total)
06:16 PM on 11/22/2010
I thought you might be interested in reading the view point of a male survivor who was on the show: http://womenspeakout.wordpress.com/2010/11/19/i-came-forward-on-oprah/
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Cowboylove
04:28 PM on 11/12/2010
I do not think that coming forward or admitting to the sexual abuse will abate many of the problems these men face. Homosexual abuse of males is intrinsically worse and harder to escape with time and space than heterosexual child abuse. There is so much guilt associated with participation in this abuse and it will likely take years to recover, if recovery is even possible.

Listening to the twin boys who were repeated raped by priests for years left me feeling ill. Or the father who sexually molested his son from the age of five or six until he was 18. How do you get over that kind of an experience? How do you get on with life with any kind of semblance of normalcy?

There is a lot of darkness in the world, vastly more than we have ever thought. Protecting children is the first order of business, but as long as people turn a blind eye, abuse will go on and the permanent damage will never fade away.
01:00 PM on 12/10/2010
Your statement "Homosexual abuse of males is intrinsically worse and harder to escape with time and space than heterosexual child abuse" makes the assumption that the gender of the perpetrators and victims decides whether the perpetrator is homosexual or heterosexual. That's a fallacious conclusion that isn't borne out in the peer reviewed science. One such study "Child Sexual Abuse and Homosexuality," says:
"Because most child molesters are men, (90%), some have argued that 'homosexual' child abuse is widespread and that homosexuals abuse children at a rate higher than their proportion of the general population, which is somewhere around 3 to 8 percent of the population. Such claims are based on the false belief that men who sexually abuse boys are homosexual. In fact, the overwhelming majority of men who sexually abuse children live their lives as heterosexual men..."
A 1994 Pediatrics article titled "Are Children at Risk for Sexual Abuse by Homosexuals?" found that: "In 82% of cases, the alleged offender was a heterosexual partner of a close relative of the child. Using the data from our study, the 95% confidence limits, of the risk children would identify recognizably homosexual adults as the potential abuser, are from 0% to 3.1%..."
The study showed that a child's risk of being molested by a relative's heterosexual partner is 100 times greater than by someone who might be identified as a homosexual.
Let's not make assumptions and protect children from actual perpetrators, not myths.
12:18 PM on 11/11/2010
@Morgantheaxe. I would ask you what is it "to be a man?" More often than not, our society encourages men to "closet" their feelings and emotions. Should we continue to support that as a means of coping. I am sure that your concern comes from a genuine place of concern. However, I would ask you to look at it from another point of view. When we define manhood (and other things) we have a tendency to box them in and limit them by these very definitions. Not all men are afraid to share their story. It is this mindset that will keep them enslaved in the idea that sharing and crying and talking/communication is what girls or women do, and that somehow this is weak.

@KeepNitReal I understand your sentiment about Tyler perry being the one to share the story. I have been having these discussions since "the movie" has come out. However,I am encouraged that the forum is being created for open dialogue about the pain that men are holding on to.

Pain, whether a woman or a man needs healing. Let's us ALLOW the process to take place. Focus on the message and we can work around the messenger.
photo
Morgantheaxe
Eisenhower Republicans don't drink tea!!
08:23 AM on 11/11/2010
This is the perfect definition of a bad idea with great intentions. Men are not women. The article touched briefly on some of the reasons men do not speak out about abuse. Such a public display is not going to have the results you would think. It will threaten most abused men. They will respond very aggresively, and it will actually serve as one more reason for them to not address any problems they have as a result of being abused. It amazes me how many in our society have forgotten about what it is to be a man.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
nikanj
free the fnords
10:16 PM on 11/11/2010
What most posters here don't understand is the truly conflicted
feelings many men have about those who molested them,
particularly if it was an adult male whom they admired.

Or if it was their mother or another female in authority over them.

I agree that public disclosure truly threatens many men, and
that they will either respond aggressively, shut down, or
transfer to one of the alternate personalities they have developed.
photo
KeepNIt2Real
Big man out? Lebron wins. What are the odds?
04:29 PM on 11/09/2010
I think these men should come out and speak of what has happened to them. The ONLY thing I don't understand is Tyler Perry's involvement in all of this. This dude makes movies that villianize men and he likes men. How confused can this guy be? He'd be the last guy I'd want to represent my story.
02:30 PM on 11/09/2010
Sad to see people angry with the messenger rather than with the people who caused their pain. Your angry at Oprah may be misplaced, since most of you don't have a clue as to what she does with her money, you seem to be in the mindset that MY pain is the most worst ever. Well it isn't. Oprah was spotlighting male abuse. You claim you want someone to spotlight this issue but when it is done in a way the millions might see it, you get mad. Soyou can't have it both ways,--spotlight it but don't spotlight it. And while this is such a sad issue in society, it isn't OPRAH's responsibility to heal YOU. Then to say that Tyler Perry's abuse doesn't give him some insight into your abuse, is well, my GOD, abused people dismissing other abused people with my abuse is worst than yours foolishness. Wonder why you need a superstar to bring attention to male abuse? Hero worship maybe? You say her web page has other silly topics on it, so what? Not everyone in this world is dealing with abuse 24/7. And finally I laughed when you said you "wouldn't presume talk to a women about womanly things which you don't experience." Really? Don't MEN preach to women about ABORTION and their bodies, some blame women for rape, or about what women should do, how they should look or how to act? You never do that to your women friends?????
12:38 PM on 11/08/2010
My mind is blown that nobody sees this- sees Oprah- for what she is. If she really wants to help people, how about donating some of those millions upon millions to setting up hotlines and support groups? And what on earth does any victim care what Tyler Perry has to say? Are victims supposed to feel better because some marginal celebrity went through the same thing? How about bringing on a vetted, trained psychologist (I am NOT looking at you, Dr. Phil). Oprah is a shock-value talk show hostess, just like the rest of them- except they at least have the self-restraint not to (or lack the self-righteousness to) try to frame this as some enlightening learning experience (the interview with the woman whose face was mauled by a monkey comes to mind). "Personal struggle, inner strength," blah blah. What a snow job. That was shock for ratings, and I don't know why more people don't see through it.

Have a read:
http://www.alternet.org/media/145084/10_good_reasons_you_should_hate_oprah_winfrey

Seriously. Disregard what you might think the tone of the article would be based on the URL, and actually go read it. Then come back and re-read this.
photo
kapalabhati
Lokah Samasta Sukhino Bhavantu
01:01 PM on 11/08/2010
Seriously? Do you have any idea how much of her millions and millions she has donated? If not, you have no way of knowing.

Read this for starters.
http://learningtogive.org/papers/paper135.html
03:07 PM on 11/08/2010
If I don't have any idea of how much she has donated, then I have no way of knowing how much she has donated? I guess I can't argue with such stunning logic.

I followed the link, but found no dollar amounts. But I checked her website, and see things like "Portia de Rossi: The Secret that Nearly Killed Her", "Lisa Marie Presley Opens Up About Ex-Husband Michael Jackson", and "Ricky Martin Opens Up About Coming Out". Maybe some people think that these stories do good for everyday people struggling with the same issues? I guess we should be applauding The Inquirer and Star for their altruistic work as well. I have a hard time delineating a shocking story about Presley from 200 men sharing their shocking stories. Let us not forget that she parsed these same topics 20 years ago, except for then it was in the Jerry Springer format. Train wrecks are train wrecks.

I think its great for the charities and causes that she does donate to, but it feels to me that this is a tool (or repayment to?) to then justify and whitewash the fact that she exploits these stories for ratings.

From someone who has lived through the content matter in question, I can tell you that I took nothing from this episode but a sense of insult. And if she really wants to help, she should focus on changing society's perception of victims.
photo
HUFFPOST COMMUNITY MODERATOR
IndyStacey
Everyone does better when everyone does better.
02:13 PM on 11/08/2010
why can't people give Oprah credit when she does a good thing? Why does she inspire such hate?
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
LadyAurora
Pagan for Peace
02:40 PM on 11/08/2010
I know it's terrible how she gets treated. When she came out on her show and told how she was abused was a big deal to me. I had been abused and told to forget it happened and just deal with it. My abuser was never held accountable and to this day denies it ever happened.

What she did made me believe finally that it wasn't my fault and that I had to find someone to talk to about it.

I think it's great that these men have finally come forward and maybe some can now really start to heal.

As to Khaqq - maybe he/she was abused and is still in denial.
03:27 PM on 11/08/2010
I think its telling that you made the leap from my criticizing of her, to "hate". I don't "hate" Oprah. I don't hate anyone. I dislike Oprah, and I am distrustful of her, but I do not hate her.

Just in the same vein that you think "haters" do not give her a fair shake, I see from where I stand "lovers" who are completely rigidly opposed to viewing any objective or alternate perspective of her. I think that, like all information presented to us in our lives, we should weigh and evaluate all sides and contexts that we are able to. I see too many people here who it seems have never questioned anything about her topics, or her motivation. Historically, allegiance that is unwavering and unchecked, without any questioning or even the smallest bit of cynicism to counter-balance one's initial perception, has consistently proven to be a dangerous thing.

And to you, Lady Aurora- despite your postulating of why I react against the can-do-no-wrong aura with which Oprah is treated, I am 1.not at all in denial, 2. do not hate the person that perpetrated these things against me, and, 3. having worked through this with the help of a psychologist and a lot of hard work on my own part. I cringe to see Oprah talking to me about something she cannot ever experience. I don't presume to talk to you about womanly matters that I could never experience.
kimroc1
kimroc1
11:49 AM on 11/08/2010
Sexual molestation needs to be addressed in our country. I think these men are brave for coming out and telling their stories. This happens more often than we realize. If a little boy, or teenager comes out and says they were molested, they get called gay. If a little girl comes out and says she was molested, they get called fast. This type of stigma needs to be stopped and we need to listen to our children when they tell us about these abuses.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:57 AM on 11/08/2010
Stuff like this makes me freak out since i have an 18 month old boy.   You want to make them free and open to new experiences and yet protect them.
 
i never faced any abuse myself. I pray all the survivors of abuse find peace.
 
09:01 AM on 11/08/2010
just want to say that I felt a humane responsibility to watch the Oprah show last friday. I was an obsessed mom on this very subject and my kids found it really annoying. they are now 19 and 17 (boys) and just watching this show proves to me, even the most cautious parent can't will their sons to "tell" when asked about abuse. I pray this hasn't happened!!! I heard things on Oprah I never heard before and I am horrified. Kudos to her and Tyler Perry (I hope they win an Emmy for this groundbreaking raw important show) and I honor the men who were brave enough to be in the audience and on the show. All I saw were those innocent kids in the portraits they held. My heart breaks for you. I hope this will aid in your healing. And, I hope this does break the door open for others to realize they are not alone in their shame. God Bless You all.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
SickOfGOPCrapola
Three R's: Recovering Reagan Republican
12:36 PM on 11/08/2010
We have no shame because we did nothing wrong. The only ones who should feel shame are our abusers, but I hold out no hope for that.
04:21 AM on 11/08/2010
Watched a doc about the "Daning Boys" in Afghanistan. Women are so untouchable its a cultural norm to keep "dancing boys" to rape and eventually murder.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MeinNH
Ooooo Silly Me
11:12 AM on 11/09/2010
I too saw that program and was saddened at the hypocrisy of it and more so the fact that it was deemed "normal" by that culture.
03:00 AM on 11/08/2010
Kudos for them to show such bravery. I honestly can't imagine what they've gone through. I guess one of the first steps in dealing with such horror is acknowledging it for what it is and having the courage to speak openly about it.
photo
Counterglow
Werner Heisenberg may have been right.
02:29 AM on 11/08/2010
If you want to cut down sexual abuse in your community, simply refuse to let any little boy be alone with a C@tholic priest...ever.
-swift
Can you put your country before your party?
09:23 AM on 11/08/2010
While the Catholic church is guilty of covering up abuse, painting every Catholic priest as an abuser is not going to help. Most people who are abused are abused by a relative or friend of the family.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Valerie Keefe
left-wing euro-tory trans lesbian
11:51 AM on 11/08/2010
Agreed. Painting every Catholic priest as a potential rapist makes about as much sense as painting every man as a potential rapist.
photo
Counterglow
Werner Heisenberg may have been right.
03:06 PM on 11/08/2010
I never said every priest is a molester. It's just that a) Enough of them are that it's sensible to be proactive and b) The abusers are protected by the church and shuffled around from one happy hunting ground to another. A relative or friend of the family will typically have access only to a very few children. A child-molesting priest will have access to hundreds, and instead of being prosecuted when he's found out, he'll just be shuffled away and the families intimidated into silence.

Don't forget that in many countries, the Catholic Church is still strong enough to silence the victims, prevent the police from acting and persuade the outraged community that everything will be fine once the molester is removed from the community.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Simba216
01:07 AM on 11/08/2010
I cannot stand Oprah, but love that she is doing this.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
HannaSchmitz
I'm just saying
03:34 PM on 11/07/2010
I watched some of it friday and it was so sad. My son came into the room and I had to turn it off because of the subject matter. I have talked to my children about being molested and to tell me if it ever happened. I also keep a eye on them at all times. I can't keep them at home with me forever and have to trust that there are good people out there that won't hurt them. But I'm extra careful (no sleep overs, etc.)
08:33 AM on 11/08/2010
Maybe it would have been better if you had let your son watch the show. So much was to be learned and sometimes lessons are better taught by others than by our own parents.